When To Look at The Jury or Judge: 884 The Behavior Ops Manual
When To Look at The Jury or Judge: 884 The Behavior Ops Manual
Many attorneys advise clients not to make much ey,e contact with the jury box
or the judge. It's a good rule of thumb, but there are exceptions. These people
are supposed to be unfeeling, detached, and removed from the emotional
situation in the courtroom, but they aren't. We want them emotionally invested
in the action. The closer we can pull them into the story, the more likely they
will silently form a confirmation bias in their mind.
Most of your work in the courtroom will be centered around confirmation bias
creation. The more the jury or judge identifies personally with your client, the
higher your chances are of winning the case.
ATTENTION
One of my most quoted lines when I teach behavior profiling is, 'Pay close
attention to attention.'
The court will be checking your client frequently. Whether their name is
brought up, a deposition is occurring, or someone is addressing the judge;
they will look.
Never look at opposing counsel when they are speaking, unless they
are speaking to you.
You want your client to direct focus away from oc <lt any time they are
making any statement to the court. The same goes for you. Looking at them
as they speak conveys importance and relevance that you want to diminish to
the furthest extent. When you take notes as OC speaks, never take notes
immediately after a damning piece of evidence surfaces. This also gives
credibility to the statement. A simple headshake is fine to dismiss it.
On the stand, your client should be briefed about a1itention with a similar brief
to this:
"When you're on the stand, give your attention to the jury every time OC
does it. If he addressed the jury, you should too. If he addresses the jucfge,
you can look in that direction as well. When he's asking you questions, .iust
look at the clock on the back wall of the courtroom until he's finished
asking. If you're regretful, look down, when something shocked, hurt,
surprised, or caused any other large emotional response, briefly look
across the members of the jury."
"When OC is speaking, relax. When I'm speaking, sit up, lean forward, and
hang on my every word If I speak to the judge, look at the judge for a
response. If I speak to the jury, you can look at the jury. If I speak about
or to OC, pretend they aren't in the room. And NEVER check your watch."
Attention matters. Help your client to use it in a calculated way, instead of 'by
accident.'
SPEECH
How your client speaks is as important as how they appear to the court.
As with movement of their body, the speech they use, needs to be measured
and unhurried. Of course, in preparation for deposition or cross-examination,
we want to ensure they know to wait for a beat to allow you time to object to
the question.
Our words are highly influential. When you prepare your client, the narrative
must be at the center of your focus. What your client says will regulate how
well the court identifies with them. Let's examine how we relate to others to
begin with. In the court, there are twelve ways the jury can identify with your
client:
Anything that is brand new for us, from meeting someone new, to having
something happen that we didn't expect to happen, generates focus. A
hundred thousand years ago, novelty meant potenfial death. If you heard c1
stick break in the woods, 100% of your focus would be on the sound, and what
made it. New situations cause our brain to focus because it has saved our
ancestor's lives. In fact, you can look at most psychology through this lens; if
humans share quirks, there's something about that quirk that saved our
ancestors lives a long time ago.
When the jury first sees your client, this is when the situation in court is MOST
novel to them. At this novelty peak, this is the most critical time to insert as
much information as you can to build rapport betwEien you, your client, and
the jury.
With the above list of the 12 factors of rapport, how could you insert these
qualities and imbue them to your client, and to the jury in the courtroom?
EXAMPLE:
There are a lot of things we identify with when people say them. Consider the
following list of topics that can be brought up when talking about your client,
or during deposition when your client is speaking about themselves:
All of these are experiences that we've all had. In your trial prep, what could
you say as soon as practicable in court, so that the court will instantly have
some shared connection with your client?
NOTE:
Remember your client is on the Hero's Journey. You can use the power of a
good story to illustrate this, as well as providing details that the jury can
identify with, to enhance their level of rapport with your client.
The jury also needs to like you, but that's another chapter that has already
been covered in this book.
When your client is on the stand or speaking, this is the excellent opportunity
to have them illustrate the bullet points you've prepared for them to humanize
them. These can be nested within answers to OC questions, or in response to
your own questions.
If you can weave the bullet points into your client's responses to OC, the entire
narrative OC has prepared could wind up making the court favor your client
even more.
Assess your client. If they are in a job that requires non-stop judgment calls
and people skills, there's a good chance they are fit to punch back in
deposition. If the client is in a more isolated job most of the time, or their
general wit or people skills aren't up to task, it might be better to advise them
to simply answer with simple answers in addition to the bullet points you
created for them.
In many cases, the act of testimony is defensive in nature. However, this can
be turned around quickly.
At the beginning of your client's deposition, they are completely within their
right to ask Opposing Counsel (OC) if they can address them by their name.
It's very hard to maintain an aggressive mindset when the witness is calling
you the same name your kids, friends, and family do.
This also makes your client look more like a friend to the jury.
Also, have your client ask opposing counsel if they c:ould simply address your
client by their first name. This is not only acceptablei, but it also humanizes
your client both to the court, and OC.
Ask to see any and all documents that you need to help you clarify or
recall facts.
Never offer to provide anything more than what they already have
(papers, recordings, etc.) Confer with counsel first.
Ask to rephrase any question that sounds like it's shaping narratives -
you can do this unlimited times.
If someone summarizes what you said, never agree, repeat what you
said again instead.
Don't keep answering the same question again. I'll object to that for
you.
In the client briefing, it's vital to cover the difference between a question and
the hidden meaning (implication) of the question. Go through a few examples
with your client to ensure they know how to answer correctly to address both
the question and the implication:
Example:
Implication: You were careless and are probably careless in other areas of
your life.
Question: " ...and that's not what you stated in your deposition, is it?"
Implication: Either way, you're a liar. It was either then or now, but we can't
trust you.
Answer (addressing both): No, it's not. The answer that I provided then
was based on the available information at that time. If new
information surfaces or becomes available, my answer will
change based on those facts.
Question: "So, you went into the office, checked emails, had a snack, and
went home. Correct?"
Answer: "I arrived at the office, used my keyc:ard to enter, and attended
a meeting with the staff. Afterwards, I responded to a few
dozen customer emails, had a working lunch with three other
managers, and left the office to work from home."
NARRATIVE
You and OC will each have a narrative. How you shc1pe it can change the entire
case.
Many firms I've worked with have made the mistake of calling the OC
narrative a 'case' or 'testimony' in the courtroom. These words add credibility
to their case. The singular words you and your client use to describe or call out
OC's tactics are very important.
Throughout the trial, inform your client you will be using words like this to
describe what opposing counsel believes. Never usei official words to describe
something that OC wants the court to believe. You could use:
Narrative
Story
Belief
Claim
Version of facts
Version
Spiel
Saga
Tale
This is a tool that I developed primarily for coaching calls. Clients could call in
with a specific need for a solution to a problem they were facing. Inevitably,
they would ask about the phrasing, linguistic techniques, and tactics they
needed to employ - skipping over what you now know to be the most
foundational and critical element of Tradecraft. They wanted the magic script.
Instead of explaining that giving them a flight checklist for a plane doesn't
make them a pilot, I'd work with them to develop their ideal method to get the
results they needed. At the conclusion of the call, I'd remind them of the
importance of authority, confidence, composure, and social skill when
employing their shiny new tactic that we developed together.
