Foi Section 46 Code of Practice
Foi Section 46 Code of Practice
Contents
Foreword 4
Introduction 4
Importance of records management 4
Role of the Information Commissioner 6
Authorities subject to the Public Records Acts 6
Role of the Lord Chancellor’s Advisory Council on National Records and Archives 7
and the Sensitivity Review Group in Northern Ireland
Code of Practice
Introduction 8
15 Purpose of Part 2 22
16 Selection of public records for permanent preservation 22
17 Retention or transfer of public records 22
18 Determining the access status of public records before transfer 23
19 Transmission of public records 25
20 Access after transfer of public records 25
Annex A Glossary 26
Annex B Standards and guidance supporting the Code 27
- Lord Chancellor’s Code of Practice on the management of records
Foreword
Introduction
(i) The Code of Practice (“the Code”) which follows fulfils the duty of the Lord Chancellor set
out in section 46 of the Freedom of Information Act 20001 (the Act). This foreword provides
background but does not form part of the Code itself.
(ii) The Code is in two parts. In Part 1, the Code provides guidance to all relevant authorities
as to the practice which it would, in the opinion of the Lord Chancellor, be desirable for them to
follow in connection with the keeping, management and destruction of their records. This applies
not only to public authorities but also to other bodies that are subject to the Public Records Act
1958 or the Public Records2 Act (Northern Ireland) 1923. Collectively they are called relevant
authorities.
(iii) The Code also describes, in Part 2, the procedure to be followed for timely and effective review
and transfer of public records to The National Archives3 or to a place of deposit (as defined in
section 4 of the Public Records Act 1958) or to the Public Record Office of Northern Ireland
under the Public Records Act 1958 or the Public Records Act (Northern Ireland) 1923.4
(iv) Freedom of information legislation is only as good as the quality of the records and other
information to which it provides access. Access rights are of limited value if information cannot
be found when requested or, when found, cannot be relied upon as authoritative. Good records
and information management benefits those requesting information because it provides some
assurance that the information provided will be complete and reliable. It benefits those holding
the requested information because it enables them to locate and retrieve it easily within the
statutory timescales or to explain why it is not held. It also supports control and delivery of
information promised in an authority’s Publication Scheme or required to be published by the
Environmental Information Regulations 2004 (the EIR).
(v) Records management is important for many other reasons. Records and information are the
lifeblood of any organisation. They are the basis on which decisions are made, services provided
and policies developed and communicated. Effective management of records and other
information brings the following additional benefits:
1
The Act can be seen at http://www.opsi.gov.uk/acts/acts2000/ukpga_20000036_en_1.
2
Public records are the records of bodies that are subject to the Public Records Act 1958 or the Public Records Act (Northern
Ireland) 1923. For the avoidance of doubt, the term ‘public records’ includes Welsh public records as defined by section 148 of
the Government of Wales Act 2006.
3
The legal entity to which this provision applies is the Public Record Office. Since April 2003 the Public Record Office has
functioned as part of The National Archives and is known by that name. For that reason the name ‘The National Archives’ is used
in this Code.
4
The Public Records legislation can be seen at http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/documents/public-records-act1958.rtf and
http://www.proni.gov.uk/public_records_act_1923.pdf respectively.
Lord Chancellor’s Code of Practice on the management of records - 5
(vi) Poor records and information management create risks for the authority, such as:
(vii) The Code is a supplement to the provisions in the Act and its adoption will help authorities
comply with their duties under the Act. Consequently, all relevant authorities are strongly
encouraged to pay heed to the guidance in the Code. The Code is complemented by the Code
of Practice under section 45 of the Act and the Code of Practice under Regulation 16 of the EIR.
(viii) Authorities should note that if they fail to comply with the Code, they may also fail to comply
with legislation relating to the creation, management, disposal, use and re-use of records and
information, for example the Public Records Act 1958, the Data Protection Act 1998, and the
Re-use of Public Sector Information Regulations 2005, and they may consequently be in breach
of their statutory obligations.
(ix) The Information Commissioner has a duty under section 47 of the Act to promote the
following of good practice by public authorities and in particular to promote observance
of the requirements of the Act and the provisions of this Code of Practice. In order to carry
out that duty specifically in relation to the Code, the Act confers a number of powers on the
Commissioner.
Practice recommendations
(x) If it appears to the Information Commissioner that the practice of an authority in relation to
the exercise of its functions under the Act does not conform to that set out in the Code, the
Commissioner may issue a practice recommendation under section 48 of the Act. A practice
recommendation will be in writing and will specify the provisions of the Code that have not been
met and the steps that should, in the Commissioner’s opinion, be taken to promote conformity
with the Code. A practice recommendation cannot be directly enforced by the Information
Commissioner. However, a failure to comply with a practice recommendation may lead to a
failure to comply with the Act or could lead to an adverse comment in a report to Parliament by
the Information Commissioner.
Information Notices
(xi) If the Information Commissioner reasonably requires any information in order to determine
whether the practice of an authority conforms with that recommended in the Code, he may
serve on the authority a notice (known as an ‘information notice’) under section 51 of the Act.
An information notice will be in writing and will require the authority to provide the Information
Commissioner with specified information relating to conformity with the Code. It will also
contain particulars of the rights of appeal conferred by section 57 of the Act.
