IJRAR
IJRAR
1
ASSISTANT PROFESSOR at B.S. ANANGPURIA INSTITUTE OF LAW, ALAMPUR, FARIDABAD,
HARYANA, INDIA
Abstract: Paid news refers to the practice of media outlets accepting money in exchange for publishing
news articles or reports that are favourable to a particular person, organization, or issue. This practice is
unethical and goes against the principles of journalism, which require impartiality and objectivity. Paid
news can distort the information presented to the public and influence public opinion, leading to a skewed
representation of the truth. In India, the phenomenon of paid news has been growing in recent years,
leading to concerns about the credibility and reliability of news media. The Indian government has taken
several measures to address this issue, including enacting laws and regulations to prevent paid news and
increasing the transparency of political advertising. However, the problem of paid news continues to persist
and requires on-going efforts to combat it. This paper will be discussing introduction, types, laws, cases,
and conclusion.
1
ASSISTANT PROFESSOR at B.S. ANANGPURIA INSTITUTE OF LAW, ALAMPUR, FARIDABAD, HARYANA,
INDIA
2
ASSISTANT PROFESSOR at B.S. ANANGPURIA INSTITUTE OF LAW, ALAMPUR, FARIDABAD, HARYANA,
INDIA
IJRAR23A1682 International Journal of Research and Analytical Reviews (IJRAR) www.ijrar.org 692
© 2023 IJRAR February 2023, Volume 10, Issue 1 www.ijrar.org (E-ISSN 2348-1269, P- ISSN 2349-5138)
Introduction
Paid news is indeed a threat to Indian democracy as it undermines the democratic values of transparency,
accountability, and free and fair representation of facts. Paid news distorts the information presented to the
public and influences public opinion, leading to a skewed representation of the truth. This can result in the
public making informed decisions based on false or misleading information, leading to negative
consequences for the democracy.
Moreover, paid news can erode public trust in the media, which is a critical pillar of democratic societies.
The media is responsible for serving as a watchdog, monitoring the actions of the government and other
institutions and holding them accountable. When media outlets engage in paid news, they compromise their
impartiality and credibility, which can have serious consequences for the functioning of democracy. Paid
news is a threat to Indian democracy and must be combated through a combination of legal and regulatory
measures, increased transparency, and public education. By doing so, we can ensure that the media serves
as an independent watchdog, promoting democratic values and supporting informed decision-making by
the public.
In India, paid news has become a widespread problem, particularly during election seasons, when political
parties and candidates pay for favourable coverage in the media to gain an advantage over their opponents.
Paid news can take many forms, including fake news stories, misleading advertisements disguised as news
articles, and editorial content that has been paid for by a particular individual or organization.
The problem of paid news has attracted the attention of the Indian government and regulators, who have
taken steps to address the issue. In 2010, the Press Council of India issued guidelines for the media to
follow in order to avoid the publication of paid news. The Election Commission of India has also taken
steps to monitor and regulate the issue during election campaigns.
Despite these efforts, paid news remains a persistent problem in India, and it continues to undermine the
credibility and impartiality of the media. Addressing this issue requires a concerted effort from media
outlets, regulators, and the public, to ensure that the media remains a reliable and trustworthy source of
information. Paid news is a major threat to democracy in India, and it undermines the integrity of the
election process and the credibility of news content. Paid news can influence public opinion, sway election
results, and distort public perception of events. In India, political parties and candidates have been known
to engage in paid news practices in order to gain an advantage during elections. This has led to a distorted
public perception of events and a loss of public trust in the media. Paid news can also create an uneven
playing field, as those who can afford to pay for favourable coverage have an advantage over those who
cannot.
IJRAR23A1682 International Journal of Research and Analytical Reviews (IJRAR) www.ijrar.org 693
© 2023 IJRAR February 2023, Volume 10, Issue 1 www.ijrar.org (E-ISSN 2348-1269, P- ISSN 2349-5138)
In addition, the prevalence of paid news in India undermines the independence of the media, as media
outlets that accept payment for favourable coverage may not report objectively and impartially on political
events. This can lead to a loss of public trust in the media and a decline in the quality of journalism.
