Labour Law
Labour Law
TRADE UNION
DEFINITION:
Trade Union means any combination, whether temporary or permanent, formed;
1. For the purpose of regulating the relations between workmen and employers,
workmen and workmen, or employers and employers or
2. For imposing restrictive conditions on the conduct of any trade or business.
A trade union may also includef two or more trade unions within itself.
FUNCTIONS OF TRADE UNION:
1. To secure for the workers fair wages.
2. To safeguard security of tenure of employment.
3. To enlarge opportunities for promotion.
4. To improve living conditions.
5. To offer good co operation in improvement of production.
6. Promotion of individual and collective welfare.
CHARACTERISTICS OF TRADE UNION:
1. It becomes a body corporate by the name under which it is registered. It is a legal
entity distinct from its members.
2. It has perpetual succession and a common seal.
3. It can acquire both movable and immovable properties.
4. It can sue and be sued.
5. It can enter into any contract.
MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS FOR A TRADE UNION:
1. There must be combination of workmen or employers.
2. There must be a trade or business and
3. The main object of the union must be to regulate relations of employers and
employees.
4. It is not necessary that every union must be registered under the Act.
5. If the union is registered under the act, then it gets the immunities, privileges and
other rights under the Act.
RIGHTS AND BENEFITS FO REGISTERED UNION:
-2-
4. Provision of adequate facility for inspection.
5. The designation of the post / employment of workers.
6. The conditions under which the fund benefits go to the workers.
7. The mode of admission of office bearers.
8. The amount of subscription. It should not be less than a prescribed amount per
worker per month.
9. The rules and regulations of the trade union.
10. The method of removal of office bearers.
11. The manner of dissolution of the trade union.
-3-
1. To dissolve a registered trade union, a notice signed by members and the
Secretary of the trade union should be sent to the Registrar within 14 days of the
dissolution.
2. If the Registrar is satisfied that the dissolution is affected according to the rules of
trade union, then he registers the dissolution.
3. The dissolution shall have effect from the date of such registration.
4. If the rules of the trade union do not provide about the distribution of funds on
dissolution, then the funds will be distributed as per the provision of the trade
union act.
AMALGAMATION OF TRADE UNION (Sec. 24 to 26)
Any two or more registered trade unions may become amalgamated together as one
trade union.
1. CORPORATE BODY:
Every registered union is a body corporate by the name under which it is registered. It
has a perpetual succession and a common seal with the power to acquire and hold
-4-
both immovable and movable properties and to contract and shall by the same name
sue and be sued.
1. The payment of salaries, allowances and expenses of the office bearers of the
trade union.
2. The payment of expenses for the administration of the trade union including the
audit of accounts of the general funds of the trade union.
3. The expenses in prosecution or defence in any legal proceedings.
4. The conduct of trade disputes on behalf of the trade union or any member
thereof. The compensation for members for loss arising out of trade disputes.
5. Allowances to members or their dependants on account of death, old 'age,
sickness, accidents or unemployment of such members.
6. The undertaking of liability of payment of premium under policies of assurance
on the lives of members.
7. The provision of educational, social or religious benefits for members or their
dependants.
8. The upkeep of a periodical published mainly for the purpose of discussing
questions affecting employers or workmen.
9. The payment of contribution to any case intended for the benefit of workmen in
general.
10. For any other object as notified by the appropriate Govt. in the official gazette.
A registered Trade Union may constitute a separate fund for promotion of civil and
political interests of the members. Such fund can be used in furtherance of the
following objects:
-5-
3. The maintenance of any person who is a member of any legislative of any
local authority.
4. The registration of the electorates or the selection of any candidate for legislative
body or any local authority.
COLLECTIVE BARGAINING
1. Collective process.
4. This includes both industrial growth as well as per capita growth of a worker.
8. The execution of the contract. It is the main part of the contract where the terms
and condition of various matters are implemented.
1. The main agenda of both employers and union are to settle the matter through
arbitration process between themselves by concluding into a common minimum
agreement rather than sorting it arbitrarily. But collective bargaining is limited to
large plants and factories. Small factory organization does not come under this
rule.
2. In India, laws give an easy way to arbitration. Under the industrial dispute act, the
parties related to the dispute can approach the government to refer the matter for
arbitration to an Industrial tribunal or labour court.
