Topic Report v4
Topic Report v4
A Project Report
Session – 2024-2025
Department of Commerce
S. D. College of Commerce
1|Page
Approval Performa of the Project Proposal
2|Page
Declaration
I hereby declare that the project titled “A Comparative Analysis of Financial Performance of HDFC
Bank and ICICI Bank,” undertaken at Muzaffarnagar, is an original work and has not been submitted,
in part or in full, to any other university or institution for the award of any degree, to the best of my
knowledge and belief.
This project has been carried out in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the award of the degree
of Master of Commerce (M. Com), 4th Semester, as a part of the prescribed academic curriculum.
This project has been carried out in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the award of the degree
of Master of Commerce (M. Com), 4th Semester, as a part of the prescribed academic curriculum.
3|Page
S D College of Commerce
(Affiliated from Maa Shakumbhari University, Saharanpur)
Bhopa Road, Muzaffarnagar – 251001 (Uttar Pradesh)
Department of Commerce
CERTIFICATE
Signature
Date
4|Page
Acknowledgement
5|Page
TABLE OF CONTENT
Chapter I: Introduction of the Topic
6|Page
Chapter 5. Results & Discussion
5.3 Conclusion
REFERENCES
ANNEXURE
7|Page
Chapter-1
INTRODUCTION
8|Page
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION TO THE TOPIC
In the modern economic framework, the banking sector holds a place of paramount
of funds from savers to borrowers. Banks not only mobilize public deposits but also
provide credit and financial services to various sectors of the economy, thereby fostering
growth and stability. In India, the private banking sector has witnessed dynamic growth
over the past two decades, marked by increased competition, innovation, and regulatory
reforms. Among the most prominent private sector banks in India are HDFC Bank and
ICICI Bank, both of which have contributed significantly to the development of the
Despite operating under the same macroeconomic conditions and regulatory framework
provided by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank have adopted
portfolio diversification, and customer service models. These strategic differences often
reflect in their financial performance. Hence, a comparative study of these two banks
provides valuable insights into how various internal policies, management efficiencies,
HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank stems from the need to assess and evaluate their relative
matter of interest not only for investors and shareholders but also for regulators, analysts,
academicians, and the general public. Evaluating financial performance using a set of
9|Page
indicators, capital adequacy, and earnings stability—enables stakeholders to draw
meaningful conclusions about the sustainability and growth potential of these institutions.
This study becomes even more relevant in the context of the increasing complexity of
financial markets, economic uncertainties, and the growing role of digital banking. As
banks like HDFC and ICICI manage these challenges. A systematic and data-driven
comparative analysis provides a foundation for identifying best practices and areas that
Furthermore, the findings of this study can serve as a practical reference for students of
finance and management, helping them understand real-world banking performance and
decision-making. It can also guide prospective investors in making informed choices
based on financial facts and trends. By critically examining and comparing financial
indicators over a span of years, this study aims to highlight the operational strengths,
weaknesses, and overall financial soundness of both banks.
In essence, the rationale of this study is rooted in its potential to contribute to the broader
understanding of private sector banking in India, to support academic learning, and to aid
According to "Banking Companies Act, 1949", "banking means the accepting (for the
The banking practices is as old as the human culture. The public bank was established in
Italy in 1157 AD named as Bank of Venice, banking industry in modern form was
10 | P a g e
prospered in around 19th century. The British Companies Act, 1883 and Joint Stock
Companies Act, 1833 gave birth to commercial banks in England and India respectively.
In India in 1881 "Oudh Bank" was first bank to be registered under companies act.
In India the companies act was not adequate to regulate and control banks hence, the
Banking Regulation Act, 1949 came into act on March 16, 1949
as the primary institution for financial intermediation. It facilitates the flow of funds
economic development. In India, the banking sector plays a crucial role not only in
capital formation but also in supporting government policies related to inclusive growth,
digitalization, and poverty alleviation. Over the years, it has evolved from a traditional,
industry.
The Indian banking system is classified into two major segments: scheduled banks and
non-scheduled banks. Scheduled banks are further categorized into commercial banks
(which include public sector banks, private sector banks, foreign banks, and regional rural
banks) and cooperative banks. Among these, private sector banks have emerged as a
Since the economic liberalization of the Indian economy in 1991, the banking sector has
new private sector banks, encouraged the infusion of capital, promoted transparency, and
led to the adoption of international standards in banking operations. This reformative era
11 | P a g e
brought a wave of innovation and modernization to the banking industry, improving its
Today, the Indian banking sector operates under the comprehensive regulatory oversight
of the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), which ensures monetary stability, manages
inflation, and enforces sound banking practices. In addition, bodies like the Securities
Authority of India (IRDAI), and Ministry of Finance work in conjunction with the
RBI to maintain a stable financial ecosystem. The introduction of Basel norms, non-
sector lending targets has further strengthened the regulatory framework of the industry.
