Recruitment and Selection.1 2
Recruitment and Selection.1 2
Introduction
Recruitment and selection has to be planned and organized, a sloppy one will
result to unwanted costs. Hiring incompetent employees due to poor recruitment and
selection process would result to low performance, thus affects the organization as a
whole. The results of the recruitment and selection procedure will have a direct impact
to different areas in the company, including the morale of the employees, motivation,
retention, quality of work.
The first chapter discusses the overview of Human Resource Management, its
definition, origin and development, functions, and the difference between human
resource management and personnel development.
Learning Objectives:
A. Activity:
B. Analysis:
C. Abstraction:
Human Resource Management is the effective and efficient use of its human
resources to achieve its organizational goals and objectives. It is also defined as:
2
Human resources refers to human capital, which pertains to people in the
organization with different personalities, values, principles, cultural and family
background. It takes a lot of patience, skills, knowledge to manage people with diverse
personalities. Managing human resources is one of the greatest challenges in every
businesses, since people is the heart of every organization. A company may have the
best strategies, facilities, values and work methods and processes but these are of no
use if an organization does not possess the right people to implement them, and if
these human resources are ill-managed. The workforce can “make or break” a
company depending on how they are managed or treated.
D. Application
_________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________
3
Lesson 2: Origin and Evolution of Human Resource
Management
A. Activity
B. Analysis
Instruction: Answers copied verbatim from the internet or from your classmates
is automatically wrong. Send your answers to anipilif37@yahoo.com.
C. Abstraction
Let’s take a look on how HRM evolved overtime, let us read excerpts for Prof.
Josephat Itika of Mzumbe University:
Fig. 1. The Stages in the Evolution and Development of Human Resource Management
Source: Josephat Stephen Itika, 2011
It was in 1900s when the economic and technological breakthrough arise because
of continued development in general and scientific knowledge.
Below were the events that transpired during the Welfare Stage:
5
• There was a huge production of goods in one industrial roof which was done
more efficiently, and this was common occurrence across Western Europe
specifically Britain, France, Spain and Italy.
• Production of war materials created a chain of industrial networks for
Germans.
• Because of the increasing workforce, managing them was a tough challenge,
therefore they search for solutions, which involves organizing its personnel
and ensuring that their welfare was well-taken for, that led to the need for
better people management techniques.
• The beginning of employees’ welfare services such as canteen and other
needs, which created a need to have an officer whose main purpose was to
take care of its employees, who are called welfare officers even today.
During the postwar period, the role of personnel administration was expanding
to meet the demands and challenges of the job, which included supervisory, skills
supervisory training, and labor disputes that threatened the organization's and
personnel's efficiency.
Below were the significant events that took place during this stage:
• Elton Mayo and Kurt Lewin pioneered human relation’s school which
emphasized on improving the work environment and work groups as a
approach to increase productivity (Rush 1959; Robbins 1990; Torrington et al.
2005).
• Employees were treated as human beings rather than working tools.
6
• There was a shift of emphasis on managing group/teams rather managing
individual employee (Davis 1980).
• Abraham Maslow introduced human hierarchy of needs and the power of
worker’s motivation on productivity (Maslow 1970).
• The concept of employee’s satisfaction that was written by Chris Argyris and
Frederick Herzberg had a substantial impact on the organizational practices in
enhancing the quality of jobs in organizations (Deci & Ryan 1985).
• Bennis & Schien’s organization development school provided useful inputs to
employees’ practices particularly in the extents of effective communication and
conflict resolution in the workplace (Davis 1980; Walton & McKerzie 1991).
• Organizational development, systematic training, manpower planning, and
management development were all covered by personnel management
functions, especially in the 1960s.
• New methods and methods for employee selection, wage and salary
administration, training, and performance evaluation were implemented.
• Personnel managers became knowledgeable in labor law and stand in for their
organizations in labor disputes (Chruden & Sherman 1984).
Below are the challenges that had a huge influence on people management in
organizations:
The late 1970s and early 1980s were a period of neoliberalism, when market
forces drove the institutional frameworks of nation states and organizations. This was
a time when there were strong arguments against direct government involvement in
the economy. It is unclear what was the ‘chicken' or ‘egg' between politicians and
academics, or who these people, often referred to as ‘experts' of the World Bank and
the International Monetary Fund are, and what their role was in the architecture and
birth of neoliberalism, as well as the marginalization of the role of government in
economic development. Whatever the case, both politicians and consultants played
important roles in the neoliberal doctrine. Margaret Thatcher, the former conservative
British Prime Minister, and Ronald Reagan, the former conservative President of the
United States of America, were both prominent supporters of neoliberalism, and their
philosophies were known by their names, Thatcherism and Reaganism, respectively.
