Technical Overview of Magnetless Motor Technologies
Introduction
Electric motors are the heart of electric vehicles (EVs), directly influencing
performance, efficiency, and reliability. As the EV industry evolves, the need for
alternatives to permanent magnet-based motors becomes more pressing. This
document explores the technical principles and attributes of magnetless motors
including Induction Motors (IM), Switched Reluctance Motors (SRM), Synchronous
Reluctance Motors (SynRM), and Ferrite-Assisted Synchronous Reluctance Motors
(FASynRM).
Induction Motors (IM)
Induction motors, especially squirrel cage types, are robust and widely used in
industrial applications. In EVs, they offer benefits like high reliability and cost-
effectiveness due to the absence of magnets. Torque production is based on
electromagnetic induction, and advanced vector control strategies improve their
performance in variable-speed drive systems. However, they exhibit lower
efficiency at partial loads compared to PMSMs.
Switched Reluctance Motors (SRM)
SRMs have a simple construction with salient poles on both the rotor and stator. The
torque is produced by the tendency of the rotor to move toward a position of
minimum reluctance. This motor type is fault-tolerant, operates at high speeds, and
is magnet-free, but produces torque ripple and acoustic noise. Control complexity
and the requirement for precise current profiling are key considerations in its
implementation.
Synchronous Reluctance Motors (SynRM)
SynRMs utilize the principle of anisotropic magnetic reluctance. They are inherently
simple, consisting of a rotor with varying reluctance paths. These motors provide a
good trade-off between cost, performance, and efficiency, and with advanced
control, they approach the performance of PMSMs. Their popularity is growing due
to the absence of rare-earth materials.
Ferrite-Assisted SynRM (FASynRM)
Combining ferrite magnets with SynRM topology allows torque density
enhancement while avoiding rare-earth materials. FASynRMs offer superior
performance than pure SynRMs, especially under field weakening conditions. Their
use is a compromise between magnet-free and high-performance motor
requirements.
Conclusion
Each of these technologies has unique benefits and trade-offs. As motor control
strategies and materials improve, these magnetless motor types are becoming
increasingly viable for mainstream EV applications. Selecting the right motor
requires evaluating vehicle needs, cost targets, and long-term sourcing strategy.