Indo Pak
Indo Pak
Omega Branch
HEARTSMUN 2024
Breaking Barriers, Building Bridges & Connecting Hearts
The Executive Board warmly welcomes you to this edition of India Pakistan Special
Summit under the banner of HeartsMUN’24. This special summit will focus on
building/repairing the already existing relationships between India and Pakistan
while also looking after disputes between the attending members and hopefully
attaining a peaceful settlement of disputes. The committee will be simulated with a
freeze date of 11th July 2024 with the sole agenda being to contemplate issues and
settling with the aim of attaining peace.
The Background guide covers important topics and sub-sections which will aid and
supplement you in your research. However, we as the Executive Board or the EB,
expect the delegates to abide by their countries stances and perform their own
research other than what is already given in the Background Guide. Keep in mind,
this Background guide is just a wormhole into the issue being discussed.
The delegates are welcome to text us personally in regards to any clarification or help
required.
Regards,
The Executive Board of India Pakistan Summit
T S Abhishek, Chairperson, +91 8903277297
Karthik Sriram, Chairperson, +91 9884991501
Delegates, it is imperative that all of you understand the fact that, this committee is
literally what it says. It is an India-Pakistan Special Summit which has been set up
entirely to promote peace talks between the 2 neighbouring nations. However, it is
completely within your right to try and stir up controversy as this is a simulation of
real-world talks, where talks are occasionally fruitful.
This committee shall have 4 representatives from India and Pakistan, namely the
Prime Minister, the External Affairs Minister, the National Security Advisor and the
Defense Minister.
There are 5 more countries which will be represented by their leader of the
government. These 5 countries will be the United States of America, the United
Kingdom of Great Britain & Northern Ireland, the French Republic, the People’s
Republic of China, and the Russian Federation.
Aside from these 13 portfolios, we shall have 21 Representatives of
countries/organizations attending this summit to pursue or express their relations
to either of the 2 primary parties to the dispute.
Since this is a special committee, the Rules of Procedure (ROP) will be explained in
detail in the upcoming sections of this Background/Study Guide. To give you a brief
further insight, the ROP followed shall be a combination of Traditional UNA USA
ROP as well specialized ROP set by us, the Executive Board. Rest assured, we shall
be briefing you on the same, on the day of the first session.
History
The issue of India versus Pakistan has always been a hot topic. From cricket to
demographics, the 2 countries have been on edge since the partition in 1947. This
rivalry can be placed amongst the list of the greatest rivalries ever, FC Barcelona vs
Real Madrid, Chennai Super Kings vs Mumbai Indians, Russia vs America and any
other rivalry you can imagine. The 2 countries have been at loggerheads since before
partition when Muhammad Ali Jinnah started the Muslim League with the agenda
of promoting Muslim representation, which ended in them getting a separate nation.
Kashmir was a primarily Muslim dominated state with a Hindu King. Raja Hari
Singh, the then ruler of Kashmir, did not wish to accede to either India or Pakistan
and wished to remain independent. However, Pakistan wanted Jammu and Kashmir
for itself which sparked the Indo-Pakistani war of 1947-48. It all started on 22nd
October 1947, when the Pashtun tribal attack was launched in the Muzaffarabad
sector. The state forces stationed in the border regions around Muzaffarabad and
Domel were quickly defeated by tribal forces (Muslim state forces mutinied and
joined them) and the way to the capital was open. Among the raiders, there were
many active Pakistani Army soldiers disguised as tribals. They were also provided
logistical help by the Pakistan Army. When Maharaja Hari Singh, asked for India’s
military assistance and intervention, India put forward the condition that the Princely
state of Kashmir was to be acceded to India after which Pakistan declared war on
India.
The rest is history, with the likes of Operation Vijay and Operation Eraze, India
succeeded in the war setting up the LOC (Line of Control) and determining the
POK (Pakistan Occupied Kashmir) , despite the United Nations calling for an
intervention in the form of Resolution 38 which called for the 2 engaging parties to
refrain from aggravating the situation in Kashmir followed by Resolution 39 which
created the United Nations Commission for India and Pakistan (UNCIP) to
peacefully settle the Kashmir issue.
On 13 August 1948, after discussions with both the governments, the Commission
unanimously adopted a three-part resolution, amending and amplifying the UN
Resolution 47.
• Part I dealt with ceasefire, calling for a complete cessation of hostilities.