One of the most remarkable shifts in the Indian banking industry has been the adoption of
technology and digital banking solutions. Banks have embraced core banking systems
electronic payment gateways, UPI (Unified Payments Interface), digital wallets, and
operational costs. These technological interventions have enabled banks to expand their
reach, improve service quality, and cater to the changing preferences of a digitally aware
customer base.
The Indian banking industry has also played a pivotal role in promoting financial
inclusion, especially through initiatives like the Pradhan Mantri Jan Dhan Yojana
(PMJDY), which aims to bring every household into the formal banking system.
payments, and rural credit schemes have further pushed the industry towards inclusive
growth.
12 | P a g e
In this competitive environment, private sector banks, particularly HDFC Bank and
ICICI Bank, have set benchmarks in terms of financial performance, innovation, risk
management, and service delivery. HDFC Bank is widely recognized for its conservative
yet efficient approach to risk management and a strong retail banking network, while
ICICI Bank is known for its diversified portfolio, strong digital infrastructure, and
aggressive expansion strategies. Both banks are listed on Indian and international stock
Types of Banks
1. Commercial bank
3. Private banks
6. Foreign banks
7. Cooperative banks
8. Non-scheduled banks
The organized sector includes rbi, commercial banks, and cooperative bank
Reserve bank of India is the India central largest banks which works on the demand
and supply of the money. It plays huge role in the monetary functions of india.it helps
Scheduled bank Scheduled Bank: Scheduled banks are covered under the 2nd
Schedule of the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934. A bank that has a paid-up capital of
Rs. 5 Lakhs and above qualifies for the schedule bank category. These banks are
Commercial bank: Commercial Banks are regulated under the Banking Regulation
Act, 1949 and their business model is designed to make profit. Their primary function
is to accept deposits and grant loans to the general public, corporate and government
A. Public sector banks: These are the nationalized banks and account for more than
75 per cent of the total banking business in the country. Majority of stakes in these
banks are held by the government. In terms of volume, SBI is the largest public
sector bank in India and after its merger with its 5 associate banks (as on 1st April
2017) it has got a position among the top 50 banks of the world.
B. Private sector banks: These include banks in which major stake or equity is held
by private shareholders. All the banking rules and regulations laid down by the
RBI will be applicable on private sector banks as well. Given below is the list of
Foreign banks: A foreign bank is one that has its headquarters in a foreign country but
14 | P a g e
operates in India as a private entity. These banks are under the obligation to follow the
regulations of its home country as well as the country in which they are operating. Citi
Bank, Standard Chartered Bank and HSBC are some leading foreign banks in India.
Regional rural banks: A foreign bank is one that has its headquarters in a foreign
country but operates in India as a private entity. These banks are under the obligation
to follow the regulations of its home country as well as the country in which they are
operating. City Bank, Standard Chartered Bank and HSBC are some leading foreign
banks in India.
Non- Scheduled banks: As per the Second Schedule of the Banking Regulation Act of
1965 a bank must satisfy the following conditions, to get fully authorized to run
a) Primary Credit Societies- These institutions are formed at village level or town level.
(b) District Central Cooperative Banks- These banks operate at the district level. They
act as a link between primary credit societies and state cooperative banks
(c) State Cooperative Banks- State Cooperative Banks are biggest forms of cooperative
banks. They operate at the state level. Some of State Cooperative banks operate in multi
States.
Cooperative bank: Cooperative banks are owned by their customers and follow the
15 | P a g e
cooperative principle of one person, one vote. Co-operative banks are often regulated
under both banking and cooperative legislation. They provide services such as savings
and loans to non-members as well as to members, and some participate in the wholesale
markets for bonds, money and even equities. Many cooperative banks are traded on
public stock markets, with the result that they are partly owned by non-members.
Member control is diluted by these outside stakes, so they may be regarded as semi-
cooperative.
16 | P a g e
1.1.1HOUSING DEVELOPMENT FINANCE CORPORATION.
from the merger of HDFC Ltd, a pioneering Housing Finance Company, and HDFC
Bank, the largest private sector bank in India, announced on April 4, 2022. With a legacy
of 45 years, HDFC Ltd has built a reputation for offering top-tier housing finance
products, while HDFC Bank extends a wide array of financial services, including
seamless home loan delivery across urban, semi-urban, and rural India. As of February
29, 2024, HDFC Bank boasts an extensive distribution network comprising 8,192
branches and 20,760 ATMs/Cash Recycler Machines across 3,836 cities/towns, including
HDFC Ltd.'s 737 outlets and 214 offices amalgamated into the bank's network.
offices in four countries, catering to Non-Resident Indians and Persons of Indian Origin
17 | P a g e
HDFC Bank Limited, commonly known as HDFC, stands as a prominent Indian banking
and financial services institution, boasting the distinction of being India's largest private
sector bank by assets. As of January 2024, it ranks as the world's sixth-largest bank by
market capitalization, a testament to its robust presence and stature in the global financial
landscape. Following its acquisition of its parent company HDFC, HDFC Bank has
Designated by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) as one of the Domestic Systemically
Important Banks (D-SIBs), alongside entities like State Bank of India and ICICI Bank,
HDFC Bank carries the weight of being considered "too big to fail." This recognition
underscores its systemic importance and the critical role it plays within India's financial
infrastructure.