Overall, paid news represents a major threat to democracy in India and undermines the integrity of the
election process, the independence of the media, and the credibility of news content. To address this issue,
it is essential to implement effective regulations, guidelines, and policies aimed at ensuring the
transparency and authenticity of news content.
Paid news is not just a problem in India, but a global issue that affects many countries around the world.
Here are a few notable examples:
United States: The United States has a long history of paid news and yellow journalism, dating back to the
late 19th century. The rise of digital media and the decline of traditional news outlets have led to an
increase in the prevalence of paid news in recent years.
Europe: Paid news is a growing problem in Europe, particularly in countries with weak regulatory
environments and a lack of transparency in the media industry. This has led to increased public scepticism
and a loss of trust in the media.
China: China has a heavily controlled media environment, but paid news is still a problem. Political
interests and commercial interests often pay for favourable coverage, leading to a distorted public
perception of events.
Latin America: Paid news is a widespread issue in many Latin American countries, particularly in
countries with weak regulatory environments and a lack of media independence. This has led to increased
public skepticism and a loss of trust in the media.
Middle East: Paid news is a growing problem in many countries in the Middle East, particularly in
countries with weak regulatory environments and a lack of transparency in the media industry. This has led
to increased public skepticism and a loss of trust in the media.
Overall, paid news is a global problem that affects many countries around the world. To address this issue,
it is important to implement effective regulations, guidelines, and policies aimed at ensuring the
transparency and authenticity of news content.
Historical Background
The phenomenon of paid news is not new and has a long history, dating back to the early days of
journalism. Paid news, also known as “yellow journalism,” refers to the practice of media outlets accepting
payment to publish news articles, advertisements, or editorials that are presented as authentic news content.
This practice can distort the public's perception of events and undermine the credibility and authenticity of
news content. In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, the term “yellow journalism” was used to describe
sensationalist and misleading news reporting in the United States, particularly during the Spanish-
IJRAR23A1682 International Journal of Research and Analytical Reviews (IJRAR) www.ijrar.org 694
© 2023 IJRAR February 2023, Volume 10, Issue 1 www.ijrar.org (E-ISSN 2348-1269, P- ISSN 2349-5138)
American War. This type of journalism was characterized by the use of sensational headlines and
fabricated stories, often with the intention of increasing newspaper sales. In more recent times, the rise of
digital media and the decline of traditional news outlets have led to an increase in the prevalence of paid
news. The ease with which paid content can be distributed online, combined with the growth of political
advertising, has created new opportunities for media outlets and political interests to engage in paid news
practices.
Overall, the history of paid news highlights the on-going challenge of maintaining the authenticity and
credibility of news content in the face of money and political interests. It is important to remain vigilant in
preventing the spread of paid news and to enforce regulations and policies aimed at ensuring the
transparency and objectivity of news reporting.
Paid news is a form of media corruption in which news organizations or journalists are paid to produce and
publish stories that are favourable to the interests of the person or organization that pays for the story. This
practice undermines the integrity of journalism and can have serious consequences for democracy. In a
democratic society, the media is expected to serve as a watchdog, holding those in power accountable and
providing citizens with accurate and impartial information. When paid news enters the picture, it can distort
the flow of information and undermine public trust in the media. This, in turn, can have serious
consequences for the functioning of democracy. Paid news can also lead to the dissemination of false or
misleading information, which can further erode public trust in the media and in democratic institutions
more broadly. Paid news is a threat to democracy because it undermines the integrity of journalism and the
media's ability to serve as a watchdog, hold those in power accountable, and provide citizens with accurate
and impartial information. It also has the potential to distort the flow of information and erode public trust
in the media and in democratic institutions more broadly.
Political Advertising: Paid political advertisements in the form of news articles, editorials, or special
supplements, which are designed to influence public opinion in favor of a particular political candidate or
party.
Sponsored News: News articles or features that are funded by corporations or other interests, but are
presented as impartial news content.
