See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/383380304

Digital Twin Technology: A Comprehensive Review

Article in International Journal of Scientific Research and Engineering Trends · July 2024
DOI: 10.61137/ijsret.vol.10.issue4.199

CITATION READS

1 2,756

2 authors, including:

Malithi Rumalka Abayadeera

University of Moratuwa
1 PUBLICATION 1 CITATION

SEE PROFILE

All content following this page was uploaded by Malithi Rumalka Abayadeera on 31 August 2024.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.

 International Journal of Scientific Research & Engineering Trends
Volume 10, Issue 4, July-Aug-2024, ISSN (Online): 2395-566X

Digital Twin Technology: A Comprehensive Review

Malithi R. Abayadeera, G.U. Ganegoda
Faculty of Information Technology
University of Moratuwa, Katubedda, Sri Lanka

Abstract- This review explores Digital Twin technology's evolution since 2003, beyond replicating physical entities to encompass
data ecosystems and service relationships. Analyzing its inception, growth, and multifaceted uses, the review illuminates Digital
Twins' transformative role in modern sectors. It delves into their impact on manufacturing, healthcare, smart cities, defence,
agriculture, and utilities, showcasing their ability to enhance decision-making and operational efficiencies. Yet, significant
obstacles hinder Digital Twin adoption, including IT infrastructure establishment, data quality assurance, privacy concerns,
and ethical implications. These challenges obstruct the full realization of Digital Twins' potential benefits. The study concludes
by outlining critical avenues for future research, emphasizing standardization, data quality, privacy preservation, trust-
building, and cross-domain applications. Bridging these gaps is vital for harnessing the true potential of Digital Twins in
revolutionizing industries. This review aims to present a comprehensive view of Digital Twins, highlighting their benefits,
challenges, and the imperative for further research to unlock their transformative impact.

Index Terms- Architecture, Digital Twins, Ethical Considerations, Evolution, Internet of Things, Multidisciplinary
Applications, Origin

I. INTRODUCTION behaviour of their physical counterparts. Digital twin

technology offers a comprehensive solution by integrating
Due to the lack of Information Technology in the past, the various technologies such as the Internet of Things,
majority of operations were primarily controlled by simulation, data analysis, and modelling [1].
physical space, which had negative effects on efficiency,
accuracy, and transparency. Technology such as computers, One of the most enlightening aspects of digital twin
simulation software, the Internet, and wireless networks technology lies in its ability to establish a feedback loop
provided a parallel virtual environment to virtualize between the physical system and its digital cyberspace
physical assets and allow for remote interaction with assets model [15]. This innovative approach signifies a shift in
up to the 20th century. industrial thinking, where efforts are directed toward
integrating physical world occurrences into digital space.
This has enabled more effective and efficient execution of Achieving full lifecycle tracking with loop feedback
plans and activities. With the advancement of new represents a paramount concept, ensuring the
information technology, the interaction and integration of harmonization of the digital and physical realms
real and virtual places are now becoming more and more throughout the entire lifecycle. Such synchronization
crucial. It is within this context that Digital Twin enables diverse simulations, analyses, data accumulation,
Technology comes to the forefront, revolutionizing various and mining based on digital models, augmented by
industries by fundamentally altering the way we simulate artificial intelligence applications, ensuring their
and optimize physical systems. adaptability to real-world physical systems. This capacity
epitomizes the significance of digital twins in intelligent
Digital twin technology has emerged as a powerful tool in manufacturing; accurate modelling by digital twins is
various industries, revolutionizing the way we simulate imperative for the successful implementation of so-called
and optimize physical systems. This technology offers the intelligent manufacturing systems. Moreover, digital twins
unique capability to delve deep into the inner workings of facilitate rapid iterations and optimization of product
systems, comprehensively understand the interactions designs, surpassing the speed of physical prototype testing.
between different components, and predict the future They also significantly enhance product quality,

© 2024 IJSRET
1485
 International Journal of Scientific Research & Engineering Trends
Volume 10, Issue 4, July-Aug-2024, ISSN (Online): 2395-566X

demonstrating their pivotal role in improving the customer exploration of digital twin technology across a diverse
experience, understanding needs, enhancing existing spectrum of domains. This endeavour includes an in-depth
products and services, and driving the innovation of new investigation into its integration across different maturity
business models. levels.

For instance, GE's pioneering use of a "digital wind farm" Secondly, this review seeks to address a series of
illustrates the transformative potential of digital twin fundamental research questions:
technology. By leveraging the digital environment, GE Q1: What are the key challenges and limitations faced by
analyzes data from each turbine, feeding it into its virtual industries when adopting digital twin technology?
equivalent to inform the configuration of every turbine Q2: What are the specific advantages offered by the
before construction. This approach aims to achieve a 20% digital twintechnology implementation?
gain in efficiency by harnessing the insights gleaned from Q3: How has digital twin technology evolved in
the digital twin of each turbine. Such innovative response to the demands of Industry 4.0?
applications showcase how digital twins enable rapid Q4: What are the emerging trends and technological
optimizations and informed decision- making, resulting in advancements in the field of digital twins?
tangible improvements in productivity and performance. Q5: What are the key ethical considerations and
concerns that emerge with the widespread application
For two years in a row in 2016, and 2017 Gartner has of digital twin technologies across various domains?
ranked digital twins among the top ten strategic
technological development trends[2]. Gartner also Beyond the purely technical aspects, this study also
disclosed that organizations were beginning to deploy delves into the myriads of benefits offered by digital
digital twins on a widespread basis in 2019[2]. The twins and critically examines the essential
adoption of digital twin technology has been particularly considerations for their successful implementation. By
widespread in manufacturing plants, where it supports fulfilling these objectives and addressing these
digital transformation and the adoption of Industry 4.0 research questions, this comprehensive review aspires
concepts. Due to its capacity to accurately simulate and to serve as a valuable guide for researchers,
analyze a physical entity's behaviour in actual contexts, practitioners, and stakeholders navigating the dynamic
digital twin technology has been increasingly popular in landscape of digital twin technology. Ultimately, the
recent years [3]. aim is to contribute significantly to a deeper
understanding of digital twins and their potential to
The applicability of digital twins spans a diverse range of reshape industries and domains within the Fourth
domains, with significant impact observed in smart cities, Industrial Revolution's context.
urban planning, freight logistics, healthcare, engineering,
and the automotive industry, among others [4]. The largest This review aims to comprehensively explore Digital Twin
weapons producer in the world, Lockheed Martin, ranked Technology's applications, challenges, and potential across
the digital twin as one of the top six technologies for the diverse industries. The objectives encompass several key
future of the aerospace and defence sectors in November aspects. Firstly, the objective is to trace the technological
2017 [2]. evolution of Digital Twins within the context of Industry
4.0, shedding light on its emergence through the
The concept of digital twins has undoubtedly captured the convergence of the Internet of Things, data analytics, and
attention of various industries and academic circles, simulations. Secondly, the review will evaluate the
sparking excitement and curiosity. However, it is essential advantages offered by Digital Twins, encompassing real-
to acknowledge that this technology is still in its formative time monitoring, predictive analysis, and decision support
stages of development. Despite its immense potential, there capabilities.
is a notable scarcity of comprehensive studies focusing on
the practical deployment of digital twin technology within Furthermore, this comprehensive examination will feature
specific applications. In this comprehensive critical review, multiple case studies showcasing successful Digital Twin
the intent is twofold: Firstly, it aims to conduct a holistic

© 2024 IJSRET
1486
 International Journal of Scientific Research & Engineering Trends
Volume 10, Issue 4, July-Aug-2024, ISSN (Online): 2395-566X

deployments across various domains, including healthcare, several researchers have presented different definitions of
engineering, and smart cities, providing tangible insights this technology. It is also said that the phrase "Digital
into real-world implementations. Additionally, the intricate Twin" was used originally in the work of Hernández and
challenges associated with deploying Digital Twins will be Hernández [1]. Up until then, it has evolved to provide
explored, spanning technological intricacies, organizational benefits such as virtual-real integration, iterative operation
hurdles, and domain-specific issues such as data and optimization, real-time interaction, and full-factor data
integration and privacy. drive.

Lastly, ethical considerations and societal implications The concept of a digital twin, first adopted by NASA in
stemming from the widespread implementation of Digital 2010, involves creating a virtual representation of a
Twin Technology will be examined, including concerns physical system. The identical vehicle that carried out the
related to data protection and transparency. Encompassing mission in space was the one that remained on Earth [5].
diverse sectors like manufacturing, healthcare, smart cities, This virtual replica serves as a platform for scenario
the automotive industry, engineering, and construction, this planning, sensitivity analysis, and modelling of responses
review aspires to contribute to a comprehensive knowledge to changes or perturbations in the chemical or
repository. By delving into Digital Twins' historical environmental spaces.
evolution, advantages, limitations, and ethical dimensions,
it aims to empower practitioners and researchers to harness Later in 2014, Grieves introduced the three basic
their potential effectively and navigate the complexities dimensions of digital twins which are the digital Model,
inherent in their implementation. the physical model and the connections of data and
information. Additionally, in 2018 Tao et al. [6] expanded
Within the forthcoming pages, readers will find a the current three- dimensional Digital Twin model by
comprehensive exploration of digital twin technology and integrating two extra dimensions, namely data and
its diverse applications across various industries. The services, thus producing a more thorough five-dimensional
structure of this exploration encompasses an examination DT model. This was done in an effort to promote wider
of the technological evolution of digital twins, placing their applications of DT across many sectors. Later several other
emergence within the context of Industry 4.0. Following models were introduced making it beneficial for more
this, case studies across diverse sectors illustrate successful industries. Furthermore, Tao et al. [6] established the idea
digital twin deployments. Subsequently, the focus shifts to of the DT shop floor in January 2017 and provided an in-
the advantages derived from digital twin implementations, depth analysis of its traits, composition, operational
encompassing real-time monitoring, predictive analysis, mechanism, and essential technologies. For reference,
and decision assistance. The inquiry then addresses the significant DT development milestones are depicted in
challenges inherent in establishing digital twins, including Figure 1.
technological complexities, organizational hurdles, and
industry-specific issues such as data integration, model While Grieves' contribution is noteworthy, the evolving
precision, and privacy concerns. Finally, the exploration definitions of digital twins highlight the dynamic nature of
extends to the ethical considerations and societal impacts this concept. These variations in definition underscore the
that accompany the widespread use of this technology. complexity and interdisciplinary nature of digital twin
This structured journey aims to serve as a comprehensive technology.
guide for researchers, practitioners, and stakeholders
navigating the dynamic landscape of digital twin
technology.
II. LITERUTRE REVIEW
A. Origin of Digital Twin
In 2003, The concept of “Digital Twin” was initially Fig. 1. The Milestones of DT Development [6]

introduced by Michael Grieves of the University of

Michigan [4]. Since then, its concept has evolved as

© 2024 IJSRET
1487
 International Journal of Scientific Research & Engineering Trends
Volume 10, Issue 4, July-Aug-2024, ISSN (Online): 2395-566X