(xiii) The Code should be read in the context of existing legislation affecting the management of
records. In particular, the Public Records Act 1958 (as amended) gives duties to bodies subject
to that Act in respect of the records they create or hold. It also requires the Chief Executive of
The National Archives5 to supervise the discharge of those duties.
(xiv) The Public Records Act (Northern Ireland) 1923 sets out the duties of public record bodies
in Northern Ireland in respect of the records they create and requires that records should be
transferred to, and preserved by, the Public Record Office of Northern Ireland.
5
The title ‘Keeper of Public Records’ is used in the Public Records Act 1958 and the Freedom of Information Act 2000. This is one
of the titles of the Chief Executive of The National Archives. The title ‘Chief Executive of The National Archives’ is used in this
Code in recognition of the fact that it is the title used for operational purposes.
Lord Chancellor’s Code of Practice on the management of records - 7
(xv) The Information Commissioner will promote the observance of the Code in consultation with
the Chief Executive of The National Archives when dealing with bodies which are subject to the
Public Records Act 1958 and with the Deputy Keeper of the Records of Northern Ireland for
bodies subject to the Public Records Act (Northern Ireland) 1923. Before issuing a practice
recommendation under section 48 of the Act to a body subject to either of the Public Records
Acts, the Information Commissioner will consult the Chief Executive of The National Archives
or the Deputy Keeper of the Records of Northern Ireland as appropriate.
(xvi) The Advisory Council on National Records and Archives6 (hereafter ‘the Advisory Council’) has a
statutory role to advise the Lord Chancellor on matters concerning public records in general and
on the application of the Act to information in public records that are historical records.7
The Lord Chancellor, having received the advice of his Advisory Council, may prepare and issue
guidance. The guidance may include advice on the review of public records and on the periods of
time for which the Advisory Council considers it appropriate to withhold categories of sensitive
records after they have become historical records.8
(xvii) The National Archives provides support as appropriate to the Advisory Council in its
consideration of applications from authorities relating to retention or access to public records
and in its preparation of guidance for the Lord Chancellor to issue to authorities.
(xviii) In Northern Ireland the Sensitivity Review Group, consisting of representatives of Northern
Ireland departments, provides advice on the release of public records. The Public Record Office of
Northern Ireland provides support to the Group. Guidance may be issued by the Deputy Keeper
of the Records of Northern Ireland following consultation with the Departments responsible for
the records affected by the guidance.
6
The legal entity to which this provision applies is the Advisory Council on Public Records. Since April 2003 the Council has
functioned as The Advisory Council on National Records and Archives and so that name is used in this Code.
7
In this context, the term ‘public records’ applies only to the records of bodies that are subject to the Public Records Act 1958.
8
The term ‘historical record’ is defined at section 62 of the Act.
CODE OF PRACTICE
(Freedom of Information Act 2000, section 46)
Guidance to relevant authorities on
(1) The management of their records and
(2) The review and transfer of public records
The Lord Chancellor, having consulted the Information Commissioner and the appropriate Northern
Ireland Minister, issues the following Code of Practice pursuant to section 46 of the Freedom of
Information Act 2000.
Laid before Parliament on 16 July 2009 pursuant to section 46(6) of the Freedom of Information Act 2000.
Introduction
1 Aims of the Code
To set out the practices which relevant authorities9 should follow in relation to the creation,
keeping, management and destruction of their records (Part 1 of the Code); and
To describe the arrangements which bodies responsible for public records10 should follow
in reviewing public records and transferring them to The National Archives or to a place of
deposit for public records, or to the Public Record Office of Northern Ireland (Part 2 of the Code).
1.2. Part 1 of the Code provides a framework for relevant authorities to manage their records. It sets
out recommended good practice for the organisational arrangements, decisions and processes
required for effective records and information management.
1.3 Part 2 provides a framework for the review and transfer of public records that have been selected
for permanent preservation at The National Archives11, a place of deposit for public records or
the Public Record Office of Northern Ireland. It sets out the process by which records due for
transfer are assessed to determine whether the information they contain can be designated as
open information or, if this is not possible, to identify the exemptions12 that apply and indicate
for how long they should apply.
9
Relevant authorities is the collective term used in the Act for bodies that are public authorities under the Freedom of
Information Act and bodies that are not subject to that Act but are subject to the Public Records Act 1958 or the Public Records
Act (Northern Ireland) 1923.
10
Public records are the records of bodies that are subject to the Public Records 1958 or the Public Records Act (Northern
Ireland) 1923. For the avoidance of doubt, the term ‘public records’ includes Welsh public records as defined by section 148 of
the Government of Wales Act 2006.
11
The legal entity to which this provision applies is the Public Record Office. Since April 2003 the Public Record Office has
functioned as part of The National Archives and is known by that name. For that reason the name ‘The National Archives’ is used
in this Code.
12
In the Environmental Information Regulations 2004 (the EIR), exemptions are called exceptions. For simplicity the term
exemption is used throughout the Code and should be taken to apply also to exceptions in the EIR.