The steps are easy to understand, but require a significant skill level to fully
utilize in crafting and minting new methods and techniques of influence. From
developing a technique for a parent to counsel and guide their children, to
jury-selection, sales, and copywriting, this system harnesses the power of
Tradecraft, and is an almost universal tool to develop brand new pieces of
'behavioral art'.
Setting Priorities
Developing methods
Overcoming Limiting Beliefs (objections)
Develop the methods to level up the top four Six-Axes
within the second phase of the PCP Model
Socialize
Minimize
Project
Rationalize
Emphasize Action
Develop the monologue and actions tc:> form the final
phase of the PCP Model
Within this formula, you can see that the behavioral profile of the subject
takes center stage at the outset. Then The PCP Model is used to formulate the
overall structure of the interaction - think of The PCP model as an outline of
the interaction.
The FATE model then steps in to formulate the Perception phase of The PCP
Model - developing and discovering the methods th,::it will influence someone
on a mammalian level.
The Six-Axis Model then comes into the picture. You will develop priorities in
this phase - reorganizing the six axes in such a way that they are arranged in
order of priority. The focus is then placed on developing methods to
specifically target the top four of the six axes on your priority list, knowing
that the final to axes will still be leveled up as a byproduct of the work donE! to
elevate the other four. In this phase, you'll also be developing a hypothesis of
the most likely limiting beliefs and barriers to influence that you will need to
covertly address through tradecraft to ensure that when the subject arrives at
the final stages, they are ready to take action.
Here is the full outline of the method, so that if you were either planning a
scenario or developing a system for someone on a coaching call, you'd be cible
to maximize the power of Tradecraft, and the likelihood of success.
DESIRED OUTCOME:
Describe the positive traits and beliefs that lead to making the
decision to take action with the operator
Develop a crystal clear list of the beliefs (some of which you may
need to install or activate within the subject) that lead to the
average person making a decision to take action toward your
listed desired outcome
Develop a list of how these fears and desires may play a part in the
Tradecraft
In this step of the process, you will use The FATE Model to develop a detailed
plan for how to influence the subject on a mammalian level.
The Six-Axis Model is the definitive guide to what factors influence human
beings. In Section One, The Model is covered in detail, and specific instructions
are given to allow you to set priorities on which of the six axes should be
considered more or less important based on the scenario, and your desired
outcomes. Reference this section to understand more about the planning
Once the priorities are set, determine which methods you will use
based on The Basic Skills Map. This map will allow you to locate a
tactic.
Once the tactic is located on The Basic Skills Map, develop the
linguistics and behavioral movement necessary to achieve the gocJls
you set forth on The Six-Axis Model.
How will these act together to shift the context closer to the ideal/
desired context-shift so that the subject is more willing to take
action?
How will the leveraging of my top four priorities on the 6AM allow me
to overcome most or all of the pre-determined unconscious
objections and limiting beliefs of the subject?
EXAMPLES
1. "I think so many people do this because ... "
2. "Everyone knows that..."
3. "Even little kids understand that people just..."
4. "I have no idea why it's one of those things people just do
and don't talk about much."
5. "There's a good reason that most people ... "
EXAMPLES
1. "And I've seen a lot of __________ and this is so tiny."
2. "There's so many people that lack the perspective to see..."
3. "When you look back on little things like this ..."
4. "There's two ways to look back 011 a decision like this ... "
5. "Every once in a while, you'll see one of those people who
lack perspective, and see everything as some huge turning
point."
6. "There's that moment when you look back at all the thin9s
that seemed important at the time and laugh at yourself..."
7. "The best nights of our lives are usually made up of small
things, and it's so often we view things as bigger than they
are."
8. " ...and it happens a 1·housand times a day, we just don't hear
about it."
9. "Being able take small actions like this ..."
10. "And there's always a few people (ep) who think it's actu,ally
a big deal to ..."
Project (it's not your fault at all, and it cari now be your success)
What are the ways that the subject ccm be made to feel less
responsible for taking this action?
What are the ways the subject can be made to feel less
responsible for not having taken this <Jction in the past?
EXAMPLES
1. " ... and with the media feeding fear down people's throat all
the time, it's no surprise people wait until these moments to
finally take action."
2. "It's one of those moments where everything lines up to
make this perfect window and pe1ople feel silly for not
realizing it sooner."
3. "People don't have a lot of educc1tion on this cause it's not
very common. It makes sense some of the people I talk to
never even have the ability to se,:! ..."
4. "At the end of the day, most people don't realize it's not
their fault at all."
5. "There's no shame in being humcrn. There's a million reasons
that a lot of people don't take action until they reach this
point."
What are the ways the operator can provide logical reasoning
and justifications to support taking action?
How can the operator aligns the action with the subject's values,
goals, or the prevailing circumstances. Use data, evidence, or
relevant examples to reinforce the rationality behind the actions.
EXAMPLES:
1. "With what you know now, there's every reason to ..."
2. "One thing I explain to people is that they didn't have this
information before - they just never had everything line up
like this, and that's why they didn't know."
3. "I agree. When things don't make sense, people don't take
action on it. It's the moment when everything lines up and
all the information finally gets put in a row. There's a lot of
confusion out there until someone who's spent a lifetime
sorting it all out finally gets to the point where it can all
make perfect sense."
EXAMPLES
1. "Just wanted to give you a heads-up, but spots are filling up
quickly. If you want in, it's best to decide soon."
2. "Time is running out, and I wouldn't want you to miss out on
this incredible opportunity. Let me know if you're ready to
dive in."
3. "This is something that doesn't come around often, and it
has the potential to be truly transformative. Take the leap
and seize it."
4. "The clock is ticking, my friend. If you feel a pull towards it,
don't wait too long. The window of opportunity won't stay
open forever."
5. "I wanted to make sure you didn't miss out on this, as it's
generating quite a buzz. If you're interested, it's best to act
now."
6. "The demand for this is high, and I wanted you to be among
the first to know. Take a moment to reflect, and if it
resonates, don't hesitate."
7. "It's not often that such an exclusive opportunity arises, and
I thought of you. Consider taking action before it becomes
widely known."
Develop the monologue and actions to form the final phase of the
PCP Model
1. "Just imagine how you'll feel if you miss out on this incredible
opportunity."
2. "You'll never know what could have beien unless you take the
leap."
RESOURCES FOR
TRADECRAFT CREATION
Here's a resource for communicating and positioning to individual Decision
Maps. The list isn't necessarily intended to be a linguistics reference, but more
to assist in determining which beliefs to draw out, and which limiting beliefs
might need to be suppressed.
1. "This isn't for everyone, only the rule-breakers and the game-
changers."
© 2016
Chase Hughes
Duplication Prohibited
1 2
3
S-11: RESOURCES AND GRAPHICS I 903
BEHAVIOR
SIX - MINUTE X - RAY
DSR
LP
© 2016
Chase Hughes
Duplication Prohibited
EXP FRE
CON
INV
NEC
EYE---------
I
E
SKILLS C
VI
<
0
MAP \0
Cl)
........