-6-
The following are the aims and objectives of collective bargaining:
1. Upholding industrial democracy
2. Ensuring equality and justice for socially and economically backwards groups
3. Protecting the working class from exploitation
4. Meeting the legitimate expectations of labourers regarding the work they have
undertaken
1. Being a part of a group helps employees to voice their demands and negotiate
better with their employers. It is harder for employers to dismiss the demands of a
unified large group of employees or a trade union in comparison with individual
employees.
2. It helps to improve the workplace conditions for employees.
3. It makes the rights and obligations of both employers and employees clear.
-7-
Every office bearer/member of union enjoys certain civil and criminal immunities. An
office bearer or member of a Registered Trade union will not be liable to punishment
under Sec. 120 -B [Criminal Conspiracy) of the I.P.C, for any act of furthering any
object of the Union.
Standard Chartered Grindlays Bank Ltd., Vs. Grindlays Bank Employees' Association,
2002 (II) LLJ 174:
The Court held that the display of posters within or outside the place of business is
permissible and the workers are entitled to the protection under Sec. 18 of the Trade
Unions Act, even if the strike is illegal.
-8-
UNIT - II
2. In other words, the functions of the industry must be carried on smoothly without
any interruptions and Industrial Disputes Act aims at prevention and speedy
settlement of dispute between the employer and the workmen so that the industrial
operations are not adversely and permanently affected.
3. The root causes of industrial disputes are due to the dissatisfaction of the workmen
that the employers are not paying sufficient wages for the work carried out by them.
So, the aim of Industrial Disputes Act is to render economic justice to the workmen by
settlement of industrial disputes judicially by rational increase in wages, etc.,
1. Any industrial dispute between the employer and the workmen is settled by
conciliation proceedings through Conciliation Officers, Boards of Conciliation, etc.
2. The awards passed by the industrial tribunals, labour courts, national tribunals and
arbitration are all binding on both the employer and the workmen.
5. The Act provides for compensation for lay off or retrenchment of workmen by the
employer. Further, the employer has to pay compensation to workmen in case of
transfer or closure of an undertaking.
-9-
6. For effective enforcement of the provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act, it
provides for penalties to the employer and the workmen.
7. The, Act provides measures for protection of workmen so that his conditions of
service are not altered when an industrial dispute is pending for conciliation or
adjudication.
8. The Act also provides for recovery of back wages and other payments through
revenue recovery proceedings, in case the award is in favour of the workmen.
The definition of industry is now very wide, but specific. Sec. 2 (j) reads `industry
means any systematic activity carried on by co-operation between an employer and
his workmen'.
Decided case laws have held that the following enterprises are not industries:
1. Spiritual or religious service.
2. Restricted category of clubs, co-operatives, research lab and gurukulas.
3. Free legal or medical services on honorarium basis.
The Supreme Court over ruled the decisions given in the earlier cases and laid down
the following conclusions:
(vi) A pious or altruistic mission may employ many persons, but there is no master
and servant relationship.
- 11 -
(vii) If there is mixture of activities, consisting of industrial and non-industrial
services, then the dominant nature of services will decide whether it is an
industry or not
(viii) Strict Sovereign functions are exempted and not the welfare activities or
economic adventures undertaken by Government or Statutory bodies.
(ix) In departments discharging Sovereign functions, if there are units, which are
industries, and if they are severable, they are considered Industries.
Thus the Bangalore Water Supply and Sewerage Board Vs. A. Rajappa over-ruled the
previous provisions and decisions, and the definition of the term ‘industry' has since
been modified.
WORKMEN [Sec. 2(s)]
i. who is subject to the Air Force Act, 1950 or the Army Act, 1950 or the Navy Act,
1957, or
ii. who is employed in the police service or as an officer or other employee of a
prison, or
iii. who is employed mainly in a managerial or administrative capacity, or
iv. who, being employed in a supervisory capacity, drawswages exceeding one
thousand six hundred rupeesper mensem or exercises, either by the nature of the
duties attached to the office or by reason of the powers vested in him, functions
mainly of a managerial nature.
ESSENTIALS:
- 12 -
4. If a contractor employs a workman to do the work which he contracted with a third
person, then the workman of the contractor does not become a workman of that third
person.
Miss. A. Sundarambal Vs. Government of Goa, Daman and Diu, 1989, I Lab LJ 61 (SC):
The Supreme Court held that in order to be a workman, an employee should be
employed to do any skilled or unskilled, manual, supervisory, technical or clerical
work. Judged in this light, a teacher cannot be called a workman.