• Part II dealt with a truce agreement. It asked for a complete withdrawal of
Pakistan's fighting forces, including the army, tribes, and other Pakistani
nationals, and stated that the evacuated territory would be administered by
local authorities under the surveillance of the Commission. Following the
Pakistani withdrawal, India was expected to withdraw the "bulk of its forces"
reducing them to the minimum level required for maintaining law and order.
• Part III stated that, after the acceptance of the truce agreement, the two
countries would enter a consultation with the Commission for settling the
future of the state in accordance with the will of the people.
Finally United Nations Security Council Resolutions 96 mandated that India and
Pakistan would work for a peaceful settlement, continue to observe a ceasefire, and
accepted the principle that the accession of the State of Jammu and Kashmir should
be determined by a free and impartial plebiscite under the auspices of the United
Nations. At the end, Resolution 98 urged the Governments of India and Pakistan to
enter immediate negotiations under the auspices of the United Nations
Representative for India and Pakistan to reach an agreement on the specific number
of troops to remain of each side of the cease-fire line at the end of the previously
established period of demilitarization.
In the 1960s Pakistan received 700 million dollars of military aid from the United
States, by signing a defense agreement in 1954, which significantly modernized
Pakistan's military equipment. During this period, despite being numerically smaller
than the Indian Military, Pakistan's armed forces had a qualitative edge in air power
and armour over India, which Pakistan sought to utilize before India completed its
defense build-up. Pakistan's leadership, under President Ayub Khan, decided to
launch a covert operation in Kashmir. On August 5, 1965, between 26,000 and
33,000 Pakistani soldiers crossed the Line of Control (LoC) dressed as Kashmiri
locals, inaugurating "Operation Gibraltar." The operation was headed by Major
General Akhtar Hussain Malik and aimed to instigate a rebellion among Kashmiri
Muslims, sabotage military targets, and pave the way for Pakistan to seize control of
the region.
As a result of the growing tensions on the Kashmir LOC which led to the Indo-
Pakistani war in the end, the United Nations Security Council on 4th September 1965,
noticed the deteriorating situation in the Kashmir LOC passed resolution 209, called
upon India and Pakistan to take all steps necessary to immediately cease fighting and
return to their respective sides of the line. The Council also called on the two
governments to co-operate fully with the UNMOGIP. The next resolution,
resolution 210 called on the parties to cease hostilities in the entire area of conflict
immediately and withdraw all armed personnel to the positions they held before
August 5, 1965.
After both the resolutions went unheeded by both India and Pakistan, the next
resolution, resolution 211, the Council demanded, let us make that clear delegates
that now the UNSC demanded that a cease-fire take effect at 0700 hours GMT on
September 22 and that both forces withdraw to the positions held before August 5.
The Council requested the Secretary General to ensure the supervision of the cease-
fire and called on all states to refrain from any action which might aggravate the
situation. The Council also decided that as soon as a cease-fire could be reached it
would consider what steps could be taken to assist towards a settlement of the
political problem underlying the conflict.
UNSC Resolutions 214 and 215, adopted in September 1965, addressed the
escalating conflict between India and Pakistan. Resolution 214, passed on September
27, demanded that both countries honour their commitment to the ceasefire called
for in Resolution 211. It also requested the Secretary-General to exert every possible
effort to ensure the ceasefire was implemented.
Finally, a ceasefire was implemented between India and Pakistan. Next, the United
States and the USSR tried their best to intervene and broker peace discussions
between the 2 parties to war. This took place at Tashkent in modern day Uzbekistan
which was then under the Soviet Union from 4th January to 10th January 1966 where
the soviets represented by Aleksei Kosygin moderated the discussion between the
Indian Prime Minister Lal Bahadur Shashtri and Pakistani President Muhammad
Ayub Khan. A declaration was released that was hoped to be a framework for lasting
peace by stating that the Indian military and the Pakistani military would pull back
to their pre-conflict positions, their pre-August lines, no later than 25 February 1966;
neither nation would interfere in each other's internal affairs; economic and
diplomatic relations would be restored; there would be an orderly transfer of
prisoners of war, and both leaders would work towards improving bilateral relations.
However, the optics and the public perception of the same was very unfortunate and
hateful and biased towards one side. This is perhaps the only time when both Indians
and Pakistanis agreed on the same topic. What their leader did by signing the
Tashkent declaration was non-beneficial to either side which caused massive public
uproar. But this uproar was because of 2 different factors. The uproar on the
Pakistani side was because President Ayub Khan signed the declaration and failed to
seemingly scam India. However, the case was different on the Indian side, as after
the Tashkent Declaration was signed, Prime Minister Lal Bahadur Shastri, died of
mysterious circumstances, where many sources said it was a heart attack, people
believed more in conspiracy theories, and thought the Pakistanis poisoned the Prime
Minister.
