INTRODUCTION

PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL

Performance appraisal is a structured, formalized method used by organizations to assess and review an
employee’s job performance over a defined period, typically annually or bi-annually. It is a key
component of the broader performance management system within an organization. At its core,
performance appraisal is more than just a periodic review, it is a systematic process designed to observe,
measure, document, and evaluate how effectively an employee carries out their assigned duties and
responsibilities.

The central philosophy behind performance appraisal is continuous improvement, not only for the
individual employee but for the organization as a whole. It reflects an organization’s commitment to:

• Accountability: Ensuring that employees are responsible for their performance.

• Transparency: Making expectations and assessments clear and standardized.

• Development: Providing a platform for dialogue on how to improve and grow.

Key Components of Performance Appraisal

The key components in the process of a performance appraisal generally includes:

1. Goal Setting: Before the appraisal period begins, expectations and objectives are typically set. This
ensures that the employee knows what is expected in terms of performance outcomes and behavior.

2. Ongoing Monitoring: Throughout the review period, supervisors or managers observe performance,
sometimes collecting real-time data or feedback from peers, clients, or team leads.

3. Documentation: Accurate records of employee activities, achievements, challenges, and feedback are
maintained to ensure a fair evaluation.

4. Evaluation: At the end of the review period, the manager compares the actual performance against the
set standards, identifying performance levels in various areas like quality, efficiency, teamwork,
communication, and initiative.

5. Feedback and Dialogue: The appraisal typically culminates in a discussion between the employee and
manager. This meeting is not only about scoring performance but also about discussing what went well,
what didn’t, and how to improve.

Nature of Performance Appraisal

1. Formal and Systematic: It follows a planned structure and process, usually based on company policy.

2. Objective and Fair: It attempts to minimize bias through predefined criteria and multiple sources of
input.

3. Developmental: While it evaluates past performance, it is also forward-looking—meant to encourage

personal and professional growth.

1
4. Interactive: Ideally, it is not a one-sided judgment but a conversation, fostering mutual understanding
and clarity.

Performance appraisal is not just a human resources function, it is a strategic tool. It aligns individual
employee contributions with the larger goals of the company, helping to ensure that everyone is working
toward common outcomes. It also strengthens the organizational culture by reinforcing values like
excellence, accountability, and collaboration.

TYPES OF PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL

1. Negotiated Appraisal

This type involves a mediator who facilitates a balanced conversation between the employee and the
manager. The manager starts by highlighting the employee's strengths before moving on to constructive
feedback. This is especially useful in conflict-prone environments. Example: A manager and an
underperforming team leader use a mediator to agree on areas of improvement and how to move forward
without hostility.

2. Management by Objectives (MBO)

In this appraisal method, managers and employees collaboratively set specific, measurable goals.
Performance is then assessed based on how well these goals are achieved. MBO encourages employee
involvement and clarity. Example: A sales manager and a sales executive agree on a goal to close 50
sales per quarter. Performance is evaluated at the end of the quarter.

3. Assessment Center Method

This method evaluates employees using role-plays, simulations, case studies, and group discussions to
assess skills such as leadership, communication, and problem-solving. Example: An employee is asked
to simulate handling a difficult customer or leading a team meeting during the evaluation.

4. Self-Appraisal

Employees evaluate their own performance by reflecting on their achievements, goals, and areas for
improvement. This can foster self-awareness and accountability. Example: An employee fills out a self-
review form noting they improved customer satisfaction scores by 20%.

5. Peer Review

Colleagues provide feedback on an employee's performance, especially regarding teamwork,

communication, and collaboration. This method is valuable in team-centric environments. Example:
Coworkers evaluate a team member's willingness to assist others and contribute ideas during meetings.

2
6. Customer/Client Review

Feedback from clients or customers helps assess how well an employee represents the company and
delivers service. Example: Clients rate a customer service representative's helpfulness and
professionalism through surveys.

7. Behaviorally Anchored Rating Scale (BARS)

BARS appraisals compare employee performance to specific behavioral examples tied to numerical
ratings. This method offers clarity and objectivity. Example: A rating of 5 may be defined as 'always
addresses customer issues promptly and courteously', while a 1 means 'often ignores customer
complaints.'