Established in August 1994, HDFC Bank commenced operations in January 1995 after
receiving approval from the RBI to operate as a private sector bank, coinciding with the
garnering a market capitalization of $145 billion as of April 2024. This places HDFC
Bank as the third largest company on Indian stock exchanges, reflecting its immense
Beyond financial metrics, HDFC Bank is also a significant employer in India, boasting
nearly 1.73 lakh employees and ranking as the sixteenth largest employer in the country.
This extensive workforce underscores the bank's significant contribution to job creation
18 | P a g e
HDFC Bank offers a diverse range of products and services covering wholesale banking,
retail banking, treasury operations, and an array of loan options including auto loans,
two-wheeler loans, personal loans, loans against property, and consumer durable loans.
Additionally, the bank provides lifestyle loans and credit cards. Complementing these
On April 4, 2022, HDFC Bank announced its merger with the Housing Development Finance
Corporation. Following the merger's completion, HDFC emerged as the fourth-largest bank
globally by market capitalization. The merger was slated to be effective from July 1, 2023. As
19 | P a g e
part of the merger, HDFC, primarily a housing financing corporation, would transfer its home
loan portfolio to HDFC Bank. Furthermore, depositors of the housing financing company
were given the option to either withdraw their funds or renew their deposits with the private
HDFC BANK IS THE LARGEST BANK IN INDIA has their headquarter in the Mumbai
HDFC bank is the largest bank by assets.it is the largest bank by market value.
It has market capital of 8trillion.it is the third largest company of NSE national stock
exchange.
HDFC banks provide many services to their customers as in the form of loans,
deposits, locker security. Auto Loans'd, two-wheeler loans, loans against the house
Investment
20 | P a g e
In march 2020 the bank has the investment of huge amount in the YES
bank. The shares of the hdfc listed in the NSE and BSE.
21 | P a g e
1.1.2 ICICI BANK
ICICI Bank, founded in 1955 through collaborative efforts of the World Bank, the
Government of India, and Indian industry representatives, initially focused on project finance
to support industrial projects. With the liberalization of India's financial sector in the 1990s,
ICICI transitioned into a diversified financial services provider, expanding its offerings to
include a broad spectrum of products and services. In 1994, ICICI Bank was incorporated,
Subsequently, in 2001, ICICI and its wholly-owned retail finance subsidiaries merged with
ICICI Bank, paving the way for a comprehensive suite of financial solutions. Notably, ICICI
Bank made history in 1999 as the first Indian company and non-Japan Asia bank to list on the
New York Stock Exchange, signifying its global recognition and stature in the financial
world.
22 | P a g e
This development finance institution boasts a vast network comprising 6,000 branches and
17,000 ATMs spread across India, with a presence in 17 countries. It operates subsidiaries in
the United Kingdom and Canada, alongside branches in the United States, Singapore,
Bahrain, Hong Kong, Qatar, Oman, Dubai International Finance Centre, China, and South
Africa. Additionally, representative offices are established in the United Arab Emirates,
Bangladesh, Malaysia, and Indonesia. Notably, the company's UK subsidiary has expanded
Recognizing their systemic importance, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has designated the
State Bank of India, HDFC Bank, and ICICI Bank as Domestic Systemically Important Banks
ICICI Bank provides a wide array of products and services catering to various financial needs.
These include savings and current accounts, trade and forex services, fixed and recurring
deposits, business loans, home loans, personal loans, auto loans, gold loans, NRI banking
services, remittances, card services, lockers, and agri and rural services. Their digital
platforms offer seamless banking experiences, with offerings such as iMobile Pay, InstaBiz,
Digital Rupee App, Retail Internet Banking, Corporate Internet Banking, Money2India,
In March 2020, ICICI Bank introduced 'ICICI STACK,' a comprehensive digital banking suite
tailored for individuals, merchants, and corporates, providing a range of online services
Moreover, in December 2020, the bank launched 'iMobile Pay', an interoperable app
facilitating payment and banking services for customers across multiple banking institutions.
Originally launched as iMobile in 2008, iMobile Pay offers over 350 services and garnered
over 10 million sign-ups from non-ICICI Bank account holders by September 2023.
23 | P a g e
Additionally, in July 2019, ICICI Bank rolled out the InstaBIZ app aimed at offering
enhanced banking and value-added services to micro, small, and medium (MSME) customers,
as well as customers of any bank. InstaBIZ enables merchants to instantly collect payments
using UPI IDs and QR codes. The app has approximately 1.5 million active users with
ICICI bank is the leading private sector bank which has headquarter in Gujrat and
Mumbai.