The death of the Awami League's Suhrawardy in 1963 gave Sheikh Mujibur Rahman
(commonly known as Mujib) the leadership of East Pakistan's dominant party.
Mujibur Rahman, who as early as 1956 had advocated the "liberation" of East
Pakistan and had been jailed in 1958 during the military coup, quickly and
successfully brought the issue of East Pakistan's movement for autonomy to the
forefront of the nation's politics. At a 1966 Lahore conference of both the eastern
and the western chapters of the Awami League, Mujib announced his six-point
political and economic program (on 5 February) for East Pakistani provincial
autonomy. These included:
1. The Constitution should provide for a Federation of Pakistan in its true sense
based on the Lahore Resolution, and the parliamentary form of government
with supremacy of a Legislature directly elected based on universal adult
franchise.
2. The federal government should deal with only two subjects: Defence and
Foreign Affairs, and all other residual subjects should be vested in the
federating states.
3. Two separate, but freely convertible currencies for two wings should be
introduced; or if this is not feasible, there should be one currency for the
whole country, but effective constitutional provisions should be introduced
to stop the flight of capital from East to West Pakistan. Furthermore, a
separate Banking Reserve should be established and separate fiscal and
monetary policy be adopted for East Pakistan.
4. The power of taxation and revenue collection should be vested in the
federating units and the federal centre would have no such power. The
federation would be entitled to a share in the state taxes to meet its
expenditures.
5. There should be two separate accounts for the foreign exchange earnings of
the two wings; the foreign exchange requirements of the federal government
should be met by the two wings equally or in a ratio to be fixed; indigenous
products should move free of duty between the two wings, and the
constitution should empower the units to establish trade links with foreign
countries.
6. East Pakistan should have a separate military or paramilitary force, and Navy
headquarters should be in East Pakistan. This plan was in direct opposition
of President Ayub Khan who wished for national integration and Ayub Khan
worried about his plans and so did many West Pakistani’s who had the same
opinion. Ayub interpreted Mujib's demands as tantamount to a call for
independence. After pro-Mujib supporters rioted in a general strike in Dhaka,
the government arrested Mujibur Rehman in January 1968.
President Ayub Khan suffered several setbacks in 1968. His health was poor, and he
was almost assassinated at a ceremony marking ten years of his rule. Riots followed,
and Zulfikar Ali Bhutto was arrested as the instigator. At Dhaka a tribunal that
inquired into the activities of the already-interned Mujib were arousing strong
popular resentment against Ayub. A conference of opposition leaders and the
cancellation of the state of emergency (in effect since 1965) came too late to
conciliate the opposition. On February 21, 1969, Ayub announced that he would not
run in the next presidential election in 1970. A state of near anarchy reigned with
protests and strikes throughout the country. The police appeared helpless to control
the mob violence, and the military stood aloof. At length, on March 25 Ayub
resigned and handed over the administration to the commander in chief, General
Agha Mohammad Yahya Khan.
Once again, the country was placed under martial law. General Yahya assumed the
titles of Chief Martial Law Administrator and President. He announced that he
considered himself to be a transitional leader whose task would be to restore order
and to conduct free elections for a new constituent assembly, which would then draft
a new constitution. He appointed a largely civilian cabinet in August 1969 in
preparation for the election, which was scheduled to take place in December 1970.
Yahya moved with dispatch to settle two contentious issues by decree: the unpopular
"One Unit" of West Pakistan, which was created as a condition for the 1956
constitution, was ended; and East Pakistan was awarded 162 seats out of the 300-
member National Assembly. Yahya had announced plans for the December 7 1970,
national election, and urged voters to elect candidates who were committed to the
integrity and unity of Pakistan.
The elections were the first in the history of Pakistan in which voters were able to
elect members of the National Assembly directly. In a convincing demonstration of
Bengali dissatisfaction with the West Pakistani regime, the Awami League won all
but two of the 169 seats allotted to East Pakistan in the National Assembly. Bhutto's
Pakistan People’s Party came in a poor second nationally, winning 81 out of the 138
West Pakistani seats in the National Assembly. The Awami League's electoral victory
promised it control of the government, with Mujibur Rehman as the country's prime
minister, but the inaugural assembly never met.
