Unit 3
Unit 3
Introduction
A criminal wrong is considered to be graver than a civil wrong as it is considered as an act
against the whole society. Increasing crimes in any legal system are an example of a chaotic and
alarming situation for the country. Amidst all crimes, certain crimes are performed repeatedly by
certain criminals, to not take revenge but to gain profits. Such instances fall under the scope of
organised crimes. This article makes an attempt to identify some of the most prominent forms of
organised crimes in India, the legal framework surrounding these crimes and the challenges faced
by the State to curb these crimes.
Commission of crime
To commit a crime (including organised crime), there are four stages that needs to be fulfilled.
First, there should be an intention to commit a crime. Secondly, there must be some preparation
to give effect to the crime. Third, there should be an attempt, i.e., presence of some action in
pursuance of the crime being committed. Lastly, the attempt should be accomplished for the
commission of that crime.
Money laundering
Money laundering is one of the most serious crimes which can severely affect any economy in
several aspects. This crime is specifically governed by the Prevention of Money Laundering Act,
2002. It is a way by which illegal money earned from sources such as drug trafficking, human
trafficking, etc. are diverted to create an impression that such money comes from a legitimate
source. Many criminals are engaged in this profession where they help people with an illegal
income to convert it into a legitimate income.
Smuggling
Smuggling is another major economic offence in a form of organised crime. This is mostly
governed by the Customs Act, 1962. It is natural that the goods which are illegal in the territory
of India or heavily taxed are smuggled to continue their trade or maintain profits. With a change
in fiscal policy, the definition of smuggled goods vary but it is mostly items such as contraband
substances, valuable jewels, electronics, certain fabrics, etc. which are smuggled in India. Due to
the vast coastline, it becomes easy for people to smuggle goods.
Drug trafficking
Drug trafficking is another major crime that poses a threat to the younger population of India,
considering its drastic effects on physical and mental health. It is usually considered that the most
important reason for the high rate of drug trafficking is the geographical condition of India. It is
located between the Golden Triangle (Myanmar, Thailand, and Laos) on the northeast and
Golden Crescent (Pakistan, Afghanistan, and Iran) on the northwest- both of which are the two
largest sources of illicit drugs in Asia. Resultantly, this form of organised crime has become more
prevalent and significant in the country.
Human trafficking
Article 23 of the Indian Constitution explicitly prohibits human trafficking. Further, there are
various trafficking prohibition laws discussed in the latter part of the article. Human trafficking is
one of the most significant and heinous organised crimes. This involves women trafficking, child
trafficking, trading in sex workers, etc. A book titled “Indian Mafia” by S.K. Ghosh has revealed
that there are more than twenty-five lakh prostitutes in the country and roughly, three lakh
prostitutes get into the profession every year. Prostitution per se is not a crime but forcefully
dragging young girls or running a brothel imposes criminal liability. Moreover, human trafficking
is undoubtedly a crime.
Criminal conspiracy
Section 120A of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC) deals with criminal conspiracy. Where two or
more persons agree to commit a crime, then they can be punished for criminal conspiracy. The
exception clearly provides that it is immaterial whether the object of such crime committed is the
main intention or incidental. Hence, organised crimes shall definitely be governed by this
provision. Further, Section 120B of the IPC imposes criminal liability which can extend up to
death punishment and even heavy fines.
Preventive laws
Miscellaneous laws
Apart from these laws, there are various other laws that govern certain specific organised crimes.
To exemplify, the Narcotics Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1884 govern the cases
relating to trafficking of different narcotic substances; Customs Act, 1962 governs and imposes
liability for cases related to smuggling; Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 governs the
cases relating to money laundering. Apart from these, there are many other laws such as
the Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act, 1956; the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973,
the Public Gambling Act, 1867 etc.
Slow trials
Though these organised criminals are tried under different laws, the whole process of trials is
very slow and there is a very low conviction rate because in most of the cases, in such a long
period of time, the witnesses deny to come out of fear and in some cases, the pieces of evidence
are lost.
Obtaining proof
As mentioned earlier, most of the witnesses deny coming out of fear, so even if they are arrested,
they are later acquitted because of insufficient evidence and longevity of time. These players are
really strong and influential in their area of operations and naturally, people would not wish to
risk their lives by providing statements against them.
Lack of resources
A major part of the country is still unorganised and lack of proper resources and technology
become an obstacle in way of curbing organised crime. The lower-ranked police officers are not
given sufficient powers and a statement before them is not an admissible evidence. Further, these
officers do not have sufficient equipment to tap these criminals.