They viciously blamed previous liberal governments for causing the 1970s economic
7
crisis through excessive government control of economies and overprotection of
workers. Privatization of state-owned enterprises, relaxation of legislation in favor of
the private sector, and the desire to maximize profits became the new agenda, as well
as the desired and required framework for managing organizations and its personnel.
As a result, cost-cutting and the pressure to justify employees' roles in developing and
sustaining market organizations became a concern. Failure to respond to these
challenges through proper personnel management strategies was viewed as a
slippery slope towards the collapse of companies with long histories of success.
• Business competition
The year 1980s and early 90s was the year of chaotic, turbulent and
unpredictable business environment. The increasing competition from Japan and
other international companies producing lower-cost but higher-quality goods put
American and European companies under intense pressure, leading to takeovers,
mergers, and business closures to deal with the crisis. These go with heavy losses of
work, part-time work, and outsourcing. Personnel specialist’s role changed from being
reactive to proactive and management of personnel functions shifted from repetitive
to strategic approach to be able to match the challenging and unstable business
environment.
• Technological change
Business competition was increased by companies that could easily adopt and
adapt specialized technologies to meet the customer’s changing needs and
expectations. The result of these, to cope with rapid technological changes,
organizations had fewer but well-trained employees. Adaption based on teams and
8
continuous learning became the main focus of people management. There was an
emphasis in sharing and using knowledge rather than monopolizing it.
The main concern was how personnel management functions could be part of
the business strategy, how it could influence the functional level, and personnel
managers could become partners in the business. A thorough method of evaluating
employee performance in relation to rewards was created, leading to the introduction
of reward systems and performance management systems, indicating a shift in
personnel management practices. Because of these changes, personnel
management was redefined which led to adoption of the human resource concept
(Storey 1989). A debate continues concerning the difference between ‘human
resources’ from ‘personnel’ up to this date.
9
D. Application:
1. What do you think is the importance of knowing and understanding the origin
and evolution of human resource management?
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
10
Lesson 3: Human Resource Management versus Personnel
Management
A. Activity
B. Analysis
C. Abstraction
11
Figure 2. The delineation between Human Resource Management and Personnel Management
(Source: Storey, 1995)
12
Lesson 4: Human Resource Management: Functions
A. Activity:
B. Analysis
1. What is the difference between the two main functions of human resource
management?
C. Abstraction
The main functions of human resource management are classified into two
groups:
1. Managerial functions
2. Operative functions
Managerial Functions
13
• Controlling – it is the process of regulating the activities of the organization in
in line with its plans to achieve the organizational objectives.
Operative Functions
D. Application:
14
UNIT II: RECRUITMENT
Introduction
This second module describes the definition of recruitment, its goals, purpose
and importance. It discusses the theories behind recruitment and the factors that
influence recruitment, process, methods and recruitment policies.
Learning Objectives:
Having completed the activities, at the end of this module, you are expected
to:
15
Lesson 1: Definition of Recruitment
A. Activity
B. Analysis
C. Abstraction
The task of choosing the right person for the right job at the right time is known
as recruitment. The process of attracting, selecting, and appointing potential
candidates to meet the organization's resource requirements is also referred to as
recruitment.
Recruitment is the process of selecting the right person for the right job at the
right time. Recruitment is also the process of attracting, selecting, and appointing
potential candidates to meet the organization's resource needs.
The following is a list that demonstrates the purpose and significance of recruitment
in an organization:
D. Application:
1. Compare and contrast the recruitment process of Coca Cola Company from
Pepsi. (Use the internet to know their recruitment process)
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
17
Lesson 2: Factors Affecting Recruitment
A. Activity
1. Before reading the topic, write down your thoughts on the factors that will
influence a company's recruitment.
B. Analysis
1. Why there is a need to know the factors the will affect recruitment of a
company?
C. Abstraction
Internal Factors
Organizations can influence the internal factors that influence their recruitment
functions. Internal factors include:
• Recruitment policy
• Job image
The size of the organization is one of the most important factors influencing
the recruitment process. Recruitment planning is required for hiring more resources
to handle future operations in order to expand the business.
18
Recruitment policy
Image of organization
Image of Job
External Factors
External factors are those that an organization cannot control. The following
are some of the external factors that influence the recruitment process:
• Demographic factors
Demographic factors are related to potential employees' characteristics such
as age, religion, literacy level, gender, occupation, economic status, and so on.