The number of West Pakistani troops entering East Pakistan had increased sharply
in the preceding weeks, climbing from a pre-crisis level of 25,000 to about 60,000,
bringing the army close to a state of readiness. As tensions rose, however, Yahya
continued negotiations with Mujib, flying to Dhaka in mid-March. Talks between
Yahya and Mujibur were joined by Bhutto but soon collapsed, and on March 23
1971, Bengalis following Mujib's lead defiantly celebrated "Resistance Day" in East
Pakistan instead of the traditional all-Pakistan "Republic Day". Yahya decided to
"solve" the problem of East Pakistan by repression. On the evening of March 25
1971, he flew back to Islamabad. The military crackdown in East Pakistan began
that same night.
On March 1, 1971, General Yahya Khan called off the National Council session
scheduled for March 3 in a radio address, setting the stage for escalating tensions.
Six days later, on March 7, Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, leader of the Awami League
party that had won a landslide victory in the 1970 Federal Elections but was denied
authority, made a historic speech at the Dhaka Race Course ground. He declared,
"The struggle this time is the struggle for our emancipation! The struggle this time
is the struggle for independence!" This powerful statement energized the Bengali
population, while Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, Pakistan's Foreign Affairs Minister, refused
to recognize Bangladesh as an independent state.
Negotiations between Yahya Khan and Sheikh Mujibur Rahman began on March
16, but the situation remained tense. On March 19, nearly 200 people were injured
in clashes between protesters and the Pakistan Army in Jaydevpur. The violence
escalated on March 24 when the Pakistan Army opened fire on Bengali protesters in
Syedpur and Rangpur, resulting in about 150 deaths.
The night of March 25-26 marked a critical turning point. The Pakistan Army
launched Operation Searchlight, a brutal crackdown in Dhaka and across the
country. Led by General Tikka Khan, known as the "Butcher of Balochistan," the
operation targeted civilians, political activists, students, and Bengali members of the
armed forces and police. This event, known as the Dhaka University Massacre,
triggered a mass exodus of refugees into India, causing concern for Indian Prime
Minister Indira Gandhi.
In the early hours of March 26, at 1:15 am, Sheikh Mujibur Rahman was arrested by
the Pakistani 3 commando unit. However, he had declared the independence of
Bangladesh just minutes before his arrest. Later that day, at 2:30 pm, M. A. Hannan,
an Awami League leader from Chittagong, officially declared Bangladesh's
independence on behalf of Sheikh Mujibur Rahman from Kalurghat. This date is
recognized as Bangladesh's official Independence Day.
May brought more violence with the Gopalpur massacre on May 5. On May 15, the
Indian army began aiding the Mukti Bahini. The Chuknagar massacre took place in
Khulna on May 20, with the Pakistan army killing nearly 10,000 people. On May 24,
Swadhin Bangla Betar Kendra found a home in Kolkata.
However, if you have the movie Sam Bahadur starring Vicky Kaushal as Field
Marshal Sam FHJ Manekshaw MC (Military Cross) (Do see it, it will help you in your
preparation), you will come to understand that it was because of his constant instinct
and planning that led to India becoming the victors in the war.
December 3, 1971:
At 5:45 PM, the Pakistan Air Force (PAF) launched surprise air strikes on eleven
Indian air fields in the western sector, including Agra, Ambala, Amritsar, Awantipur,
Bikaner, Halwara, Jodhpur, Jaisalmer, Pathankot, Safdarjung, and Srinagar. This pre-
emptive strike, known as Operation Chengiz Khan, was intended to replicate the
success of the Israeli Air Force in the Six-Day War. However, it failed to achieve its
objectives, as most of the Indian aircraft were protected in reinforced concrete
bunkers. In response to these air strikes, at 9:30 PM, Indian Prime Minister Indira
Gandhi addressed the nation, declaring that the air strikes were a declaration of war
against India. She announced that India would react to defend its national integrity
and security. This marked the official beginning of India's full-scale involvement in
the war.
December 4, 1971:
The Indian Air Force retaliated with counter air strikes. At dawn, Indian Hunters
attacked PAF bases in Murid, Mianwali, Sargodha, and Chandher. Throughout the
day, the Indian Air Force conducted over 500 sorties against Pakistani targets. On
the ground, the Indian Army launched a multi-pronged assault into East Pakistan.
The Indian Army's II Corps, commanded by Lt. Gen. T.N. Raina, advanced from
the western sector towards Jessore. The IV Corps, under Lt. Gen. Sagat Singh,
pushed from the eastern sector towards Sylhet. The XXXIII Corps, led by Lt. Gen.