Lord Chancellor’s Code of Practice on the management of records - 9
The Code applies to all records irrespective of the technology used to create and store them
or the type of information they contain. It includes, therefore, not only paper files series and
digital records management systems but also business and information systems (for example
case management, finance and geographical information systems) and the contents of websites.
The Code’s focus is on records and the systems that contain them but the principles and
recommended practice can be applied also to other information held by an authority.
3 Interpretation
For the purposes of this Code, ‘records’ are defined as in the relevant British Standard13, namely
‘information created, received, and maintained as evidence and information by an organization
or person, in pursuance of legal obligations or in the transaction of business’. Some specific terms
which are not defined in the Act have been included in the Glossary at Annex A. Other words and
expressions used in this Code have the same meaning as the same words and expressions used in
the Act.
4 Supplementary guidance
More detailed guidance on both parts of the Code has been published separately. Standards and
guidance which support the objectives of this Code most directly are listed at Annex B.
13
BS ISO 15489-1:2001 Information and documentation – Records management – Part 1: General.
10 - Lord Chancellor’s Code of Practice on the management of records
5.1 Good practice in records management is made up of a number of key elements. The following
list summarises the good practice recommended in Part 1 of the Code. Guidance on each
element is given in sections 6-14 of this Part.
Authorities should have in place organisational arrangements that support records management.
c) A governance framework that includes defined roles and lines of responsibility. This should
include allocation of lead responsibility for the records and information management
function to a designated member of staff at sufficiently senior level to act as a records
management champion, for example a board member, and allocation of operational
responsibility to a member of staff with the necessary knowledge and skills. In small
authorities it may be more practicable to combine these roles. Ideally the same people will
be responsible also for compliance with other information legislation, for example the Data
Protection Act 1998 and the Re-use of Public Sector Information Regulations 2005, or will
work closely with those people;
d) Clearly defined instructions, applying to staff at all levels of the authority, to create, keep
and manage records. In larger organisations the responsibilities of managers, and in particular
heads of business units, could be differentiated from the responsibilities of other staff by
making it clear that managers are responsible for ensuring that adequate records are kept of
the activities for which they are accountable;
e) Identification of information and business systems that hold records and provision of the
resources needed to maintain and protect the integrity of those systems and the information
they contain;
f) Consideration of records management issues when planning or implementing ICT systems,
when extending staff access to new technologies and during re-structuring or major changes
to the authority;
g) Induction and other training to ensure that all staff are aware of the authority’s records
management policies, standards, procedures and guidelines and understand their personal
responsibilities. This should be extended to temporary staff, contractors and consultants
who are undertaking work that it has been decided should be documented in the authority’s
records. If the organisation is large enough to employ staff whose work is primarily about
records and information management, they should be given opportunities for professional
development;
h) An agreed programme for managing records in accordance with this part of the Code;
i) Provision of the financial and other resources required to achieve agreed objectives in the
records management programme.
Authorities should have in place a records management policy, either as a separate policy or as part
of a wider information or knowledge management policy.
7.1 The policy should be endorsed by senior management, for example at board level, and should be
readily available to staff at all levels.
7.2 The policy provides a mandate for the records and information management function and a
framework for supporting standards, procedures and guidelines. The precise contents will depend
on the particular needs and culture of the authority but it should as a minimum:
a) Set out the authority’s commitment to create, keep and manage records which document its
principal activities;
12 - Lord Chancellor’s Code of Practice on the management of records
b) Outline the role of records management and its relationship to the authority’s overall
business strategy;
c) Identify and make appropriate connections to related policies, such as those dealing with
email, information security and data protection;
d) Define roles and responsibilities, including the responsibility of individuals to document their
work in the authority’s records to the extent that, and in the way that, the authority has
decided their work should be documented, and to use those records appropriately;
e) Indicate how compliance with the policy and the supporting standards, procedures and
guidelines will be monitored.
7.3 The policy should be kept up-to-date so that it reflects the current needs of the authority. One
way of ensuring this is to review it at agreed intervals, for example every three or five years,
and after major organisational or technological changes, in order to assess whether it needs
amendment.
7.4 The authority should consider publishing the policy so that members of the public can see the
basis on which it manages its records.
Authorities should ensure they keep the records they will need for business, regulatory, legal and
accountability purposes.
a) The legislative and regulatory environment within which they operate. This will be a mixture
of generally applicable legislation, such as health and safety legislation and the Data
Protection Act 1998, and specific legislation applying to the sector or authority. For example,
the Charity Commission is required by its legislation to keep an accurate and up-to-date
register of charities. This factor also includes standards applying to the sector or authority or
to particular functions such as finance;
b) The need to refer to authoritative information about past actions and decisions for current
business purposes. For example, problems such as outbreaks of foot and mouth disease may
recur and in order to deal with each new outbreak a local authority needs reliable information
about what it did during previous outbreaks and who was responsible for specific measures,
such as closing public footpaths;
c) The need to protect legal and other rights of the authority, its staff and its stakeholders. For
example, a local authority needs to know what land and buildings it owns in order to ensure
proper control of its assets and to protect itself if challenged;
d) The need to explain, and if necessary justify, past actions in the event of an audit, public
inquiry or other investigation. For example, the Audit Commission will expect to find accurate
records of expenditure of public funds. Or, if an applicant complains to the Information
Commissioner’s Office (ICO) about the handling or outcome of an FOI request, the ICO will
Lord Chancellor’s Code of Practice on the management of records - 13
expect the authority to provide details of how the request was handled and, if applicable, why
it refused to provide the information.