• Labor market
The labour market determines both the supply and demand for labor. For
instance, if the supply of people with a specific skill is less than the demand, the
hiring process will be more difficult. On the other hand, if the demand is greater
than the supply, hiring will be easier.
• Unemployment rate
If the unemployment rate in a particular area is high, hiring resources will be
simple and straightforward due to the large number of applicants. In contrary, if
the unemployment rate is low, recruiting becomes extremely difficult due to a lack
of resources.
• Labor laws
19
The social and political environment of a market is reflected in labor laws,
which are created by the national and provincial governments. These laws govern
the pay, working conditions, safety and health regulations, and so on for various
types of jobs. The laws change in tandem with the changes in government.
• Legal considerations
Legal considerations enacted by the government will have an impact on the
organizations' recruitment policies, either positively or negatively.
• Competitors
When companies in the same industry start competing for the most qualified
resources, it's critical to analyze the competition and provides the best resource
packages in terms of industry standards.
D. Application
1. Describe at least two factors that affects recruitment, and explain how it influence
recruitment.
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________
20
Lesson 3: Recruitment Process
A. Activity:
B. Analysis
C. Abstraction
These five practices ensure that recruitment is successfully carried out and
without setbacks. Furthermore, these practices certify consistency and compliance
during the hiring process.
21
The recruitment process is the first step in building a strong resource base.
The process follows an organised procedure, beginning with sourcing resources,
moving on to organizing and conducting interviews, and lastly selecting the best
candidates.
Recruitment Planning
1. Identifying Vacancy
2. Job Analysis:
• Job Description
• Job specification
3. Job Evaluation
• Identifying Vacancy
The first and most important step in developing a recruitment plan is identifying
a vacancy. This process begins with the Human Resources Department receiving a
requisition for recruitments from various departments within the organization, which
includes:
- The number of positions to be filled
- The number of available positions
- Duties and responsibilities to be carried out
- Required qualifications and experience
• Job Analysis
Job analysis is the process of identifying, analyzing, and determining the
duties, responsibilities, skills, abilities, and work environment of a specific job. These
22
factors help determine what a job requires and what an employee must have in order
to perform a job productively. Job analysis assists in determining which tasks are
critical and how to carry them out. Its goal is to establish and document the job-
relatedness of employment procedures such as hiring, training, compensation, and
performance evaluation. In order to properly analyze a job, the following steps must
be taken:
Job descriptions and job specifications are the immediate outcomes of job
analysis.
Job Descriptions
• Job Location
• Job Summary
23
• Machines, Materials, and Equipment
• Supervision Process
• Working Conditions
• Health Hazards
Job Specification
The job specification focuses on the requirements of the candidate who will be
hired by the HR team. The first step in creating a job specification is compiling a list
of all jobs in the organization and their locations. The second step is to generate the
job information. This is the information about each job in an organization:
• Physical characteristics
• Mental characteristics
• Physical characteristics
• Emotional characteristics
• Behavioural characteristics
• Qualification
• Experiences
24
(Source: SpriggHR, 2020)
• Job Evaluation
Recruitment Strategy
• Types of recruitment
• Geographical area
• Recruitment sources
• Analyzing HR strategy
• Source activation: Once the line manager confirms and approves the existence
of the vacancy, the candidate search begins.
• Selling: The organization chooses the media through which vacancies are
communicated to prospective candidates.
Searching entails attracting job seekers to open positions. Internal Sources and
External Sources are the two broad categories of sources.
Internal Sources
External Sources
27
Evaluation and Control
The final stage of the recruitment process is evaluation and control. The
effectiveness and validity of the process and methods are evaluated during this
process. Because recruitment is an expensive process, it is critical that the
performance of the recruitment process be thoroughly evaluated. The costs incurred
during the recruitment process must be effectively evaluated and controlled. These
include the following: recruiter salaries; advertising costs and other costs incurred in
recruitment methods, such as agency fees; administrative expenses and recruitment
overheads; overtime and outstanding costs while vacancies remain unfilled; costs
incurred in recruiting suitable candidates for the final selection process; and time spent
by management and professionals in preparing for the final selection process. Finally,
the question is whether the methods of recruitment used are valid or not. And how
effective is the recruitment process itself? Statistical data on the costs of the
recruitment process should be useful.
D. Application
1. Make a list of three companies for which you would like to work, followed by a
list of organizations for which you would not like to work. Why do you think you'd
prefer to work for one company over another? Where did you get your
expectations?