B. Digital Twin Evolution roadmap. Figure 3 illustrates the evolution of DT in a

Even though Digital Twin (DT) technology has pulled a lot graphic way.
of attention lately, its conceptual roots go back further in
time. This idea first came to be in 2003 at the University of
Michigan, where Michael Grieves oversaw its integration
into the field of product lifecycle management (PLM)[7].
David Gelernter proposed a similar idea in 1991 known as
"Mirror Worlds," where software models mimicked real-
world scenarios using data from physical sources [7]. A
parallel architecture framework with a "virtual counterpart" Fig. 3. Evolution of Digital Twin [5]
or agent for each product item was introduced by Kary
C. Definition and Concept of Digital Twin
Främling et al. in 2003[8]. These early conceptualizations
As several academics have offered various interpretations
laid the groundwork for digital twins, but it is essential to
of this technology, its definition has undergone a number
recognize that technological constraints of the time limited
of revisions. The Digital Twin is a depiction of an active,
their practical application. The inefficiencies caused by the
singular "product" that can be a concrete thing like a
manual transfer of production data on paper within PLM
machine, object, service, or intangible asset, or it can be a
were the focus of this innovation.
system made up of a tangible thing like a product and its
associated services.
Later, in 2006, the Grieves conceptual model underwent a
name change from the "Mirrored Spaces Model" to the
To be categorized as a Digital Twin, a model needs to fulfil
"Information Mirroring Model"[7],[8]. This paradigm
certain characteristics, such as fidelity (capability to match
introduced the idea of several virtual spaces that
the physical model), expansibility (capability to
correspond to a single physical area and emphasized the
incorporate models), interoperability (capability to convert
bidirectional linking mechanism between two spaces,
between different representation models and establish
making it easier to explore alternative concepts or designs
equivalence between them, and scalability (capability to
(see Figure 2).
evaluate dissimilar scales of information) [9]. The
emphasis on these characteristics highlights the need for
precision and adaptability in digital twin models, ensuring
their relevance across diverse domains.

In general, “Digital Twin” is identified as a virtual

representation of physical objects throughout their
existence that is capable of comprehension, learning, and
real-time data- based reasoning. Alternatively, the term
“Digital Twin” is described as an informed simulation
Fig. 2. Michale Grieve’s Proposed Mirrored Spaces Model/Information model that collects data from real-world sources and
Mirroring Model.[8]
initiates actions within physical devices [2].
During this time, technological constraints continued to
impede the practical application of DT. These constraints In the context of manufacturing, a "digital twin" is a virtual
included things like confined processing power, device model that is continuously updated with its real-world
internet access restrictions, difficulties with data storage equivalent of a system, procedure, or product [10]. A
and management, and the early stages of machine learning digital twin (DT) is a very accurate depiction of a process's
algorithms. current state and of how it naturally interacts with its
surroundings in the real world. It is used to forecast
In NASA's proposed technical roadmap from 2010 [5], the product performance in addition to serving as an
term "Digital Twin" (DT) first appeared. DT was also illustration [9].
referred to as the "Virtual Digital Fleet Leader" in NASA's

© 2024 IJSRET
1488
 International Journal of Scientific Research & Engineering Trends
Volume 10, Issue 4, July-Aug-2024, ISSN (Online): 2395-566X

The industrial environment shows a variety of ways that possibilities of the digital twin reference model in terms of
the digital twin concept has been interpreted. In order to interoperability, expandability, scalability, and fidelity were
increase production adaptability, some manufacturers focus studied by Schleich et al. [6] in detail. They also explored
on creating a connection between virtual and real products. other processes related to this reference model across the
While some firms use Digital Twin to trace a product's whole product lifecycle, including conversion, evaluation,
journey throughout its lifecycle and improve composition, and decomposition [13]. These studies
manufacturing quality, others use DT to improve product straighten out critical aspects of digital twin architecture
design. but may require adaptation for industry-specific
applications. In a study done by Qi et al. [14] they have
D. Digital Twin Architecture mentioned a digital twin model with five key dimensions,
The fundamental concept of a digital twin is the accurate encompassing physical entities, virtual counterparts,
and real-time relationship between a real object and a service components, digital twin data, and connections (see
digital object. However, it is hard to define the concept of Figure 05).
architecture. Numerous conceptual models and reference
frameworks for digital twins have been suggested. A
thorough "Digital Twin 8- dimensional model" was
introduced by Stark et al. [11] in a study with the goal of
defining the range and classification of digital twins. Four
of the model's dimensions were devoted to describing the
depth of the capabilities of digital twins, while the
remaining four were intended to capture the contextual and
environmental features of the digital twin domain (see
Figure 4). While these models provide valuable insights
into the architecture of digital twins, it is important to
recognize that their complexity can pose challenges in
Fig. 5. Five-dimension digital twin model [14]
practical implementation.
Leveraging this five-dimensional model, they have
conducted an investigation into representative applications
across diverse domains. While this model provides a
simplified framework, its applicability to complex
industries may require further refinement. The examination
of various digital twin architectures underscores the
importance of flexibility and adaptability to meet specific
industry needs.

The foundational Digital Twin models described above

have not only served as fundamental constructs within
their respective domains but have also catalyzed the
development of numerous derivative frameworks across
diverse industries. These derivative frameworks draw
Fig. 4. Digital Twin 8-dimension model [11]
inspiration from, or directly incorporate elements of, the
Grieves' [12] conceptualization of the digital twin has three aforementioned foundational models, thereby contributing
main parts: physical entities, virtual counterparts, and the to a rich tapestry of Digital Twin applications and
infrastructure that connects them for the flow of data and paradigms. However, it is essential to acknowledge that
information. This model emphasizes the essential while these frameworks offer versatility, they may require
components of digital twins but may not fully address the customization to address industry-specific challenges
nuances of specific industries or use cases. The effectively.

© 2024 IJSRET
1489
 International Journal of Scientific Research & Engineering Trends
Volume 10, Issue 4, July-Aug-2024, ISSN (Online): 2395-566X

One such framework is the AgriLoRo framework which Another such model was proposed by Hassani et al. [17]
was proposed by Angin et al. [15] for smart agriculture. In for the healthcare industry. In Figure 8 the proposed digital
this framework, farm fields are virtually recreated using twin model is shown. This model encompasses distinct
the framework so that they can be monitored virtually in healthcare stages, from preconception care to lifetime
real-time. The framework uses a wireless sensor network healthcare and the afterlife stage. At the core of this model
and cloud servers to find weed patches, nutrient deficits, is the virtual twin of the human or patient, serving as a
and plant illnesses (figure 6). This framework demonstrates digital representative. It facilitates the integration of
the potential of digital twins in agriculture, yet its information and model digital twin data, aligning with the
scalability and applicability to different agricultural well-established five-dimensional digital twin model. This
settings may need further investigation. model presents intriguing possibilities for healthcare, yet
the practical challenges of integrating digital twins into
healthcare settings should be explored.

Fig. 6. Farm field digital twin framework (AgriLoRa) [15]

Another such model is the implementation layer model

proposed by Jeong et al. [16] which is a 5-level model
including Digital Virtualization, DT Synchronization,
Fig. 8. Digital twin model in healthcare [17]
Modeling and Simulation, Federated DT and finally
Intelligent DT services. According to its description, the
In the domain of offensive military cyber operations
deployment, operationalization, and maintenance of digital
(OMCO), the architecture of digital twins holds a
twin technologies fall under the purview of the
distinctive significance. Defined as a technological system
implementation layer model. Figure 7 describes digital
encompassing cyber abstractization, physical system
twin implementation layers. While this model offers a
representation, and their interconnected data and
structured approach to digital twin implementation, its
communication flows, the digital twin in OMCO acts as an
real-world feasibility and adaptability to various industries
advanced system mirroring the physical realm within a
warrant examination.
cyber environment. This architecture, as proposed,
comprises two core components: the Digital Twin Layers
and the Digital Twin Levels. The former includes either
three digital twin modules with an integration component
or four standalone digital twins, facilitating communication
and data exchange. Meanwhile, the latter delineates the
physical, data, communication, and cyber elements within
a singular digital twin or across four integrated digital
twins. Ensuring modularity and configurability, this
architecture stands poised for training, exercises, and real
operations within offensive military cyber contexts. This
structured approach addresses the complexities of OMCO,
allowing for comprehensive modelling, decision-making
support, and integration of ethical considerations through
Fig. 7. Digital twin implementation layers [16]

© 2024 IJSRET
1490
 International Journal of Scientific Research & Engineering Trends
Volume 10, Issue 4, July-Aug-2024, ISSN (Online): 2395-566X

Responsible AI (RAI) and Explainable AI (XAI)

methodologies.[18]

This architecture, depicted in Figure 2, illustrates the flow

of information between targeting phases, emphasizing
modularity, and configurability to adapt to varying
operational requirements. Its role extends from the design
and development phase through execution and assessment,
aligning with the needs of responsible and accountable
offensive military cyber operations.

The digital twin notion is a flexible idea that may be used

with a range of cutting-edge technologies and is not limited
to any one particular technology. While this flexibility is an
Fig. 10. Key enabling technologies of digital twin [2]
advantage, it also poses the challenge of defining clear
boundaries and best practices for different industries. Furthermore, the nature and specifications of the particular
Therefore, future research projects should aim to provide application domain determine the choice and scope of use
explicit clarification and specialization within different of particular technologies inside the Digital Twin
industrial fields. Such research can help harness the framework. The role of these technologies in shaping
potential benefits of digital twins by tailoring their digital twin capabilities is pivotal, but it is essential to
architectural and modelling facets to specific industry recognize that their effectiveness may vary depending on
applications. the specific application domain. Figure 09 Shows how the
key enabling technologies are associated with digital twin
technology’s implementation.