FORMED IN 1995 with the main of providing long term loan and medium term loan
ICICI bank provide services like net banking, long term loans and short term loans ,
locker facility, loan against security, credit cards ,debit card, ATM cards, CICI
wallets.
ICICI bank has also listed in BSE and NSE of the India.
24 | P a g e
ICICI Bank is one of the big four bank of India. The bank has subsidiaries in the United
Kingdom and Canada; branches in United States, Singapore, Bahrain, Hong Kong, Qatar,
Oman, Dubai International Finance Centre, China[and South Africa] as well as representative
offices in United Arab Emirates, Bangladesh, Malaysia and Indonesia. The company's UK
25 | P a g e
1.1Justification of the topic
The topic “A Comparative Analysis of Financial Performance of HDFC Bank and ICICI
Bank” has been chosen due to its strong relevance in the present-day financial and
economic environment, where the performance and stability of banks are under constant
scrutiny by investors, regulators, and the public. The banking sector is not only the
lifeline of any economy but also a major driver of financial inclusion, economic
development, and capital mobilization. In India, the banking industry has undergone
significant transformations in the last few decades, especially following the economic
liberalization of the 1990s. These changes have brought in increased competition, the
emergence of new private sector banks, widespread technological adoption, and stricter
regulatory frameworks.
Amidst this evolving banking landscape, two private sector banks—HDFC Bank and
ICICI Bank—have emerged as industry leaders, commanding large market shares, vast
customer bases, and a strong presence in both urban and rural areas. These banks are
advancement, and service innovation. However, while both are leaders in the same sector
and often seen as peers, they differ significantly in terms of their origin, strategic
orientation, risk appetite, customer focus, and financial management practices. These
The justification for selecting this topic lies in the critical need to understand how
different strategic and operational choices impact the financial performance of major
study aims to provide clarity on which bank performs better in specific financial
dimensions such as profitability, liquidity, capital adequacy, earnings quality, and asset
This topic is also justified from a stakeholder analysis perspective. Investors require
Customers want to bank with institutions that are financially strong and service-efficient.
Regulators are concerned with systemic stability and need to monitor the financial health
side-by-side financial evaluation of two industry giants serves all of these purposes
simultaneously.
Additionally, this topic is especially relevant in the post-COVID era, where banking
management. During the pandemic, banks were tested on their ability to maintain
liquidity, control credit risk, and continue lending under stressful conditions. A
insights into which institutions are better prepared for future shocks and economic
uncertainties.
From an academic standpoint, the study allows for an in-depth exploration of financial
analysis tools such as ratio analysis, trend analysis, comparative financial statement
analysis, and benchmarking. It enables the application of these tools on actual financial
data, thereby bridging the gap between theoretical learning and practical financial
27 | P a g e
assessment. Such an analysis enhances financial literacy and analytical thinking, which
are essential skills for any student pursuing finance, accounting, or management.
Moreover, HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank are not only national players but also have
international footprints, which makes this study more impactful in understanding global
best practices and how Indian banks are positioning themselves on the global financial
Return on Equity (ROE), Net Interest Margin (NIM), Gross NPA ratio, and Capital
Adequacy Ratio (CAR) reflect their strategic strengths and operational capabilities.
Bank and ICICI Bank” is highly justified given its relevance, depth, and value addition.
It addresses a timely and practical need to assess the financial robustness of leading
stakeholders, and provides meaningful academic and professional insights into banking
performance and strategy. The comparative nature of the study enhances its analytical
28 | P a g e
Chapter : 2
REVIEW OF LITREATURE
29 | P a g e
REVIEW OF LITREATURE
A comprehensive review of literature provides insights into previous studies conducted on
financial performance analysis across both national and international contexts. It helps
identify trends, methodologies, findings, and existing gaps that justify the relevance of the
current research. This section includes a mix of both national (Indian) and international
financial analyses using financial ratios, performance frameworks, and benchmarking tools.
In their study “A Comparative Study on Financial Performance of HDFC and ICICI Bank,”
the authors used financial ratios to evaluate profitability, liquidity, and efficiency. They found
HDFC Bank to have more stable and consistent growth compared to ICICI Bank, which faced
volatility due to higher NPAs.
Their research focused on comparing private sector banks using profitability, asset quality,
and solvency ratios. The study concluded that HDFC Bank had better earnings and capital
adequacy metrics, whereas ICICI Bank showed improvement in asset quality over time.
In the article “Financial Performance Comparison: HDFC vs ICICI Bank”, a five-year trend
analysis showed HDFC Bank performing better due to more conservative financial
management, consistent returns, and better asset quality.