M.L. Thapan, moved from the north towards Rangpur and Bogra.
December 5, 1971:
The Battle of Longewala began in the Thar Desert of Rajasthan. A company of 120
Indian soldiers, supported by Indian Air Force Hawker Hunters, managed to thwart
an attack by an entire Pakistani brigade of 2,000 soldiers backed by an armored
regiment. In the Bay of Bengal, the Indian Navy launched Operation Trident, a
devastating attack on Karachi harbor. Indian missile boats sank several Pakistani
ships, including the destroyer PNS Khaibar, minesweeper PNS Muhafiz, and MV
Venus Challenger. This operation effectively neutralized the Pakistani Navy's threat
in the Arabian Sea.
December 6, 1971:
India officially recognized Bangladesh as an independent nation. This diplomatic
move further solidified India's support for the Bengali cause and increased
international pressure on Pakistan. The Battle of Hilli, which had been ongoing since
November 22, intensified. Indian forces finally broke through the Pakistani defenses,
capturing this strategic location in northwestern Bangladesh.
December 7, 1971:
The Indian Air Force conducted deep penetration strikes inside Pakistani territory,
targeting airfields, radar installations, and other strategic assets. On the eastern front,
Indian forces made significant advances. The 57 Mountain Division captured
Akhaura, a crucial railway junction, cutting off Pakistani forces in Tripura.
December 8, 1971:
The Indian Navy launched Operation Python, a follow-up to Operation Trident.
This second strike on Karachi harbor further crippled Pakistani naval capabilities
and destroyed fuel storage facilities. In East Pakistan, the Mukti Bahini (Bengali
freedom fighters) and Indian forces liberated Jessore, dealing a significant blow to
Pakistani control in the region.
December 9, 1971:
The Indian Army's 57 Mountain Division, along with Mukti Bahini forces, captured
Comilla, a strategically important town in eastern Bangladesh. In the western sector,
Indian forces made advances in the Shakargarh bulge, aiming to cut off Pakistani
forces in the region.
It is important to establish at this point that the United States of America, the United
Kingdom, and many other countries supported Pakistan in this war rather than
India. In fact, the then Secretary of State of the United States Government Henry
Kissinger as well as the US Ambassador to India, Kenneth Heating issued a threat
to Indira Gandhi at the Prime Minister’s Office. The US had stationed the aircraft
carrier USS Enterprise naval task group entry into the Indian Ocean during the
closing stages of 1971 Indo-Pak Conflict which led to further deterioration in the
relations between India and the United States (US), and this estrangement lasted
until the end of the Cold War.
It was at this juncture that the Soviet Union stepped in to provide support to India.
The Soviet Union proposed the Indo–Soviet Treaty of Peace, Friendship and
Cooperation aimed at strategic cooperation which was signed in August 1971, in
response to increasing ties between the United States of America and Pakistan. The
war stripped Pakistan of more than half of its population, and with nearly one-third
of its army in captivity, clearly established India's military, and political dominance
of the subcontinent. India successfully led a diplomatic campaign to isolate Pakistan.
On state visits to the United Kingdom and France, Prime Minister Indira Gandhi
convinced them to break with their ally the United States and block any pro-Pakistan
resolution in the United Nations.
After the Indo-Pakistani War of 1971, Pakistan’s martial leader, president and army
chief Yahya Khan fell in the graces of the public due to Pakistan’s surrender to India.
As a result, he handed over the presidency to the all-favourite leader of the People’s
Party, Zulfikar Ali Bhutto. It was also Bhutto, who released Mujibur Rehman who
was housed in a prison in Pakistan and allowed him to fly to London.
On 2nd July 1972, Zulfikar Ali Bhutto and Prime Minister Indira Gandhi met in
Shimla, Himachal Pradesh and signed the Shimla agreement. The treaty's official
purpose was stated to serve as a way for both countries to "put an end to the conflict
and confrontation that have hitherto marred their relations" and to conceive the
steps to be taken for further normalization of India-Pakistan relations while also
laying down the principles that should govern their future interactions. The treaty
also gave back more than 13,000 km square of land that the Indian Army had seized
in Pakistan during the war, though India retained a few strategic areas, including
Turtuk, Dhothang, Tyakshi (earlier called Tiaqsi) and Chalunka of Chorbat Valley,
which was more than 883 km square.
