Impact of The Harmonic Pollution of Railway Locomotive On The Sound System: Experimental Measurement, Modelling and Simulating
Impact of The Harmonic Pollution of Railway Locomotive On The Sound System: Experimental Measurement, Modelling and Simulating
201
1
Power Electronics Team, Intelligent Control, Automatic and Robotic Techniques,
Mohammadia School of Engineers, Mohammed V University Rabat, Morocco
* Corresponding author’s Email: moine.elhajji@gmail.com
Abstract: Air pollution caused by the transport sector has become a very worrying subject. To minimize toxic gas
emissions, people start to prefer rail transportation. This high demand has caused high energy consumption in the
electric railway. Thus, Moroccan Railway Company was obliged to use different traction locomotives of different
technologies which can generate electromagnetic interferences between systems. Reason why the study of
electromagnetic pollution has become a necessity to avoid these inter-system electromagnetic disturbances by
analysing the experimental measurements on the railway site and by proposing a solution which is the
implementation of an active filter capable of eliminating the parasites caused during the connection of the
locomotive. However, the authorization to put into operation remains a real subject of study since different
parameters must be taken into account, namely the weight, the location, the size and the electromagnetic
interferences (EMI) of the filter. This paper discusses the electromagnetic noise by analyzing the impact of the
auxiliary power supply quality generated by electric locomotive E1250 on the sound systems when it is coupled to
multi-unit Corail cars and by detailing an overview of the conversion chain located in the electric locomotive under
test and the sound system installed in Corail car which keeps passengers constantly informed when approaching and
arriving at a station, and gives them other indications about the train. Next, static test bench and dynamic
experimental tests will be measured in order to determine the Electromagnetic Compatibility (EMC) disturbances in
the Common Mode (CM) by studying the harmonics generated by the static converter that feeds the Corail cars, and
analyzing their impact on all operating systems especially sound system since it is considered as a very sensitive
organ to the least source of noise. In the end, the conversion system will be modeled and a proposed solution will be
implemented to mitigate the electromagnetics noises.
Keywords: Railway transport, Power quality, Static converter, EMC, Harmonics pollution.
has become a commitment and a priority to avoid and the supply chain side of the train. The 3 phases
interference between railway equipment. power supply provided by the auxiliary static
Various reports of dysfunction of the sound converter feeds the Corail train to ensure the
system have been located when connecting an old comfort of the passengers on board such as air
type of locomotive named E1250 which is still in conditioning, heating, lighting, and sound system.
service since there is a high demand for availability That is why our study is based on the impact of the
of railway equipment during the specific periods. static converter of this type of locomotive E1250 on
The problem was raised thanks to a study made of the communication quality transmitted in the sound
the computerized maintenance management tool, system by analyzing the polluted harmonics power
which makes it possible to identify the steps of visits supply.
and revision of each organ of railway rolling stock. Reference [6] analyses how the railway
The problem is described as a noise parasite when Netherlands public transport deals with the high
coupling the locomotive with the Corail train demand during the peak period from an
because of harmonic electrical pollution that is environmental point of view, and how to make off-
considered to be a distortion of the sinusoidal signal peak period more attractive than the peak for
and has the effects mentioned below: travelers through the ticket price. In Ref. [9] deals
Instantaneous effects: that create disturbances in with the electromagnetic pollution in Italian railway
the functioning of devices sensitive to harmonics, lines by taking experimental measurements,
this is the case of the problem identified through the analyzing harmonics generated by different sources
parasites detected in the speakers. such as converters located in the Uninterruptible
Medium and long-term effects: that cause the Power Supply (UPS) and onboard the train. In Ref.
heating and premature aging of the electrical [10] analyzes a proposed method to reduce CO2
equipment, this advanced deterioration of the organs emissions and energy costs by introducing a new
often generates breakdowns which obliges the solution of reactive power and compensation in
railway company to replace them before the date of order to minimize the THD. In Ref. [11] proposes
the change prescribed by the maintenance how Chinese railway deals with the citizen protest
management tool. against expansion of the railway high speed
Harmonic analysis and the quality of the power infrastructure because of health and environmental
system is fundamental for the electric railway impacts such as noise, destruction of green areas,
transport, the energy is regulated and fed to electric electromagnetic compatibility in the radiation mode.