Celebrity Endorsements: Paid news articles or features that promote products or services through the
endorsement of celebrities, politicians, or other public figures.
Influencer Marketing: Paid news articles or features those promote products or services through the
endorsement of social media influencers.
IJRAR23A1682 International Journal of Research and Analytical Reviews (IJRAR) www.ijrar.org 695
© 2023 IJRAR February 2023, Volume 10, Issue 1 www.ijrar.org (E-ISSN 2348-1269, P- ISSN 2349-5138)
Astroturfing: Paid news articles or features that create the illusion of widespread support for a particular
product, service, or political candidate, but are actually funded by a small group of individuals or interests.
Product Placement: Paid news articles or features that promote products or services through subtle
references or visual representations.
The causes of paid news can be complex and multifaceted, but some of the main drivers of this unethical
practice include:
Commercialization of the media: As the media industry becomes more commercially driven, there is
increased pressure on media outlets to generate revenue and attract advertisers. Paid news can be seen as a
way for media outlets to make additional money while also pleasing their advertisers.
Lack of regulation: In many countries, there are few regulations or penalties in place to prevent or punish
the practice of paid news. This lack of oversight and enforcement can make it easier for media outlets to
engage in paid news without fear of consequences.
Political influence: Paid news can also be used as a tool of political influence, with politicians and
political parties paying for favorable coverage in the media to gain an advantage over their opponents.
Shortage of resources: Some media outlets, particularly smaller and local outlets, may lack the resources
and manpower needed to thoroughly investigate and report on news stories. Paid news can be seen as a
way to fill the gaps and generate content quickly and easily.
Financial pressure: In some cases, media outlets may be facing financial pressure, and paid news can be
seen as a way to generate additional revenue to keep the outlet afloat.
Decline of traditional news media: The decline of traditional news media and the rise of digital media has
led to increased competition for advertising revenue and audience attention. This has created incentives for
media outlets to accept payment to publish news articles, advertisements, or editorials that are presented as
authentic news content.
Influence of money and political interests: Paid news is often driven by the influence of money and
political interests. Political parties, candidates, and special interest groups may seek to use paid news to
influence public opinion, advance their agendas, and sway election results.
Weak regulatory environment: In many countries, the regulatory environment for media is weak or
ineffective, making it easier for media outlets to engage in paid news practices without facing
consequences. This lack of enforcement allows paid news to flourish and undermines the credibility of
news content.
IJRAR23A1682 International Journal of Research and Analytical Reviews (IJRAR) www.ijrar.org 696
© 2023 IJRAR February 2023, Volume 10, Issue 1 www.ijrar.org (E-ISSN 2348-1269, P- ISSN 2349-5138)
Lack of transparency: The lack of transparency in the media industry makes it difficult to detect and
prevent paid news. This can lead to a distorted public perception of events and a loss of public trust in the
media.
Market demand for sensational news: The market demand for sensational news, combined with
declining news budgets, creates incentives for media outlets to engage in paid news practices in order to
attract more viewers and increase revenue.
Overall, these factors contribute to the spread of paid news and the decline of credible and authentic news
content. To address this issue, it is essential to implement effective regulations, guidelines, and policies
aimed at ensuring the transparency and authenticity of news content. These are just a few of the factors that
can contribute to the problem of paid news. Addressing this issue requires a combination of regulations,
education, and cultural changes within the media industry, as well as greater public awareness and
accountability.
Paid news is a major challenge in India, particularly during election campaigns. Here are a few notable
examples of paid news during elections in India:
Uttar Pradesh Assembly Elections (2007): The Election Commission of India found several instances of
paid news during the 2007 Uttar Pradesh Assembly elections. The media was found to have published
misleading and false news articles in favour of certain candidates, with the intention of influencing the
election results.
Karnataka Assembly Elections (2008): During the 2008 Karnataka Assembly elections, several media
outlets were found to have published misleading news articles and editorials in favour of certain political
parties and candidates. This led to a significant public backlash and calls for stricter regulations to prevent
the spread of paid news in India.