()
0
::J
-+
0
~
+-
c
(l)
E Q)
·- C
o..0
.2 oE-
Cl) Q)
(l)
C: u ~ ..J
E "'O
Cl)
C
<( (l)
(l) .Q
V)
2
><
....C :::::,
l: 0
-0 u
--;
I PRE-FRONTAL CORTEX
m
OJ
m
~~ Planning, Maturity, Executive Function
I
p
<
H
C>-<
Cl 2016 . Cha$4' HU<;jhes
0
;o Duplication Prohibited CEREBRAL CORTEX
0
-cl Thinking, Motor-Planning, Verbal,
U1
Visual, Attention, Impulse-Control
3:
p
z
C
p
' LIMBIC SYSTEM
-----a
Emotions, Memory-Formation,
Social Bonding
CEREBELLUM
Rhythm, Balance,
Attention, Coordination,
Emotional Regulation
BRAIN STEM
Heartbeat, Breathing,
Consciousness, Sleep
Cerebral...........___
Cortex, -.....
Corpus
Calossum
Lateral Ventricle
Parietal Lobe
Frontal Lobe
Third
Ventricle
Limbic Lobe
Occipital
Lobe
Hypothalamus
Thalamus
Temporal
Cerebellum Lobe
Fourth Pituitary
Ventricle
Brain Stem
Axion
Node of R1Jnvier
Myelin she<Jth
Cell
.
Ependymal cells membrane
Synaptic End
Terminals~, '
Synapse
,
7
Oligodendrocytes Astrocytes
• •
llllmlll •
..J
....at,
..J <(
<( c:: w
(/)
C::f,
~
u 0 ..J
t-t
~ I~
~-.❖, t-t
::::>
U t?
w~
l:
w
>
<( 0.
:I: :I: l:
w.....: t-t
.... 1.. ·
u w
al
l "'"O
Qj Qj
.s=-
Cl'.ij
::, ,_
:I: ,c
.....e
Qj
0 C:
.s:; 0
U -.::
·o
-ou
o=g.
N
g o
I
th many economic issues, how long cou!d you keep [topic] alive?
f something happened today that threatened to kill [topic] what
SURVIVAL would keep it alive?
Are you in a place where you're able to live without worrying
====--~-------------~---==-~.......~
-- ------ - - - - - - - - - ---
about your ability to [topic] to survive?
1-
u
..,w
m
::::,
Cl)
w
:c
I-
a:
0
I-
<(
0::
w
a.
0
w
:c
I-
3
LIMITING EMPOWERING
2
LACK
COMPOSURE
C
C
\p
COLLAPSE POSTURING
00000000(~
COLLAPSE COMPOSURE POSTURING
C)-(
914 I THE BEHAVIOR OPS MANUAL
THE AUTHORITY TRIANGLE
BEHAVIOR () EFFECT
E T A S F
HABITS
--- z
>-
I-
M
...I
w >-
-
M
0 ID V V
M M z z
- -
I- I- <
V II) M
<
I-
II) w w ...I
V
::, z C) a. w
V z C) :I: a.
0 a. 0 ::, 0 ><
II. 0 V II) V w
~-j,--,r~
C>-<
~~::a~~=
y C
• Desired Point
UJ
u
z<(
J-
C/)
H
0
Where the current .
experts are
L---------------------
TIME
916 I THE BEHAVIOR OPS MANUAL
THE ANIMAL BEHAVIOR CHART
How our childhood protective mechanisms transform into adult behaviors
~~
-
r.r,
C>-<
~::T~~ ~
'
;;o
m e 2016 . Chase Hughes
r.r, Duplication Prohibited
0
C
;;o
n
m
r.r,
►
z
0
(j)
;;o
►
lJ
I
H
n
r.r,
There is nothing positive about any of the traits. They simply
-"
-0
~~
I
m
CD
m ► Comfort-level with behavior
I
► ► Lack of fear of social sanctions
<
H
0
► Frequency of behavior in cultural environment
;o
► Social acceptance of display of behavior (some behaviors are acceptable in private)
0
1J ► Distance from the person's behavioral "home"
(/)
► Previous enjoyment of behavior or similar behavior
3:
► ► Conversational precursors: gradual acceptance of boundary-jumping topics
z
C
►
r
"'-C
cu cu
.c.,_
0>]5
:::, ,_
:c.c
0
0
CUL.
"'a..
Oc
5.g
·c
-ou
o=a
N:::,
(90
LIMBIC TARGETS FRONTAL CRITICAL
TARGETS
..'
'{'
' ''
Junk Food
IMMEDIATE REWARD
Veggies
DELAYED REWARD
i~
s"
OG
f•O
~! .x.
l
-
;ti
m
ii
!• t
fJ)
0
C LU
;ti
()
c:::
m
fJ)
::J
(/)
)>
z <!
0 UJ
Gl ...J
;ti
)> a..
lJ
I
H
()
fJ)
- TIME
-
-0
-0
-0
"'0 THE HUGHES IDENTITY WINDOW The Hughes identity window (red box) is
a fluid and movable window that
-I
I
m
determines many aspects of life from
{lJ success and happiness to psychological
m
I capacity.
~
H
0
Al
~~ INTERNAL
Our locus of control: the degree to
LOCUS OF CONTROL which people believe they, as opposed
0 C>-(
"'O
en
3'.
)>
c, 2016 . Cho se Hullhes
Duplication Prohibited
... to external forces beyond their
influence, have control over the events
z in their lives. Locus of control can shift
C
)> upward or downward in response to life
r
GROWTH SELF-ABSORPTION events, personal growth, and the
influence of those around us.
What's Ii kely to
happen is . ..
The person's expectation
of what is going to
I
~(C!
(\>
-
.___.
- '\.~
~C:,
I What's true is ...
This is the person's
assumptions about you,
and their status relative
(/)
)>
happen or what is likely "'>J-o ~
~v to yours. This is also a
z to happen in the coming ~ measure of how they
0
(j) interaction as it begins. view their own capacity
~~ to be confident.
;o
)>
"tJ
I
H
n
(/)
CK
- C> 2016 . Chase Hughes
Duplication Prohibited
-0
....
N
-0
N
BASELINE BEHAVIOR MEASUREMENT
N
-I
I
m
CD
m NONVERBAL VERBAL
I
)>
<
H SMOOTH/
0 CONFIDENT REVEALING
;o
0
°{)
(/)
3:
)>
z
C
)>
r
OPENING/ ~ ! CLOSING/
REVEALING ◄ . ,..___ ► PROTECTING FOCUSED ◄ 0 -~~~ ► VAGUE
INSECURE/ CONCEALING
STIFF
~~
C)-{
0 2016 . Chase Hughes
Duplication Prohibited
THE FORMATION OF IDENTITY AND BELIEF
~
WITH THE IDEA ►---= ~
~~
-
(f)
'
;o
m
CK
e 2016 . Chose Hughes
Duplication Prohibited
(f)
0
C
;o
n
m
(f)
)>
z "-. THE PERSON ATTEMPTED
0 THE PERSON EXPERIENCED /
(j)
;o STRONG EMOTIONS WHEN cf D TO GET OTHERS TO ADOPT
)>
-u FORMING THE BELIEF THE BELIEF
I
H
n
(f)
-0
N
"'
Cl 2016 . Chase Hu!lhes
Duplication Prohibited
• Personal Behavior
0 Behavior Profiling
0 Influence
e Authority Tripwires
APPEARANCE
CONFIDENCE
NEEDS
IDENTIFICATION
CONNECTION /
ATTENTION
l
(CALLER FOCUSED?) VICTIM FOCUSE9
'
CERTAIN/ HOPEFUL/ UNSURE
_J
<(
EMOTIONAL / DETACHED ::i
z
<(
L
(f)
POLITE / DEMANDING a.