30 | P a g e
4. Ramesh K. & Kavitha R. (2019)
This study compared several private banks including HDFC and ICICI using trend analysis
and financial ratios. They found that HDFC Bank’s consistent return on assets and higher net
interest margins placed it ahead of ICICI Bank in financial strength.
RBI’s Financial Stability Reports and Banking Sector Performance Reviews provide critical
macroeconomic and financial insights into Indian banks. These reports consistently highlight
private sector banks like HDFC and ICICI as leading institutions in terms of credit growth,
technological adoption, and risk management.
In his comparative study of Malaysian commercial banks, Sufian evaluated bank performance
using ROA, ROE, and NIM. He observed that private banks tend to outperform government-
owned banks in terms of profitability and operational efficiency.
The study “Factors Influencing Performance of UAE Commercial Banks” identified risk
management, capital adequacy, and technological capability as key drivers of financial
performance. This aligns with similar findings in India where private banks outperform due to
advanced risk control and innovation.
31 | P a g e
4. Flamini, V., McDonald, C., & Schumacher, L. (2009) – Africa
This IMF study titled “The Determinants of Commercial Bank Profitability in Sub-Saharan
Africa” highlighted that bank size, inflation, and credit risk are major factors affecting
profitability. These findings are useful in understanding how macroeconomic factors
influence bank performance globally, including in India.
In their work on bank efficiency and financial performance, the authors used econometric
models to establish that cost efficiency, asset utilization, and sound risk management lead to
superior financial results—lessons that also apply to Indian banks like HDFC and ICICI.
ICICI Bank, while competitive, has faced challenges in asset management but has
improved over time.
Common tools across both domains include Return on Assets (ROA), Return on
Equity (ROE), Net Interest Margin (NIM), and Capital Adequacy Ratios (CAR).
32 | P a g e
Chapter 3
RESEARCH
METHODOLOGY
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
33 | P a g e
Research methodology is the backbone of any academic research as it defines the framework
ensures that the study is objective, reliable, and valid. In this research, the methodology has
two of India’s leading private sector banks—HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank. The
profitability, efficiency, liquidity, and solvency, and drawing meaningful conclusions using
Type of Research
Descriptive research aims to describe the existing financial performance of the banks
Analytical research involves the use of quantitative tools like financial ratios, trend
analysis, and comparisons to interpret the collected data and make logical conclusions
4. Two study the profitability performance of the HDFC and ICICI banks.
5. To give the findings and suggestions to enhance the performance of the banks.
34 | P a g e
Research hypothesis
A hypothesis is an assumption that demonstrates the interpreted relationships among various
possible factors. The hypothesized correlation coefficients are based on existing writings.
Many such inferential statistics or methodologies can be used to confirm all such
relationships. Based on the success of regression techniques, these hypotheses may or may
not be embraced.
H0= There is no significance difference between of gross profit ratio in selected HDFC Bank
H1= There is a significance difference between of gross profit ratios of selected HDFC Bank
H0= There is no significance difference between of Net profit ratio in selected HDFC Bank
H1= There is a significance difference between of Net profit ratio in selected HDFC Bank and
ICICI Bank
H0= There is no significance difference between of Return on assets ratio in selected HDFC
35 | P a g e
H1= There is a significance difference between of Return on assets ratio in selected HDFC
36 | P a g e
Scope of the study
Financial statement analysis is used to identify the past trends and relationships between
financial and profitability statement items. Both internal users and external users such as
analysts, creditors, and investors of the banks financial statements need to assess a
company's profitability, liquidity, and solvency. The most common methods we use for
financial statement analysis are trend analysis, common‐size statements, and ratio analysis.
These methods include calculations and comparisons of the results to historical and
secondary data of the banks , competitors annual reports, or industry averages to determine
Data collection
The sample of the study only includes two banks; HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank. Simple
random sampling was used to select the sample from this banks which are working in the
stock market based on the current situation. The study works on largely on secondary data
that was taken from the annual reports of the selected banks. Seconday data is collected from
the IBA Bulletins, RBI publications, different publication, Bank Quest and journals , various
books, periodicals, journals and relating banking industry etc. have also been used for better
Annual report and different publications have also been used in this study. The collected data
is duly edited, classifies, tabulated according to the needs of the objectives and hypothesis.
Mathematical and statistical tools and techniques like Ratio, Trends, Simple & multiple
correlations have been used. The most appropriate Parametric & Non parametric test have
37 | P a g e
Type of Data
The study uses secondary data, which is data already published and available in the public
domain.
Sources of Data
Annual Reports of HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank for the years 2019 to 2023.
Publications by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), including the Financial Stability
Reputed financial portals like Moneycontrol, NSE, BSE, and Yahoo Finance.