28
Lesson 4: Types of Recruitment
A. Activity:
1. Search for two companies you like or love, then take notes the types of
recruitment they implement or use.
B. Analysis:
1. Compare and contrast their type of recruitment. What do you think is the best
type of recruitment (based on the article you read)? Defend your answer.
C. Abstraction
29
responsibilities, pay, benefits, and status. Many organizations fill higher-level
vacant positions through internal promotions.
• Transfers - The process of moving from one job to another with no change in
rank or responsibilities is referred to as transfer. Employees may be transferred
from one department to another or from one location to another, depending on
the position's requirements.
• Previous Applicants - In this stage, the hiring team reviews the profiles of
previous applicants from the organization's recruitment database. These are
applicants who have previously applied for jobs. These resources are easily
accessible, and in most cases, the response will be positive. It is also a low-
cost method of filling open positions.
Pros and Cons of Internal Sources of Recruitment
30
• There is no need for induction or training because the candidates are already
familiar with their job and responsibilities
The following are the disadvantages of hiring candidates from within the
organization:
• It prevents potential resources from being hired in the future. New resources
can sometimes bring innovative ideas and new ways of thinking to the organization.
• Employees who are not promoted may become dissatisfied and demotivated.
• Because the selection process is lengthy, this process takes more time.
32
• When compared to internal sources, the cost incurred is extremely high.
D. Application
1. Discuss and compare the different types or methods of recruitment. In your own
opinion, what is your best type or recruitment? Elaborate your answer.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________
33
Lesson 5: Recruitment Policy
A. Activity
1. Go back again to Google Company, read and learn about their recruitment
policies.
B. Analysis
C. Abstraction
D. Application
34
UNIT III: EMPLOYEE TESTING AND SELECTION
Introduction
Employee testing and selection entails utilizing a variety of tools and techniques
to select the best candidate for the job. The selection of the right candidate for a vacant
position will be an asset to the organization, assisting it in meeting its goals.
Learning Objectives:
A. Activity
B. Analysis
1. What components are included in the selection process? Which one do you
think is the most important?
C. Abstraction
The process of selecting the best candidate for a vacant job position in an
organization is known as selection. In other words, selection can be defined as the
process of administering an employment test, interviewing candidates, assessing their
qualifications for a specific job, and then selecting the best candidate for the job. A
good selection process will assist the organization in selecting the best candidate for
the job.
35
Selection is defined differently by different authors. Here's a rundown of some
of the definitions:
The following are the key distinctions between recruitment and selection:
Importance of Selection
The goal of selection is to find the best candidate who can meet the
requirements of the jobs available in an organization and will be a successful applicant.
It is critical to evaluate various attributes of each candidate in order to meet the
organization's goals, such as their qualifications, skills, experiences, overall attitude,
and so on. After eliminating candidates who are unsuitable for the vacant position, the
most suitable candidate is chosen in this process.
36
Because hiring the right candidate for a position costs a lot of money, the
organization must follow a proper selection process or procedure. If the selection is
incorrect, the cost of inducting and training the wrong candidate will be a huge loss to
the employer in terms of money, effort, and time. As a result, selection is critical, and
the process should be flawless for the organization's benefit.
Advantages of Selection
A good selection process aids in the selection of the best candidate for a vacant
position in an organization.
37
capable of performing a job. This exam assists the organization in selecting
physically and mentally fit candidates.
• Final Selection: The final selection is the process by which an applicant proves
that he or she has qualified in all rounds of the selection process and will be
issued an appointment letter.
A selection process based on the steps outlined above will assist any
organization in identifying and selecting the best candidates for the job.
D. Application
1. Assume that you are an HR Manager, design your own selection process.
38
Lesson 2: Applications and Resumes
A. Activity
B. Analysis
C. Abstraction
The application letter is a common starting point in the selection process. The
resume or bio-data is attached to the application letter. The applicant's education, work
experiences, and so on are all listed on the resume. Applications and resumes are
used to screen applications in order to select the most qualified candidates for
interviews. Screening is an important part of the recruitment process because it aids
in the elimination of unqualified or irrelevant candidates.
While reviewing resumes and application letters, HR must keep the following
points in mind to ensure better screening or filtering of potential candidates.
You can usually find out what an applicant can do and even some of their
working behaviour by looking at or evaluating their resumes and application letters, or
by looking at the previous jobs they have held, the reason for the change of job, and
their longevity with each organization for which they work. When compared towards
the job description and specifications, you can get a good sense of whether they are
the best person for the job.