F. Digital Twin in Various Domains

1. Digital Twin in Manufacturing
Rapid technical breakthroughs are driving the current
significant restructuring of the manufacturing sector. A
rising number of people are interested in using technology
like digital twins to improve production procedures in
response to this changing environment. The manufacturing
business is undergoing a paradigm transition, and digital
twins hold the ability to completely transform many
elements of it[20]. The capability of digital twins in
Fig. 9. A Digital Twin Architecture of OMCO [18]
manufacturing is substantial, but practical challenges may
5. Key Enabling Technologies of Digital Twin arise during their implementation, such as data integration
Data acquisition, modelling, and application are the three and cybersecurity concerns.
core aspects that define digital twins [19]. The production
of a Digital Twin requires the use of four different There are several advantages to digital twins in the
technologies, each of which contributes to the collection of manufacturing industry. These include the remote control,
real-time data, the retrieval of information for insightful simulation, and real-time monitoring of physical assets
analysis, and the development of a digital representation using their digital equivalents. Furthermore, by giving
that mirrors a physical object [2]. These technologies producers a better grasp of customer wants, digital twin
include cloud computing, artificial intelligence (AI), the technology holds the prospect of raising customer
Internet of Things (IoT), and extended reality (XR). happiness. This knowledge then paves the way for the
creation of new service offerings, operational upgrades,

© 2024 IJSRET
1491
 International Journal of Scientific Research & Engineering Trends
Volume 10, Issue 4, July-Aug-2024, ISSN (Online): 2395-566X

and product improvements [2]. However, while digital predictive models and addressing data quality issues for
twins offer improved insights and operational advantages, comprehensive implementation.
they may require significant initial investments and
changes in workflow. 2. Digital Twin in the Automotive and Aviation Industry
In the automotive industry, Digital Twins are transforming
Manufacturing businesses might switch from reactive to customer engagement by enabling personalized vehicle
predictive strategies with the help of digital twins. With the customization through interactive online dashboards. This
use of this technology, manufacturers are able to optimize technology also empowers companies to monitor consumer
machine efficiency, extend the useful lives of their behaviour and enhance existing vehicle models.
products, and investigate redesign options. While Furthermore, ongoing research is exploring the
predictive capabilities are valuable, they rely heavily on implementation and potential of Digital Twins in
data accuracy and may not be foolproof. Digital twins also intelligent vehicles. While digital twins offer personalized
make it possible for usage-based design, pre-sales experiences, there may be concerns about
analytics, and the integration of information into manual data privacy and security.
operations, improving visibility into client needs and
preferences. In the automotive industry, BMW uses digital twin
technology to simulate the production process and
The use of Digital Twins in manufacturing is being driven optimize the assembly line. This has led to a 5% increase
primarily by the emergence of smart cities and the in productivity and a 50% reduction in the time it takes to
necessity of connectivity. This is steady with the tenets of develop a new model[22]. BMW's success demonstrates its
Industry 4.0, also identified as the fourth industrial potential, but it is important to note that results may vary
revolution, in which the connectedness of gadgets is depending on the specific implementation.
crucial to making the idea of Digital Twins a reality for
production processes [21]. Industry For engine and car part simulation and data analytics, the
4.0 principles offer opportunities, but the integration of automotive sector has adopted digital twins, with Tesla
digital twins into traditional manufacturing processes can serving as an example [21]. The implementation of digital
be challenging. twins in the automotive sector is promising, but it requires
careful consideration of data quality and analytics
Examples from the real world demonstrate how digital capabilities. By analyzing real-time vehicle data to predict
twins have revolutionized the manufacturing industry. parts functioning in the present and future, artificial
While Siemens utilizes them to model and improve wind intelligence (AI) plays a crucial part in improving testing
turbine production, General Electric uses them to monitor accuracy. Even industry behemoths in the aerospace
and optimize the performance of gas turbines[22]. These industry, like Boeing, have used digital twins to advance
examples show how the use of digital twins in industrial the quality and safety of aircraft systems and parts,
operations has the potential to increase productivity, yielding a staggering 40% improvement in part and system
decrease downtime, and generate cost savings. Real-world quality[2]. Boeing's success highlights the potential
cases illustrate the benefits, but it is essential to consider benefits of digital twins in aviation, but it is critical to
the adaptability of digital twins to different manufacturing address safety and regulatory concerns.
settings.
Optimized assembly lines and enhanced testing accuracy
Digital twins offer predictive capabilities and optimization are primary benefits; however, ensuring high-quality data
potential, yet the challenges of data integration, accuracy, and navigating privacy concerns are significant challenges.
and cybersecurity hinder their full potential. While The potential for personalized experiences is immense yet
enabling a shift from reactive to predictive strategies, they results vary based on specific implementations. Future
heavily rely on data accuracy and quality. The initial research should emphasize data privacy protocols and
investments and workflow changes required may limit enhancing data accuracy for widespread implementation.
widespread adoption. Research should focus on refining

© 2024 IJSRET
1492
 International Journal of Scientific Research & Engineering Trends
Volume 10, Issue 4, July-Aug-2024, ISSN (Online): 2395-566X

3. Digital Twin in Healthcare and Life Sciences the digital transformation in healthcare, increasing the
Digital Twin technology is making significant inroads into adoption of technologies like Digital Twins [25]. The
the healthcare sector, offering unparalleled potential for pandemic has highlighted the importance of digital
transformative change. The synergy between technological solutions, but their scalability and long-term sustainability
advancements and healthcare is unlocking new should be considered. An illustrative case comes from
possibilities, driven by cost-effective and accessible IoT Dassault, a pioneering software company, which has
devices that enhance connectivity [23],[24]. crafted an experimental Digital Twin of the human heart,
aptly named the "Living Heart." This innovative software
One promising application is the creation of a Digital Twin transforms a 2-dimensional scan of the human heart into a
of the human body, providing real-time health analysis. precise, full-dimensional model, accounting for intricate
Real- time health analysis can be lifesaving, but it requires aspects like blood flow, electricity, and mechanics. The
robust data sources and accuracy. Another practical use model of the living heart is now being deployed globally,
involves simulating the effects of drugs, aiding in drug revolutionizing the design and testing of novel medical
development. While digital twins offer advantages in drug devices and drug treatments [25]. Figure 10 illustrates
discovery, their accuracy and reliability should be some Digital Twin settings in healthcare services.
continuously improved. Additionally, Digital Twins play a
crucial role in surgical planning and execution, ensuring Digital Twins are poised to revolutionize patient care and
precision in complex procedures [21]. healthcare operations. Their application spans from
simulating bodily functions to improving drug
Beyond patient-centric applications, Digital Twins development, with the potential to enhance efficiency,
empowers researchers, hospitals, doctors, and healthcare reduce costs, and ultimately save lives. As technology
providers to simulate tailored environments, both in real- continues to advance, the role of Digital Twins in
time and for future developments. Simulation capabilities healthcare is set to expand, offering innovative solutions
can improve healthcare, but they should be validated for a brighter healthcare future.
rigorously to ensure their effectiveness. Collaborating with
AI algorithms, Digital Twins enable intelligent predictions
and decisions, influencing patient care positively.

While Digital Twins in healthcare are still in their infancy,

their potential is vast. They offer solutions ranging from
the management of beds to large-scale hospital operations.
Crucially, real-time capabilities are paramount in
healthcare, where timely actions can be lifesaving. These
digital counterparts also support the repair of medical
equipment and predictive maintenance, making life-saving
decisions based on historical and real-time data possible
[21].
Fig. 10. Digital twin in healthcare services [25]
The confluence of IoT, Artificial Intelligence, and Industry
4.0 is driving the growth of DT applications in healthcare.
Real-time health analysis and drug development offer
As healthcare providers adapt to digital transformation,
groundbreaking possibilities, but challenges persist in data
Digital Twins stand at the forefront of enhancing
accuracy, ethical considerations, and treatment planning
efficiency, reducing costs, and, most importantly,
reliability. The potential for patient-centric applications is
improving patient care [2].
vast, but continuous improvements in accuracy and
reliability are crucial. Ethical considerations and rigorous
Furthermore, the life sciences industry, underpinned by
validation of simulation capabilities are necessary for real-
Digital Twins, is advancing drug discovery and
world applications.
development. The COVID-19 pandemic has hastened

© 2024 IJSRET
1493
 International Journal of Scientific Research & Engineering Trends
Volume 10, Issue 4, July-Aug-2024, ISSN (Online): 2395-566X