0
(l:'.
0
H
RELUCTANT / ANSWERS QUESTIONS ;
: ~
I
w
Ill
w
REPEATS PHRASES/ NO REPETITION :
~~ I
f--
-0
.._,
N
SOCIAL RESPONSIE - - - - - - - - - CHEMICAL
U)
C:
0
1-W W ,__, U ,__, U
S!Z Z U W U LU
~w w O ..J O . .J
0-- - - -0 - - - - · U) - - - w-- - - - U) - - - - -w • - - -
II
F~CUS-DRIVING I
+ NHANCEMENT
M vement and conversational
e I hancement of focusI
COMPLIANCE ENHANCEMENT
B*avioral and psychological
PHYSIOLOGICAL COMPLIANCE c mpliance using level 3 of
• Behavioral entrainment level two A kpro ,
• Response to physical suggested
movement
PROFILE LEVERAGE -
CQNNECTION
Deep level 6MX profile points
le.lVeraged ro increase feelings
or connection
I
NOVELTY INJECTION 2
• Capitalize on consistency hacking
• Leveraging initial identity formation
• Leveraging initial deviance escalation
• Injection of novelty through language
• Injection of novelty through movement
DEVIANCE ESCALATION
• Leveraging identity/ priming/
6MX data
• Escalation based solely on
values and decision pillar
from 6MX
PERMISSION TRANSFER
Compliance is leveled up to
maximum through permission
transfer
CALL TO ACTION -
CONNECTION
Usage of nonverbal and linguistic
techniques to close
Cell Key
Index Gesture Types
Deception Not Likely DNL
A -Universal Closed
Open lc• .1
..i
Open ■ Fully Open
Universal• Males U/m Agg "'9<;1-.-~e
Variable
Before Answering B Uns Unwn1
During on Answer High Stress
After on Answer >
~
Mostly Males
Mostly Females
M
"0 ■ Deceptive/Stress
0
Ukraine UKR u ■ Facial Expression
Middte East ME
Capillary Pressure /Of Capitl ■ Deceptive if Mixed
Asian Countries AS!
Bulgaria BLG ■ Temperature Affect
C I
,,..
Pd
Pupil OIi
Sw,Jp
Wp,l,
Sp
,.,
,,.. "-
Wd,01
ONL
Sq
Squint
..
Ol,Hs
l,O
0/U
,,., ,,
OtlL
..
Sh
Shrug
WO
l.O
-- ONL
-
,-
V
No
.,
Of
Nooo
No
-BLG
Heod
Lf
Lock Finger
DI,£,
Bi,r•
Capij
C/0
u
Hands
St
C!,Hb
a,
Cop~
Steeple
<
U/m
a.,.
ttonds
Tch ~niv F Tp ~ u
ct,esf Tctuch ooubble cross Topping Fidgeting
Jp,Cc Uns Ob,Oc Closed Fl,Cg Open Tp,Bon Uns
Hu,.;i; , Acc,Thc )(, ,lp Ml,Pf Fr
Nor,e H<1nd, Le; L-OS Prenure Hon!ls None Honds
2.1)
Kh u Bi
Knee Hug Digital Flex Binding
Sh'ij,Bl C/U Pdn.La Clos.Id Oc,Lo
·-
G
Fl,Jp • GJ;d'z
None Arm$
Deception indicated by a
total of 11 or more Sr : Be u We u Jb M
Stoe Re:mov Carelessness wo,ch ChKk Jacket Button
Deception Rating Scale Ke,Jb Open None Open Kc,Jc,L 0µ$, 8g CloMCI
Hb::.,, "'I( AQ,$0 "i f w-
(DRS) points for each Plovlng Objec! Pd Object Copil Oti;ecT Copill Object
behavioral group.
The full guide to The
Behavioral Table of
Elements can be found ~Eu;
.!:::
at 0>
...
"''"' 111.chasehughes.com
International Copyright
© 2012-2020
CK
APPLIED BEHAVIOR RESEARCH
17 18
..........
Ga u Ct
12 13 14 15 lb
,,
FJ,Br
..., CloMd
Le u Ts UiM
Tu Ore u u Wd u
Lip Compress Teeth Sock Turtling Object-Mouth Jaw C~ch Wing Dilation
Jc,Of Cl Le.Of Swl Sh,FI Jc uns Df,Wcl Agg Pd,SI Agg
;;,Shg Face
c, £c,Ct Lr,Bn Lc,Cr <•
"' •= " ,., He<ld Ip Face Coo Pf
"'
- Vh
Fl Hb Lr u Ot u Bn u
.."
IU2M
·- . " ..,,
Flushing Head Bock LlpRetroct Orbit Tension Brow Narrow Ventilation
Sw,Hd c, o,.. Oi,8n Uns Oi,Bn
10 11
Ha,Le
Ha,Lc
.., "~
Cp
,, ,~, Br Foce
Fz,Ag
Eyes 01
''"
Sw,Fr
8reothlnc;,
Sp
Neck
>O
ONC
Pr u S·.·. u Ee '
u
Protecting Swallow
..
Elbowaose
Sw,Hd Ctosed Hd,Pr Closed Ip.Of CloH
,,_
Of.Shg llc,Ec
,_, ~~<-:'
Bh u ' Bb Mi'
Cr u Wp ~ Fz Ft
A ~=•·Hip,
-
Behind Hd Mi' ~~'~""" Behind Back COf\Sf, Raise Const. Raise Fnreze Dtgttht
Cl OoM!d Cr Closed Jc Open Fr,Ss S1,C9 CloMd Pt,Br Hu,l'ns
Sw,Ff
Tht.imbS
Lp
None
N
Shoulder
Le.Ho
~~ Shoulder f!>:!e' ~:,. \JhSw
La '
u Gm The Wt Ip Er Kc u Fw
Lock Ankle
o,;,e; Cic..d
Grooming
Lp,Vh Uni
ThighClosph
Pt,Hb ~
' Wrist Touch
Vh,Ps
M
Ck>Md
Inward Pt
Tc:h,Pr
Ey@lidRub
Tch.Sw Uns
Knee Clasp
Tch,Fw Uns Cl,Jp
Gm.Br Legs ':!;.g Honch
Pd,Wd
Copill Hands ,,..,
Co,S, Sw.Gn
Fl
Son,Fw
CoP"
,.,
pl.Ca
Copil
·-
Fr,Ot
Cc Ob u Ca u Gs u Bs u Ftb Oc u Jp Cl
Covering {pull)
Jb,Bg
'
Closed
Obj. Barrier
Df,Lc
Choir Arms
Closed Lo,O Un1
GroinShieki
Gpr,Oc Closed
Security Check
Jb,WI ~
Fisls•Table
Pd.Ag Agc;,,
Concealment
Tch,Ff Closed
J-elry
01,c, Uns
Choir Legs
a,£r Uns
Vh,PI IQ.Cg
"~· Ft.WI
..,_
Jp,BI Lo,Ge,H Jb,Cj so
....,.,.