39
The goal of screening is to narrow the list so that the interviewer can spend
more time with each candidate during the formal interview; therefore, the golden rule
should be to interview fewer people for a longer period of time.
D. Application
1. Write/make an application letter and resume. (Look for a job postings in the
internet, write your application letter based on the job postings/vacant jobs). Send
your resume and application letter to anipilif37@yahoo.com (Your resume and
application letter will be the basis for your job interview).
40
Lesson 3: Conducting Tests of Applicants
A. Activity:
B. Analysis
1. What do you think is the most effective job-selection test? Defend your response.
2. Discuss how you will determine the most appropriate selection tool/test
C. Abstraction
Employee testing is just one of the instruments of choice to assess whether the
candidate is truly best suited for the position or for the organisation. The findings of
this test should be validated by interview, and certain tests require psychometric
interpretations.
Ability Tests
These tests are used to measure the level of mental or physical ability of the
candidate such as:
a) verbal reasoning
b) numerical ability
c) problem-solving skills
d) motor or spatial agility
e) mechanical ability
f) finger dexterity (typing, assembling, etc.)
Aptitude Tests
41
In an IT firm, for example, applicants were submitted to conduct a number of
computer tests, the idea being to determine who was inherent in the applicants' ability
to learn and understand computer programming quickly.
Performance Tests
Personality Tests
Personality tests are important because they ensure that a company does not
hire someone who has a personality disorder that manifests itself in one's way of
thinking, perceiving situations, and relating to others, traits that can be dysfunctional
to the organization. These tests, however, should not be used solely as a selection
tool; they must be validated by an interview.
1. Rorschach test – is a sequence of ten symmetrical ink spots that you must
interpret. The ink-blot test was devised by Rorschach, a Swiss psychiatrist, to
study personality and diagnose the psychopathologic conditions of the
candidate taking the test. Psychologists use the test to investigate a person's
personality traits and emotional functioning.
42
Honesty or Integrity Tests
In some companies, a polygraph or lie detector test was used, with the
applicant's consent, and in others, paper and pencil honesty tests were used. These
tests are not widely used or popular; it all depends on the weight of the responsibility
of the vacant position. For example, positions with fiduciary responsibilities, such as
bank tellers or cashiers.
All of these tests should not be used as the sole basis for selecting the best
candidate; they should be validated by an interview.
D. Application
1. Go online and look for a job that requires you to take a test before applying. What
was the nature of the test? How do you believe the test will assist the employer in
shortlisting candidates who are likely to be able to perform the job? What exactly
was the test testing?
43
Lesson 4: The Interview
A. Activity
B. Analysis
1. What do you think is the best interview technique? Defend you answer.
C. Abstraction
To find the best candidate, both the interviewer and the candidate must be
adequately prepared for the interview. As the old adage goes, "failing to prepare is
preparing to fail." It is essential to be well-prepared for the interview.
Interviews must be conducted correctly because they are the foundation of the
selection process. There are three primary goals that the interviewer must keep in
mind:
a. Obtaining information
We should assist the candidate in being fully prepared for the interview in order
for the interview to go smoothly and to avoid wasting time and resources.
1. Ascertain that adequate notice of the date and time of the interview was
provided.
3. When the candidate arrives at the premises, make sure they know where to
go and who to contact.
4. Ascertain that the candidate is aware of the documents that must be brought
to the actual interview.
44
Preparation by the Interviewer
It is essential that the interviewer prepare for the interview; thus, it is the
foundation of the selection process. The key to a successful interview is preparation.
The interviewer should receive proper training on how to conduct an effective interview
and be aware of the dos and don'ts during the interview.
1. Go over all of the pertinent information ahead of time – job descriptions, employee
profiles, application forms, and so on. Examine each CV or application form to identify
areas to inquire about during the interview.
2. Create a plan for how you intend to conduct each interview – consistency is
essential. This should include a list of similar questions to ask all candidates
based on the job description, employee profile, and CVs or resumes, so you
can compare like with like.
3. Set up a suitable location for the interviews. The location and layout of the room
will have an effect on the outcome.
4. Make sure you don't have any interruptions while interviewing, and don't
schedule too many interviews on the same day.
5. Allow sufficient time between each interview, allowing yourself time after each
one to finalize your notes.
6. Give your receptionist a list of candidates and their interview times. This will
assist in projecting a professional image to candidates upon their arrival.