Maharashtra Assembly Elections (2009): In the run-up to the 2009 Maharashtra Assembly elections,
there were numerous instances of media outlets publishing misleading and false news articles and
advertisements in favor of certain candidates and political parties. The Election Commission of India took
strong action against these instances of paid news, including imposing fines and ordering the seizure of
media assets.
General Elections (2014): During the 2014 General Elections, there were numerous instances of paid
news, particularly in the form of misleading and false news articles and advertisements. The Election
Commission of India took strong action against these instances of paid news, including imposing fines and
ordering the seizure of media assets.
IJRAR23A1682 International Journal of Research and Analytical Reviews (IJRAR) www.ijrar.org 697
© 2023 IJRAR February 2023, Volume 10, Issue 1 www.ijrar.org (E-ISSN 2348-1269, P- ISSN 2349-5138)
Effects Election Paid News
The effects of election paid news can be significant and far-reaching, as it has the potential to distort the
democratic process and undermine the principles of free and fair elections. Some of the key effects of
election paid news are:
Skewed representation of facts: Paid news can present false or misleading information to the public,
distorting the representation of facts and influencing public opinion.
Undue influence: Paid news can give an unfair advantage to certain candidates or political parties,
allowing them to manipulate public opinion and gain an undue advantage in elections.
Erosion of public trust: Paid news can erode public trust in the media and political institutions,
undermining the credibility and legitimacy of the democratic process.
Misinformed voters: Paid news can result in voters making decisions based on false or misleading
information, leading to uninformed and potentially harmful choices.
Corruption: Paid news can lead to the corrupt use of money and resources, with candidates and political
parties using paid news to further their own interests at the expense of the public.
Election paid news has far-reaching effects and can undermine the integrity of the democratic process. To
protect the principles of free and fair elections, it is important to prevent and address the problem of paid
news through increased transparency and accountability measures.
The United Nations (UN) has not issued specific guidelines on paid news. However, the UN recognizes the
importance of press freedom and media independence and has called for the protection and promotion of
these values.
The Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which was adopted by the UN General Assembly in 1948,
includes provisions on freedom of expression and the press. Article 19 of the Declaration states that
everyone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression and that this right includes freedom to hold
opinions without interference and to seek, receive and impart information and ideas through any media and
regardless of frontiers.
The UN has also established the UN Plan of Action on the Safety of Journalists and the Issue of Impunity,
which aims to promote a safe and enabling environment for journalists and media workers and to address
the issue of impunity for crimes committed against journalists.
Additionally, the UN has established the Special Rapporteur on freedom of expression, who is responsible
for promoting and protecting the right to freedom of expression and information globally. The Special
Rapporteur has issued a number of reports and recommendations on the importance of press freedom and
IJRAR23A1682 International Journal of Research and Analytical Reviews (IJRAR) www.ijrar.org 698
© 2023 IJRAR February 2023, Volume 10, Issue 1 www.ijrar.org (E-ISSN 2348-1269, P- ISSN 2349-5138)
media independence, including the importance of ensuring the authenticity and transparency of news
content.
Although the UN has not issued specific guidelines on paid news, these broader principles and initiatives
highlight the importance of press freedom, media independence, and the right to freedom of expression and
information.
The issue of paid news in India is regulated by a combination of media laws, election laws, and consumer
protection laws. Some of the relevant laws include:
The Press Council of India Act, 1978: This act establishes the Press Council of India, which is
responsible for maintaining the standards of journalism and protecting the freedom of the press. The Press
Council of India can investigate and reprimand journalists who engage in unethical practices, such as paid
news.
The Representation of the People Act, 1951: This act governs the conduct of elections in India, and it
includes provisions that prohibit candidates and political parties from making payments to the media in
exchange for favourable coverage.
The Consumer Protection Act, 1986: This act provides a framework for protecting the rights of
consumers, and it includes provisions that allow consumers to seek redressal in cases of false or misleading
advertisements, including those that are disguised as news articles.