For the specifics of the Shimla Agreement, use the following link:
https://www.mea.gov.in/Portal/LegalTreatiesDoc/PA72B1578.pdf
After the Shimla Agreement, a trilateral agreement was signed between the countries
of India, Pakistan, and Bangladesh. This agreement was signed on 28th August 1973
and ratified only by India and Pakistan and was signed by the External Affairs
Ministers of the 3 countries in New Delhi. This agreement was called the Delhi
Agreement. This agreement detailed the repatriation of Prisoners of War (PoWs)
from the country they were being held in to the country they belonged to.
The treaty came into effect on 28 August 1973 and ended on 1 July 1974. Under the
terms of the agreement, UNHCR (United Nations High Commissioner for
Refugees) supervised the repatriation of Bangladeshi and Pakistani citizens.
According to the UN, 121,695 Bengalis were moved from Pakistan to Bangladesh.
They included high-level Bengali civil servants and military officers. 108,744 non-
Bengali civilians and civil servants were moved from Bangladesh to Pakistan. India
released 6,500 Pakistani PoWs, who were mostly transported by train to Pakistan. In
1974, General Niazi was the last Pakistan officer symbolically repatriated through
the Wagah - Attari Border.
After the same, the 2 countries-maintained peace till 1999 with a series of conflicts
and issues leading up to the 1999 Kargil War. However, the beginning of the decade
was not all the worse so to say. It had a better start than most with the signing of an
agreement which was signed on 31 December 1988 and entered into force on 27
January 1991 provides, inter alia, that India and Pakistan inform each other of the
nuclear installations and facilities to be covered under the Agreement on the first of
January of every calendar year.
We then move on 1998, when the Prime Minister Mr. Atal Bihari Vajpayee
commanded Mr APJ Abdul Kalam and Mr. R Chidambaram to prepare for another
nuclear weapons test. This operation was called Operation Shakti and was conducted
in the same Pokhran Range in Rajasthan. This operation was conducted in such
secrecy by the Indian authorities, it is considered one of the worst intelligence
failures in the history of the United States. These tests took place on 13th May 1998
and subsequently India declared that it shall not conduct any more tests.
Parallelly, Pakistan’s nuclear weapons test which was dubbed Operation Chagai-I
which had been in planning since the 1970s was conducted in direct response to
India’s nuclear weapons test. Operation Chagai-I was conducted on 28th May 1998
followed by Operation Chagai-II on 30th May 1998. Pakistan’s nuclear arsenal was
built with help from China and the United States alike, but when India built its own
self sufficient nuclear weapons, it was responded with sanctions and threats led by
the United States and Japan. However, since United States could not show
themselves as supporters to either side, economic sanctions were imposed on
Pakistan too.
The nuclear tests by both parties led to a cold war in the Indian subcontinent. To
defuse the situation, the Lahore Declaration was signed. This declaration was signed
on 21st February 1999. Under the terms of the treaty, a mutual understanding was
reached towards the development of atomic arsenals and to avoid accidental and
unauthorised operational use of nuclear weapons. The Lahore Declaration brought
added responsibility to both nations' leadership towards avoiding nuclear race, as
well as both non-conventional and conventional conflicts. This event was significant
in the history of Pakistan and it provided both countries an environment of mutual
confidence. In a much-covered televised press conference in both countries, Prime
Minister Nawaz Sharif and Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee signed the treaty. It
was the second nuclear control treaty signed by both countries and pledged to
continue the use of the first treaty, Non-Nuclear Aggression Agreement, was signed
in 1988. The Lahore treaty was quickly ratified by the parliaments of India and
Pakistan and came into force the same year. This treat was a major breakthrough in
Indo-Pak relations and gave promises to find a peaceful and bilateral solution to the
Kashmir Conflict.
The Kargil War or Operation Vijay as it is commonly referred was a pivotal point in
Indian and Pakistani history alike. The war began on 3rd May 1999 and ended on 26th
July 1999.
The first signs of trouble emerged on May 3, 1999, when local shepherds reported a
Pakistani intrusion in the Kargil district. This initial report was followed by a tragic
incident on May 5, when five Indian soldiers sent to patrol the area were captured
and subsequently killed. The situation escalated quickly, with heavy shelling by the
Pakistan Army damaging Indian ammunition dumps in Kargil on May 9.
By May 10, multiple infiltrations across the LoC were confirmed in the Dras, Kaksar,
and Mushkoh sectors. The Indian military responded swiftly, moving more soldiers
from the Kashmir Valley to the Kargil district by mid-May. The conflict entered a
new phase on May 26 when the Indian Air Force (IAF) began airstrikes against
suspected infiltrator positions.