Lack of coordination
Since there is no central agency controlling these activities, every state has its own way of
functioning. These criminals do not stay for long at one place and keep migrating every now and
then. In such cases, due to lack of coordination, it becomes difficult and sometimes, impossible to
catch them.
Conclusion
The aforesaid discussion reveals the concept of organised crime where the ultimate intention of the
criminals is not to harm someone but rather make profits, however, some form of injury is caused.
Some common features of these crimes have also been mentioned above. Such crimes occur in
various forms including drug trafficking, human trafficking, money laundering, contract killings, etc.
There are various central and state laws such as the Indian Penal Code, PMLA, NDPS Act, preventive
laws, etc. to govern and curb organised crimes. Despite the existence of various legislation, the State
has not been successful in curbing these crimes to a considerable extent. This is because of various
challenges faced by the State such as lack of proper enforcement, lack of resources, slow trials,
difficulty in obtaining proof, etc. In light of these circumstances, it is imperative that the Parliament
bring in some laws specifically governing organised crimes and form diplomatic relations with other
nations since many of these crimes are transnational in nature.
White collar crime is a crime committed by the people who belongs to the higher class of society and
are from the reputable group of society. This crime is committed during the course of their
occupation. The people who are committing this crime have usually a better understanding of
technology, their respective field, disciplines etc. White collar crimes are largely evolved from few
years. And they are seen to be committed in large organizations that cover a large number of
activities. So we can say that these crimes are common to trade, commerce, education, health etc. As
the criminal profile has changed a lot in few years the traditional crimes have partially switched by
the white collar crimes in the country. The primary difference between the white and the blue crime
is that the ordinary i.e. the criminals of blue crime are people of under-privileged section and upper
class is involved in white collar crime and they commit the crime in a very organized manner. They
maintain their respect in the society until the crime is discovered.
Historical Background:
# Edwin Sutherland an American sociologist who first defined the white collar crimes in the global.
He described this crime to be committed by the person of high social status as compared to those
who commit ordinary crimes during the course of his employment.
# In 1934, Again Morris drew attention to the necessity of a change in emphasis regarding crime. He
arrested that anti-Social activities of persons of high status committed in course of their profession
must be brought with the category of crime and should be made punishable.
# Finally, E.H. Sutherland through his pioneering Work emphasised that these ‘ Upper Worked1
crimes which are committed by the persons of upper Socio-economic groups in course of their
occupation - violating the trust , Should be termed as “ White Collar Crime “ So as to be distinguished
from traditional crime which he called “ Blue Collar Crime “
# And the concept of White Collar Crimes found its place in criminology for the first time in 1941.[1]
# These crimes are difficult to detect and not at all personal. And on the other hand, the ordinary
crimes are direct and are very personal. They also involve violent methods such as using force to
commit crime.
# The ordinary criminals are usually afraid of the law agencies after committing the crime but the
white collar criminals are not at all afraid of the law agencies because of the fact that if they got
detected they will be fined or transferred or the maximum that they will get a short-term
imprisonment.
# Another difference between blue and the white collar crime is that the economic loss of white
collar crime is thousands time higher than that of the ordinary crimes. The financial loss which the
society has to bear is higher in white collar crimes than the crimes committed by the people of low-
social standard.
· White collar crime committed out of greed and it is ver y well planned and executed on the other
hand blue crimes are usually committed out of rage, revenge and other emotions. In white
collar crime harm is caused to the casualties or cash but harm is physical in case of blue
collar crime.
How White Collar Crimes Affects More Than Just The Criminals:
White collar crime can have a large impact on the society and it does not only affect the
criminals. It is also called as a socio-economic crime because it has a direct impact on the
society. When a white collar crime is committed huge losses on business occur which have a
direct impact on the consumers and the society. There are various numbers of frauds and
scams that had been exposed in our country from the past few years like 2g scam, havala
scam, banking scam, fodder scam and many more. Due to these frauds and scams the
economy of our country has shambled. And then to make up these losses of fraud or any
scams, they increase the costs. This means higher prices for the consumers in the way of
higher taxes, government revenue, and increased insurance costs. The impact of white collar
crime on society is great. There is loss in every field from the costs of commodities to the
securities and insurance. One financial fraud can affect the businessmen, the investors and the
government. All you need is one bad employee who out of greed of money will commit a
financial fraud and will cause harm to the reputation of the company, lack of profits and gain
of losses.
2) Bribery: Bribery is also a very common type of white collar crime. By bribery we means
giving money or some goods to the person at a high position in return of a favor. In simple
words bribery is when one man gives money to the other which is in authority. It is done for
the purpose of insisting him to do something or to prevent him from doing something. It is
the most common income of most of the public officials of our country.