Toh
·''
Tugging
.., Objec,
ONC
Uu,g Object Holdlf'lg Oqeci
BOA
Wilh 0-
BOA
Ob,<ci o,,
°"'"" Hiding
>O
Objec! Object Wrap Object
--
Res
.....
•5h
4.0
C
.., 40
,_.,
1-m
-u
lp,No
..,
...... .."
Pal
...,_,
.. .....,
.. Mc u
Mlnl•Conffls
40
_,
Exe
,.....,
@ www.chasehughes.com
CK
element of skills of the operator. This combines the willingness of the subject
""
N to engage, and the operator's ability to generate social interaction.
--i
I CON FES S I ON METHO D 2 FOCUS AND TRUST
m Continuing use of novelty and authority to develop high-
Confession method number two. This creates a behavioral
()J
m window, the size of which will be determined by many factors. levels of focus and suggestibility simultaneously. The
I This method follows the Socialize, Minimize, Rationalize, operator's skill in storytelfing and presence of powerful
)> and Project framework. social skills are critical in this space.
<
H ENTRAINMENT - OPEN P H Y S I C -C OMP LI AN CE
0 Physical entrainment is now patternistic in the Obtaining physiological compliance as early as
;;o
subject. Operator will utilize this phenomenon possible In the interaction using behavioral
0 by shifting their physiology into the behavior entrainment levels 1-3 enhances compliance on
lJ
(/) of nonverbal interest and relaxation such as the 6AM. Some operators may need to force
3: lowering blink-rate, leaning, abdominal this physiological compliance using more
)> breathing, lowering shoulders. advanced techniques. This phase must be
z complete for KAPTOR to function properly.
C CONFUSION - OPEN
)> The operator uses one of the two confusion DEVIANC E ESC A L A TI ON
r scripts from BP trimester three and ensures Escalating deviance using the Dl-5 model
movement and physical contact occur to brings subject out of normal behavior after
ensure 'object tracking' is present in the focus, compliance, and suggestibility have
subject's neurology during the confusion been boosted from the initial point of contact
statement. Command follows confusion for int he interaction. This prepares them for the
subject to open. following step. Using the Dl-5 model, the
COMPLIANCE subject feels a natural response to the
While Behavioral Ent rainment continues ' escalation in these behaviors.
throughout the interaction, this phase alsu begins OPENNESS..,. EN T RAINi...iEN T
to incorporate physical compl iance through direct This phase relies on the linguistic methods of
commands and requests for subject to perform actions. forcing openness in the subject such as
negative dissociation, positive association,
DEVIANCE ESCALATION identity agreements, elicitation, and the use
In this second phase of Deviance of heavy command-language.
Escalation, the operator moves up ESCALATE
an appropriate level on the Dl-5 scale. REGRESSION OPENNESS
From the subject's Delta point to their Regression takes place rapidly due to the previous The openness on the 6AM is elevated here
PL and BL limits on the behavioral steps. Small linguistic advances toward regression are using a different method so that attention
deviation occur here using the methods all that is needed. Vivid languages should be used to is not called to escalation. In this phase,
from Mastery and relying heavily on the regress the subject while using both statement and the subject's Needs are leveraged to
identification of the subject's deviance question methods to do so, and the operator vii!! enhance their level of safety around
boundaries. sharpen their language toward the 6MX of the subject. being vulnerable.
CIChoseHughes - App!iedBehaviorReseorch-2019
2. Novelty: The use of novelty raises the level of focus and connection even
more than authority does on its own. Novelty also works to force
the subject to re-define the frame of the interaction .
6. Command: Leverag ing the state of mental confusion and severe cogn it ive
load, social factors inhibit the subject from resisting the command
due to co nfusion methods 4-7. The ensuing command is readily
accepted and acted upon.
0 UNCONSCIOUS
(/)
z 1
0 INDIFFERENCE
H
f-
u
,,
UJ
en
2 DISBELIEF CONFUSION
0
a:
:)
0
LL
UJ OBSTACLES
I
f-
4
HIGH ENERGY
' Acceptance
'---"
LOW ENERGY
DISSOCIATION
...J
w
w
LL
>-
w
::c
I-
~
0
::c
MASTERY
AMATEUR
~:- /
Duplicatioo Prohibited
TROUBLESHOOTING
TRADECRAFT ISSUES
When people encounter problems with learning Tradecraft, there is typically a
fault in one of three areas:
Observation
Communication
Self-Management
The things that affect our abilities to perform reliable Tradecraft will come
down to one of these three elements. Before we dive into a troubleshooting
list, I want to show you how I fix the most common issues on coaching calls
with my government and civilian VIP clients. Here's my (not-secret-anymore)
process for discovering the root cause of issues people are facing with
Tradecraft skill development:
FIRST
I want to establish what the issue is. I ask questions to determine where the
failure is taking place. Their answer may not be 'accurate', but it helps me in
determining what factors need to be modified. As the client speaks about their
issues, I make careful notes of the issue they describe, and listen carefully to
help me navigate step two.
SECOND
I ask several questions that continue to dive deeper to the issue the client is
experiencing. Over the course of five to ten minutes, the client will tell me all
kinds of real-world examples of their issue, how it's affecting them, and a
description of what they think is causing the issue. While their description isn't
always about the main issue, it almost always points to the issue.
1. Are they having trouble on the left or the rii ght side of the Taxonomy?
(Keep in mind that their description may be about the right side,
where the subject is, but secretly hinting toward the left side, where
the operator is.)
3. I ask direct questions about each of these, still knowing that these
questions will reveal more unconscious issues going on within the
client.
THIRD
Lastly, I will walk the client through a scenario to determine specifically where
this happened, and if it has happened more than once. Oftentimes, a client will
admit that they are imagining that something will happen, so they think there
will be a problem in the future. They haven't actually gone out and practiced
the skills yet, or developed a mindset of an operator, in which case the issue
lies w ithin the COMFORT section of the ACSS Framework. They are
uncomfortable trying out new skills until they think they 'have it all perfect' in
their mind. In other cases, they have spent time developing themselves, and
their mastery of techniques is lacking, so that the issue is genuinely a skill-
development problem. Most clients who call will tell me they have a skill-
development issue, but I work backwards on the AC:SS to determine the issue:
Most commonly, cl ients experience issues due to th,e 'magic pill mirage' and
the 'skill placebo'. They mentally 'go through' the stuff in developing authority,
assuming they can grasp it by mentally rehearsing it a few times, and not
seriously buckling down and keeping track of their life for a while and getting
a firm grip on their own life's steering wheel.