INDUSTRIAL DISPUTE [Sec. 2 (k)]
1. INDIVIDUAL DISPUTES:
If any employer discharges, retrenches or dismisses an individual workman, such
dispute between such a workman and his employer is deemed to be an individual
dispute.
2. COLLECTIVE DISPUTES:
- 13 -
A dispute, which may be initiated by an individual, may be taken up by the fellow
workers or a Union, or a sufficient number of workers, and then it assumes the
collective character and becomes an industrial dispute.
The following are the industrial dispute machineries to bring about industrial peace
and conciliation:
CONCILIATION:
POWERS:
A Conciliation Officer may enter the premises occupied by the establishment for the
purpose of inquiry into any existing or apprehended industrial dispute.
BOARDS OF CONCILIATION.
The appropriate Government, by notification in the Official gazette, may constitute a
Board of Conciliation for promoting the settlement of industrial disputes. The Board
consists of a Chairman and two or more members.
DUTIES OF BOARD:
1. When a dispute is referred to the Board by the Government, it shall try to bring
about a settlement of such dispute. It investigates the dispute and does things
necessary for the purpose of amicable settlement of dispute.
2. If settlement of dispute is arrived at, the Board sends a report to the Government
along with the Memorandum of Settlement
3. If no settlement is arrived at, it sends a report stating the steps taken by it and the
reasons for the failure. The report must be submitted within two months from the
date of reference by the Government. The Government publishes the report within
30 days.
ADJUDICATION MACHINERIES (Sec. 7 TO 9)
REFERENCE OF DISPUTES TO BOARDS, COURTS OR TRIBUNALS
LABOUR COURTS:
The appropriate Government (i.e) either Central or State Government may constitute
one or more courts for adjudication of industrial disputes. The Labour Court consists
of only one person, named as ‘Presiding Officer’
The Presiding officer must have been a Judge of the High Court or a District Judge or
Additional District Judge, with 3 years experience. Must have held the office of the
chairman of the Labour Appellate Tribunal for atleast 5 years and or any Judicial
Officer with atleast 7 years experience.
- 15 -
REFERENCE OF DISPUTES:
The following are the matters which can be adjudicated by the Labour Court.
i. The legality of an order passed by the employers under the standing orders.
ii. Discharge or dismissal of workmen including reinstatement.
iii. Withdrawal of any perquisites or privileges.
iv. Legality of Strike or Lock out.
FUNCTIONS:
Adjudication of industrial disputes relating to any matter specified in the second
schedule namely:
1. The propriety of legality of any order passed by an employer under the standing
orders.
2. The application and interpretation of standing orders.
3. Discharge or dismissal of workmen including reinstatement.
4. Withdrawal of any customary concession or privilege.
5. Illegality or otherwise of a strike or lockout
6. All matters other than those specified in the 3rd schedule.
DUTIES:
1. The labour court has to adjudicate the industrial disputes relating to the matter
within its jurisdiction.
2. When an industrial dispute has been referred to the Labour Court, it should hold
proceedings immediately, and submit its award within the specified period to the
appropriate Government.
3. The award should be in writing and should be signed by its Presiding Officer.
4. The award should be published within a period of 30 days from the date of its
receipt by the appropriate Government.
INDUSTRIAL TRIBUNALS:
The appropriate Government, by notification in the Official Gazette, may constitute
one or more industrial tribunals for adjudication of industrial disputes. The tribunal
consists of only one person called the presiding officer.
JURISDICTION:
- 16 -
The industrial tribunal can exercise jurisdiction in the following matters:
a. Wages.
b. Compensatory and other allowances.
c. Leave with wages and holiday.
d. Hours of work and rest intervals.
e. Bonus, provident fund and gratuity.
f. Shift working system.
g. Classification by grades.
h. Rules of discipline.
i. Nationalization.
j. Retrenchment of workmen and closure of establishment.
REFERENCE OF DISPUTES:
If there is any industrial dispute existing or apprehended, the appropriate Government
may refer the dispute to a Tribunal for adjudication.
- 17 -
9. The award must be a speaking one. Failure to give reasons constitutes an error
of law.
10. An award, therefore, should be a determination of the dispute. If there is no
determination, there can be no award.
11. Before giving an award, the parties must be heard. An award made without
giving a party sufficient opportunity of making representation is bad.
12. The award must also be confined to the terms of the reference and should not go
beyond the terms.
13. An award does not have retrospective effect.
- 18 -
But the total period of operation of any award shall not exceed 3 years from the date
on which it came into operations.