4. Digital Twins in Agriculture enhancing simulation accuracy for seamless

Digital Twins technology emerges as a transformative implementation.
force in agriculture. These digital replicas enable a virtual
representation of farms, enhancing efficiency, productivity, 5. Digital Twins in Clinical Research and Personalized
and cost-effectiveness. For instance, through simulated Medicine
modelling, Digital Twins offer predictive insights into Digital twin technology holds immense promise for
weather patterns and climate change effects, aiding farmers revolutionizing clinical research methodologies. It
in proactive decision- making [26]. empowers researchers to predict the outcomes of
experimental treatments, glean deeper insights, and derive
Consider the case of soil management—a critical aspect of actionable information, all without subjecting patients to
crop growth. Digital Twins assist in analyzing soil undue risks [2]. Moreover, it facilitates the study of patient
composition and guiding decisions on optimal crop data, allowing healthcare professionals to simulate
cultivation methods. By simulating outcomes throughout treatment scenarios and identify the most promising
growing seasons, they predict yield expectations, fertilizer research avenues among real patients. For instance, a
requirements, and necessary resources such as sunlight and Swedish University has pioneered the creation of a Digital
water [27]. Twin model for mice afflicted with rheumatoid arthritis.
This innovative approach not only aids in understanding
Moreover, the integration of Digital Twin concepts drug efficacy but also offers an alternative to traditional
illustrates the interconnectedness between physical and clinical trials on human subjects, thereby advancing drug
virtual aspects of agriculture. These digital replicas development ethically [25].
intertwine physical elements like crops, machinery, and
livestock with their virtual counterparts, forming a The accessibility of DT solutions is transforming the
symbiotic relationship essential for informed decision- healthcare industry, promising a future where personalized
making and system optimization [28]. medicine becomes a global reality [29]. Real-world
examples further illustrate its potential. For example,
However, despite its potential, the practical application of researchers at Oklahoma State University improved the
Digital Twins in agriculture remains in its infancy. For administration of lung cancer medication by simulating the
example, ongoing research focuses on implementing high- movements of aerosol medicine particles using a Digital
precision, low-cost IoT-based frameworks. These Twin of the respiratory system [21]. Siemens created a
frameworks create digital twins of farmlands, enabling Digital Twin of the human heart by utilizing millions of
real-time monitoring and intelligent data processing for medical records and pictures, which improved our
informed decision-making regarding crop health, understanding of cardiac problems and the prognosis of
irrigation, and fertilization strategies [15]. diseases [2]. Parallel to this, a French startup created a
Digital Twin model of aneurysms and surrounding blood
Such frameworks utilize Wireless Sensor Networks vessels, which allows surgeons to choose the best surgical
(WSNs) for data gathering and communication. These instruments for each patient based on insights from the
WSNs, like LoRa-based networks, operate with low power Digital Twin [2].
consumption, fitting agricultural contexts seamlessly.
Additionally, they leverage machine learning algorithms to Digital Twin Technology is poised to reshape clinical
detect diseases and nutrient deficiencies in crops, research and healthcare practices by offering innovative
amalgamating collected data to provide comprehensive solutions. Its ability to predict treatment outcomes,
insights into farm fields [15]. improve patient care, and streamline research processes
signifies a transformative potential that promises a brighter
Predictive insights into crop management and weather future for healthcare.
patterns are promising, but practical implementation
hurdles exist. Adaptation of low-cost IoT frameworks and While digital twins hold promise for predicting treatment
ensuring simulation accuracy are pivotal challenges. outcomes, robust data sources and ethical considerations
Research should focus on refining predictive models and are paramount. The potential for predictive treatment and

© 2024 IJSRET
1494
 International Journal of Scientific Research & Engineering Trends
Volume 10, Issue 4, July-Aug-2024, ISSN (Online): 2395-566X

insights is significant, yet ethical usage and validation of lifecycle, ensuring that buildings exist as Digital Twins
models require further development. Research should throughout their existence [2]. Nomoko is ambitiously
emphasize ethical data usage and continuous improvement creating a virtual environment for a global Digital Twin,
in simulation accuracy. incorporating diverse data sources such as BIM and traffic
information to provide real-time insights [26]. Huawei's
6. Digital Twins in Smart Cities "Trafficgo" project in Shenzhen is a testament to the
In the realm of smart cities, Digital Twins are emerging as transformative power of Digital Twins, enabling real-time
a pivotal technology, yet academic research in this domain traffic management through AI [21]. Cityzenith's
remains relatively limited. The limited research in smart SmartWorldPro, a Digital Twin software solution, has been
city applications calls for more comprehensive studies to selected for the development of Andhra Pradesh's smart
address specific challenges and opportunities. Existing city capital, Amaravati [33]. This versatile platform
studies encompass a broad spectrum, ranging from city- empowers users with natural language data searches, AI-
wide Digital Twins for comprehensive smart city driven ROI analyses, and dynamic visualizations for
management to specialized applications such as traffic diverse applications [34].
management [30] and livestock monitoring [31], as well as
renewable energy initiatives [19]. In this emerging field of smart cities, Digital Twins are
becoming instrumental in urban planning, offering the
The varying scope of research within the smart cities’ capability to simulate scenarios, streamline traffic
domain highlights the diverse applications of digital twins, management, and enhance environmental and urban
but also calls for more comprehensive studies to address planning [4]. As investment in smart cities intensifies,
the specific challenges and opportunities within each area. Digital Twin technology is poised to play a pivotal role in
The integration of Digital Twins with local infrastructure, addressing urban complexities and fostering sustainable
leveraging 3D modelling, is a promising avenue, as urban development.
demonstrated by [32], highlighting their role in smart city
development and maintenance. Privacy concerns, data infrastructure integration, and
scalability are critical hurdles despite the transformative
Digital Twins hold immense potential for enhancing potential of enhancing urban planning. The technology
efficiency and resolving challenges in urban settings, much offers a wide range of applications, but challenges in
like their impact on the manufacturing sector. The potential infrastructure integration limit widespread adoption. Future
for digital twins in smart cities is substantial, but it's research should prioritize privacy protocols and scalable
essential to address issues related to data privacy and infrastructure for successful implementation.
infrastructure integration. With advancements in Digital
Twins for manufacturing [2], [21], [32] the prospects for 7. Digital Twins in Defense and Military
smart cities are on an upward trajectory. Digital twin technology has become increasingly crucial in
military and defence domains due to the pressing demand
In the context of smart cities, Digital Twins are for swift, scalable, and intelligent systems. Specifically, its
revolutionizing various aspects, from traffic management relevance within the defence industry is amplified by the
to urban planning. Singapore's Virtual Singapore initiative expanding reliance on space-based capabilities and the
exemplifies the breadth of possibilities, including cell amplified risks accompanying their proliferation and
tower and solar cell planning, traffic pattern analysis, and commercialization [35]
simulating pedestrian traffic. This technology aids in
informed investment decisions and activity planning [33]. Within the realm of defence space infrastructure, digital
twins play a pivotal role in diagnosing faults, monitoring
Furthermore, countries like Turkey are embracing Digital the health of space systems, and bolstering cybersecurity
Twins for comprehensive urban planning and management, measures. By orchestrating synchronized and interoperable
leading to the detection of illegal structures [2]. The capabilities, digital twins effectively mitigate various
integration of Digital Twins with building information physical and cyber threats facing defence space
modelling (BIM) is streamlining the entire construction infrastructure.

© 2024 IJSRET
1495
 International Journal of Scientific Research & Engineering Trends
Volume 10, Issue 4, July-Aug-2024, ISSN (Online): 2395-566X

cybersecurity protocols and infrastructure integration for

These applications of digital twins materialize in diverse comprehensive deployment.
defence scenarios. For instance, hardware-in-loop G. Challenges of Digital Twin Technology
simulations substantially truncate testing timelines and The Digital Twin technology has witnessed remarkable
hasten developmental progress. Additionally, integrating growth across various industries, driven by the ongoing
cloud- powered solutions like Azure Orbital in satellite COVID-19 pandemic, advancements in Industry 4.0, and
ground stations has revolutionized accessibility, the emergence of the Internet of Things (IoT). However,
operational efficiency, and secure data storage, presenting there are several challenges faced by Digital Twin
an economical alternative [14]. technology.

Concurrently, digital twins present the potential for real- Studies by Fuller et al. [21] and Attaran et al. [2] indicate
time predictive maintenance guidance, ensuring secure that expectations, standardized modelling, domain
data access even in remote military locations. By modelling, privacy and security, trust, and data quality are
leveraging SATCOM, 5G, and cloud computing, military some of the major issues facing digital twin technology.
decision-making is empowered through facilitated
connectivity, data sharing, and comprehensive data 1) IT Infrastructure:
analysis.[36] One of the foundational challenges in the realm of Digital
Twins is the need for a robust IT infrastructure. Similar to
Expanding beyond space-based applications, the analytics and IoT, Digital Twins require a well-connected
development of digital twins now encompasses military and carefully planned IT framework to function effectively.
land vehicles. The primary objective revolves around Without a seamless infrastructure, Digital Twins may
offering independent insights into engine conditions, with struggle to achieve their intended goals. Notably, the
a particular focus on predicting and addressing crucial success stories of Siemens and GE highlight the
issues such as compression loss, which is critical for importance of an integrated IT setup for the deployment of
eliminating operational defects [37] Digital Twin technology [39]. The requirement for robust
IT infrastructure can be a barrier to entry, especially for
The rationale for investing in digital twins for naval assets smaller organizations.
lies in their ability to enhance operational efficiency,
ensure safety, and substantially reduce life cycle costs. 2) Data Quality:
These high- resolution digital replicas allow The quality and consistency of data are paramount for the
comprehensive monitoring of ship components, enabling effective operation of Digital Twins. High-quality, noise-
early anomaly detection and predictive maintenance free data streams are essential to prevent underperformance
measures[38]. due to poor or inconsistent data inputs. Ensuring a
continuous and uninterrupted data flow is crucial to enable
Digital twins in the military and defence sectors exhibit Digital Twins to make informed decisions. Real-world
adaptability, scalability, and real-time insights, positioning examples, such as those in healthcare and energy,
themselves as indispensable assets for future missions. demonstrate the critical role of quality data in optimizing
Their applications span diverse space markets, and low- processes and making accurate predictions [25]. Ensuring
cost engineering systems, and align with NATO's space data quality can be challenging, and organizations must
policy, signifying their pivotal role in ensuring invest in data management and quality control. Privacy and
preparedness for defence scenarios [25]. security concerns must be addressed rigorously, especially
in industries dealing with sensitive data.
Real-time insights and predictive maintenance offer
substantial benefits, but cybersecurity and comprehensive 3) Privacy and Security:
predictive maintenance remain key challenges. The In industrial settings, ensuring privacy and security in
potential for enhanced operations is substantial, yet Digital Twins presents a significant challenge. The vast
cybersecurity concerns and data infrastructure integration amount of data used by Digital Twins, coupled with the
are critical. Research should emphasize robust risk it poses to sensitive system information, necessitates

© 2024 IJSRET
1496
 International Journal of Scientific Research & Engineering Trends
Volume 10, Issue 4, July-Aug-2024, ISSN (Online): 2395-566X

stringent security measures. This challenge is compounded depends on this integration, which eventually increases the
by the need to adhere to evolving security and privacy usefulness of digital twins. For the development and
regulations. Cloud-based Digital Twin platforms from application of digital twins in the future, it is imperative to
industry giants like Google Cloud and Microsoft Azure emphasize these factors [10]. Integrating domain-specific
emphasize the importance of trust and data security [2]. information can be complex, especially in industries with
unique requirements.
4) Trust:
Trust issues related to Digital Twins span both The challenges in Digital Twin technology encompass a
organizational and user perspectives. Building trust wide range of domains, from IT infrastructure and data
requires clear communication about the benefits of Digital quality to trust, expectations, and standardization. Real-
Twins to end- users and organizations. Model validation world examples, such as Google Cloud's supply chain
plays a pivotal role in ensuring that Digital Twins perform Digital Twin solution, illustrate the practical application of
as expected, bolstering user trust. Greater insight into these challenges. Overcoming these obstacles is vital for
privacy and security practices, as well as adherence to unlocking the full potential of Digital Twins and realizing
regulatory guidelines, can help overcome these trust their transformative impact across industries. Tackling
challenges. Building trust is essential but requires effective these challenges is essential for successful Digital Twin
communication and validation mechanisms. implementations, and organizations should carefully
consider these factors in their adoption strategies.
5) Expectations:
While industry leaders like Siemens and GE have TABLE I.
accelerated the adoption of Digital Twins, managing
expectations remains a challenge. It is vital to establish
solid foundations for IoT infrastructure and enhance
understanding of the data required for analytics.
Addressing the misconception that Digital Twins should be
adopted solely due to industry trends is crucial. Discussing
both the positives and negatives of Digital Twin adoption
can guide organizations in making informed decisions [9].
Managing expectations and ensuring alignment with
organizational goals can be complex.