38 | P a g e
A. Profitability Ratios
These ratios indicate how efficiently a bank generates profit:
B. Liquidity Ratios
These measure a bank’s ability to meet short-term obligations:
C. Efficiency Ratios
These show how well the bank uses its assets and controls costs:
D. Solvency Ratios
These measure the long-term financial stability of the bank:
Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR) = (Tier 1 + Tier 2 Capital) / Risk Weighted Assets
39 | P a g e
E. Market-Based Ratios
These offer investor insights:
F. Analytical Techniques
Trend Analysis: Observing the direction of financial ratios over five years.
Graphical Analysis: Bar graphs and line charts will be used to visually interpret
trends.
The limitation of the study is only that the data is collected by secondary source of the banks.
The data is taken from the past five years and one reports of the banks. and whatever the
outcome will come be depend on this secondary data. The data is taken from consecutive past
five years.
This study covers only 2 banks listed and actively traded on NSE and BSE out of whole
banking industries therefore the results might or might not be same for the whole banking
industry.
The study is limited to secondary data, which may carry the risk of reporting bias or
outdated information.
Non-financial performance indicators (like customer satisfaction, brand loyalty, or
employee engagement) are not considered.
The study does not factor in external macroeconomic factors in great detail, such as
inflation, currency fluctuation, or political risks.
As it focuses only on two banks, the results may not be generalized to the entire Indian
40 | P a g e
banking sector
CHAPTER 4
41 | P a g e
Data Representation and Interpretation
To interpret the data, various statistical techniques are used. The analysis is limited to Gross
Profit Ratio, Net Profit margin Ratio, Return on Asset, and Return on Capital Employed. All
the data related to these aspects are presented and discussed below.
This ratio measures the gross profit on the total net sales made or earned by the company.
The gross profit represents the excess of sales proceeds during the period under observation
over their cost, before taking into account administration, selling and distribution and
financing charges.
Importance
• This ratio shows the relationship between the gross profit and net sales
42 | P a g e
43 | P a g e
44 | P a g e
Interpretation
The table above, the Gross Profit Ratio of the HDFC and ICICI Banks are represented during
the time period of the study from 2015-16 to 2019-20. In HDFC Bank the Ratio shoes
continuously increasing trend. The average Profit Ratio of the HDFC Bank were19.678%
during the study period. The ratio was the highest to 22.23% during 2019-20, whereas it was
In case of ICICI Bank the Ratio shows fluctuating trend during the study period. It was
In HDFC Bank the Ratio was higher during the study period. Hence the performance of
45 | P a g e
b) Net Profit Margin Ratio
This is the ratio of net profit to net sales. The concept of net profit is different from net
operating profit. In calculating the net profit, all non-operating expenses and losses are also
deducted and all non-operating income is added. The net profit ratio is the overall measure of
a firm’s ability to turn each rupee of business income into profit. It indicates the efficiency
with which a business is managed. A firm with a high net profit ratio is in an advantageous
position to survive in the face of cost of firm. where the net profit is low, the firm will find it
It’s computed as
Where, Net profit = Net operating Profit + Non-op Operating Incomes- Non-operating
Expenses.
46 | P a g e
Interpretation
The above table indicates the Net Profit Ratio of the HDFC and ICICI Banks during the
period of the study from 2015-16 to 2019-20. In HDFC Bank the Ratio shows fluctuating
trend. The average Profit Ratio of the HDFC Bank was 21.11% during the time of study
period. The ratio was the highest in 21.79% during 2018-19, where as it was the lowest of
20.41% during 2016-17. In case of ICICI Bank the Ratio shows decreasing trend during the
study period. This show that the ratio 22.76% in 2015-16 which decrease to 5.304% in 2019-
20 it was lowest. In HDFC Bank the Ratio was higher during the study period, Hence the
performance of HDFC bank is good than ICICI Bank except in one year.
47 | P a g e
c) Return on Total Assets Ratio Return on assets
Return on Total Assets Ratio Return on assets (ROA) is an indicator of how profitable a
company is relative to its total assets. ROA gives a manager, investor, or analyst an idea as
Businesses (at least the ones that survive) are ultimately about efficiency: squeezing the most
out of limited resources. Comparing profits to revenue is a useful operational metric, but
comparing them to the resources a company used to earn them cuts to the very feasibility of
that company's’ existence. Return on assets (ROA) is the simplest of such corporate bang-for-
the buck measures. ROA is calculated by dividing a company’s net income by total assets. As
48 | P a g e
49 | P a g e
interpretation
The given table indicates the Return on Assets Ratio of the HDFC and ICICI Banks during
the period of the study from 2015-16 to 2019-20. In HDFC Bank the Ratio shows fluctuating
trend. The average Profit Ratio of the HDFC Bank was 1.69 during the study period. The
ratio was the higher to 1.73 during 2016-17, where as it was the lower to 1.643 during 2018-
19. In case of ICICI Bank the Ratio shows decreasing trend during the study period. It was
1.735 in 2015- 16 which decreases to 0.272 in 2019-20 it was lowest. In HDFC Bank the
Ratio was higher during the study period, Hence the performance of HDFC bank is good than
50 | P a g e
d) Return on capital employed.