3) Cybercrime: Cybercrime is the biggest cause leading to these type of crime in India. It is
the latest problem prevailing in the cyber world. Cybercrime is the crime which is related to
‘computer networks’. With the rapid increase of advancement of technology there is also a
rapid increase in the crime related to the technology. Cybercrime involves the persons who
are expert in computer related technology. And it is committed against the victim directly or
indirectly to cause a harm to his reputation or to harm in physical or mental way using
internet, networks and other technological sources.
Cybercrime threatens the nations as well as the person’s security and financial status.
Cybercrime can cause huge financial loss to the country. Not only the financial loss but it can
also threaten the privacy of a person. Disclosure of confidential information can create
privacy problems. Also cybercrime against women is also rising. By the use of
telecommunication networks, mobile phones cyber stalking, sending obscene messages and
pictures by criminals to women is also increasing.
# Hacking,
# Child pornography,
# Copyright infringement,
# Cyber terrorism,
# Cyber stalking are some of common examples of cybercrime.
4) Money Laundering: Money laundering is a crime in which the criminals disguise the
identity of the money. In this crime, criminals try to hide the original ownership of the money
and the place where they obtained that money by illegal means. Laundering is done with the
intention of making that money came from legal sources. In simple words money laundering
means to show the illegitimate money as legal money. For instance if a person obtain money
from black marketing, trafficking of illegal goods the money will be considered ‘dirty’ and he
cannot deposit into the banks as it may seem suspicious if he directly deposit money into the
financial institutions because he had to create statements and records stating that where the
money came from. Money laundering involves three steps:
# Firstly, the owner of the money obtain the money from some illegal means and deposit into
the bank by some way.
# Then through multiple transactions the transfer of money is being done.
# Lastly, they return the money into banks to make it legitimate.
5) Tax Evasion: Tax evasion is committed with an intention to conceal one’s actual taxable
income and one’s original position to the authorities. This concealment of income is done to
reduce the tax liability in the eyes of government. In simple words it means to hide the money
obtained from the illegal means in order to reduce one’s liability to pay tax and to show low
income to the tax authorities. Tax evasion has a negative impact on the social values as it
demoralized honest tax payers and they might also want to do tax evasion also it gives
economy power in the hand of few undeserving people.
6) Identity Theft: Identity theft is one of the easiest type of crime these days. Due to
advancement of technology it is very easy to access personal information of anyone. Identity
theft is the crime in which the criminal access unauthorized information such as name,
address, phone number etc. and use this information to gain money. In simple words identity
theft is committed by using some other person identity to commit fraud or to gain money by
illegal means.
2) In Legal Profession:
# Fabrication of forged documents.
# Threatening the witnesses of the other party.
# Violation of ethical standard of legal profession to gain money.
3) In Education:
# Collecting huge sums of money in the name of donations by students in order to give them
admission.
# Merit based admission is replaced by donations.
# Collect huge amount of money in the name of government grants.
PINK-COLLAR CRIME
Pink-collar crime was popularized by Dr. Kathleen Daly, originally mentioned in her 1989
article, “Gender and varieties of white-collar crime,” in the academic
journal, Criminology. Pink-collar crime refers to embezzlement-related crimes, which are
often times lower- to mid-level office women, who steal from their employers. Examples
could include bookkeepers, office managers, and accountants, who have limited opportunity
and access to intimate information.
It is important to note pink-collar crimes are not exclusive to women as it’s the position, not
the gender that defines pink-collar crimes. Generally speaking, there are more women than
men in these roles of opportunity. Though not as publicized, pink collar crime is serious and
is growing at an alarming rate, approximately increasing 40% since 1990.
GREEN-COLLAR CRIME
A seemingly more recent form of crime, some consider “green crimes” to be a subsect of
white-collar crimes. Green-collar crimes are defined as crimes committed against the
environment for profit.
In 2013, Ian David Macdonald and David John Downes of the U.K. were the two of the first
individuals to be charged with a green-collar crime for their involvement with a carbon credit
boiler room scam, ultimately defrauding investors out of $9 million dollars (U.S.). The men
were charged with 4 and 8 year prison sentences, proving green-collar crimes are considered
serious.
Blue-collar crime is considered to be any crime committed by someone from the working
class or lower class of society. These crimes tend to fueled by passion, lust, or rage, in
opposition to white collar crimes, which tend to involved extensive planning and are
meticulously calculated. Examples of blue-collar crimes include burglary, drug crimes,
assault, sexual assault, and theft crimes
Since blue-collar crimes often cause immediate and highly visible injury to society, they tend
to be punished more severely than other forms of collared crimes.