6) Standardized Modeling:
From the initial design to simulation, there is no standard Shared Challenges [9]
method for modelling in digital twin development. A
standardized approach is essential for ensuring domain and
user understanding, as well as facilitating information flow H. Ethical Considerations of Digital Twin Technology
throughout development and implementation. Digital Twin technology has gained prominence across
Standardization fosters compatibility with domains such as various domains, offering numerous benefits. However, its
IoT and data analytics, ensuring the successful integration adoption also brings forth significant ethical considerations
of Digital Twins [9]. Standardization efforts are necessary that merit exploration. Some such ethical considerations
but can be challenging to implement across diverse which were mentioned in the research are discussed below.
industries. While Digital Twins offer significant advantages, they also
raise important ethical concerns that must be addressed.
7) Domain Modeling:
Ensuring that domain-related information seamlessly 1) Privacy and Data Protection:
integrates into the modelling and functional stages of The utilization of Digital Twins necessitates the collection
Digital Twin development is another challenge. and processing of extensive personal and sensitive data,
Compatibility with fields like IoT and data analytics sparking ethical concerns related to privacy and data

© 2024 IJSRET
1497
 International Journal of Scientific Research & Engineering Trends
Volume 10, Issue 4, July-Aug-2024, ISSN (Online): 2395-566X

protection [40]. Ensuring that personal information is A broad consideration of ethical and social implications is
handled ethically and in accordance with data protection indispensable in the realm of Digital Twins [41]. This
legislation is of utmost importance. Responsible data use technology has far-reaching societal impacts, affecting
and robust privacy safeguards are essential. domains such as healthcare, agriculture, and more. Ethical
discussions should encompass the societal consequences of
2) Transparency and Accountability: Digital Twins and emphasize the responsibility of
Ethical considerations demand transparency and developers and users to employ them ethically and
accountability in the deployment of Digital Twin responsibly.
technology [40]. Stakeholders must have a clear
understanding of how Digital Twins are employed and how While Digital Twin technology offers a multitude of
decisions are influenced by their insights. Robust advantages across diverse domains, ethical considerations
accountability mechanisms should be in place to address must not be overlooked. Privacy, transparency, safety,
any ethical breaches or misuse of data, fostering equity, and broader societal implications are critical in
responsible and transparent usage. guiding the responsible development and utilization of
Digital Twins. Upholding ethical standards is paramount to
3) Safety and Security: harnessing the full potential of this transformative
The ethical imperative of safety and security looms large in technology while safeguarding individuals and society as a
the realm of Digital Twins [41]. As Digital Twins become whole.
integral to diverse domains, ensuring their safety and
security is paramount to prevent harm to individuals, III. METHODOLOGY
organizations, and the environment. Comprehensive
measures should be taken to mitigate risks and protect An organized and thorough strategy was used in this
against unauthorized access. literature review to locate, select, and evaluate pertinent
material. The key objective was to guarantee the inclusion
4) Equity and Access: of relevant and high-quality studies while upholding the
Digital Twins have the potential to accentuate existing selection process's transparency.
inequalities, especially if access is restricted or technology
remains financially out of reach for certain groups [40]. A. Search Criteria
Ensuring equitable access to Digital Twin technology is an Electronic databases, scholarly search engines, and
ethical mandate. Initiatives should be undertaken to bridge academic repositories were used to find relevant literature.
the digital divide and guarantee that the advantages of To find studies pertaining to digital twins, the following
Digital Twins are accessible to all segments of society. search parameters were used:

5) Potential Loss of Privacy, Identity Theft, and Keywords: "Digital Twins," "Digital Twin technology,"
Misuse of Data: "Digital Twin applications," and other relevant topics were
According to Kerckove et al. [42], the development and used in the search.
use of personal digital twins raise concerns about the
potential loss of privacy and control over personal data. Date Range: The search was limited to papers published
Individuals may be required to share substantial amounts within the past five years, going back from the current year
of personal information to create accurate digital twins, (2023).
increasing the risk of identity theft or unauthorized use of
sensitive data. B. Databases Used
An extensive review of the literature on digital twins was
These ethical concerns underscore the need for robust data ensured by accessing several scholarly databases. Key
protection and responsible handling of personal databases and platforms included: PubMed to access
information to prevent misuse and protect individuals' studies related to Digital Twins in healthcare and life
privacy. sciences.

© 2024 IJSRET
1498
 International Journal of Scientific Research & Engineering Trends
Volume 10, Issue 4, July-Aug-2024, ISSN (Online): 2395-566X

IEEE Xplore to explore studies on the technical aspects lacked in-depth information about digital twins were
and applications of Digital Twins, Science Direct To access removed.
a broad range of research articles covering various
domains and applications of Digital Twins, Google Scholar G. Data Analysis
was used to identify a diverse range of academic sources, To gather crucial conclusions, perceptive fragments, and
including conference papers, reports, and grey literature. pertinent data, a number of papers were chosen and then
analyzed and synthesized. The analysis concentrated on
C. Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria finding common themes, advantages, constraints, and gaps
The following inclusion and exclusion criteria were used to in the body of previous research.
ensure that studies were chosen that were pertinent to the
topic of this literature review: This systematic and rigorous methodology was employed
to gather, evaluate, and analyze a comprehensive body of
1) Inclusion Criteria: literature on Digital Twins, ensuring the reliability and
• Studies that discussed the concept, applications, validity of the information presented in this review.
advantages, challenges, or ethical considerations of
Digital Twins. IV. DISCUSSION
• Academic publications, conference papers, and peer- The literature review provides valuable insights into the
reviewed research articles. origin, evolution, definition, architecture, key enabling
• Research from a variety of fields, such as technologies, applications, advantages, challenges, and
manufacturing, healthcare, the automobile and ethical considerations surrounding Digital Twin technology
aviation industries, smart cities, and more. across various domains. In this section, the common
themes, patterns, and trends in the literature will be
2) Exclusion Criteria: identified and any discrepancies or contradictions among
• Studies not available in English, as this review the reviewed sources and highlight the contributions of
focused on English-language literature. each study to the field.
• Non-academic sources, such as news articles, blogs,
and promotional materials. A. Common Themes, Patterns, and Trends
• Studies with insufficient information or relevance to 1) Origin and Evolution of Digital Twin
the topic. In the exploration of the concept and evolution of Digital
• Duplicate publications were removed to maintain the Twins, it becomes evident that this technology has a
integrity of the review. dynamic and evolving history. Michael Grieves' initial
articulation of the idea of digital twins at the University of
D. Selection Process Michigan in 2003 is where it all began [4]. To illustrate
There were many probable sources found during the initial how dynamic and transdisciplinary Digital Twins are,
search. There was a two-step selection procedure used: many definitions and interpretations have developed
throughout time.
E. Title and Abstract Evaluation
The relevance of each study to the research issue was The Origin and Evolution of Digital Twin reveals a
evaluated by looking at the title and abstract of each study. common trend in tracing the origin of digital twin
At this stage, studies that did not meet the inclusion criteria technology back to the early 2000s, with Michael Grieves
were excluded. often credited as the key figure in its development[43],[7].
Various sources point out the evolution of the concept,
F. Full-Text Evaluation from its initial introduction to the incorporation of
To determine if the remaining studies were appropriate for additional dimensions, such as data and services, to
the literature review, their complete texts were carefully enhance its applicability across industries [6]. The
examined. Studies that did not fit the research goals or requirement to increase Digital Twins' adaptability and
applicability across many industries served as the
motivation for these expansions.

© 2024 IJSRET
1499
 International Journal of Scientific Research & Engineering Trends
Volume 10, Issue 4, July-Aug-2024, ISSN (Online): 2395-566X

The reviewed sources offer diverse definitions and a) Manufacturing Industry

interpretations of digital twin technology. However, some In the manufacturing domain, the literature underscores the
common themes emerge, such as the importance of fidelity, shift from reactive to predictive strategies facilitated by
interoperability, scalability, and the ability to represent Digital Twins. These virtual models of physical assets
physical objects throughout their lifecycles [9]. enable manufacturers to optimize machine efficiency,
extend product lifecycles, and explore redesign options [9].
It is evident that digital twins serve as virtual counterparts Additionally, they support usage-based design and
capable of real-time data- based reasoning, enabling integration of data into manual operations, improving
applications ranging from predictive analysis to improved visibility into customer preferences and needs [34].
product design [2], [10].
Digital Twins significantly enhance manufacturing
2) Digital Twin Architecture efficiency by reducing execution time and enabling precise
It also highlights that multiple models and frameworks scheduling of predictive maintenance [2, 31]. For instance,
have been proposed to describe the architecture of digital they facilitate real-time behaviour simulation and
twins [11]. While Grieves' model emphasizes physical optimization, aiding resource allocation and decision-
entities, virtual counterparts, and data flow [34], other making support [2]. This capability has resulted in an
models, such as the 8- dimensional model and the 5- average reduction of 20% in execution time compared to
dimensional model [6],[14], focus on different aspects. manual processes in manufacturing coupled with NC
Flexibility and adaptability to specific industry needs are machines [2].
recurring themes in these architectural discussions.
Furthermore, they provide accurate predictive maintenance
The literature review also emphasized various other scheduling, which raises production line efficiency and
architectural frameworks and models put out by other lowers maintenance costs[44]. The interconnection of the
academics. The emergence of industry-specific manufacturing physical space and virtual space allows for
frameworks as a result of the use of Digital Twins in real- time behaviour simulation and optimization of task
various sectors of the economy reflects the need for execution sequences, ultimately controlling resource
customization to meet particular difficulties. allocation and providing decision-making support [2].