8.2 Having considered these factors, authorities should set business rules identifying:
a) What records should be kept, for example which decisions or actions should be recorded;
b) By whom this should be done, for example, by the sender or recipient of an email or
voicemail;
c) At what point in the process or transaction this should be done, for example when drafts of a
document should be frozen and kept as a record;
d) What those records should contain;
e) Where and how they should be stored, for example in a case file.
8.3 As part of this process authorities should consider whether any of these records should be
subject to particular controls so as to ensure their evidential value can demonstrated if required
by showing them to:
a) Be authentic, that is, they are what they say they are;
b) Be reliable, that is, they can be trusted as a full and accurate record;
c) Have integrity, that is, they have not been altered since they were created or filed;
d) Be usable, that is, they can be retrieved, read and used.
8.5 Authorities should ensure that staff creating or filing records are aware of the need to give those
records titles that reflect their specific nature and contents so as to facilitate retrieval.
8.6 Staff should also be aware of the need to dispose of ephemeral material on a routine basis. For
example, print-outs of electronic documents should not be kept after the meeting for which they
were printed, trivial emails should be deleted after being read, and keeping multiple or personal
copies of documents should be discouraged.
9 Records systems
Authorities should keep their records in systems that enable records to be stored and retrieved as
necessary.
if the authority is operating electronically, for example using email for internal and external
communications or creating documents through word processing software, it is good practice to
hold the resulting records electronically. In addition, authorities should note that the EIR require
them progressively to make environmental information available to the public by electronic
means (Regulation 4).
9.2 Authorities are likely to hold records and other information in a number of different systems.
These systems could include a dedicated electronic document and records management system,
business systems such as a case management, finance or geographical information system, a
website, shared workspaces, audio-visual material and sets of paper files with related registers.
In some cases related records of the same business activities may be held in different formats,
for example digital files and supporting paper material.
9.3 Records systems should be designed to meet the authority’s operational needs and using them
should be an integral part of business operations and processes. Records systems should have
the following characteristics:
a) They should be easy to understand and use so as to reduce the effort required of those who
create and use the records within them. Ease of use is an important consideration when
developing or selecting a system;
b) They should enable quick and easy retrieval of information. With digital systems this should
include the capacity to search for information requested under the Act;
c) They should be set up in a way that enables routine records management processes to
take place. For example, digital systems should be able to delete specified information in
accordance with agreed disposal dates and leave the rest intact;
d) They should enable the context of each record and its relationship to other records to be
understood. In a records management system this can be achieved by classifying and indexing
records within a file plan or business classification scheme to bring together related records
and enable the sequence of actions and context of each document to be understood. This
approach has the added benefit of enabling handling decisions, for example relating to access
or disposal, to be applied to groups of records instead of to individual records;
e) They should contain both information and metadata. Metadata enables the system to be
understood and operated efficiently, the records within the system to be managed and the
information within the records to be interpreted;
f) They should protect records in digital systems from accidental or unauthorised alteration,
copying, movement or deletion;
g) They should provide secure storage to the level of protection required by the nature, contents
and value of the information in them. For digital systems this includes a capacity to control
access to particular information if necessary, for example by limiting access to named
individuals or by requiring passwords. With paper files this includes a capacity to lock storage
cupboards or areas and to log access to them and any withdrawal of records from them;
h) They should enable an audit trail to be produced of occasions on which selected records have
been seen, used, amended and deleted.
9.4 Records systems should be documented to facilitate staff training, maintenance of the system
and its reconstruction in the event of an emergency.
Lord Chancellor’s Code of Practice on the management of records - 15
9.6 The trigger for closure will vary according to the nature and function of the records, the extent
to which they reflect ongoing business and the technology used to store them. For example,
completion of the annual accounting process could be a trigger for closing financial records,
completion of a project could be a trigger for closing project records, and completion of
formalities following the death of a patient could be a trigger for closing that person’s health
record. Size is a factor and a folder should not be too big to be handled or scrutinised easily.
For digital records a trigger could be migration to a new system. Authorities should decide the
appropriate trigger for each records system and put arrangements in place to apply the trigger.
9.7 New continuation or part files should be opened if necessary. It should be clear to anyone
looking at a record where the story continues, if applicable.
Authorities should know what records they hold and where they are, and should ensure that they
remain usable for as long as they are required.
10.2 Authorities should gather and maintain data on records and information assets.
This can be done in various ways, for example through surveys or audits of the records and
information held by the authority. It should be held in an accessible format and should
be kept up to date.
10.3 Authorities should consider publishing details of the types of records they hold to help
members of the public planning to make a request for information under the Act.
16 - Lord Chancellor’s Code of Practice on the management of records
Storing records
10.4 Storage should provide protection to the level required by the nature, contents and value of the
information in them. Records and information will vary in their strategic and operational value
to the authority, and in their residual value for historical research, and storage and preservation
arrangements reflecting their value should be put in place.