8. 360-Degree Feedback

This comprehensive method gathers input from all levels-supervisors, peers, subordinates, and
sometimes clients. It gives a rounded view of employee performance. Example: A manager is reviewed
by their direct reports, peers, and supervisor on leadership and communication skills.

9. Rating Scale Appraisal

Uses a standardized scale to rate various aspects of performance such as punctuality, initiative, and job
knowledge. Example: An employee receives a 4/5 for initiative and a 3/5 for communication on a scale
of 1 to 5.

10. Checklist Method

Managers check off pre-defined statements that apply to an employee's behavior and output. Example:
Checklist items include 'arrives on time', 'meets deadlines', and 'follows instructions accurately'.

11. Critical Incident Method

Managers keep a log of particularly positive or negative employee behaviors throughout the review
period. This log is then used to guide the evaluation. Example: A manager documents an incident where
an employee successfully resolved a system outage quickly.

12. Forced Distribution Method

Employees are ranked and placed into performance categories. This creates a distribution, often like a
bell curve. Example: A company categorizes employees as top 10%, middle 70%, and bottom 20%,
forcing managers to differentiate performance levels.

3
USES OF PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL

Performance appraisal is a crucial process in human resource management that serves several purposes.
Here are the uses of performance appraisal:

1. Employee Development

 Identifying strengths and weaknesses: Performance appraisals help identify areas where employees
excel and areas that need improvement.
 Creating development plans: Based on the appraisal, development plans can be created to help
employees improve their skills and performance.
 Providing feedback: Regular feedback is essential for employee growth and development.

2. Performance Feedback

 Regular feedback: Performance appraisals provide employees with regular feedback on their
performance, helping them understand their progress and areas for improvement.
 Constructive criticism: Appraisals offer an opportunity to provide constructive criticism that can
help employees improve their performance.

3. Goal Setting

 Setting performance goals: Performance appraisals help set clear performance goals and
expectations for employees.
 Aligning goals with organizational objectives: Appraisals ensure that employee goals align with the
organization's overall objectives.

4. Promotion and Career Advancement

 Evaluating performance: Performance appraisals evaluate employee performance to determine

eligibility for promotions.
 Identifying potential leaders: Appraisals help identify employees with leadership potential and
develop them for future roles.

5. Compensation and Benefits

 Determining salary increases: Performance appraisals provide a basis for determining salary
increases or bonuses.
 Rewarding high performers: Appraisals help identify high performers who deserve rewards and
recognition.

6. Identifying Training Needs

 Identifying skill gaps: Performance appraisals help identify areas where employees require
additional training or development.
 Creating training programs: Based on the appraisal, training programs can be created to address skill
gaps and improve employee performance.
4
7. Succession Planning

 Identifying future leaders: Performance appraisals help identify employees with leadership potential
and develop them for future roles.
 Developing succession plans: Appraisals inform succession planning, ensuring that the organization
has a pipeline of talented employees ready to take on key roles.
 Better decision-making: Performance appraisals provide valuable data for making informed
decisions about promotions, compensation, and development

8. Improving Employee Engagement

 Recognizing and rewarding employees: Performance appraisals provide an opportunity to recognize

and reward employees for their contributions.
 Boosting motivation: Regular feedback and recognition can boost employee motivation and
engagement.
 Improved performance: Regular feedback and evaluation can lead to improved employee
performance.
 Increased employee engagement: Recognizing and rewarding employees can boost motivation and
engagement.

EFFECT OF PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL

Effects on Employees

Performance appraisals can serve as either a catalyst for growth or a source of discouragement,
depending on how they're delivered and received. Effect on employees include:

1. Boosts Motivation and Morale

When employees receive positive feedback or meaningful recognition, it nurtures a sense of worth and
drives them to aim higher. Example: Fatima, a customer service rep, was highlighted during her review
for her exceptional empathy with frustrated customers. That recognition didn't just affirm her value; it
re-energized her to continue doing her best even on hard days. Employees who feel appreciated are more
likely to be engaged, loyal, and productive. Recognition reinforces purpose.