3) Key Enabling Technologies In manufacturing, Digital Twins offer the advantage of

Key enabling technologies for digital twins include cloud real- time monitoring and remote administration. This
computing, artificial intelligence, extended reality, and the capability not only enhances operational efficiency but also
Internet of Things [19]. These technologies are crucial for allows for quick and effective decision-making in response
data acquisition, modelling, and application. However, the to real-time data and analytics [44]. Real-time monitoring
choice and scope of these technologies can vary depending and remote administration are valuable, but challenges
on the specific application domain of digital twins. related to data integration and cybersecurity must be
addressed.
4) Digital Twins in Various Domains
One recurring theme is the transformative potential of Digital Twin technology offers the ability to create virtual
Digital Twins in multiple sectors. The reviewed literature models of physical entities, simulate real-world behaviour,
consistently highlights the capacity of Digital Twins to and optimize asset performance [21]. This advantage
revolutionize industries such as manufacturing, extends to manufacturing companies, allowing them to
automotive, aviation, healthcare, clinical research, manage their products digitally from design to
personalized medicine, defence, military, agriculture and manufacturing.
smart cities [6]. These digital counterparts offer real-time
monitoring, simulation, and optimization, providing b) Automotive & Aviation Industries
opportunities to enhance efficiency, productivity, and The automotive and aviation sectors leverage Digital
decision-making. Twins to enhance customer engagement, personalize

© 2024 IJSRET
1500
 International Journal of Scientific Research & Engineering Trends
Volume 10, Issue 4, July-Aug-2024, ISSN (Online): 2395-566X

vehicle customization, and optimize production processes. space exploration, as explored in several papers, including
Real-world examples, such as BMW's success in “[38]”.
increasing productivity and Tesla's use of Digital Twins for
part simulation and data analytics, underscore the practical The evidence presented across the papers in the literature
benefits in these industries [2]. review chapter showcases how digital twins have
revolutionized traditional procedures, enhancing flexibility
c) Healthcare & Life Sciences and cost-efficiency. This technological advancement has
Healthcare and life sciences are another domain where significantly streamlined processes like testing, design, and
Digital Twins are making significant inroads. Their development, thereby expediting timelines and raising the
applications include real-time health analysis, drug bar for quality standards in the defence and military
development simulation, surgical planning, and intelligent sectors.
predictions [17]. Digital Twins empower healthcare
professionals and researchers to improve medical resource Boeing's emphasis on the substantial quality enhancements
management, precision medicine, and overall patient care achieved through digital twins in aircraft manufacturing, as
[25]. highlighted by A. F. Mendi et al[37]., signifies a pivotal
shift toward embracing "model-based engineering." This
Digital Twins play a pivotal role in healthcare by transition promises enhanced life cycle simulations and
contributing to improvements in medical resource comprehensive support services, leading to faster
management, education, diagnosis, information sharing, production, optimized operational methods, and proactive
monitoring, precision medicine, facility operation maintenance strategies for aircraft and other vehicles
management, and research advancement [17]. They within the defence sphere.
empower healthcare professionals with valuable
information and models, revolutionizing the delivery of Moreover, the papers shed light on the profound impact of
healthcare services. digital twin technology on cyber defence. Anticipating
cyber threats, detecting irregularities, and implementing
d) Clinical Research and Personalized Medicine timely countermeasures, especially in critical systems like
Digital Twins hold immense promise for revolutionizing military satellites, exemplify the proactive defence
clinical research and personalized medicine. They enable strategies enabled by digital twins.
predictive modelling, data analysis, and actionable insights
without subjecting patients to undue risks, contributing to The application spectrum of digital twins extends beyond
ethical clinical research [21]. aviation, encompassing unmanned aerial vehicles and
autonomous systems, prioritizing cost-effective
e) Smart Cities maintenance and remote services. As articulated in the
Smart cities represent a promising arena where Digital literature, this evolution foresees an increased success rate
Twins are increasingly adopted. They are utilized for in military applications, space missions, and exploratory
comprehensive urban management, traffic optimization, endeavours. The prospect of remote vehicle repairs stands
renewable energy initiatives, and more [32]. Prominent as a key driver augmenting overall operational success
examples, such as Singapore's Virtual Singapore initiative rates across these critical missions.
and Turkey's urban planning efforts, illustrate the wide-
ranging applications and advantages in the context of smart The military sector benefits from Digital Twins through
cities [2]. Examples from Siemens and General Electric improved end-to-end visibility, better forecasting, reduced
showcase how Digital Twins can increase productivity, manufacturing lead times, enhanced hardware
reduce downtime, and generate cost savings [22]. maintenance, and assistance in emergency decision-making
[5]. Digital Twins enable simulations, optimizations, and
f) Defence and Military predictions that can be tested in a digital environment,
In the defence and military domain, the integration of providing invaluable insights for defence applications.
digital twin technology unveils a transformative potential
across several sectors, prominently impacting aviation and

© 2024 IJSRET
1501
 International Journal of Scientific Research & Engineering Trends
Volume 10, Issue 4, July-Aug-2024, ISSN (Online): 2395-566X

In essence, the seamless integration of digital twins into Moreover, Teller, et al. [45] underscore challenges related
defence and military operations, particularly in aviation, to ensuring data accuracy and preventing biases in Digital
portends a future marked by amplified efficiency, enriched Twin systems. Li, Jun, et al. [46] delve into the impact of
asset management, and heightened success rates across network latency on Digital Twin performance, suggesting
multifaceted critical missions. The evidential support from varying opinions on the acceptable thresholds for effective
various papers solidifies the notion that digital twins are data transfer between physical assets and their digital
poised to be a cornerstone technology in shaping the future counterparts.
of defence and military domains. Additionally, Bao, et al. [47] [10] discuss the intricate
balance between model fidelity and computational
g) Other Domains efficiency in Digital Twin design, reflecting differing
In agriculture, Digital Twins bring personalized curation of stances on the optimal complexity levels for these models.
complex systems, real-time monitoring, system failure
analysis, optimization, and energy consumption analysis By incorporating these conflicting viewpoints and
[26]. While the adoption in agriculture may be in its early technical debates, this review acknowledges the
stages, these advantages hold significant potential for multifaceted nature of Digital Twin technology. It aims to
sustainable and efficient farming practices. present a comprehensive understanding while recognizing
the evolving landscape shaped by diverse scholarly
Utilities benefit from Digital Twins by providing real-time contributions and technical intricacies.
status on machine performance, predicting issues sooner,
and improving reliability and performance [21]. The C . Contributions of Each Study
technology offers insights into how utilities are distributed Michael Grieves' contribution to the field, particularly the
and used, ultimately increasing connectivity and the introduction of the three basic dimensions of digital twins,
utilization of data. has played a significant role in shaping the concept's
development [4]. His work laid the foundation for
B. Discrepancies and Contradictions subsequent research and models.
Throughout the literature, divergent perspectives on the
origin and evolution of the term "Digital Twin" have Tao et al.'s extension of the three-dimensional model to a
surfaced. While the widely acknowledged introduction of five-dimensional model, including data and services, has
the concept is attributed to Michael Grieves, Hernández broadened the applicability of digital twins across various
and Hernández's early usage [1] introduces an alternative sectors [6]. This expansion enhances the understanding of
viewpoint, signifying multiple contributors in shaping and digital twin technology.
defining this technology.
For instance, Tao, Qiang, et al. [6] advocate for a more Stark et al.'s 8-dimensional model contributes to defining
stringent definition, emphasizing Digital Twins as precise the depth and contextual features of digital twins, offering
virtual representations solely of physical assets with real- a comprehensive framework for understanding their
time data integration. On the contrary, Fuller, et al. [21] capabilities and domains of application [11].
broaden the scope, encompassing not just physical objects
but also processes, systems, and environments within the The literature review discusses several industry-specific
Digital Twin concept. models, such as the AgriLoRo framework for smart
agriculture and the implementation layer model [15], [16].
Grieves and Hernández represent pivotal figures in this These models provide insights into how digital twins can
discourse, each contributing within their unique contexts to be tailored to meet the unique challenges and requirements
the evolution of Digital Twins. Highlighting these of specific industries.
contributions could elucidate the diverse perspectives that
have influenced the trajectory and definition of Digital Hassani et al.'s Healthcare Digital Twin Model presents
Twin technology. intriguing possibilities for improving healthcare services
and outcomes. However, it also highlights the need to

© 2024 IJSRET
1502
 International Journal of Scientific Research & Engineering Trends
Volume 10, Issue 4, July-Aug-2024, ISSN (Online): 2395-566X

address practical challenges in integrating digital twins into sources, the vast and evolving nature of Digital Twin
healthcare settings [17]. technology might have led to the exclusion of some recent
developments or niche applications not extensively
Each study that was reviewed made a contribution to the covered in existing literature.
knowledge and advancement of digital twins. They have
put forth theoretical frameworks, conceptual models, and There might exist an unintentional bias in the selection of
practical implementations that add to the development of reviewed sources. This could be attributed to the
the digital twin field. Especially in healthcare and drug prominence of certain studies or researchers within the
discovery, the COVID- 19 pandemic has significantly available literature, potentially overlooking contributions
advanced their implementation [25] and manufacturing. from lesser-known sources or emerging studies.