motors to provide traction for railway vehicles. To mitigate Total Harmonic Distortion (THD)
Auxiliary power dedicated for forced ventilation of which is significant of the pollution of the three-
electric traction motors and passenger comfort is phase network supplied by the locomotive, EMC
also regulated but can be a major source of interferences study in the CM was carried out based
electromagnetic noise. Because, it has many on the impact of the auxiliary static converter of the
considerable and even catastrophic impact locomotive on the sound system installed in the
especially on the functioning of the railway Corail cars. This interference causes noise in the
signaling systems for different cases of cantonment speakers that announces permanent location
such as European Rail Traffic Management System information of the train which requires us to isolate
(ERTMS) the restricted automatic block with track the sound system to avoid noise disturbances,
circuit or axle counter [7, 8]. The resonance however passengers report their dissatisfaction with
phenomenon can be caused by many sources such as the non-functioning of the sound system. This is
the auxiliary static converters located in the why experimental measures have been done to
locomotive. The 3 kV DC power source comes from analyze the behavior of the power supply provided
the sub-station which is composed of a step-down by the static converter [12, 13], it has been modeled
transformer with two secondary windings, a silicon through Matlab-Simulink with a proposed solution
diode rectifier and it is transmitted to the railway implemented in the output of the static converter
traction vehicle by a system of suspended flexible which is the active filter chosen because of his
contact lines called catenary with an articulated power gain, it provides reliable operation control
device mounted on a locomotive called pantograph systems to eliminate any harmonic despite the
is brought into contact as seen in Fig.1. Once the variable amplitude of harmonic ranks due to the
substation feeds the locomotive through the catenary, variable load on the Corail train side and to mitigate
we distinguish in the locomotive the traction power the harmonic distortion pollution rate that impacts
train through motors, and auxiliary for forced the operating of the sound system and cause the
ventilation of motors, reactor vessels, resistances premature aging of the equipment on board the train,
International Journal of Intelligent Engineering and Systems, Vol.13, No.3, 2020 DOI: 10.22266/ijies2020.0630.19
Received: February 14, 2020. Revised: March 10, 2020. 203
Table 3. The systems powered by the CVS train side 3. Experimental measurements of the
Systems installed for each Corail car alimentation output voltage of the static converter
Air conditioning system 380V - 50 Hz
Lightning system 220V - 50 Hz 3.1 Measuring instruments and mode
Sound system 220V - 50 Hz
Automatic closing system for access To experimentally investigate the power quality
220V - 50 Hz
doors and electric harmonic pollution presence in the
Others 220V - 50 Hz power supply generated by the locomotive [14].
Many measurements were performed on the
2.2 Sound system Moroccan railway lines within two operations:
The sound system installed in the rail passenger
transport equipment is very important and - Operation 1: was dedicated for static
primordial since it announces the following measurements in a maintenance depot, the input
information: the permanent location by self- and output power measurement of each organ
localization, the next stations and next stops, the reported in Fig. 9, 10, 11 in particular the
destination, climate and other information, etc. interference observations on the sound system
Sound system train consists of different elements test bench.
starting with the GPS box capable of processing the - Operation 2: was dedicated for dynamic
location frames through a GPS antenna and measurements reported in Fig. 12 on a track
connected to a control box that allows the from Marrakech to Rabat which was given
processing and transfer of information during the off-peak period thanks to the layout
announcement through an armored cable named of the regulation so as not to disturb the train
LTS composed of 4 wires (LT1, LT2, LTM) and traffic.
which is connected to an amplifier to amplify and
diffuse the signal by the speakers as reported in the The power quality and harmonics measurements
Fig 6. provided by the locomotive at the electric coupler
This system installed in Corail cars was were made by a network analyzer capable of
developed in our research laboratory to make the recording the voltage and current readings in real
necessary tests to analyze the cause of parasite time. The tests were carried out by installing
because of the feeding provided by the auxiliary ammeter pincer and crocodile pincer of each phase
static converter of the locomotive as seen in the Fig. and neutral were plugged into the analyzer as seen
7. in the Fig. 8 and then plugged into a software
recorder installed in a laptop to store all the power
and energy data consumed in the path. Static and
dynamic tests on a test railway track were carried in
order to understand and to analyze closely the noise
of the sound system and to understand the power
quality supply of the static converter under test, the
Figure. 6 Synoptic diagram of the sound system aim of this tests is recording the absorbed voltage
and current waveform of each phase onboard the
train and the output coupler.
The electric coupler reported in Fig. 8 has 4
cables including 3 phases and neutral surrounded by
a non-flammable rubber sheath. It allows the
continuous transmission of power between each
Corail car and the locomotive as shown in the Fig. 4,
the return loop is done in the last car of the train.