The term investment may refer to total assets or net assets. The funds employed in net assets
are known as capital employed. Net assets equal net fixed assets plus current assets minus
current liabilities excluding bank loan. Alternatively, capital employed is equal to net worth
Return on Capital Employed = Net Profit Before Interest and Tax/ Capital
Employed significance:
51 | P a g e
52 | P a g e
interpretation
The table indicates the Capital Employed Ratio of the HDFC and ICICI Banks during the
period of the study from 2015-16 to 2019-20. In HDFC Bank the Ratio shows fluctuating
trend. The average Profit Ratio of the HDFC Bank was 1.788 during thetime of study period.
The ratio was the higher of 1.83 during 2015-16, where as it was the lower of 1.72 during
2018- 19. In case of ICICI Bank the Ratio shows fluctuated trend during the study period. It
was 0.171 in 2015-16 which decrease to 0.289 in 2019-20 it was lowest. In HDFC Bank the
Ratio was higher during the study period, Hence the performance of HDFC bank is good than
53 | P a g e
Hypothesis testing
H0= There is no significance difference between of gross profit ratio in selected HDFC Bank
H1= There is a significance difference between of gross profit ratio in selected HDFC Bank
This indicates that calculated value of ‘t’ is 4.4383, while table value of ‘t’ is 2.306 which is
less than the calculated value. So null hypothesis is rejected and alternative hypothesis is
accepted. It shows that there is a significance difference in Gross Profit Ratio of HDFC Bank
54 | P a g e
Hypothesis testing for net profit ratio
H0= There is no significance difference between of Net profit ratio in selected HDFC Bank
H1= There is a significance difference between of Net profit ratio in selected HDFC Bank
55 | P a g e
Two-Sample Assuming Equal Variances
RESULT
This shows the result of t-test according to that calculated value of ‘t’ is 1.8926, while table
value of ‘t’ is 2.306 which is less than the calculated value. So, null hypothesis is accepted
significance difference in Net Profit Ratio of HDFC Bank and ICICI bank.
56 | P a g e
CHAPTER – 5
RESULTS AND
DISCUSSIONS
57 | P a g e
FINDINGS
HDFC Bank has consistently maintained a higher Net Profit Margin than ICICI Bank over the
five-year study period (2019–2023), indicating more efficient cost management and
Return on Assets (ROA) remained higher for HDFC Bank across all years, showing that the
bank utilized its assets more effectively to generate income compared to ICICI Bank.
Earnings Per Share (EPS) of HDFC Bank was significantly higher than that of ICICI Bank,
Net Profit Margin, ROA, and EPS, particularly after 2020, suggesting strong recovery and
strategic realignment.
Both banks maintained a Current Ratio close to 1, indicating sound liquidity management
and the ability to meet short-term liabilities using their current assets. HDFC Bank’s slightly
HDFC Bank showed superior operational efficiency, with a consistently lower Cost-to-
Income Ratio. This indicates effective control over operating expenses and better
58 | P a g e
ICICI Bank showed a positive trend in operational efficiency, with its Cost-to-Income Ratio
decreasing over the years, signifying progress in reducing overheads and improving internal
cost structures.
Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR) for both banks exceeded regulatory norms, reflecting strong
financial stability and the ability to absorb potential losses without significant risk to
depositors or investors.
HDFC Bank maintained a marginally higher CAR than ICICI Bank throughout the study
period, suggesting a slightly stronger capital buffer and lower exposure to risk.
ICICI Bank exhibited substantial improvement in its solvency position, with a noticeable
rise in its CAR, showcasing effective risk management and capital optimization in recent
years.
HDFC Bank displayed consistent performance in all key financial indicators, underscoring
its strong foundation, stable operations, and continued dominance in the private banking
sector.
ICICI Bank significantly narrowed the performance gap with HDFC Bank over time,
Both banks performed well during and after the COVID-19 pandemic, with resilience
evident in their financial recovery, efficient cost management, and improved earnings.
59 | P a g e
From an investor's perspective, HDFC Bank remains a more stable and consistently
rewarding option, while ICICI Bank presents strong growth potential due to its rapid
60 | P a g e
Discussion and suggestions
maintain its competitive edge, particularly in digital banking and AI-driven customer
experience.
ICICI Bank is advised to further enhance its cost optimization strategies, as reducing the
Cost-to-Income Ratio will significantly improve its operational efficiency and net profitability
Both banks should diversify their income sources further, focusing on non-interest income
ICICI Bank should intensify efforts to strengthen its retail banking portfolio, as the retail
sector offers more stable returns and customer retention compared to corporate lending,
HDFC Bank, despite its strong position, should enhance rural and semi-urban outreach, as
financial inclusion in underbanked regions can open new markets and sustain long-term
growth.