- 19 -
4. Award prohibits a suit or action in a Civil Court. Where as settlement does not
prohibit a suit or action in a Civil Court.
5. Award becomes enforceable and expiry of 30 days from the date of publication
whereas settlement becomes enforceable immediately.
- 20 -
UNIT – III
STRIKES AND LOCKOUTS: (Sec. 22 to 25)
i. The workman must give the employer a notice of strike within 6 weeks before the
strike. So a strike notice is valid only for 6 weeks. No strike can be started after the
expiry of 6 weeks unless a fresh notice of strike is given.
ii. The employee must not go on strike within 14 days of giving such notice. So, a
strike immediately after the notice is also illegal.
iii. The workman should not go on strike before the expiry of the date specified in the
aforesaid notices.
iv. The workman should not go on strike during the pendency of Conciliation
proceeding before the Conciliation Officer and 7 days after the conclusion of such
proceedings, i.e., only from 8th day of conclusion of proceedings, a strike can be
commenced.
RULES:
1. Notice of strike within six weeks before striking is not necessary; here there is
already a lock out in existence.
2. Notice may be given by the Trade Union or the representatives of the workmen
authorised in this behalf.
3. A notice of strike shall not be effective after 6 weeks from the date it is given. So,
the strike must be commenced within the six weeks period.
4. Section 22 (4) says that the notice of strike must be given by prescribed number of
persons to prescribed person/persons in prescribed manner.
5. If, on any day, an employer receives from his workman employed by him any strike
notice, he must within five days of receipt of notice, report to the Appropriate
Government/ Authority.
2. IN INDUSTRIAL ESTABLISHMENTS: (Sec. 23)
- 21 -
A workman employed in any industrial establishment must not go on strike in breach
of contract with employer.
b. The workman must not go on strike during the pendency of proceedings before a
Labour Court. Industrial or National Tribunal and within 2 months after the
conclusion of such proceedings.
c. The workmen must not go on strike during the pendency of any arbitration
proceedings before an arbitrator and within 2 months after the conclusion of such
proceeding or
In Madurai Coats Ltd., Vs. Inspector of Factories; Madurai, 1981 I LLJ 255 (SC.)
The workmen went on strike without serving a strike notice. They claimed wages for
national holiday which fell in between the strike period.
The Supreme Court held that they were not entitled to wages, because they had
themselves brought about a situation by going on strike without giving a notice
whereby the management was deprived of their right to get work from them.
1. STAY IN STRIKE: The workers remain inside the factory. They play and talk, but do
not work.
2. TOKEN STRIKE: It is otherwise known as sympathetic strike. It is not actually a
strike. For e.g. `X' Company employees striking on behalf of `Y' Company.
3. Go - SLOW STRIKE: It is also known as work according to schedule, but not
working efficiently. It reduces the production.
4. PEN - DOWN STRIKE: It is refusal to do work or write.
5. TOOL - DOWN STRIKE: It is refusal to use the tools in handling the machines. It is
dangerous for the safety of the workers.
6. RELAY STRIKE: It is only a strike by a part [group] of the workmen in an industry
and in rotation.
7. HUNGER STRIKE: It is of recent discovery and it is the most advocated form of
strike. It may also be 'relay hunger strike'.
8. ILLEGAL STRIKE: (Sec. 24)
For illegal strike, there is no justifiable reason or demand. It is an intentional or willful
strike. Any of the above methods may be adopted for illegal strike.
In the following cases, strike is deemed illegal:
- 22 -
1. Public Utility Services: If the four conditions given above are violated, it is illegal
strike.
2. In Industrial Establishments: If the four conditions given above are violated, the
strike is illegal.
3. If any industrial dispute is referred to the Board of Conciliation, Labour Court,
Industrial Tribunal or National Tribunal, the appropriate Government by order, may
prohibit the continuance of strike in connection with such dispute.
4. If any industrial dispute is referred to arbitration, the appropriate Government may
prohibit the continuance of strike in connection with such dispute.
Any continuance of strike in violation of the above provisions is deemed to be illegal,
though it is not illegalat its commencement.
LOCK – OUT
Sec. 2 (1) defines a lock out as the temporary closing of place of employment or
suspension of the work or refusal by the employer to continue to employ any number
of persons employed by him.
Thus lock out indicates the temporary closure of the place of business. Lock out
succeeds strike. Lockout is the weapon for the employers, as strike is the weapon for
the workmen.
ESSENTIALS OF LOCKOUT:
1. There is temporary closure of the place of business or the suspension of work or
withholding of work by the employer.