7. Obviously, if two or more of you are conducting the interviews, the amount of
preparation required increases because each of you needs to know what role each of
you will play during the interview.
Conducting an Interview
A well-known and simple structure known as the WASP approach (lifted from
Failte Ireland, Online Business Tools) is commonly used to ensure consistency in the
interview. The acronym WASP stands for:
W – Welcome;
A- Acquire Information;
S- Supply Information;
Welcome
45
The interviewer should establish rapport with the applicant during the first
phase of the interview in order to make him or her open, relaxed, and straightforward.
A relaxed candidate will perform better. The interviewer should be friendly, offer him a
seat, and start by making small talk about the weather or something the candidate is
interested in. Show your appreciation for their interest in working for your company,
and the candidate will repay you by feeling more at ease and being more likely to speak
up.
The interviewer should also explain the purpose of the interview at this point. It
may be a good idea to give the candidate a realistic view of the open position, including
a preview of the position and its responsibilities.
The interview should be structured, with the interviewer outlining the format and
approximate timings and informing the candidate that he will be taking notes during
the interview.
Acquire Information
The interviewer should start with general questions and then move on to
specific questions. The interviewer should have a questioning strategy in place to elicit
information about the candidate's background, characteristics, personality, suitability,
and so on that is relevant to the job specification and description. The interviewer
should investigate any gaps in the applicant's resume or bio-data, but should not grill
the applicants. Keep in mind that they are applicants, not criminals. The applicants
should speak for at least 80 percent of the time and should not be interrupted while
speaking.
Supply Information
The interviewer should give the applicant the opportunity to ask questions
about the company and the job. To provide an overview of their potential role in the
company, the interviewer should discuss the roles or job description of the vacant
position. Because applicants are hesitant to inquire about the salary of a vacant
position, the interviewer should provide information about the salary and conditions of
the position.
46
The final stage of the interview is to ensure that both parties are aware of the
next steps following the interview. Before calling the references provided by the
applicant, the interviewer should obtain permission from the applicant. If the salary was
not mentioned during the interview, the interviewer should bring it up. Furthermore, the
interviewer should provide a timetable or schedule for the decision, as well as how the
applicant will be notified. The interviewer should make a point of thanking the applicant.
D. Application
2. Assume that you are an HR Manager. Conduct telephone interview with your
classmates (at least 5 interviews). Apply the WASP Approach.
A. Activity:
47 in job interviews.
1. Write possible interview questions used
B. Analysis
1. What do you think is the best question technique? Defend your answer.
C. Abstraction
• Open
• Clear
• Relevant
• Well Worded
• Not leading
• Questioned throughout the interview
Types of Questions
1. Open Questions
The basic rule is to avoid using categorical questions that can only be answered with
yes or no, as this will end the discussion. Use open-ended questions to allow the
candidate to express themselves. Open questions begin with "Tell Me" or "Who",
"What", "Why", "When", "Where", and "How:"
48
2. Probing Questions
Probing questions are intended to delve into something the applicant has said
or done. The interviewer should never take an applicant’s statement for granted. He
should probe to find out more information from the applicant, particularly if it is relevant
to the job.
Example: “I see from your CV that you graduated in year 2015, and had your
first work experience sometime in year 2019. Tell me what happened during those 3-
year gap, what did you do during 2015 – 2018?
3. Comparison Questions
4. Behavioural Questions
Questions should not have the feel of an interrogation, nor should they be
critical or disparaging. The interviewer must ensure that the questions are not too long,
as this will confuse the applicant. Questions should not be overly personal or out of
line. Furthermore, interview questions should not be closed, as this limits the
applicant's ability to provide information. An interviewer must be completely aware of
what questions he can and cannot ask during the interview. Listening is a skill in an
interview, and the interviewer must have this skill or the candidate may be turned off.
1. Eye Contact – The interviewer must maintain eye contact with the applicant,
proving that he is listening and encouraging the applicant to talk.
49
2. Nodding – Nodding in agreement with what the applicant has said indicates
that the interviewer is interested in what the applicant is saying, which
encourages the applicant to express himself/herself.
7. Minimal Note-taking – The interviewer should not take too many notes
because it may break eye contact and be offensive to the applicant.
D. Application
1. Write your interview questions used in your job-interview and its best answers.
50
Lesson 6: Common Reasons Why Interview Fails
A. Activity
B. Analysis
2. Discuss why there is a need to plan and prepare for the interview.
C. Abstraction
2. A hasty decision was made. - The interviewer makes a hasty decision, which is
subjective and deprives the applicant of a fair chance. Prejudices will be able to
influence their decisions as a result of this.