Both banks should invest more in employee training and upskilling, especially in the areas
of fintech, cybersecurity, and customer service, to stay ahead in a rapidly evolving financial
environment.
61 | P a g e
ICICI Bank should focus on further improving its asset quality, by closely monitoring its loan
portfolio and minimizing non-performing assets (NPAs) through better credit risk
HDFC Bank could benefit from enhancing customer engagement through personalized
services, using advanced data analytics to tailor offerings based on customer profiles and
behavior.
Both banks should strengthen their environmental, social, and governance (ESG)
HDFC and ICICI should also improve transparency in their financial disclosures, by adopting
best practices in integrated reporting and sharing more real-time operational metrics with
stakeholders.
ICICI Bank can accelerate its digital transformation journey by further automating back-
office functions and expanding its suite of mobile and online banking services, to match or
strong capital buffers, regularly stress test their portfolios, and remain vigilant about
macroeconomic risks such as inflation, currency fluctuation, and global financial instability.
Collaborative initiatives between banks and fintech startups could be explored by both
62 | P a g e
63 | P a g e
CONCLUSION
CONCLUSION
64 | P a g e
The comparative analysis of the financial performance of HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank over
the period 2019 to 2023 provides valuable insights into the strengths, progress, and
competitive positions of these two major players in the Indian private banking sector.
HDFC Bank has consistently demonstrated superior financial performance across most key
parameters, including profitability, operational efficiency, liquidity, and solvency. Its stable
growth, robust earnings, higher returns, and effective cost management reflect strong internal
characteristics have enabled HDFC Bank to maintain its leadership position and market
On the other hand, ICICI Bank, while initially trailing in several metrics, has shown
remarkable improvement in recent years. The bank has enhanced its profitability, reduced its
cost-to-income ratio, improved its asset quality, and strengthened its capital base. These
Both banks have maintained sound liquidity and capital adequacy, reflecting their resilience
and preparedness to face future financial risks. Their steady adoption of digital banking and
economy.
In conclusion, while HDFC Bank leads in overall performance and consistency, ICICI Bank’s
rapid improvement and evolving strategy highlight its growing potential. Both institutions
serve as benchmarks for private sector banking in India, and their continued focus on
efficiency, customer service, and innovation will shape the future of Indian banking. For
65 | P a g e
investors, policymakers, and researchers, this comparative study offers critical perspectives
on sustainable banking practices and competitive dynamics in the financial services sector
66 | P a g e
REFERENCE
67 | P a g e
REFERENCE
https://www.hdfcbank.com
https://www.icicibank.com
3. Reserve Bank of India (RBI). (2023). Financial Stability Report. Retrieved from
https://www.rbi.org.in
4. Khan, M.Y., & Jain, P.K. (2020). Financial Management (8th ed.). Tata McGraw Hill
Education.
5. Pandey, I.M. (2021). Financial Management (11th ed.). Vikas Publishing House.
6. Sharma, R.K., & Gupta, S.K. (2020). Management Accounting. Kalyani Publishers.
7. Kaur, P., & Kaur, G. (2022). “Comparative study of financial performance of HDFC
Bank and ICICI Bank.” International Journal of Research in Finance and Marketing,
12(5), 101–110.
sector banks in India.” Journal of Banking and Finance Review, 7(2), 65–78.
9. Moneycontrol. (2023). Financial Ratios and Stock Data for HDFC and ICICI Bank.
10. Economic Times Markets. (2023). Banking Sector Updates and Analysis. Retrieved
from https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/markets
68 | P a g e
ANNEXURE
69 | P a g e
ANNEXURE
ICICI BANK
EQUITIES AND
LIABILITIES
SHAREHOLDE
R'S FUNDS
70 | P a g e
Deposits 1,610,348. 1,412,824. 1,180,840. 1,064,571. 932,522.16
02 95 70 61
ASSETS
OTHER
ADDITIONAL
INFORMATION
71 | P a g e
Capital Adequacy 16.55 16.33 18.34 19.16 19.12
Ratios (%)
KEY
PERFORMANC
E INDICATORS
ASSETS
QUALITY
CONTINGENT
LIABILITIES,
COMMITMENT
S
HDFC BANK
72 | P a g e
BALANCE MAR 25 MAR 24 MAR 23 MAR 22 MAR 21
SHEET OF
HDFC BANK (in
Rs. Cr.)
EQUITIES AND
LIABILITIES
SHAREHOLDE
R'S FUNDS
73 | P a g e
Other Liabilities 146,128.52 135,437.93 95,722.25 84,407.46 72,602.15
and Provisions
ASSETS
OTHER
ADDITIONAL
INFORMATION
KEY
74 | P a g e
PERFORMANC
E INDICATORS
ASSETS
QUALITY
CONTINGENT
LIABILITIES,
COMMITMENT
S
75 | P a g e