The Magic Pill Mirage occurs when someone can lec1rn something quickly
w ithout needing to exert much effort to obtain the results. The confusion
techniques in this book, for example, are one of the best examples of this.
938 I T HE B EHAVIOR O PS MA N U A L
Someone learns a few of them after 'skimming' the authority section because
'they got it' and then the techn iques almost feel like authority, confidence,
leadership, composure, etc. aren't necessary to successfully deploy the
technique.
The skill placebo is similar, but it's an internal feeling that reassures people
they have true skills, when in reality, they don't. One example of this from my
own life is when my son was very young. He told me he could run away and
live in the mountains. I asked him how he would survive if he did that. He told
me he learned everything from playing Minecraft. He could build a house and
'craft,' all the tools he needs out there in the wild.
Adults aren't immune to this. Someone who reads one book on body language
and 'understands' it, might assume they also have skills. They confuse the
possession of information with the possession of skills. This is a common
mistake people make, and there's no judgment if you've made it. It's like
holding a flight manual for a Boeing 737, and assuming you could get the
plane off the ground. The manual doesn't make you a pilot, the skills do.
TIME APPEARANCE
APPEARANCE CONFIDENCE
FINANCIAL INTENT
They may think their authority is developed, but they might be unknowingly
posturing. It's up to me to discover that using questions. This would indicate
itself by the client telling me that their authority is fine, but their comfort-level
is lacking.
"My authority is fine. I'm able to understand and do all the authority stuff.
It's just something about the conversations. I'm not sure I'm ready to get
the techniques out 'cause they don't sound good enough yet."
" Yeah. I think the Authority stuff is handled completely. When I'm
executing these skills, there's no reaction in the subject. I'm doing it
precisely as described and exactly how you taught us how to do it. I may
need to find more intelligent people to practice on."
This is a problem with social skills. If you can't determine why, you may have
an issue with Skills, in the Observation section of th1~ issue triangle described
at the beginning of this chapter.
"Chase, I just don't know. I know all the skills and I can deploy them any
time. It's like most of the people I try to practice on don't care much
about what I'm saying at all. I'm not sure the te,chniques are powerful
enough."
This is a problem with Authority. You can hear the hidden issue here in the
client's words.
"Ok. I 've got it all handled, but it doesn't feel right. I'm doing the reps, t.>ut
there's something that is off about the delivery. I want you to listen to how
I say this."
Th is is an issue with skill most likely. You can hear the authority in the person's
demeanor even in a few words. This person genuinely went hardcore into the
authority section, and developed into a confident operator, and only needs
help leveling up on the skill , and communication side of the diagnosis tool.
THE THREE-STEP
DIAGNOSTIC PROCESS
To diagnose an issue, fi rst determ ine which side of 1'he triangle the issue
(genuinely) is.
Authority
Comfort
Social Skills
Skill-development
If you were able to spot your issues with real clarity, you 'd be able to say
something like the following sentence, which uses the three-step formula
above in reverse:
"I was struggling to obtain focus in people because I lacked the comfort
to display confident behavior, and my self-management is most likely the
fastest way to change this."
To troubleshoot the issue, all you have to do is come up with a program for
yourself by going back to the authority section, creating a daily routine or
weekly checklist, and developing the comfort-levels you need, plus the
confidence you need to establish the levels of focus you need.
For any issue you diagnose, you can refer to that section to develop a plan to
correct the issue, or watch that video training in Mastery.
So, if I had an issue with Communication in the issue triangle, and a (genuine)
issue with Comfort on the ACSS Framework, I need to do work on
communicating with more confidence and comfort. I might need to join a
Toastmasters, hire a coach, or take other approaches to gradually expose
myself to increasingly st ressful situations to inoculate myself to the stress.
A person with this issue might think initially that people don't like them, or that
they lack social skills. This isn't the case. Understanding how to dive deep into
the root cause of issues and determine the issue on these to frameworks, is
what provides you with a road ahead.
Once this is determined , go back to The Taxonomy of Influence, and see if the
place you had an issue with was misdiagnosed, or you found a way to
understand it better. You might find out that all you needed was a little more
storytelling ability, or a little more comfort talking to strangers, instead of
months of studying more 'techniques.'
Instead of letting them blame the world, I want them to take ownership, so I
ask if they will participate in a sentence-completion exercise that might sound
a little ridiculous at first. Then I ask them, "Have you ever heard the old saying
that a bad sailor blames the wind?"
" What about the one where a bad worker blames the tools he has?"
Great job. I'm glad we did that. I like to do that on every call just to help
remind me and everyone that we are all accountable people. And
accountable people don't blame anyone."
"In your own words, can you describe the issue you're having?"
"Okay. Got it. Now can you tell me about a scenario where you noticed
this?"
9 4 2 I TH E BEH AV I O R O PS M A NUAL
"What other times have you noticed this?"
"Let's say you were traveling, and you needed to use Tradecraft to get
into a gym that you're not a member of, just so you could work out for a
day. How would this come up in this scenario?
"Okay. And if you suddenly joined a door-to-door sales team selling home
alarm systems, how would this problem play out?"
In these two scenario questions at the end, I deliberately put them in two
different spots - one where they are speaking to a low-level employee, and
one where they aren't in charge at all , and they are on someone else's
property. This helps to determine if they have an issue with the authority side
that they might not be telling me about. To make one final determination
about the authority issue, I will ask them one more scenario with slightly
higher stakes:
"Great Ok. Last one. If you were traveling with a family member who
forgot their blood pressure medication, and you had to walk into a
hospital alone to obtain it, explain how, while using Tradecraft, this issue
would come up with the doctor who's speaking to you. At the hospital
now."
I put them into the situation using linguistics here, so that their response is
more appropriately tailored to respond to the authority challenge. This is also
a composure test to determine if self-management is to blame if a client is
telling me they have an issue learning techniques, but are unaware they need
to develop more on the Authority Assessment and Composure Scale.
I assess what the client told me very carefully and determine the root cause of
their issues. If I were using a wallet-sized card to make a diagnosis, it would
look something like this:
INITIAL ISSUE:
OVERALL ISSUE:
Technical or Behavioral
Using the _____ model, I will coach the client on how to develop this
plan for the _____ day period, and will foll low up with them to ensure
they are able to _____ .
1. Physiological
2. Psychological
3. Behavioral
4. Skill
PSYCHOLOGICAL = 90 DAYS
PHYSIOLOGICAL = 40 DAYS
These methods are usually rooted in body mechanics, and stem from
psychological patterns that the person has already overcome.
However, the anatomy of the spinal cord is layered in such a way that
the physiological issues can remain after the psychological ones are
overcome. These recommendations typically involve body
detoxification (such as colonies) and lymphatic massage at the
outset of the 40 days, followed by the use of KT tape to remind the
client to adjust the body's position over t ime. The body responds to
changes in the environment just like the mind does. The initial shift in
environment (in my opinion) within the body assists the physiological
pathways to re-learn confident and comfortable behavior in new,
clean surroundings.
Second, with the aid of the client's physician, the physiological issues
can further be treated with regimens of beta-blockers and non-
drowsy muscle relaxers that are both non-psychoactive compounds
so that the body will learn the new behaviors of comfort and calm
without being state-dependent on the presence of a psychoactive
chemical.