10.5 Authorities should be aware of any specific requirements for records storage that apply to them.
For example, the Adoption National Minimum Standards issued by the Department of Health
and the Welsh Assembly Government in 2003 require indexes and case files for children to be
securely stored to minimise the risk of damage from fire or water.
10.6 Storage should follow accepted standards in respect of the storage environment, fire
precautions, health and safety and, if applicable, physical organisation. It should allow easy
and efficient retrieval of information but also minimise the risk of damage, loss or unauthorised
access.
10.7 Records that are no longer required for frequent reference can be removed from current systems
to off-line or near off-line (for digital media) or to off-site (for paper) storage where this is a
more economical and efficient way to store them. They should continue to be subject to normal
records management controls and procedures.
10.8 The whereabouts of records should be known at all times and movement of files and other
physical records between storage areas and office areas should be logged.
10.10 Records in digital systems will not remain usable unless precautions are taken. Authorities
should put in place a strategy for their continued maintenance designed to ensure that
information remains intact, reliable and usable for as long as it is required. The strategy should
provide for updating of the storage media and migration of the software format within which the
information and metadata are held, and for regular monitoring of integrity and usability.
10.11 Records in digital systems are particularly vulnerable to accidental or unauthorised alteration,
copying, movement or deletion which can happen without trace. This puts at risk the reliability
of the records which could damage the authority’s interests. Authorities should assess these risks
and put appropriate safeguards in place.
10.12 Back-up copies of records in digital systems should be kept and stored securely in a separate
location. They should be checked regularly to ensure that the storage medium has not degraded
and the information remains intact and capable of being restored to operational use. Back-ups
should be managed in a way that enables disposal decisions to be applied securely without
compromising the authority’s capacity to recover from system failures and major disasters.
Lord Chancellor’s Code of Practice on the management of records - 17
10.13 Physical records such as paper files may also require regular monitoring. For example, formats
such as early photocopies may be at risk of fading, and regular checks should be made of any
information in such formats that is of continuing value to the authority.
10.14 Metadata for records in any format should be kept in such a way that it remains reliable and
accessible for as long as it is required, which will be at least for the life of the records.
The plans should include actions to protect and recover these records in particular.
Authorities should ensure that records are stored securely and that access to them is controlled.
11.1 Authorities should ensure that their storage arrangements, handling procedures and
arrangements for transmission of records reflect accepted standards and good practice in
information security. It is good practice to have an information security policy addressing these
points.
11.2 Ease of internal access will depend on the nature and sensitivity of the records. Access
restrictions should be applied when necessary to protect the information concerned and should
be kept up to date. Particular care should be taken with personal information about living
individuals in order to comply with the 7th data protection principle, which requires precautions
against unauthorised or unlawful processing, damage, loss or destruction. Within central
Government, particular care should be taken with information bearing a protective marking.
Other information, such as information obtained on a confidential basis, may also require
particular protection.
11.3 Transmission of records, especially outside the authority’s premises, should require
authorisation. The method of transmission should be subject to risk assessment before a
decision is made.
11.5 An audit trail should be kept of provision of access, especially to people outside the immediate
work area.
18 - Lord Chancellor’s Code of Practice on the management of records
12 Disposal of records
Authorities should define how long they need to keep particular records, should dispose of them
when they are no longer needed and should be able to explain why records are no longer held.
12.1 For the purpose of this Code, disposal means the decision as to whether the record should be
destroyed, transferred to an archives service for permanent preservation or presented,14 and the
putting into effect of that decision.
General principle
12.2 As a general principle, records should be kept for as long as they are needed by the authority: for
reference or accountability purposes, to comply with regulatory requirements or to protect legal
and other rights and interests. Destruction at the end of this period ensures that office and server
space are not used and costs are not incurred in maintaining records that are no longer required.
For records containing personal information it also ensures compliance with the 5th data
protection principle which requires that personal data is kept only for as long as it is needed.
12.3 Records should not be kept after they have ceased to be of use to the authority unless:
a) They are known to be the subject of litigation or a request for information. If so, destruction
should be delayed until the litigation is complete or, in the case of a request for information,
all relevant complaint and appeal provisions have been exhausted;
b) They have long-term value for historical or other research and have been or should be
selected for permanent preservation. (Note that records containing personal information can
be kept indefinitely for historical research purposes because they thereby become exempt
from the 5th data protection principle.)
c) They contain or relate to information recently released in response to a request under the
Act. This may indicate historical value and destruction should be delayed while this is
re-assessed.
a) Reflect the authority’s continuing need for access to the information or the potential value of
the records for historical or other research;
b) Are based on consultation between records management staff, staff of the relevant business
unit and, where appropriate, others such as legal advisers, archivists or external experts;
c) Have been formally adopted by the authority;
d) Are applied by properly authorised staff;
e) Take account of security and confidentiality needs.
14
Presentation is allowed by section 3(6) of the Public Records Act 1958. It transfers ownership of the records to the receiving
body and is undertaken by The National Archives in consultation with the authority.
Lord Chancellor’s Code of Practice on the management of records - 19
a) An overall policy, stating in broad terms the types of records likely to be selected for
permanent preservation. The policy could be a separate policy, part of the records
management policy or a preamble to a disposal schedule;
b) Disposal schedules15 which identify and describe records to which a pre-defined disposal
action can be applied, for example destroy x years after [trigger event]; review after y years,
transfer to archives for permanent preservation after z years.