2. Clarifies Expectations and Responsibilities

Appraisals provide clarity. When employees understand what’s expected of them, they align their work
with organizational goals, and confusion is minimized. Example: Chinedu had been working extra
hours, but his performance score was low. During his appraisal, he learned that the company prioritized
efficiency over volume. That feedback helped him realign his efforts and improve results. Clear
communication fosters strategic effort. It reduces wasted time and energy.

3. Identifies Areas for Personal and Professional Growth

Through constructive feedback, employees can identify their strengths and the areas needing
improvement. This builds a growth mindset and opens doors for career development. Example: Ada’s
manager pointed out her consistent excellence in handling group presentations. With mentorship, she
5
transitioned from a data analyst role into a client-facing consultant role where she truly shone. A good
appraisal turns feedback into a future. It’s a mirror and a map.

4. Can Demotivate or Create Anxiety (When Done Poorly)

If appraisals are unfair, vague, overly negative, or biased, they can breed resentment, self-doubt, and
disengagement. Example: Joseph was told he “wasn’t meeting expectations” but wasn’t given specific
reasons or support. He felt judged rather than guided. His passion faded, and eventually, he resigned.
Unclear or harsh appraisals damage morale. Criticism without coaching crushes potential.

5. Improves Communication and Trust

A well-handled appraisal is a two-way conversation, not a one-sided verdict. It strengthens relationships

and builds transparency between staff and management. Example: During her review, Ifeoma was
encouraged to express her challenges and career aspirations. Her manager listened, adjusted her
responsibilities, and later nominated her for a leadership program. When people feel heard, they feel
safe. And when they feel safe, they grow.

Effects on the Organization

Appraisals don’t just benefit individuals, they play a strategic role in the growth and health of the entire
organization.

1. Drives Higher Productivity and Performance

A workforce that knows its value, understands its objectives, and receives regular feedback tends to be
more productive and focused. Example: A retail company introduced quarterly appraisals with
personalized development plans. Within a year, overall sales increased by 15%, and staff absenteeism
dropped significantly. Engaged employees perform better. Motivation is contagious.

2. Informs Strategic Planning and Decision-Making

Performance data collected through appraisals helps leadership make informed decisions on promotions,
restructuring, or training investments. Example: Through appraisal trends, a hospital discovered that
many of its junior nurses needed emotional resilience training. After introducing workshops, staff stress
levels declined and patient satisfaction improved. Data from reviews becomes fuel for innovation and
intervention.

3. Supports Succession Planning and Leadership Development

Performance appraisals help identify high-potential employees who can take on bigger roles in the
future, ensuring leadership pipelines remain strong. Example: Kelechi consistently scored high on
leadership, initiative, and teamwork in his evaluations. HRnominated him for a managerial mentorship
program, and today he heads his department. Your future leaders are likely already on your payroll, if
you’re paying attention.

4. Strengthens Company Culture and Loyalty

6
When appraisals are handled with fairness, compassion, and consistency, they reinforce a culture of
growth, openness, and accountability. Example: A tech firm known for its transparent, feedback-rich
appraisal system retained 90% of its employees over 5 years, in an industry plagued by high turnover.
Culture is built in conversations, especially the hard ones.

5. Protects the Organization Legally and Ethically

Documented performance reviews create a record that can be used to justify HR decisions like
promotions, terminations, or disciplinary actions, reducing legal risk. Example: When a dismissed
employee challenged the company’s decision, well-documented appraisal records showed consistent
underperformance and attempts to help them improve. Good documentation isn’t just policy, it’s
protection.

Conclusively, performance appraisal is a critical, formalized process designed to evaluate and guide
employee performance in alignment with organizational expectations. While it includes assessment, its
broader purpose is to build a culture of continuous feedback, development, and improvement. It serves
as a reflective mirror, showing both the employee and the organization how well efforts are aligning
with goals, and where progress can be made. By using performance appraisals effectively, organizations
can improve employee performance, engagement, and development, ultimately driving business success.