The Cable Television Networks (Regulation) Act, 1995: This act governs the regulation of cable
television networks in India, and it includes provisions that prohibit the broadcast of misleading or false
advertisements.
The Information Technology Act, 2000: This act governs the regulation of information technology in
India, and it includes provisions that prohibit the publication of false or misleading information online.
Press Council of India (PCI) Guidelines: The PCI, a self-regulatory body for the Indian press, has issued
guidelines for the media to prevent paid news and ensure the authenticity and credibility of news content.
Broadcasting Services Regulation Act, 1995: This act regulates the content of television and radio
broadcasting, including restrictions on paid news and political advertising.
Election Commission of India (ECI) Guidelines: The ECI, the body responsible for conducting free and
fair elections in India, has issued guidelines for the media to prevent the publication of paid news during
election campaigns.
IJRAR23A1682 International Journal of Research and Analytical Reviews (IJRAR) www.ijrar.org 699
© 2023 IJRAR February 2023, Volume 10, Issue 1 www.ijrar.org (E-ISSN 2348-1269, P- ISSN 2349-5138)
In addition to these laws, the Election Commission of India has also issued guidelines for the media to
follow during election seasons in order to prevent the publication of paid news. The Indian government has
also taken steps to address the issue, including setting up a committee to investigate the matter and
proposing amendments to relevant laws to strengthen the regulation of paid news.
Committees
In India, several committees have been formed over the years to address the issue of paid news. Some of
the most notable ones include:
Press Council of India's Committee on Paid News: In 2010, the Press Council of India established a
Committee on Paid News to examine the issue and make recommendations for addressing it. The
Committee made several recommendations, including the need for stricter regulatory mechanisms and
stronger legal penalties for those involved in paid news practices.
Election Commission of India's Committee on Paid News: In 2011, the Election Commission of India
established a Committee on Paid News to investigate the issue during the electoral process. The Committee
made several recommendations, including the need for greater transparency in political advertising and a
ban on the publication of paid news during election campaigns.
Ministry of Information and Broadcasting's Task Force on Paid News: In 2014, the Ministry of
Information and Broadcasting established a Task Force on Paid News to investigate the issue and make
recommendations for addressing it. The Task Force made several recommendations, including the need for
greater transparency in political advertising and stronger legal penalties for those involved in paid news
practices.
Overall, these committees have played an important role in highlighting the issue of paid news in India and
making recommendations for addressing it. However, implementation of these recommendations remains a
challenge, and the issue of paid news continues to be a major concern in India.
Judicial Cases
There have been several notable judicial cases related to paid news in India and other countries. Some
examples include:
Ram Jethmalani vs. Election Commission of India (2010): In this case, the Supreme Court of India
declared that the publication of paid news during election campaigns is illegal and violative of the
Representation of the People Act.
Uttar Pradesh Subordinate Services Selection Commission vs. Rajesh Kumar & Anr. (2017): The
Allahabad High Court ruled that the publication of paid news during the recruitment process for
government jobs was illegal and violate of the rules and regulations of the selection commission.
IJRAR23A1682 International Journal of Research and Analytical Reviews (IJRAR) www.ijrar.org 700
© 2023 IJRAR February 2023, Volume 10, Issue 1 www.ijrar.org (E-ISSN 2348-1269, P- ISSN 2349-5138)
Challenges Paid News
These cases demonstrate the consequences of engaging in paid news and the importance of enforcing laws
and regulations to prevent this unethical practice. There are several challenges to addressing the issue of
paid news in India, including:
Lack of Clear Definition: There is no clear definition of what constitutes paid news, making it difficult to
identify and penalize those involved in paid news practices.
Lack of Effective Regulations: There are currently no effective regulations in place to prevent or punish
paid news practices, and the existing laws are often not adequate to address the issue.
Lack of Monitoring and Enforcement Mechanisms: Even if regulations are put in place, there is a lack
of effective monitoring and enforcement mechanisms to ensure that they are being followed.
Complexity of the Issue: Paid news is a complex issue that involves multiple stakeholders, including
media outlets, political parties, advertisers, and individual journalists, making it difficult to address.