RED-COLLAR CRIME
The term “red-collared crime” has been used to describe white-collar crimes that turn
horribly violent. After their white-collar crimes have been discovered, red-collar criminals
use murder as a method of concealment, also called “fraud concealment homicide”, thus
changing the white-collar crime to a red-collar crime. The red-collar criminal usually has a
mixed criminal history of white-collar and non-white-collar crimes, that often includes a
history of violence.
Frank Perri coined the term “red-collar crime” in a 2015 article in the International Journal of
Psychological Studies, stating, “red-collar criminals engage in violence to silence those who
are in a position to detect and/or disclose their fraud schemes: hence the name fraud detection
homicide describing the motive to classify the murder.
BLACK-COLLAR CRIME
Though not officially confirmed in criminology studies, the term “black-collar crime” has
been used to refer to priests who commit crimes. Often times, these crimes are subsequently
covered by the Church.
Blue, pink, red, white, black, and green-collared crimes are different types of crimes
unfortunately present in modern-day society. Regardless of the type of crime, being informed
can help us understand how and why these crimes are committed. It also can help law
enforcement officers, lawyers, and our criminal justice system learn how to properly process
individuals convicted of these crimes.
WHITE COLLAR CRIMES
White Collar Crimes are crimes committed in the context of their employment by a person of
high social status and respectability. It is a crime committed by workers or business people
and usually involves a form of financial robbery or stealing. In 1939, sociologist Edwin
Sutherland described the term “White Collar Crime” as a non-violent felony committed by
business owners who have access to substantial amounts of money by fraudulent activities.
White Collar Offences are committed by people who are not involved in legal businesses,
across a wide range of activities. Unless their crime is exposed, offenders have a respectable
part to play in the communities. The legislation on white-collar crimes depends on the type of
crime committed.
There are many types of white-collar crimes, the following are some of them:
1. Tax and Bank frauds: Bank fraud includes engaging in such activities with a view to
defrauding a bank by using dishonest ways of acquiring properties owned by financial
institutions, while tax fraud means avoiding taxes by providing fake tax information
by secretly transferring assets in order to escape taxes.Computer fraud, such as
hacking or manipulating data from an agency or individual, is also used.
2. Embezzlement and Inside trading: It is embezzlement when someone entrusted with
cash or property uses it for their own use, and inside trading is when someone uses
classified knowledge to invest on publicly traded corporate securities.
3. Blackmailing and Bribery: Blackmail means asking for money by threatening a
person with physical harm or revealing his secrets, and Bribery means offering
someone money, goods or other presents to manipulate his acts. When someone else
pays or takes a bribe, it is a crime.
4. Extortion and money laundering: If a person illegally acquire the property of a person
by means of an actual or threatening force, so it is called extortion, while money
laundering means concealing the sources of money illegally obtained.
CAUSES OF WHITE-COLLAR CRIMES
The prevailing belief is that, irrespective of corruption or economic instability, white-collar
crimes are committed. However, regardless of the situational burden or the innate essence of
possessing more than any of them, some crimes are always committed. Any defendant is
convinced that their actions are not assaults, as the behaviours involved do not resemble
street crimes. In committing crimes, some people excuse for thinking that the administrative
legislation does not understand the realistic complexities of competition in the free enterprise
climate. The lack of awareness of people is one of the main factors of white-collar crime. The
nature of the crime is different from traditional crimes, because while they are the worst
victims of the crime, people scarcely remember it. Greed is another of the crime
commission’s reasons. Some people claim that others break the rules as well, and so it’s not
bad if they do the same. Another factor inherent in committing crimes is requirement. To
appease their ego or help their families, people commit white collar crimes.
ORGANISED CRIMES
Organized crime is defined as “one involved in continuing serious illicit activity to a
considerable degree elsewhere, typically operating with others.” Organized offenders
operating together for the duration of a single illicit crime or crime are what we call an
orchestrated gang of criminals. The mechanisms of organised crime are distinct. Successful
gangs of organised crime often consist of a long-lasting nucleus of significant people. There
is a circle of supervisors, advisors, and other more temporary members accompanying them,
plus an expanded network of redundant associates. In reality, most gangs are loose networks
of criminals that come together for the duration of an illicit activity, operating on their skills
and expertise in different roles. Collaboration is strengthened by shared knowledge (such as
incarceration) or guidance from trustworthy individuals. Others are related to family or race
relations. Organized criminals make use of practitioners, often from a number of criminal
organisations, who deliver services. Tools include transportation, money laundering, loan
management or the supply of false documents, a wide number of organised criminals
underpin identity theft.