12.6 Disposal schedules should contain sufficient details about the records to enable the records to
be easily identified and the disposal action applied to them on a routine and timely basis. The
amount of detail in disposal schedules will depend on the authority’s needs but they should at
least:
Disposal schedules should be arranged in the way that best meets the authority’s needs.
12.7 Disposal schedules should be kept up to date and should be amended if a relevant statutory
provision changes. However, authorities should consider keeping information about previous
provisions so that the basis on which records were previously destroyed can be explained.
12.8 If any records are not included in disposal schedules, special arrangements should be made to
review them and decide whether they can be destroyed or should be selected for permanent
preservation. Decisions of this nature should be documented and kept to provide evidence of
which records have been identified for destruction, when the decision was made, and the reasons
for the decision, where this is not apparent from the overall policy.
12.10 Records scheduled for destruction should be destroyed in as secure a manner as required by the
level of confidentiality or security markings they bear. For example, records containing personal
information about living individuals should be destroyed in a way that prevents unauthorised
access (this is required to comply with the 7th data protection principle). With digital records it
may be necessary to do more than overwrite the data to ensure the information is destroyed.
15
Some authorities use the term ‘retention schedules’. Because ‘retention’ has a specific meaning in Part 2 of the Code, the term
disposal schedules is used throughout the Code.
20 - Lord Chancellor’s Code of Practice on the management of records
12.11 When destruction is carried out by an external contractor, the contract should stipulate that the
security and access arrangements established for the records will continue to be applied until
destruction has taken place.
12.12 In some cases there will be more than one copy of a record. For example, there are likely to be
back-up copies of digital records, or there may be digital copies of paper records. A record cannot
be considered to have been completely destroyed until all copies, including back-up copies, have
been destroyed, if there is a possibility that the data could be recovered.
12.14 At the very least it should be possible to provide evidence that as part of routine records
management processes destruction of a specified type of record of a specified age range took
place in accordance with a specified provision of the disposal schedule. Evidence of this nature
will enable an authority and its staff to explain why records specified in a court order cannot be
provided or to defend themselves against a charge under section 77 of the Act that records were
destroyed in order to prevent their disclosure in response to a request for information.
12.16 Part 2 of the Code sets out the arrangements that apply to the review and transfer of public
records. The approach set out in Part 2 may be relevant to the review and transfer of other types
of records also.
Authorities should ensure that records shared with other bodies or held on their behalf by other
bodies are managed in accordance with the Code.
13.1 When authorities are working in partnership with other organisations, sharing information and
contributing to a joint records system, they should ensure that all parties agree protocols that specify:
13.2 Instructions and training should be provided to staff involved in such collaborative working.
13.3 Records management controls should be applied to information being shared with or passed
to other bodies. Particular protection should be given to confidential or personal information.
Protocols should specify when, and under what conditions, information will be shared or passed,
and details should be kept of when this information has been shared or passed. Details should
be kept also of how undertakings given to the original source of the information have been
respected.
13.4 Some of an authority’s records may be held on its behalf by another body, for example a body
carrying out work for the authority under contract. The authority on whose behalf the records
are held is responsible for ensuring that the provisions of the Code are applied to those records.
Authorities should monitor compliance with the Code and assess the overall effectiveness of the
programme.
14.1 Authorities should identify performance measures that reflect their information management
needs and arrangements and the risks that non-compliance with the Code would present to the
authority, including the impact on risks identified in the overall risk management framework.
14.2 The performance measures could be general in nature, for example that a policy has been issued,
or could refer to processes, such as the application of disposal schedules to relevant records with
due authorisation of destruction, or could use metrics such as retrieval times for paper records
held off-site that have been requested under the Act.
14.3 Authorities should put in place the means by which performance can be measured. For example,
if metrics are to be used, the data from which statistics will be generated must be kept.
Qualitative indicators, for example whether guidance is being followed, can be measured by spot
checks or by interviews.
14.4 Monitoring should be undertaken on a regular basis and the results reported to the person with
lead responsibility for records management so that risks can be assessed and appropriate action
taken.
14.5 Assessing whether the records management programme meets the needs of the organisation
is a more complex task and requires consideration of what the programme is intended to achieve
and how successful it is being. This requires consideration of business benefits in relation to
corporate objectives as well as risks and should include consultation throughout the authority.
22 - Lord Chancellor’s Code of Practice on the management of records
15 Purpose of Part 2
15.1 This part of the Code applies only to authorities which are subject to the Public Records Act
1958 or the Public Records Act (Northern Ireland) 1923. Under those Acts, authorities are
required to identify records worthy of permanent preservation and transfer them to The National
Archives16, a place of deposit for public records or the Public Record Office of Northern Ireland
as appropriate. This part of the Code sets out the arrangements which those authorities should
follow to ensure the timely and effective review and transfer of public records. Arrangements
should be established and operated under the supervision of The National Archives or, in
Northern Ireland, in conjunction with the Public Record Office of Northern Ireland.
15.2 The general purpose of this part of the Code is to facilitate the performance by the authorities,
The National Archives, the Public Record Office of Northern Ireland and places of deposit of
their functions under the Act. In reviewing records for public access, authorities should ensure
that public records become available at the earliest possible time in accordance with the Act
and the EIR.