SKILL = 12 DAYS
4. Keep your cells healthy (Eat for your cells, not your enjoyment).
7. Never complain.
If my clients follow this simple checklist of these 8 points, they will seldom
need to touch base with me, saving both of us time. This 8-point list is also
sometimes a good starting-off point on calls when a client tells me there's an
issue. I will often go through this very list and ensure that there isn't something
simple that can be fixed within five minutes.
This section has the potential not only to troubleshoot errors, but to shine light
into unconscious areas that might be otherwise causing issues with your
Tradecraft.
GLOSSARY I 949
Attentional Captivity The state a subject is in where the amount ,of
focal exclusion (ign,oring their surroundings
and distractions) is at a peak during a
conversation - this is a measure of focus, but
also a measure of tlhe abilities and skills of an
operator
GLOSSARY I 951
Cause-Blindness The tendency for a person or group to focus
solely on the symptoms or byproducts of
larger issues that c1Jused them. For instance,
a person wanting to achieve success might
focus solely on what successful people do,
wear, or own. Alternatively, a politician may
focus on mandatini~ gun laws to prevent
shootings, while completely ignoring the
psychological and sociological decay that
might be responsible for this behavior
becoming more prevalent.
GLOSSARY I 953
Discipline The ability to prioritize and then perform
actions on those priorities over other
competing tasks or behaviors. Chase defines
this as the ability to place the needs of your
future self ahead of the needs or desires of
your present-tense self.
Dorsal Anterior Cingulate Gyrus The Brodmann area 32, also known in
the human brain as the dorsal anterior
cingulate area 32, refers to a subdivision of
the cytoarchitecturally defined cingulate
cortex. In the humcJn it forms an outer arc
around the anterior cingulate gyrus.
The cingulate sulcus defines approximately its
inner boundary and the superior rostral
sulcus (H) its ventrnl boundary; rostrally it
extends almost to the margin of the frontc1I
lobe. Cytoarchitecturally it is bounded
internally by the vemtral anterior cingulate
area 24, externally by medial margins of
the agranular frontal area 6, intermediate
frontal area 8, granular frontal area
9, frontopolar area 10, and prefrontal area 11-
1909. (BrodmarinlCJ'-09).
GLOSSARY I 955
FATE The FATE model is derived from the four
factors: Focus, Authority, Tribe, and Emotion
Four Levers of Influence The four ways that thoughts are processed
and decisions are made in the human brain.
These are Electrical (thoughts), Chemical
(emotions), Behavioral (patterns), and
Impulse (spinal cord and DNA). These four
levers are the four ways a person can be
influenced. The most powerful being Impulse,
and the least being Electrical.
GLOSSARY I 957
Self-concept is made up of one's self-
schemas, and interncts with self-esteem, SE!lf-
knowledge, and the social self to form the self
as a whole. It includes the past, present, and
future selves, where! future selves (or possible
selves) represent individuals' ideas of what
they might become, what they would like to
become, or what they are afraid of becoming.
Possible selves may function as incentives for
certain behavior.
GLOSSARY I 959
Mammalian Brain See: Limbic System
GLOSSARY I 961
Permission The degree to which a person feels both thE~
ability and the license to perform an action
that is suggested or implied from an outside
source. Permission provides reassurance
during any time a prediction cannot be
reliably made about outcomes. Permission
provides us with a license to behave in certain
ways and diffuses our feeling of responsibility
for the outcome of some of our actions ..
GLOSSARY I 963
Resting Potential The imbalance of electrical charge that exists
between the interior of electrically excitabli=
neurons (nerve cells) and their surroundings.
The resting potentic1I of electrically excitable
cells lies in the range of -60 to -95 millivolts (1
millivolt = 0.001 volt), with the inside of the
cell negatively charged. If the inside of a cell
becomes more electronegative (i.e., if the
potential is made greater than the resting
potential), the membrane or the cell is said to
be hyperpolarized. If the inside of the cell
becomes less negative (i.e., the potential
decreases below th,e resting potential), the
process is called depolarization.
Six-Axis Model of Influence The Six-Axis Model represents the six aspects
or approaches to influence. Focus,
Suggestibility, Openness, Connection,
Compliance, and Expectancy. Achieving a
high level of three or more elements
exponentially increoses the likelihood of
obtaining a desired persuasion outcome. For
instance, the Milgrc1m Experiment, despite the
extreme results achieved, only leveraged
three of the six axes: Focus, Suggestibility,
and Compliance.
To be affected by a communication or
expectation such that certain responses are
overtly enacted, or subjectively experienced,
without volition, as in automatism.
GLOSSARY I 965
Thalamus The thalamus is the· switchboard operator of
our brain. Any sensory information (except for
smell) that comes into our bodies goes to our
thalamus first and the thalamus sends the
information to the right parts of our brain to
get processed.
GLOSSARY I 967
NEUROGENIC TREMORS
In this paper, I published a number of findings rega1rding neurogenic tremors,
and their potential for therapeutic use. Although I dlon't use them in Avery for
this purpose, I believe this article to be of help to those wishing to bring this
into practice.
THERAPEUTIC NEUl~OGENIC
TREMORS FOR TRE)~TING
NEUROGENIC PATHOLOGIES
Chase Hughes
Applied Behavior Research, Frontiers
February 6, 2023
ABSTRACT
INTRODUCTION
STRESS MECHANISM
GLOSSARY I 969
(Hobofll, 1989) has suggested that during a stress response, the neocortex,
which is responsible for higher thinking, learning, and understanding, is
inhibited, while the reptilian and mammalian brains,. which are concerned with
survival and emotions, are stimulated, leading to a state of hyperarousal. This
shift in brain function can result in increased forgetfulness, decreased rational
thinking, and more impulsive behavior. The triune brain concept, similar to
Maslow's hierarchy of needs, can help explain these changes. Research by
Liston (Liston, 2009) supports these findings, suggesting that chronic stress
can even lead to executive dysfunction. This insight into the brain's response to
stress might explain why conventional talk therapy is not always effective in
treating PTSD, anxiety, and other stress-related illm~sses. The triune brain
concept, when applied to stress response suggests that the neocortex
becomes inhibited during stress, while the reptilian ,::md mammalian brains
become stimulated, leading to a state of hyperarousal. This shift in brain
function is due to the body's focus on survival or su1·vival of offspring. This can
lead to forgetfulness, impulsive behavior, and decreased rational thinking (
(Harrison, 2009). The two brains activated during a stressful event, which may
result in trauma, are non-verbal, emotional, and focused on survival, which
may help explain further issues with talk therapy.