International Journal of Intelligent Engineering and Systems, Vol.13, No.3, 2020 DOI: 10.22266/ijies2020.0630.19
Received: February 14, 2020. Revised: March 10, 2020. 206
√∑𝑛𝑖=2 𝐼𝑛2
(1)
𝑇𝐻𝐷 − 𝐼(%) = × 100
𝐼1
350
300
250
200
150
100
50,0
V 0,00
-50,0
-100
-150
-200
-250
-300
-350
12/07/2019 19,992 (ms) 12/07/2019
20:34:54.799 3 ms/Div 20:34:54.819
300
250
200
150
100
50,0
A 0,00
-50,0
-100
-150
-200
-250
-300
International Journal of Intelligent Engineering and Systems, Vol.13, No.3, 2020 DOI: 10.22266/ijies2020.0630.19
Received: February 14, 2020. Revised: March 10, 2020. 208
Table 4. Statistical analysis of the harmonic content of the static converter recorded during the measurements
Harmonic order Frequency (Hz) Amplitude of Phase 1 Amplitude of phase 2 amplitude of phase 3
1 50 235.5 216.7 224.8
3 150 1.2 3.6 1.1
5 250 19.8 22.3 20.2
7 350 11.4 12.7 9.8
9 450 1.3 0.6 0.1
11 550 3.4 4.3 4.8
13 650 5.2 4.7 2.8
15 750 1.2 0.6 0.1
17 850 1.4 2.2 0.7
19 950 3.8 1.9 1.3
21 1050 1.2 0.3 0.0
23 1150 0.6 1.3 0.8
25 1250 1.3 1.0 0.9
THD-I 20.6 21.1 21.1
The solution to mitigate the EM noise is to opposition, to eliminate the harmonics seen on the
introduce an active filter with compensation battery. supply network [19].
However, to implement this study that has been We can quantify the power generated by the
dimensioned, the place and weight of this harmonics. This power is better known Distorting
component is very worrying at the locomotive. Power, noted D and it is related to deforming amps.
Adding to that, it requires a commissioning license This power has an immediate consequence on the
that takes a long time for validation and testing. waveform and the distortion rate harmonic current.
Reason why we have also decided to introduce a the reactive energy compensation equipment will be
temporary solution while the authorization is of no use, since it only acts on the displacement
validated by adding a stabilizer at the level of Corail factor. Correcting a reactive power generated by the
cars capable of stabilizing the static converter output harmonics will become more dangerous for the
voltage to correct the sound situation. reactive energy compensation equipment. Indeed,
The compensation capacitors installed at the the harmonics will move the switching point and the
output of the converter can lead to the amplification equipment will not compensate at the desired time
of existing harmonics. Amplification means the and will be more solicited. To eliminate the current
increase in harmonic distortion rates in voltage as in harmonics (deforming amperes), it will be necessary
current. This amplification is due to an electrical to install a filtering equipment which allows either
resonance between the capacity of the battery and in the passive case, to short-circuit some rank or in
the line and source inductances. To compensate for the active case, to inject a current, in opposition of
reactive energy is to supply this energy in place of phase, in order to eliminate the harmonics seen on
the distributed power network. This is why it is wise the network. The installation of these filtering
to install a capacitor bank after measuring the power equipment requires a sizing of the filter according to
reported on the Tab. 5 to improve the power factor. the distorting amps. The proposed solution shows
which can be represented in the mathematical the ultimate role of the active compensator and filter
formula: by reducing the harmonics [20]. This spectrum
improvement is also accompanied by an
improvement of the forms wave voltage and current
as seen in the Fig.14, 15 (percentage and rank of the
harmonic represent respectively the Y-axis and X-
axis).
The advantage of the active compensator is
clearly seen on the current waveform: reduction of
the crest factor after correction and improvement of
the power factor. The graphs show the impact of the
active compensator with a very significant
attenuation of THD-I. The advantages linked to this
implemented solution are the following:
𝑆12 = 𝑃2 + 𝑄 2 (3)
- Increase the active power available at the
transformer secondary.
𝑆 = √𝑃2 + 𝑄 2 + 𝐷 2 = √𝑆12 + 𝐷 2 (4)
- Reduce in voltage drops and line losses.
- Eliminate excessive consumption of reactive
with, 𝑄 : reactive power without harmonic. energy.