Resistance from Media Organizations: Media organizations and journalists may resist efforts to regulate
paid news, as they see it as an infringement on press freedom and media independence.
Difficulty in Proving Paid News: Proving that a particular piece of news was paid for can be difficult, as
those involved in paid news practices often take steps to conceal their activities.
Preventing paid news involves implementing regulations and guidelines to ensure the authenticity and
transparency of news content. This can be achieved through the following measures:
Media Ownership Regulations: Clear regulations regarding media ownership can prevent conflicts of
interest and ensure unbiased news coverage.
Disclosure Requirements: News outlets should be required to disclose any sponsored or paid content to
the public.
Ethical Journalism Standards: Journalists and media outlets should follow ethical journalism standards,
such as objectivity and accuracy, to avoid publishing paid news.
Advertising Transparency: Advertising agencies should be required to disclose the source of their
funding and any conflicts of interest.
Media Monitoring: Independent media watchdog organizations can monitor and investigate instances of
paid news to hold media outlets accountable.
Legal Consequences: Paid news should be made illegal, with penalties for media outlets and individuals
who engage in this practice.
IJRAR23A1682 International Journal of Research and Analytical Reviews (IJRAR) www.ijrar.org 701
© 2023 IJRAR February 2023, Volume 10, Issue 1 www.ijrar.org (E-ISSN 2348-1269, P- ISSN 2349-5138)
Public Awareness: The public should be educated about the dangers of paid news and the importance of
discerning authentic news from paid content.
Strengthening Regulations and Policies: Effective regulations and policies are needed to prevent and
penalize those involved in paid news practices. This can include guidelines for political advertising,
restrictions on political spending during election campaigns, and stronger penalties for those involved in
paid news practices.
Increasing Transparency: Transparency in political advertising and campaign financing can help prevent
paid news practices by making it easier to track the sources of political funding and to identify those
involved in paid news practices.
Enhancing Media Literacy: Raising public awareness about the issue of paid news and increasing media
literacy can help reduce its impact by empowering the public to identify and reject paid news content.
Promoting Media Independence: Supporting media independence and encouraging a diversity of news
sources can help prevent paid news practices by reducing the incentives for media organizations to
participate in such activities.
Conclusion
Paid news is a major challenge that undermines the credibility and authenticity of news content, erodes
public trust in the media, and undermines the principles of free and fair journalism. The rise of paid news is
driven by the increasing influence of money and political interests in the media. To address this issue, it is
essential to implement effective regulations, guidelines, and policies aimed at ensuring the transparency
and authenticity of news content. This can be achieved through measures such as media ownership
regulations, disclosure requirements, ethical journalism standards, advertising transparency, media
monitoring, legal consequences, and public awareness. The enforcement of these measures is critical to
ensuring a media environment that is free from the influence of money and political interests, and where
the public has access to credible and authentic news. paid news represents a significant threat to democracy
by undermining the integrity of the election process and the credibility of news content. Paid news can
influence public opinion, sway election results, and distort public perception of events, creating an uneven
playing field for political candidates and parties. The issue of paid news is complex and multi-faceted, and
addressing it requires a comprehensive and coordinated effort from multiple stakeholders, including the
government, media organizations, and civil society. Effective regulations, guidelines, and policies are
IJRAR23A1682 International Journal of Research and Analytical Reviews (IJRAR) www.ijrar.org 702
© 2023 IJRAR February 2023, Volume 10, Issue 1 www.ijrar.org (E-ISSN 2348-1269, P- ISSN 2349-5138)
needed to ensure the transparency and authenticity of news content and to prevent the spread of paid news.
The threat posed by paid news to democracy highlights the importance of an independent and impartial
media, which plays a critical role in informing the public and holding those in power accountable.
Addressing the issue of paid news is essential to maintaining the integrity of the democratic process and to
ensuring that the public has access to accurate and reliable information.
References
IJRAR23A1682 International Journal of Research and Analytical Reviews (IJRAR) www.ijrar.org 703