3. Interviews with no structure - If there is no set format for the interview, each
interview will be conducted differently, making it impossible to conduct a common
assessment of candidates.
4. Environment of the Interview - If one or both parties are uncomfortable with the
location/venue, the interview will suffer as a result. For example, if the venue is too hot
51
or too cold, the interviewer or applicant may be unable to focus on the questions
because of their discomfort.
6. Inadequate interview skills – If the interviewer does not work to improve their skills,
they are likely to make some or all of the errors listed above.
D. Application
1. Write a narrative on your job interview experience, what are the mistakes you
experience while conducting an interview, and discuss how you successfully
manage the interview.
52
Lesson 7: Evaluating the Results of the Interview
(Payos, R. 2020)
A. Activity
B. Analysis
2. Discuss the reason why you chose the applicant (shortlisted) over the others.
C. Abstraction
1. Intelligence
2. Decisiveness
3. Energy
4. Results-oriented
5. Maturity
6. Assertiveness
7. Sensitivity
8. Openness
9. Tough-mindedness
53
Make a hiring decision only after careful consideration of the information
gathered following the evaluation. Decisions must be made on the basis of hard facts
and objective observations that have been gathered and synthesized.
D. Application
1. Submit the shortlisted applicants and its interview results. What is the basis of
your evaluation?
B. Analysis
C. Abstraction
After gathering all relevant information from the evaluation process, the best fit
candidate or applicant is chosen and appointed. The best-fit applicant will be chosen
only after all interviews have taken place. As an interviewer, you should not make a
hasty decision to hire someone based solely on your gut instinct. Despite the fact that
we are only humans, we have a tendency to be subjective. To eliminate subjectivity,
the following steps must be taken:
2. Prepare an assessment that incorporates all of the criteria; this can be done
using a numerical or descriptive scale (see Appendix A for sample).
4. Allow time after each interview to complete the assessment form for the
applicant in question while the details are still fresh in your mind.
5. After all of the interviews have been completed, compare all of the
assessment forms to determine the best candidate or candidates. If the
assessment identifies more than one qualified candidate, create a short list of
qualified applicants for a subsequent round of interviews or selection methods.
Appointing Candidates
55
Every company has its own approach to hiring candidates, but the following are
the general steps in hiring successful candidates:
Appointment should be made after selecting the best of the best from among
the qualified applicants. A verbal offer is made to the applicant, usually via phone call,
informing him or her that he or she has passed the interview and has been chosen.
Some companies notify the successful applicant via email, text message, or phone
call, and invite the applicant to visit the company for contract signing. Some businesses
send a letter of appointment to the applicant and schedule the contract signing.
D. Application
___________________________________________________________________
56
UNIT IV: INDUCTION AND TRAINING
Introduction
Because “first impressions last,” every employee recalls their first few days on
the job. If the new entrant's experience falls short of their expectations, or if they have
a negative impression, expect them to have some doubts about their employment, or
worse, to consider quitting. As a result, induction is a critical activity in any business or
company.
Induction is the process of welcoming new employees and providing them with
the basic information they need to become acquainted with the company and their job
quickly. Induction is planned, and it is a systematic process that introduces new
employees to the company, coworkers, and their primary job. Orientation is another
term for induction. The goals of an induction are as follows: a.) to make the new
employee's first few days in the company as smooth and easy as possible; b.) to
quickly establish a favorable attitude and opinion of the company in the mind of the
new employee so that he or she is more likely to stay in the company; c.) Obtaining
the desired output from the new employee in the shortest amount of time.
Learning Objectives:
57
Lesson 1: Orientation: The Acculturation Process
A. Activity
B. Analysis
C. Abstraction
58
to avoid employee turnover in the long run. Orientations should not be boring or
excessively long. Avoid overloading new employees with information about the
company, and give them the opportunity to ask questions and clarify some issues.
This begins with a greeting from the Human Resource Officer/Head and, if
possible, the CEO. The CEO's welcome speech gives the impression that the new
entrants are an important part of the business. The welcome section includes an
overview of the company, its history, vision, mission, culture, products, and services,
which is usually done in the form of a power point presentation or a video presentation.
This is an important aspect of orientation; a tour of the facilities will help them
feel at ease and familiarize themselves with their surroundings. The tour should include
the plant or office facilities, the Human Resource Department, the Accounting
Department, and other top management offices. There will also be a tour of the medical
clinic, canteen, locker rooms, and rest rooms.