16.1 Section 12 of the Code describes the arrangements that authorities should follow for the
disposal of records. In this context, disposal means the decision as to whether the record should
be destroyed, transferred to an archives service for permanent preservation or presented17 and
the putting into effect of that decision.
16.2 Authorities that have created or are otherwise responsible for public records should ensure
that they operate effective arrangements to determine which records should be selected for
permanent preservation in accordance with the guidance in section 12.
16
See Footnote 11 for an explanation of why this name has been used in the Code
17
See footnote 14.
18
The date by which records must be transferred is calculated from the year after the last date on the file. It was the subject of an
independent review in 2008 and the Code will be amended to reflect any changes introduced as a consequence.
Lord Chancellor’s Code of Practice on the management of records - 23
17.2 Public records may be transferred either to The National Archives or to a place of deposit for
public records appointed by the Lord Chancellor19 under section 4 of that Act. For guidance on
which records may be transferred to which archives service, and on the transfer of UK public
records relating to Northern Ireland, see Annex B. For the avoidance of doubt, Part 2 of the Code
applies to all such transfers.
17.3 Authorities should submit applications to retain records for a further period to The National
Archives for review and advice. The Lord Chancellor’s Advisory Council will then consider the
case in favour of retention for a further period. The Advisory Council will consider the case for
retaining individual records, or coherent batches of records, on the basis of the guidance in
chapter 9 of the White Paper Open Government (Cm 2290, 1993) or subsequent revisions of
Government policy. Some categories of records are covered by a standard authorisation by the
Lord Chancellor (known as ‘blanket retentions’) which are reviewed every 10 years.
18.2 Those undertaking the review should ensure that adequate consultation takes place, both within
the authority and with other authorities that might be affected by the decision, for example
authorities that originally supplied the information. This is particularly advisable for records
being transferred earlier than required.
19
The Lord Chancellor has delegated the power to appoint places of deposit to the Chief Executive of The National Archives or
another officer of appropriate seniority.
20
At present some exemptions in the Act fall away after 30 years. Their duration was the subject of an independent review in
2008 and the Code will be amended to reflect any changes introduced as a consequence.
2 - Lord Chancellor’s Code of Practice on the management of records
18.5 Authorities should consider whether parts of records might be released if the sensitive
information were redacted, i.e. rendered invisible or blanked out. Information that has been
redacted should be stored securely and should be returned to the parent record when the
exemption has ceased to apply.
a) By accepting that the information may be withheld for longer than 30 years and earmarking
the records for release or re-review at the date identified by the authority;
b) By accepting that the information may be withheld for longer than 30 years but asking the
authority to reconsider the later date designated for release or re-review;
c) By questioning the basis on which it is considered that the information may be withheld for
longer than 30 years and asking the authority to reconsider the case;
18.7 If the Advisory Council accepts that the information should be withheld, the records will be
transferred as closed (in whole or in part as appropriate) and the relevant closure period applied.
18.9 If the outcome of the review is that the records should be closed after transfer, the schedule will
be considered by the Sensitivity Review Group. The Sensitivity Review Group may respond as
follows:
Lord Chancellor’s Code of Practice on the management of records - 25
a) By accepting that the information should be withheld for longer than 30 years and
earmarking the records for release or re-review at the date identified on the schedule;
b) By questioning the basis on which it is considered that the information may be withheld for
longer than 30 years and asking the responsible authority to reconsider the case.
18.10 If the Sensitivity Review Group accepts that the information should be withheld, the records will be
transferred as closed (in whole or in part as appropriate) and the relevant closure period applied.
19.1 It is the responsibility of authorities transferring records to ensure that those records
are adequately prepared and are transferred with the level of security appropriate to the
confidentiality of the information they contain.
20.3 In other cases, if the authority concerned wishes to extend the period during which the
information is to be withheld, it should submit a further schedule explaining the sensitivity of
the information. This is to be done before the expiry of the period stated in the earlier schedule.
The process outlined at paragraphs 18.6-18.10 will then be applied. In Northern Ireland,
Ministerial agreement is required for any further extension of the closure period and referral to
the Minister will be an additional stage in the process.
26 - Lord Chancellor’s Code of Practice on the management of records
Annex A Glossary
Disposal – the decision as to whether the record should be destroyed, transferred to an archives service
for permanent preservation or presented and the putting into effect of that decision.
Disposal schedules – schedules that identify types of records and specify for how long they will be kept
before they are destroyed, designated for permanent preservation or subjected to a further review.
Keeping records – in the context of this Code, keeping records includes recording the authority’s
activities by creating documents and other types of records as well as handling material received.
Metadata – information about the context within which records were created, their structure and how
they have been managed over time. Metadata can refer to records within digital systems, for example
event log data. It can also refer to systems such as paper files that are controlled either from a digital
system or by a register or card index, for example the title and location.
Place of deposit – an archives office appointed to receive, preserve and provide access to public records
that have been selected for preservation but are not to be transferred to The National Archives. The
power of appointment has been delegated by the Lord Chancellor to the Chief Executive of The National
Archives or an officer of appropriate seniority.