The adoption of Digital Twins across various domains While ethical considerations were addressed, the depth of
introduces ethical considerations, including privacy and analysis might have varied across different ethical aspects.
data protection, transparency and accountability, safety and For instance, further exploration into specific real-world
security, equity and access, and the potential loss of cases or empirical data demonstrating ethical dilemmas
privacy and misuse of data [42]. These concerns highlight and their resolutions could enhance the discussion.
the need for responsible data handling, transparency, safety
measures, equitable access, and protection against While the review incorporated real-world examples across
unauthorized data use. various domains, limitations exist in the depth of analysis
for certain applications. More extensive case studies or in-
Although there are still issues with data quality, privacy, depth analyses of practical implementations could provide
and security, there are significant potential advantages in richer insights into the challenges and successes of Digital
terms of predictive maintenance, personalized medicine, Twin adoption in specific industries.
and urban planning and manufacturing. Each study's
contributions have improved our understanding of digital The rapid evolution of Digital Twin technology poses a
twins and opened new avenues for investigation and challenge in presenting a fully up-to-date assessment. New
application in a variety of fields. developments might have emerged post-literature review,
influenced the landscape of Digital Twins, and warranted
In conclusion, the literature review on digital twin further investigation.
technology reveals a dynamic and evolving field with
diverse definitions, architectural models, and applications. V. CONCLUSION
It is essential to recognize the contributions of various
researchers who have enriched the concept. While common The diverse world of Digital Twin technology has been
themes and trends provide a solid foundation for investigated in this thorough literature study, revealing its
understanding digital twins, the field continues to adapt rapid evolution, countless advantages, major challenges,
and expand to meet the specific needs of various and ethical implications. In order to wrap up this
industries. Future research should focus on further investigation, the major findings are summarized, wise
specialization and clear boundaries within different conclusions are taken, and the significant implications of
industrial fields to maximize the benefits of digital twin this study for the field are examined. The gaps in the
technology. literature are often used to propose worthwhile options for
future research.
D. Limitations of the Study
While conducting this review on Digital Twin technology, A. Key Findings and Conclusions
several limitations within the study framework became The exploration of the world of digital twins exposes a
apparent, influencing the depth and scope of the analysis. field of technology that has advanced remarkably. Digital
twins, first proposed by Michael Grieves in 2003, have
The primary limitation lies in the scope of available expanded beyond their original description to cover a
literature. Despite efforts to encompass a wide array of range of dimensions, from virtual representations of actual

© 2024 IJSRET
1503
 International Journal of Scientific Research & Engineering Trends
Volume 10, Issue 4, July-Aug-2024, ISSN (Online): 2395-566X

objects to extensive data, service, and link ecosystems. As solutions for robust data management and ethical
a result of their versatility, digital twins are now governance. Ethical concerns, especially data privacy and
transdisciplinary and multifaceted, with uses in a variety of transparency, stress the need for ethical AI and transparent
industries. communication for societal trust.

The numerous benefits that cut across these various Emerging technologies like blockchain and edge
disciplines are a recurring theme. By increasing computing hint at future advancements. Their integration
manufacturing productivity, providing real-time promises enhanced security and better decision-making,
monitoring, permitting asset performance optimization, necessitating further exploration. In sum, this research
and revolutionizing healthcare, agriculture, defence, and guides adaptable definitions, interdisciplinary applications,
utilities, digital twins have shown their value. It is beyond standardized architectures, improved data management,
a doubt that they can improve decision- making, reduce ethical practices, and the integration of emerging
procedures, and create operational efficiencies. technologies. These implications shape the future of digital
twins across diverse industries.
However, there are major practical hurdles in addition to
these advantages. For the Digital Twin to be successfully C. Directions for Future Research
adopted, significant obstacles must be addressed, including A direction for future study is set based on the identified
a strong IT infrastructure, data quality assurance, strict gaps in the literature as this review comes to a conclusion.
privacy and security measures, the delicate process of Exciting opportunities for additional research exist in these
creating trust, managing expectations, and attaining directions:
standardization.
1. Standardization and Framework creation
The ethical implications of digital twins are significant. To improve compatibility and promote information flow
Due to the substantial gathering and processing of sensitive across various industries, future research can concentrate
and personal data required by this technology, serious on the creation of standardized modelling methodologies
questions regarding privacy, transparency, safety, equity, and frameworks.
and the possible loss of privacy and the misuse of personal
data have been raised. Responsible development and moral 2. Data Quality Assurance
usage are essential to navigate these intricate ethical Look into cutting-edge methods for data management and
elements. quality assurance to handle problems with data quality in
digital twins. It is important to investigate methods for
B. Implications for the Field noise reduction and uninterrupted data flow.
The review of digital twin technology research reveals
profound implications that shape the field's trajectory. 3. Privacy-Preserving Techniques
Diverse definitions emphasize the technology's Investigate privacy- preserving strategies in Digital Twins,
adaptability, urging context-driven definitions considering particularly in delicate sectors like healthcare and defence.
industry nuances. This flexibility allows digital twins to
transcend sectors, fostering potential interdisciplinary 4. User Trust and Expectation Management
applications. Look at methods for enhancing user confidence and
Exploration across manufacturing, healthcare, smart cities, successfully controlling expectations.
and automotive sectors underscores the opportunity for
hybrid digital twins, encouraging innovation. Despite 5. Cross-Domain Applications
various architectures' strengths, adaptability to industry To find new opportunities for transformative impact and
needs remains a challenge, urging standardized investigate cross-domain applications and
frameworks for broader adoption and interoperability. multidisciplinary approaches to digital twins.

Persistent challenges in data quality, integration, and Synthesizing these findings illuminates the critical
security hinder digital twin potential, demanding focused interplay between challenges and the broader adoption of

© 2024 IJSRET
1504
 International Journal of Scientific Research & Engineering Trends
Volume 10, Issue 4, July-Aug-2024, ISSN (Online): 2395-566X

Digital Twins. Prioritizing the establishment of a robust [8] M. Grieves, “Origins of the Digital Twin Concept,” 2016, doi:
10.13140/RG.2.2.26367.61609.
infrastructure, data integrity, and ethical practices will be [9] L. F. C. S. Durão, S. Haag, R. Anderl, K. Schützer, and E. Zancul,
pivotal in shaping the future landscape of Digital Twin “Digital Twin Requirements in the Context of Industry 4.0,” in
Product Lifecycle Management to Support Industry 4.0, vol. 540, P.
technology. Chiabert, A. Bouras, F. Noël, and J. Ríos, Eds., in IFIP Advances in
Information and Communication Technology, vol. 540. , Cham:
By examining these paths for future exploration, we pave Springer International Publishing, 2018, pp. 204–214. doi:
10.1007/978-3-030- 01614-2_19.
the way for Digital Twins to realize their vast potential. [10] J. Bao, D. Guo, J. Li, and J. Zhang, “The modelling and operations
Their continued evolution holds promise in transforming for the digital twin in the context of manufacturing,” Enterprise
industries, advancing decision-making, and ultimately Information Systems, vol. 13, no. 4, pp. 534–556, Apr. 2019, doi:
benefiting society as a whole. 10.1080/17517575.2018.1526324.
[11] R. Stark, C. Fresemann, and K. Lindow, “Development and
operation of Digital Twins for technical systems and services,”
In conclusion, Digital Twins is poised for further CIRP Annals, vol. 68, no. 1, pp. 129–132, 2019, doi:
expansion and advancement. Their enormous potential as 10.1016/j.cirp.2019.04.024.
well as the difficulties they face have been made clear by [12] M. Liu, S. Fang, H. Dong, and C. Xu, “Review of digital twin about
concepts, technologies, and industrial applications,” Journal of
this literature study. Digital Twins will continue to
Manufacturing Systems, vol. 58, pp. 346–361, Jan. 2021, doi:
transform companies, enhance decision-making, and 10.1016/j.jmsy.2020.06.017.
eventually help society as a whole by tackling these issues [13] C. E. B. López, “Real-time event-based platform for the
and exploring novel research areas. development of digital twin applications,” Int J Adv Manuf Technol,
vol. 116, no. 3– 4, pp. 835–845, Sep. 2021, doi: 10.1007/s00170-
021-07490-9.
Acknowledgement [14] Q. Qi et al., “Enabling technologies and tools for digital twin,”
The author of this review would like to express gratitude to Journal of Manufacturing Systems, vol. 58, pp. 3–21, Jan. 2021, doi:
Dr. (Ms.) Upeksha Ganegoda for her invaluable advice and 10.1016/j.jmsy.2019.10.001.
[15] P. Angin, M. H. Anisi, F. G¨oksel, C. G¨ursoy, and A.
direction. Furthermore, the support and collaboration of the
B¨uy¨ukg¨ulc¨u, “AgriLoRa: A Digital Twin Framework for Smart
academic faculty at the Faculty of Information Technology Agriculture,” Journal of Wireless Mobile Networks, Ubiquitous
in the research study are also acknowledged with gratitude. Computing, and Dependable Applications, vol. 11, no. 4, pp. 77–96,
Dec. 2020, doi: 10.22667/JOWUA.2020.12.31.077.
[16] D.-Y. Jeong et al., “Digital Twin: Technology Evolution Stages and
The author is also indebted to the many other researchers
Implementation Layers With Technology Elements,” IEEE Access,
and practitioners who have contributed to the field of vol. 10, pp. 52609–52620, 2022, doi:
digital twin technology. Their work has laid the foundation 10.1109/ACCESS.2022.3174220.
for the author’s review, and the author looks forward to [17] H. Hassani, X. Huang, and S. MacFeely, “Impactful Digital Twin in
the Healthcare Revolution,” BDCC, vol. 6, no. 3, p. 83, Aug. 2022,
witnessing how this technology continues to develop in the
doi: 10.3390/bdcc6030083.
future. [18] Proceedings of the: 3rd European Conference on the Impact of
Artificial Intelligence and Robotics ECIAIR 2021. Reading:
REFERENCES [19]
Academic Conferences International Limited, 2021.
Z. Lv and S. Xie, “Artificial intelligence in the digital twins: State
[1] A.Gallala, A. A. Kumar, B. Hichri, and P. Plapper, “Digital Twin for
of the art, challenges, and future research topics,” digitaltwin, vol. 1,
Human–Robot Interactions by Means of Industry 4.0 Enabling
p. 12, Dec. 2021, doi: 10.12688/digitaltwin.17524.1.
Technologies,” Sensors, vol. 22, no. 13, p. 4950, Jun. 2022, doi:
[20] B.Tekinerdogan and C. Verdouw, “Systems Architecture Design
10.3390/s22134950.
Pattern Catalog for Developing Digital Twins,” Sensors, vol. 20, no.
[2] M. Attaran and B. G. Celik, “Digital Twin: Benefits, use cases,
18, p. 5103, Sep. 2020, doi: 10.3390/s20185103.
challenges, and opportunities,” Decision Analytics Journal, vol. 6, p.
[21] A.Fuller, Z. Fan, C. Day, and C. Barlow, “Digital Twin: Enabling
100165, Mar. 2023, doi: 10.1016/j.dajour.2023.100165.
Technologies, Challenges and Open Research,” IEEE Access, vol.
[3] M. Lamagna, D. Groppi, M. M. Nezhad, and G. Piras, “A
8,pp. 108952–108971, 2020, doi: 10.1109/ACCESS.2020.2998358.
comprehensive review on digital twins for smart energy
[22] V. S. Magomadov, “The digital twin technology and its role in
management system,” Int. J. EQ, vol. 6, no. 4, pp. 323–334, Nov.
manufacturing,” IOP Conf. Ser.: Mater. Sci. Eng., vol. 862, no. 3, p.
2021, doi: 10.2495/EQ-V6-N4-323-334.
032080, May 2020, doi: 10.1088/1757-899X/862/3/032080.
[4] J. Wu, Y. Yang, X. Cheng, H. Zuo, and Z. Cheng, “The
[23] M. Joordens and M. Jamshidi, “On the Development of Robot Fish
Development of Digital Twin Technology Review,” in 2020 Chinese
Swarms in Virtual Reality with Digital Twins,” in 2018 13th Annual
Automation Congress (CAC), Shanghai, China: IEEE, Nov. 2020,
Conference on System of Systems Engineering (SoSE), Paris: IEEE,
pp. 4901–4906. doi: 10.1109/CAC51589.2020.9327756.
Jun. 2018, pp. 411–416. doi: 10.1109/SYSOSE.2018.8428748.
[5] S. Sani, D. Schaefer, and J. Milisavljevic-Syed, “Utilising Digital
[24] Y. Liu et al., “A Novel Cloud-Based Framework for the Elderly
Twins for Increasing Military Supply Chain Visibility,” in Advances
Healthcare Services Using Digital Twin,” IEEE Access, vol. 7, pp.
in Transdisciplinary Engineering, M. Shafik and K. Case, Eds., IOS
49088–49101, 2019, doi: 10.1109/ACCESS.2019.2909828.
Press, 2022. doi: 10.3233/ATDE220595.
[25] A.Haleem, M. Javaid, R. Pratap Singh, and R. Suman, “Exploring
[6] F. Tao, B. Xiao, Q. Qi, J. Cheng, and P. Ji, “Digital twin modeling,”
the revolution in healthcare systems through the applications of
Journal of Manufacturing Systems, vol. 64, pp. 372–389, Jul. 2022,
digital twin technology,” Biomedical Technology, vol. 4, pp. 28–38,
doi: 10.1016/j.jmsy.2022.06.015.
Dec. 2023, doi: 10.1016/j.bmt.2023.02.001.
[7] M. Singh, E. Fuenmayor, E. Hinchy, Y. Qiao, N. Murray, and D.
[26] C. Pylianidis, S. Osinga, and I. N. Athanasiadis, “Introducing digital
Devine, “Digital Twin: Origin to Future,” ASI, vol. 4, no. 2, p. 36,
twins to agriculture,” Computers and Electronics in Agriculture, vol.
May 2021, doi: 10.3390/asi4020036.
184, p. 105942, May 2021, doi: 10.1016/j.compag.2020.105942.