- 23 -
2. There is an element of demand for which the place of employment is locked out or
closed.
3. Intention to re employ the workers is present.
Lay off takes place only in a continuing business. During lay off, only a portion of
business is closed.
1. The employer must fail or refuse or must be unable to continue the employees in
his employment.
- 24 -
2. On the day of lay off, the name of the workman laid off must be present in the
Muster roll.
3. The failure, refusal or inability to give employment must be due to shortage of raw
materials or accumulation of stock or break down of machinery or for any other
reason.
4. The employee must not have been discharging workman temporarily.
CIRCUMSTANCES OF LAY OFF: Under the following three circumstances lay off takes
place:
1. If any workman presents himself for the work at the appointed place and if he is
not given any work within three hours, then it is lay off for the day
2. If any workman is not given any employment in the first half of the shift, but given
in the second half of the shift, then lay off is only for half a day.
3. If any workman is given employment for a few hours in both I and II half of the
shift, then there is no lay off and it is considered as a full working day and full
wages is given for the day.
- 25 -
b. The same wages as in the original employment should be paid.
2. If the employee does not present himself for the work at the establishment and at
the appointed hour during normal working hours at least once a day, no lay-off
compensation is payable.
3. If lay off is due to illegal strike or slow down production by the workers, then no
lay-off compensation is payable.
Lock out is the temporary closing of place of employment or suspension of the work
or refusal by the employer to continue to employ any number of persons employed by
him. ‘lock out' indicates the temporary closure of the place of business. For illegal
lock out, the employer must pay full back wages to the workman.
RETRENCHMENT (Sec. 25-F, 25-G, 25-H & 25-K)
- 26 -
CONDITIONS PRECEDENT TO RETRENCHMENT OF WORKMEN (RETRENCHMENT
COMPENSATION): (Sec. 25-F)
A workman with a continuous service of more than one year can be retrenched. To
invoke the provisions of retrenchment, the workman must have continuous service of
240 days in a calendar year of 365 days.
1. Lay off period is maximum 45 days plus one week with the consent of worker.
Retrenchment cannot exceed 45 days.
2. Lay off is the 1 st step; Retrenchment is the 2nd Step.
3. Compensation is half day wage per day in lay. if Compensation is 15 days wages
for every one year period in retrenchment.
4. No ‘last went first come' rule is applicable for lay off. ‘Last went first come’ is the
rule of reinstatement for the retrenched person.
An employer who violates the provisions relating to prohibition of Lay off and
conditions precedent to retrenchment of workmen shall be punished with
imprisonment extending to one month or fine up to one thousand rupees or with both.
PROBLEMS:
3. A worker of 235 days service was laid off for 45 days and then retrenched. Daily
wage was Rs.70/0 what is his retrenchment compensation?
Period of service is 235 days, lay off 45 days and wage Rs.70/- per day. He is not
entitled to any compensation because his period of service is below one year i.e. 235
days.
4. A workman has put on 11 years and 51/2 months. He was laid off for 60 days and
then retrenched. He was drawing Rs.4000/- at the time of lay off. Please calculate the
compensation payable?
The workman has completed 11 years and 5 ½ months. It is rounded to 11 years. 5 ½
months is neglected as it is below 6 months. Therefore period of service is taken as
11 years. Wage Rs. 4000/- half Rs. 2000/- for 11 years = 22000.
Lay off for 60 days:
Compensation allowed for 45 days only. Half of this period of 22 ½ days or ¾ month
Rs.4000 x ¾ = 3000
For 15 days full wages = 2000
Total compensation = 22000 + 3000 + 2000 = 27000
ARBITRATION (ARBITRATOR) Sec. 10-A
FORM OF AGREEMENT:
1. The arbitration agreement should be in the prescribed form and signed by the
parties.
2. A copy of the arbitration agreement is sent to the appropriate Government and the
Conciliation officer.
3. Within one month from the date of receipt of such copy, the appropriate
Government shall publish the same in the official Gazette.
AWARD:
The arbitrator or arbitrators shall investigate the dispute and submit to the
appropriate Government, the arbitration award signed by a single arbitrator or all the
arbitrators.
The award is signed by the single arbitrator or all the arbitrators. The procedural
formalities in respect of voluntary arbitration agreements are laid down in Part II of
the Industrial Disputes (Central) Rules, 1957.
- 29 -
5. He must not depend upon any document presented by a party, unless it is shown
to the other party.