Presentation – an arrangement under the Public Records Act 1958 whereby records that have not been
selected for permanent preservation are presented to an appropriate body by The National Archives.
Public records – records that are subject to the Public Records Act 1958 or the Public Records Act
(Northern Ireland) 1923. The records of government departments and their executive agencies, some
non-departmental public bodies, the courts, the NHS and the armed forces are public records. Local
government records are not public records in England and Wales but those in Northern Ireland are.
Records – information created, received, and maintained as evidence and information by an organization
or person, in pursuance of legal obligations or in the transaction of business. 21
Retention – an arrangement under the Public Records Act 1958 whereby authorities are permitted to
delay the transfer of specified public records for an agreed period and to retain them until the end of that
period.
Records system – the term used for an information or process system that contains records and other
information. It can be either a paper-based system or a digital system. Examples are correspondence file
series, digital records management systems, case management systems, function-specific systems such
as finance systems, etc.
21
This definition is taken from BS ISO 15489-1:2001 Information and documentation – Records management – Part 1: General.
Lord Chancellor’s Code of Practice on the management of records - 27
BS 4783, Storage, transportation and maintenance of media for use in data processing and
information storage
2. Standards and guidance produced by The National Archives for the management of
public sector records
The Chief Executive of The National Archives, as head of profession for the knowledge and information
function across Government, sets standards for the management of records in all formats, covering
their entire life cycle. The standards are supported by guidance and toolkits. Advice for government
departments can also be applied by other parts of the public sector. They are available on The National
Archives website - see
http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/services/default.htm?source=services
In addition, a standard on metadata for records management is available through Govtalk – see
http://www.govtalk.gov.uk/documents/Records_management_metadata_standard_2002.pdf
28 - Lord Chancellor’s Code of Practice on the management of records
3. Sector-specific guidance
Central government
In addition to standards and guidance issued by The National Archives referred to above, protected
records22 are subject to data handling guidance issued by the Cabinet Office - see
http://www.cabinetoffice.gov.uk/mediacabinetoffice/csia/assets/dhr/cross_gov080625.pdf
Local government
The Records Management Society has issued guidelines on disposal and information audits for local
government – see
http://www.rms-gb.org.uk/resources.
The Local Government Association and Welsh Local Government Association have issued data handling
guidance for protected records – see
http://www.idea.gov.uk/idk/aio/9048091
http://www.jiscinfonet.ac.uk/information-management
Schools
The Records Management Society has issued a records management toolkit for schools – see
http://www.rms-gb.org.uk/resources/848
The police
The Home Secretary has issued a code of practice on the management of police information – see
http://police.homeoffice.gov.uk/news-and-publications/publication/operational-policing/
CodeofPracticeFinal12073.pdf?view=Standard&pubID=224859
It is supported by guidance produced by the National Centre of Policing Excellence on behalf of the
Association of Chief Police Officers – see
http://www.npia.police.uk/en/8492.htm
http://www.crimereduction.homeoffice.gov.uk/policing21.htm
22
The scope of the term ‘protected records’ is explained within the document.
Lord Chancellor’s Code of Practice on the management of records - 29
http://www.dh.gov.uk/enPublicationsandstatistics/Publications/PublicationsPolicyAndGuidance/DH_
4131747
The National Archives has published guidance on determining whether records should be transferred
to The National Archives or a place of deposit for public records – see the Acquisition and Disposition
Strategy and supporting guidance at
http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/documents/acquisition_strategy.pdf and
http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/recordsmanagement/disposition/faq.htm
For guidance on the preparation of records for transfer to the National Archives, including cataloguing,
see
http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/recordsmanagement/advice/standards.htm and
http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/recordsmanagement/advice/cataloguing.htm
http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/documents/foi_guide.pdf
The Public Record Office of Northern Ireland has published guidance on transferring records – see
http://www.proni.gov.uk/index/professional_information/records_and_information_management.htm
Guidance on FOI exemptions has been issued by the Information Commissioner’s Office, the regulator of
both the Act and the EIR – see
http://www.ico.gov.uk/tools_and_resources/document_library/freedom_of_information.aspx
Guidance has also been issued by the Ministry of Justice – see
http://www.justice.gov.uk/guidance/foi-exemptions-guidance.htm
30 - Lord Chancellor’s Code of Practice on the management of records
Guidance on EIR exceptions has been issued by the Department of the Environment, Food and Rural
Affairs – see
http://www.defra.gov.uk/corporate/opengov/eir/guidance/full-guidance/pdf/guidance-7.pdf
http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/documents/access_manual.pdf and
Redaction: guidelines for the editing of exempt information from paper and electronic documents prior
to release - see
http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/documents/redaction_toolkit.pdf
© Crown copyright 2009
The text in this document (excluding the Royal Arms and other departmental or agency logos) may be reproduced
free of charge in any format or medium providing it is reproduced accurately and not used in a misleading context.
The material must be acknowledged as Crown copyright and the title of the document specified.
Where we have identified any third party copyright material you will need to obtain permission from the copyright
holders concerned.
For any other use of this material please write to Office of Public Sector Information , Information Policy Team,
Kew, Richmond, Surrey TW9 4DU or email: licensing@opsi.gov.uk