The following day, May 27, marked a significant escalation in the conflict. The
Pakistan Army's Air Defence Corps, using Anza surface-to-air missiles, shot down
two Indian aircraft - a MiG-21 and a MiG-27. Flight Lieutenant Kambampati
Nachiketa, the pilot of the MiG-27, was captured by Pakistani forces and given
Prisoner of War (POW) status. He was later released on June 3, 1999. The loss of
aircraft continued on May 28, when an Indian Mi-17 helicopter was shot down by
Pakistani forces, resulting in the deaths of four crew members.
As the conflict intensified, the Pakistan Army began shelling operations on India's
National Highway 1 in Kashmir and Ladakh on June 1. This strategic road is crucial
for supplying Indian forces in the region. In a significant development on June 5,
India released documents recovered from three Pakistani soldiers, providing official
evidence of Pakistan's involvement in the conflict. This revelation helped to counter
Pakistan's initial claims that the infiltrators were merely Kashmiri freedom fighters.
The Indian Army launched a major offensive in Kargil on June 6, marking the
beginning of a concerted effort to reclaim the occupied positions. Success came
quickly, with Indian troops recapturing two key positions in the Batalik sector on
June 9. To further strengthen its case internationally, India released intercepts of
conversations between Pakistani Chief of Army Staff General Pervez Musharraf
(who was on a visit to China) and Chief of General Staff Lieutenant General Aziz
Khan (in Rawalpindi) on June 11. These intercepts served as additional proof of the
Pakistan Army's direct involvement in the infiltrations.
The tide of the war began to turn decisively in India's favor from mid-June. On June
13, Indian forces secured Tololing in Dras after a fierce battle with militias backed
by Pakistani troops. This victory was strategically important as it provided Indian
forces with a vantage point to observe and target Pakistani positions.
The latter half of June and early July saw a series of Indian victories. On June 29,
under pressure from their government, Pakistani forces began their retreat from
Indian-administered Kashmir, while the Indian Army advanced towards Tiger Hill,
a strategically important peak. The Battle of Tiger Hill, one of the most significant
engagements of the war, took place on July 4. Three Indian regiments (Sikh,
Grenadiers, and Naga) engaged elements of the remaining Pakistani Northern Light
Infantry regiment in a grueling 12-hour battle, ultimately recapturing the region.
The war's end was in sight when, on July 5, Nawaz Sharif officially announced the
Pakistan Army's withdrawal from Kargil following a meeting with President Clinton.
Indian forces swiftly capitalized on this withdrawal, taking control of Dras on the
same day. The momentum continued with Indian troops recapturing Jubar Heights
in Batalik on July 7, followed by the retaking of key peak points in Batalik on July 11
as Pakistani forces disengaged from the region.
On July 14, Indian Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee declared Operation Vijay,
the codename for the Indian operation in Kargil, a success. The Indian government
also set conditions for future talks with Pakistan, signaling its position of strength
following the military victory.
The Kargil War officially came to an end on July 26, 1999, when the Indian Army
announced the complete withdrawal of Pakistani irregular and regular forces from
the region. This conflict, while relatively short, had significant implications for India-
Pakistan relations and brought international attention to the ongoing Kashmir
dispute.
The war resulted in hundreds of casualties on both sides and highlighted the risks of
conflict between the two nuclear-armed nations. It also led to diplomatic isolation
for Pakistan and increased international sympathy for India's position in Kashmir.
The conflict's aftermath saw increased defense spending in India and a reevaluation
of intelligence and military preparedness in both countries.
With that, we end with India- Pakistan conflict history. There have been many more
conflicts, many more disputes, many more historic landmarks, but that is for you to
research upon, understand and apply. The most recent dispute/conflict are the 2016
Surgical Strikes and 2019 Balakot Airstrikes. However, there is a lot of room for
discussion there.
This part talks about the Rules of Procedure that we will be establishing in the
committee. While most of the elements that we follow will be part of the UNA USA
RoP, there are some things that we shall be doing differently, because an India
Pakistan Special Summit is in no way affiliated with the United Nations.
To begin with we shall have 2 different types of voting procedures. These voting
procedures will be called procedural and substantiative voting. Both will be explained
below.
Procedural Voting:
Under this we shall be voting on the various motions such as roll call, setting of the
agenda, unmoderated caucuses etc. In the case of this committee, all 34 members of
this committee will be given the power to vote.
Substantiative Voting:
This voting method shall be used when we are discussing the end document to
committee which in this case shall be a working paper. This working paper can be
either unanimous or divided.