6. The arbitrator acting under section 10-A has the status of a Statutory tribunal.
7. There is an implied statutory obligation on the arbitrator to give his reasons in
support of the conclusions of fact and law reached by him in the award.
8. The arbitrator is not expected to write a lengthy judgment like a Court, but he
must briefly indicate the working of his mind, i.e., the process of reasoning which
leads him to decide the dispute referred in the way he does by the award.
9. Failure to give reasons when it is obligatory to do so constitutes an error of law
apparent on the face of the record.
- 30 -
UNIT - IV
Sec.2 (1) (d) defines the term `dependent' and gives a list of persons who are
dependents. Usually a dependent is a person who depends upon another for
livelihood. The dependents are alone entitled to get compensation fort the accidental
death of the workmen in the course of and out of employment.
1. Relations who are dependent whether they are actually dependant or not.
E.g.: (i) Widow (ii)Minor legitimate son
(iii) Unmarried legitimate daughter or (iv) a widowed mother.
a. Even after remarriage, a widow is considered dependent and in the same way, a
widowed mother after re-marriage is considered as dependent.
b. Unmarried daughter includes a widowed daughter who is being maintained by
her father during his life time.
c. Relations who are dependents if they are wholly dependent on the earnings of
the workman at the time of his death.
2. Relations who are dependents if they are wholly or partly dependent on the
workman at the time of his death -
- 31 -
a. Widower.
b. A parent other than widowed mother.
c. A minor illegitimate son, an unmarried illegitimate daughter.
d. A minor brother or minor unmarried or widowed sister.
e. A widowed daughter in law.
f. A minor child of a predeceased son.
g. A minor child of a predeceased daughter where no parent of the child is alive.
h. A paternal grand parent, if no parent of the workman is alive.
A. PARTIAL DISABLEMENT:
Partial disablement is a disablement which reduces the earning capacity of a
workman in any employment or in every employment.
- 32 -
For e.g.: If a person losses only one finger i.e., the small finger in one hand
permanently by amputation, then it is a permanent partial disablement, because it
reduces the earning capacity of a workman in every employment.
Even if an injury to a workman caused by an accident did not reduce his capacity to
work, but if the injury has stamped him incapacitated for every work in the sense that
his earning capacity would be fully destroyed to make it as permanent total
disablement.
B. TOTAL DISABLEMENT:
Total disablement is a disablement when it incapacitates a worker for all work he was
capable of doing at the time of the accident resulting in such disablement.
For e.g.: If a person losses all the ten fingers in both the hands, then it is total
disablement, since incapacitates a worker for all work he was capable of doing at the
time of the accident.
- 33 -
3. Every injury specified in Part I of Schedule II is deemed to result in permanent total
disablement; and
4. It is also deemed to result from any combination of injuries specified in Part II of
Second Schedule where the aggregate (total) percentage of the loss of earning
capacity, as specified against those injuries, amounts to 100% or more.
For e.g.: If a person loses all the ten fingers in both the hands permanently by
amputation, then it is a permanent total disablement, because it renders the workman
incapable for all work which he was capable of performing at the time of accident
resulting in such disablement.
For e.g.: If a person sustains bleeding injuries in all the ten fingers in both the hands
for a temporary period of ten days (after which the injuries get cured), then during the
period of bleeding injuries, it is a temporary total disablement because it
incapacitates a workman for all work which he was capable of performing at the time
of the accident.
1. If the injury did not result in total or partial disablement of the workman for a
period exceeding three days.
2. If any injury does not result in death or permanent total disablement, then the
employer can plead:
a. That the workman was at the time of accident under the influence of drinks or
drugs.
b. That the workman willfully disobeyed an order expressly given or a rule
expressly framed for the purpose of securing safety of workmen, and
c. That the workman knowing that certain safety guards or safety devices
specifically provided for the purpose of securing his safety, willfully
disregarded or removed such safety guards or safety devices.
d. Mere death in ordinary course by some bodily disease or ailment does not
constitute personal injury by accident.
ARISING OUT OF AND IN THE COURSE OF EMPLOYMENT:
Thus where a worker lost his mental balance as a result of an injury by accident and
committed suicide, it was held that the accident arose out of employment.
In order to prove that injury arose `out of employment' two conditions must be
fulfilled:
i. Injury must have resulted from some risk incidental to the duties of the service
and inherent in the nature or condition of employment.
ii. At the time of injury, the worker must have been engaged in the business of the
employer and must not be doing something for his personal advantage or benefit.