The distorting power D has an immediate
consequence on the waveform and current harmonic 5. Conclusion
distortion rate. Correcting reactive power generated
The main purpose of this analysis is to determine
by harmonics will become more dangerous for
the electromagnetic disturbance generated by the
reactive energy compensation equipment. Indeed,
static converter located in the locomotive which has
the harmonics will move the switching point and the
a negative impact on the functioning sound system.
equipment will not compensate at the desired time
This is why experimental measurements was made
and will be in great demand. To eliminate the
to analyze the power quality and harmonics
current harmonics (the distorting amps), it will be
generated and. The system from the static converter
necessary to install a filtering equipment which
to the sound system receiver was modelled and
allows in the active case, to inject a current, in phase
International Journal of Intelligent Engineering and Systems, Vol.13, No.3, 2020 DOI: 10.22266/ijies2020.0630.19
Received: February 14, 2020. Revised: March 10, 2020. 210
International Journal of Intelligent Engineering and Systems, Vol.13, No.3, 2020 DOI: 10.22266/ijies2020.0630.19
Received: February 14, 2020. Revised: March 10, 2020. 211
[4] A. Hoffrichter, A. R. Miller, S. Hillmansen, and future”, Electricity Journal, Vol. 29, No. 10, pp.
C. Roberts, “Well-to-wheel analysis for electric, 49–61, 2016.
diesel and hydrogen traction for railways”, [15] CENELEC EN 50121-4, Railway Application:
Transportation Research Part D: Transport Electromagnetic Compatibility, Emission and
and Environment, Vol. 17, No. 1, pp. 28–34, Immunity of signaling and telecommunication
2012. appliances, 2006.
[5] B. Lin, C. Liu, H. Wang, and R. Lin, [16] CENELEC EN 50121-5, Railway Application:
“Modeling the railway network design Electromagnetic Compatibility, Part 5:
problem: A novel approach to considering Emission and immunity of railway fixed power
carbon emissions reduction”, Transportation supply installations, 2006.
Research Part D: Transport and Environment, [17] CENELEC EN 61000-4, Electromagnetic
Vol. 56, pp. 95–109, 2017. Compatibility : Testing and measurements
[6] P. Rietveld, “Why railway passengers are more techniques –5: surge immunity to conducted
polluting in the peak than in the off-peak; disturbances induced by radio frequency fields,
environmental effects of capacity management 2007.
by railway companies under conditions of [18] A. Morant, A. Wisten, D. Galar, U. Kumar, and
fluctuating demand”, Transportation Research S. Niska, “Railway EMI impact on train
Part D: Transport and Environment, Vol. 7, No. operation and environment”, In: Proc. of IEEE
5, pp. 347–356, 2002. International Symposium on Electromagnetic
[7] L. Xiaotian, Z. Haijing, Q. Bo, and H. Bochong, Compatibility, 2012.
“EMC in Rail Transportation”, Energy [19] Y. Liu, J. Xu, Z. Shuai, Y. Li, G. Cui, S. Hu
Procedia, Vol. 104, pp. 526–531, 2016. and B. Xie, “Passivity-based decoupling control
[8] S. Midya and R. Thottappillil, “An overview of strategy of single-phase LCL-type VSRs for
electromagnetic compatibility challenges in harmonics suppression in railway power
European Rail Traffic Management System”, systems”, International Journal of Electrical
Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Power and Energy Systems, Vol. 117, No.
Technologies, Vol. 16, No. 5, pp. 515–534, October 2019, p. 105698, 2020.
2008. [20] H. Mahdinia Roudsari, S. Jamali, and A.
[9] M. Brenna, A. Capasso, M. C. Falvo, F. Jalilian, “Dynamic modeling, control design
Foiadelli, R. Lamedica, and D. Zaninelli, and stability analysis of railway active power
“Investigation of resonance phenomena in high quality conditioner”, Electric Power Systems
speed railway supply systems: Theoretical and Research, Vol. 160, pp. 71–88, 2018.
experimental analysis”, Electric Power Systems
Research, Vol. 81, No. 10, pp. 1915–1923,
2011.
[10] L. Liudvinavicius, “Compensation of Reactive
Power of AC Catenary System”, Procedia
Engineering, Vol. 187, pp. 185–197, 2017.
[11] G. He, A. P. J. Mol, and Y. Lu, “Public protests
against the Beijing-Shenyang high-speed
railway in China”, Transportation Research
Part D: Transport and Environment, Vol. 43,
pp. 1–16, 2016.
[12] D. Serrano-Jimenez, L. Abrahamsson, S.
Castano-Solis, and J. Sanz-Feito, “Electrical
railway power supply systems: Current
situation and future trends”, International
Journal of Electrical Power and Energy
Systems, Vol. 92, pp. 181–192, 2017.
[13] J. Ilonciak, L. Struharnansky, and J. Kuchta,
“Modular Concept of Auxiliary Converters for
Diesel Electric Locomotives”, Procedia
Engineering, Vol. 192, pp. 359–364, 2017.
[14] S. Ronnberg and M. Bollen, “Power quality
issues in the electric power system of the
International Journal of Intelligent Engineering and Systems, Vol.13, No.3, 2020 DOI: 10.22266/ijies2020.0630.19