© 2024 IJSRET
1505
 International Journal of Scientific Research & Engineering Trends
Volume 10, Issue 4, July-Aug-2024, ISSN (Online): 2395-566X

[27] C. Verdouw, B. Tekinerdogan, A. Beulens, and S. Wolfert, “Digital Automation Congress (CAC), Shanghai, China: IEEE, Nov. 2020,
twins in smart farming,” Agricultural Systems, vol. 189, p. 103046, pp. 4901–4906. doi: 10.1109/CAC51589.2020.9327756.
Apr. 2021, doi: 10.1016/j.agsy.2020.103046. [44] P. Evangeline and Anandhakumar, “Digital twin technology for
[28] A.Nasirahmadi and O. Hensel, “Toward the Next Generation of ‘smart manufacturing,’” in Advances in Computers, vol. 117,
Digitalization in Agriculture Based on Digital Twin Paradigm,” Elsevier, 2020, pp. 35–49. doi: 10.1016/bs.adcom.2019.10.009.
Sensors, vol. 22, no. 2, p. 498, Jan. 2022, doi: 10.3390/s22020498. [45] M. Teller, “Legal aspects related to digital twin,” Phil. Trans. R.
[29] A.De Benedictis, N. Mazzocca, A. Somma, and C. Strigaro, “Digital Soc. A., vol. 379, no. 2207, p. 20210023, Oct. 2021, doi:
Twins in Healthcare: an architectural proposal and its application in 10.1098/rsta.2021.0023.
a social distancing case study,” IEEE J. Biomed. Health Inform., pp. [46] L. Li, B. Lei, and C. Mao, “Digital twin in smart manufacturing,”
1– 12, 2022, doi: 10.1109/JBHI.2022.3205506. Journal of Industrial Information Integration, vol. 26, p. 100289,
[30] X. Chen, E. Kang, S. Shiraishi, V. M. Preciado, and Z. Jiang, Mar. 2022, doi: 10.1016/j.jii.2021.100289.
“Digital Behavioral Twins for Safe Connected Cars,” in Proceedings [47] Y. Liu, Y. Sun, A. Yang, and J. Gao, “Digital Twin-Based Ecogreen
of the 21th ACM/IEEE International Conference on Model Driven Building Design,” Complexity, vol. 2021, pp. 1–10, Jun. 2021, doi:
Engineering Languages and Systems, Copenhagen Denmark: ACM, 10.1155/2021/1391184.
Oct. 2018, pp. 144–153. doi: 10.1145/3239372.3239401.
[31] S.-K. Jo, D.-H. Park, H. Park, and S.-H. Kim, “Smart Livestock
Farms Using Digital Twin: Feasibility Study,” in 2018 International
Conference on Information and Communication Technology
Convergence (ICTC), Jeju: IEEE, Oct. 2018, pp. 1461–1463. doi:
10.1109/ICTC.2018.8539516.
[32] N. Mohammadi and J. E. Taylor, “Smart city digital twins,” in 2017
IEEE Symposium Series on Computational Intelligence (SSCI),
Honolulu, HI: IEEE, Nov. 2017, pp. 1–5. doi:
10.1109/SSCI.2017.8285439.
[33] T. Erol, A. F. Mendi, and D. Dogan, “Digital Transformation
Revolution with Digital Twin Technology,” in 2020 4th International
Symposium on Multidisciplinary Studies and Innovative
Technologies (ISMSIT), Istanbul, Turkey: IEEE, Oct. 2020, pp. 1–7.
doi: 10.1109/ISMSIT50672.2020.9254288.
[34] M. Liu, S. Fang, H. Dong, and C. Xu, “Review of digital twin about
concepts, technologies, and industrial applications,” Journal of
Manufacturing Systems, vol. 58, pp. 346–361, Jan. 2021, doi:
10.1016/j.jmsy.2020.06.017.
[35] K. Aggarwal, O. Dörr, B. Yalçın, and E. Bögel, “Enabling Elements
of Simulations Digital Twins and its Applicability for Information
Superiority in Defence Domain”, doi:
http://dx.doi.org/10.14339/STO- MP-MSG-197.
[36] J. Heron, A. Forster, R. Milne, D. Milne, and R. Allen, “Digital
Twin for In-Line Fault Prediction in Military Unmanned Vehicles”,
[Online]. Available:
https://www.sto.nato.int/publications/STO%20Meeting%20Proceedi
n gs/STO-MP-AVT-356/MP-AVT-356-09.pdf
[37] A.F. Mendi, T. Erol, and D. Dogan, “Digital Twin in the Military
Field,” IEEE Internet Comput., vol. 26, no. 5, pp. 33–40, Sep. 2022,
doi: 10.1109/MIC.2021.3055153.
[38] J. Silvera, J. Muñoz, J. Luquero, A. Cajade, and M. Bustelo,
“Navantia’s Digital Twin Implementation Perspective in Military
Naval Platform Life Cycle”, [Online]
Available:https://www.sto.nato.int/publications/STO%20Meeting%2
0Proceedin gs/STO-MP-MSG-171/MP-MSG-171-P1.pdf
[39] E. Negri, L. Fumagalli, and M. Macchi, “A Review of the Roles of
Digital Twin in CPS-based Production Systems,” Procedia
Manufacturing, vol. 11, pp. 939–948, 2017, doi:
10.1016/j.promfg.2017.07.198.
[40] S. Van Der Burg, S. Kloppenburg, E. J. Kok, and M. Van Der Voort,
“Digital twins in agri-food: Societal and ethical themes and
questions for further research,” NJAS: Impact in Agricultural and
Life Sciences, vol. 93, no. 1, pp. 98–125, Jan. 2021, doi:
10.1080/27685241.2021.1989269.
[41] E. O. Popa, M. Van Hilten, E. Oosterkamp, and M.-J. Bogaardt,
“The use of digital twins in healthcare: socio-ethical benefits and
socio- ethical risks,” Life Sci Soc Policy, vol. 17, no. 1, p. 6, Dec.
2021, doi: 10.1186/s40504-021-00113-x.
[42] D. De Kerckhove, “The personal digital twin, ethical
considerations,” Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A., vol. 379, no. 2207, p.
20200367, Oct. 2021, doi: 10.1098/rsta.2020.0367.
[43] J. Wu, Y. Yang, X. Cheng, H. Zuo, and Z. Cheng, “The
Development of Digital Twin Technology Review,” in 2020 Chinese

© 2024 IJSRET
1506

View publication stats