OCCUPATIONAL DISEASES:
Usually workers employed in certain occupations are exposed to certain diseases
which are normal in those occupations.
E.g.: A person working in any process involving use of Lead Tetra Ethyl is liable to
get poisoning. Such diseases are called occupational diseases.
If the employer is also responsible for the death of a workman, then the death is
deemed to have arisen out of employment.
The Employees' State Insurance Act provides for social insurance to the labourers. It
provides measures for compulsory - sickness, maternity and employment injury
benefits for workers in factories.
The aim of the Act is to establish social and economic justice to the poor. Labour
welfare activities are extended to workers of every factory, industry, mines, plants and
communication, etc.
1. The Act extends to the whole of India. Different provisions of the Act may be
extended to any other establishment either by the Central or State Government in
consultation with one another, after giving 6 months notice.
2. It extends to co-operative society whose workers are shareholders of the society.
Any co-operative society employing its members for wage in a manufacturing
process is also covered.
3. The Act does not apply to any factory belonging to Central Government or under
the control of the Government where employee receives better benefit than under
E.S.I.
4. If any of the provisions of the Act are brought into force in any part of a State, then
they are also extended to other establishments in another part of the State.
5. The extension of the E.S.I. Act does not depend upon the number of persons
employed in any factory.
6. The Act extends to any shop engaged in sale of goods or service rendered. E.g.
Tailoring shop also comes under the Act.
7. Seasonal factories are excluded from the purview of the Act. The factory must be
engaged exclusively in 1. Cotton ginning. 2. Cotton or jute processing.
8. Persons employed by contractors are entitled to the benefit of the Act.
- 37 -
WORKING AND POWERS OF THE CORPORATION, STANDING COMMITTEE AND
MEDICAL BENEFIT COUNCIL:
1. The Standing Committee has the power to administer the affairs of the
Corporation. It submits any case for consideration and decision to the
Corporation.
2. The Corporation promotes measures for improvement of health and welfare
rehabilitation and reemployment of insured persons who are disabled or injured.
3. The Corporation and the Standing Committee seek the advice of the Medical
Benefit Council in matters relating to the administration of medical benefit, etc.
4. Any act by the Corporation, Standing Committee or the Medical Benefit Council is
not invalid only due to defects like irregularity in election, or appointment of any
member, due to any disqualification, or defect in constitution of the Corporation,
Standing Committee or the Medical Benefit Council.
The Employee's State Insurance Act 1948 provides for the creation of a fund under
Sec. 26 called Employees State Insurance Fund. The fund is used for payment of
benefits to the insured person.
The fund is created from contributions from employees and employers, the insurance
of persons including the Government.
- 39 -
7. Meeting the cost of expenses in the Insurance Courts set up under the Act.
8. Payment of sums under any contract entered into by the Corporation or duly
authorised officers for the purposes of this Act.
9. Payment of sums under any decree, order or award or any Court or Tribunal
against the Corporation.
10. To meet the expenses and other charges of any Civil or Criminal proceedings.
11. Meeting the expenses for improvement of health of the insured persons and for
the rehabilitation or re-employment of disabled or injured persons.
12. Such other authorised purposes by the Corporation with the previous approval
of the Central Government.
- 40 -
UNIT - V
The Minimum Wages Act was passed for securing the welfare of the workers, by
fixing the minimum limit of wages in certain employments carried on by or under the
Central Government, railway, mine, oil fields or part or any Corporation and by the
State Governments and for other employments covered by the Schedule of the Act.
The following are the important features of the Minimum Wages Act 1948:
1. Minimum time rate of wages, minimum price rate, guaranteed time rate, over time
rate for different occupations are prescribed in the Act.
2. Minimum wages consist of basic rate of wages and a cost of living allowance or
basic rate of wages with or without the cost of living allowance.
3. As per the Act, wages should be paid in cash.
4. The cost of living, etc are computed by the competent authorities.
5. The Act provides for fixation of number of hours of work per day, weekly holiday,
overtime wages, etc.
6. The Act provides for maintenance of registers and records as prescribed under
the Act.
7. Inspectors and Authorities are appointed for hearing and deciding claims arising
out of payment of wages at less than the minimum rates of wages.
8. Complaints for violations of the provision of the Act and penalties for such
violations are also provided.
9. The minimum wages rates must minimum ensure the physical need of the
worker to keep him just above starvation.
10. It should provide for the bare subsistence of his life and must provide for some
measure of educational, medical requirements and amenities.