A meeting with the top management gives new entrants a sense of importance.
An introduction to their co-workers and immediate superior is also important because
it will put them at ease knowing who they will be interacting with on a regular basis.
Some companies assign a buddy or a mentor to new entrants to assist them in
adjusting to their new environment.
59
Paperwork completion
Employees must receive and read the employee handbook before signing a
receipt attached to a perforated portion of the handbook indicating that they have read
and understood the contents of the employee handbook.
The job responsibilities of new entrants must be reviewed during or at the time
of the induction session to ensure that his expectations are aligned with those of the
company. During the review of the job description, standards should be established
against which his future performance will be measured. To avoid future legal issues,
the performance evaluation system must be explained to new entrants.
A proper orientation can help the employee start right and finish his job quickly,
lowering the costs associated with learning the job.
60
3. It saves the supervisor and co-workers time.
The less time supervisors and co-workers will have to spend teaching the
employees, if the orientation is better.
If the orientation is good, new entrants will learn as soon as possible what is
expected of them and what others can expect of them. Learn about the organization's
values and culture as well.
D. Application
1. Assume again that you are an HR Manager of a particular company, and write
your own orientation program.
61
Lesson 2: Training and Development
A. Activity
B. Analysis
3. What are the advantages of conducting training and development? On the part
of the employer? Employees?
C. Abstraction
62
• Education is the systematic exposure to new knowledge, concepts, and ideas.
It is usually intended to increase knowledge or change attitudes and beliefs.
• Training refers to solutions to a learning need that entail being taught or shown
how to do things. It is primarily a skill issue.
• Learning is centered on the needs of the employee and begins with the
individual as the beneficiary.
Training and development can take many different forms. The following are
some examples of different training and development activities:
• Induction training
Remedial skills training is used to close "skill gaps" or shortage of skills, when
an employee or group of employees lacks the skills required to perform their current
job task effectively. It is especially critical as the rate of technological change
accelerates. Investing in new machinery and software would be pointless if the existing
workforce could not use it.
63
It is also important to remember that skill development can take two forms:
Importance of Training
The following are some of the reasons why training is critical for every
organization:
• Flexibility
The environment in which businesses operate is becoming increasingly
volatile. Employees within organizations must be adaptable in order for
organizations to be able to adapt to changing environments. An organization can
only benefit from an emerging market or move into a new market niche if its
employees have the necessary skills to operate effectively in the new market or
niche (Crofts, 1995).
• New technology
64
With the advancement of technologies, there is an increased demand for
labor that possesses the necessary knowledge and skill to effectively use the
technology. Companies will be unable to capitalize on new technological
developments or adapt to new technology unless their workforce possesses the
necessary skills. It is also critical for managers to receive training in new technology
if they are to be able to disseminate knowledge to their subordinates (Hyman,
1996).
65
the trained worker does not fully understand the training, all of the workers in that
section will be under-trained as a result.
Companies cannot expect to find skilled workers among the shrinking pool of
unemployed in times of low unemployment. In such a case, if a company requires
specific skills, it becomes increasingly important to develop them in-house. However,
when there are a large number of unemployed people, organizations do not need to
train. Most labor markets experience skill shortages, so even if there are a large
number of people looking for work, they may lack the necessary skills and knowledge.
66
D. Application
1. Make a list of all the reasons why training and development are critical to the
success of organizations.
2. Search for a real company (internet or in real business setting) , give comments
on their Training and Development. What do you think is/are the appropriate
training(s) for that particular business?
67
References
Failte Ireland (2013) Recruitment and Selection: A Guide to Help You Review Your
Existing Approach to Recruitment and Selection.
Picardi, C. (2019). Recruitment and Selection, Strategies for Workforce Planning and
Assessment. University of Bridgeport, USA.
Parker, Y. (2012). The Damn Food Resume Guide: A Crash Course in Resume
Writing.
Fein, R. (2012). 101 Hiring Mistakes Employers Make, & How to Avoid Them.
68
APPENDICES
69
Appendix B
COURSE GUIDE
Course: Recruitment and Selection Semester: 1st School Year: 2021-2022
Course Description:
Course Outline
SCHEDULE TOPIC
Course Requirements:
71
References:
1. Failte Ireland (2013) Recruitment and Selection: A Guide to Help You Review Your
Existing Approach to Recruitment and Selection.
2. Dessler, Gary (2010) Human Resource Management. Prentice Hall.
3. 3G Learning (2016). Human Resource Management in Small Business.
Consultation Schedule:
72