All other RoP shall be explained on the day of committee beginning and all are
expected to be there to avoid any delays. If you miss out, you can read the UNA
USA RoP and come to committee.
Position Paper
We expect a Position Paper from every delegate, detailing your stance on the issue
and how you would like the issue. It is mandatory. That being said, we might or
might not mark you on it. But we shall be following your actions very closely after
the submission of the Position Paper.
Portfolio:
Delegate Name:
Agenda:
(Body)
Keep in mind, your position paper can be submitted both electronically and via a
hard copy either in print or handwritten. The general rules that need to be followed
are that your position papers are not to exceed 2 pages at most. The font of the body
shall be Times New Roman, Font Size 12. The font of the other information
required can be as per your wish. For electronic submissions, the email-ID will be
provided when the WhatsApp groups are opened. The last date and time for
submissions are 10th August 2024, 7 am. The EB will not be accepting any position
papers that are late even by a minute electronically. For hard copy submissions, we
will be opening the floor after committee starts for 10 minutes for all to submit their
position papers which are in hard copy. The same rule about discipline applies to
you submitting your hard copy. Any reasons in delay need to be communicated to
the EB at least 1 hour prior to the submission date and time. We reserve the right to
demark you or even suspend you, if we see any effort at convincing us to extend the
date. Keep this in mind delegates.
Working Paper
The End document for this committee will be a Working Paper. The rules for the
working paper are that there shall be only 2 sponsors (countries) that can represent
any one working paper that is submitted. The EB shall be accepting a maximum of
3 working papers. Where and how the working papers need to be sent will be
elaborated on the last day of committee. One important point that you need to keep
in mind is that, at the end of the day, this is an India Pakistan Special Summit. When
it comes to voting, you will need the support of either India and Pakistan at least to
make your working paper pass. If both countries do not vote for the working paper,
that paper fails and is scrapped and thrown in the dustbin. (Imagine Kobe Bryant
throwing a paper into a dustbin and yelling Kobe!)
That said, the following is the format:
Sponsors:
Signatories:
- recommendation (a)
India should… Pakistan withdraws…
- recommendation (b)
Kashmir will accede…
Please keep in mind that your recommendations need not be limited to 2. There can
be as many as you want. This Working Paper is where we will be using the concept
of Substantiative Voting.
Crisis
Rest assured; you will not need to send in directives to have an update. The EB will
be sending in updates. We will have SSL’s (Special Speakers List) to discuss the
update in detail. As a result, you will not be having any Moderated Caucuses.
Lines of Communication
Delegates, the Executive Board shall also be expecting you to form relations with
different countries which are in a way beneficial to just you or other countries as
well. When we say relations, the EB is not referring to love and the relationships that
you typically undergo in real life. However, if you try to get Narendra Modi and
Giorgia Meloni married, the EB will be seriously impressed. But we will be
entertaining lines of communication such as Memorandum’s of
Understanding/Treaties and Press Releases/Presidential Statements.
Measures
Delegates, below are some measures already taken by the primary parties to resolve
disputes. Be clear, these are to show an example of how things are done and what
kind of measures can be taken. When and if proposing solutions, make sure that
they are not already existing and make sure you get creative because at the end of
the day, a MUN is always about out-of-the-box thinking.
These instances are to push you in the right direction. There is scope for debate but
not based on these already existing measures.
Questions
The following are some questions which the EB expects you to answer. These
include:
1. Are long lasting and peaceful relations possible between the 2 neighbouring
nations?
2. What mechanisms can be put in place to prevent nuclear escalation and
promote strategic stability between the two nuclear-armed nations, including
potential confidence-building measures and arms control agreements?
3. How can India and Pakistan collaborate to combat shared regional challenges
such as terrorism and what role can international organizations play in
facilitating this cooperation?
4. Which party to dispute is fated to succeed when it comes to their regional
claims over a disputed area?
Research Databases
Delegates, throughout this Background/Study Guide, the Executive Board has
stressed to you the importance of Research. While we cannot help you entirely, we
will help you choose how you can make your research worthwhile.
Thank you, delegates. The Executive Board is excited to see your performances at
this conference. We value your participation and expect you to maintain absolute
diplomacy and respect not only for us but for your fellow delegates as well. Any ill
treatment towards any other delegate will result in immediate disqualification. We
implore the delegates to respect the timings put forward by the EB as discipline is
another important aspect of Diplomacy and a Model United Nations.
This background guide serves just as a beginner source for your research. The
Executive Board expects each delegate to do their individual research apart from
what is given in the Background guide.