WAGES - CONCEPT OF SUBSISTENCE WAGE, MINIMUM WAGE, FAIR WAGE AND
LIVING WAGE
The term `wages' is defined in Sec. 2 (h) of the Minimum Wages Act, 1948. It reads -
Wages' means all remunerations, capable of being expressed in terms of money,
which becomes payable to an employed person for the work done in his employment,
provided the terms of the contract of employment are fulfilled.
CLASSIFICATION OF WAGES:
- 41 -
Wages are classified into four categories:
1. Subsistence wage2. Minimum wage 3. Fair wage 4. Living wage
SUBSISTENCE WAGE:
The Subsistence theory of wages is also known as the Iron Law of Wages. The wage
that can meet only the bare physical needs of a worker and his family is called
subsistence wage.
FAIR WAGE:
Fair wages is an adjustable step that moves up according to the capacity of the
industry to pay, and the prevailing rates of wages in the area of industry.
The wages must be fair, i.e. sufficiently high to provide standard family with, food,
shelter, clothing, medical care and education of children appropriate to the workmen.
LIVING WAGE:
In living wage, workers can maintain the health and decency, a measure of comfort
and some insurance.
The basic `minimum wage' provides bare subsistence and it is at a poverty line level -
a little above the minimum wage is `fair wage' and finally the `living wage' which
comes at a comfort level. It is not possible to demarcate these levels of wage
structure with precision.
OBJECTIVES OF FACTORIES ACT - 1948
The Factories Act was first enacted in 1881 in order to regulate working conditions in
factories. Since then, the Act underwent many amendments and the present Factories
Act 1948 came into force in April 1949.
The main object of the Act is to protect the workers employed in factories against
industrial and occupational risks. The Act imposes upon the owners/ occupiers with
obligations to protect the workers against industrial risks and secure the workers
suitable conditions conducive to protect their health and safety.
FACTORY:
Sec. 2 (m) defines ‘Factory’ as any premises including the precincts thereof
1. Where 10 or more workers are working with the manufacturing process being
carried on with the aid of power.
- 42 -
2. Where 20 or more workers are working or were working in any day in the
preceding 12 months with the manufacturing process being carried on without the
aid of power.
3. The term `factory' does not include mines, because mines are covered under
Indian Mines Act.
4. Similarly, the mobile unit of armed forces, railway running shed or hotel,
restaurant, etc, dare not `factory'.
- 43 -
iv. Independent contractor or his servants or his coolies under the complete control
of the contractor.
When the owner of the factory has leased it to another person and if the owner has
been only collecting the rent, then the lessees will be the occupier within the meaning
of Sec. 2 (n) of the Act, as they alone have ultimate control.
DUTIES OF OCCUPIER: (Sec. 7-A)
1. The occupier should provide for the health, safety and welfare of the workers.
2. He should provide for maintenance of plant and systems of work which are safe
for health.
3. Safety should be provided in handling, storage and transport of articles and
substances.
4. For health and safety of all workers, by providing information, instruction, training
and supervision.
5. Maintaining the places of work in safe condition.
6. He should also prepare and reverse the written statement of his general policy
regarding health and safety of the workers.
Sections 11 to 20 of the Act deal with the provisions ensuring the health of the
workers in the conditions under which work is carried on in the factories.
- 44 -
v. All doors and window frames and other wooden or metallic framework and
shutters should be kept painted or varnished and the painting or varnishing
should be carried out at least once in every period of five years.
vi. The date on which the processes are carried out must be entered in the prescribed
register.
- 45 -
b. All such points must be legibly marked drinking water in a language understood
by a majority of the workers employed in the factory.
c. In every factory, where more than 25 workers are ordinarily employed, provision
should be made for cooling drinking water during hot weather by effective means and
for distribution thereof.
The following are the provisions dealing with the safety of the workers:
Fencing of machinery (Sec. 21): In every factory, dangerous parts of any machinery
must be securely fenced- while such parts of the machinery are in motion. If it is not
covered, it is an offence.
i. The doors of exit from any room should not be locked or fastened. They should be
easily and immediately opened from inside. All the doors should open outwards
except sliding doors.
- 47 -
ii. In all the factories, exits, in case of fire, should be marked in a language easily
understood by the workers and in letters or some other effective signs.
iii. Provisions should be made so that every person in the factory clearly hears the
warning given in case of fire.
iv. In every room of the factory, free passage way giving access to means of escape
should be maintained.
- 48 -