The freeze response is one of the three options the body has during a stress
response: flight, fight, or freeze. It occurs when the danger is inescapablH and
too life-threatening to fight, and humans can exhibit it through physical
immobility or dissociation (Levine P., 1997). Dissocicltion is defined as a clinical
psychiatric condition characterized by fragmentation and splitting of the
mind, altered perceptions and behavior, numbing aind avoidance. A study by
(Van der Kolk, 1996) provides that the freeze response is marked by
bradykinesia, decreased heart rate and breathing, 1Jnd release of opioids, and
is believed to be mediated by the vagal nerve. The polyvagal theory states
that the vagal nerve has three distinct functions, including stimulation of the
SNS for fight or flight, stimulation of instinctual extreme co-activation of the
PNS for the freeze response, and stimulation of the PNS for social
engagement. (Payne, 2015)
The aim of the body is to respond to a state of ventral vagal activation, which
promotes social engagement and a calm state. The polyvagal theory
attributes three functions to the vagal nerve: to stimulate the SNS for fight or
flight, to stimulate extreme co-activation of the PNS for the freeze response,
and to stimulate the PNS for social engagement ( (Marx, 2008). Polyvagc1I
theory is linked to the concept of neuroception, which is the neural system's
ability to detect whether a situation or person is safe, dangerous, or life-
threatening. (Marx, 2008) provides that neurogenic tremors are thought to be
the natural way to return to the ventral vagal state and end the stress
response, but only occur when the neural system determines that the
environment is "safe enough ( (Volchan, 2011)." The theory of neuroception
and the polyvagal theory are important in understonding how the body
responds to different levels of danger and how it returns to a calm state.
The ANS, which primarily controls the stress response, consists of two
branches, the sympathetic nervous system (SNS) and the parasympathetic
nervous system (PNS) (Scaer, 2001). The SNS is activated in response to
perceived danger, preparing the body for action by activating the
cardiovascular system, skeletal muscles, and releasing hormones while
simultaneously inhibiting non-essential bodily functions (Payne, 2015). This
leads to symptoms such as increased heart rate and breathing, pupil dilation,
perspiration, hypertension, decreased salivation, indigestion, constipation,
increased blood-glucose, and cortisol. Chronic stress, or chronic dysregulation
of homeostasis, can lead to long-term health problems such as heart disease,
gastrointestinal disease, diabetes, adrenal fatigue, increased inflammation,
and reproductive problems (Van der Kolk, 1996). People with interstitial cystitis
and pelvic pain (IwPD) suffer from autonomic dysregulation, including
GLOSSARY I 971
cardiovascular problems, gastrointestinal complain1·s, and autonomic
dysregulation, which is associated with fatigue in IwPD and other conditions.
(Swisher, 2010) studied how exercise has been used in the past to promote
health. The study reveals that exercise has been viewed a key component of
maintaining good health and promoting longevity since ancient times. It has
been extensively researched for its potential benefits on physical fitness,
overall health, psychology, quality of life, and even the brain. This is
particularly important for the elderly and individuals with neurodegenerative
diseases such as Parkinson's Disease (PD). The belie!f that exercise can be
considered a form of medicine dates back to Hippocrates. Regular exercise
has been shown to have potential neuroprotective effects in people with
Parkinson's disease (PD) and improve their quality e>f life (QoL) (Berryman,
Exercise is medicine: a historical perspective , 2010). It has been found tc>
stimulate dopamine synthesis, promote brain repair and neuroplasticity, and
improve motor and non-motor symptoms. (Berrymc1n, Exercise is medicine: a
historical perspective, 2010) further offers that exercise can also enhance
motor cortex activation and improve balance and overall function. People with
PD are generally more inactive than healthy peers, and declining physicc1I
activity levels can contribute to functional decline. Exercise interventions can
lead to functional improvements and improve QoL.
(Morris M. e., 2010) states that most persons with Pcirkinson's disease (PD) turn
to complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) therapies to help manage
their symptoms, as it is estimated that 40-76% of pE~ople with PD use some
form of CAM. CAM therapies for PD include yoga, Tcii Chi, Qigong, dance
therapies, music therapy, drum circles, expressive writing, active theatre
therapy, mindfulness therapy, acupuncture, massage, reflexology, Alexander
technique, Feldenkrais method, stochastic resonance therapy, progressive
relaxation, and whole-body vibration therapy (Mitterauer, 2015). These CAM
therapies have been shown to be beneficial for improving QoL, depressive
moods, sleep, and cognition. Specifically, acupuncture and Tai Chi may help
with depressive moods, QoL, and sleep, while dance! and yoga have some
evidence in improving cognition, apathy, and fatigue.
(Kirby, 2013) posit that vibrational and tremor therapies have been researched
for their effects on Parkinson's disease (PD). These therapies are based on the
idea that vibrations and tremors can be therapeutic for the human body, as
they are with most of the animal population. Vibrational therapies are often
induced by a therapist through a machine, while self-initiated tremors can be
induced through selective exercises, breathing techniques, or sound. The
theories behind why vibration and tremors might be beneficial for the human
body include biomechanical and sensorimotor stimulation, allowing the body
to reorganize itself through neural noise, and being the body's innate response
to stress (Atterbury, Doctor dissertation 2019). There are various tremor
therapies that have been researched for their effects on PD, including whole-
body vibration therapy, Lee Silverman Voice Therapy, and stochastic
resonance therapy. There are also other tremor therapies that have not been
researched, but they may have a promising effect on PD.
Additionally, it is believed that the vibration may improve blood flow and
oxygenation to the brain, which can result in improved motor function and
decreased symptoms of PD. The Alexander technique is a therapy that focuses
on re-educating the body to move in a more efficient and harmonious manner,
which in turn can reduce symptoms of PD (Atterbury, Doctor dissertation
2019). The technique involves teaching individuals to change their habitual
patterns of movement and posture, which can reduce muscle tension and
stiffness and improve balance, coordination, and mobility. The therapy is
performed by a qualified practitioner and involves a series of gentle, hands-on
directions and verbal cues to help the individual learn to move in a new and
more efficient way. Although not many studies have been conducted on the
Alexander technique and PD, the results from the available studies are
promising, with improvement in balance, posture, and mobility reported. WBV
and the Alexander technique are both therapies that have been used to help
manage symptoms of PD, and both have shown promising results (Kwok J. Y.,
2016). However, more research is needed to better understand the underlying
mechanisms and to determine the most effective protocols for these therapies.
GLOSSARY I 973
WHY HUMANS MIGHT SUPPRESS NATURAL
TREMORS
· SOMATIC EXPERIENCE
Neurophysics therapy (NPT) was developed by Ken Ware and operates on ,:i
different approach than SE or TRE. It uses TNT to improve individuals but does
not view the tremor as a stress response, instead it is seen as a body's natural
self-healing and re-organization process (Atterbury, Doctor dissertation 2019).
NPT is performed on gym equipment cit ultra-slow speeds and with a relaxed
state of mind. The slow speed allows the nervous system to detect and adjust
Tension and Trauma Releasing Exercises™ (TRE) was developed by Dr. David
Berceli, based on his observations of how people react to traumatic events. He
noticed that when people (and animals) were faced with threats, they
instinctively curled their bodies inward, into a fetal position (Berceli D. e.,
2014). He also observed that children would shake or tremor in response to
traumatic events, but adults would not. This led Berceli to believe that the
tremoring was a natural phenomenon of the body to discharge tension. He
then returned to the USA and began to research this mechanism. With his
background as a monk, social worker, psychologist, and massage therapist,
Berceli developed TRE to help individuals release tension and trauma from the
body through spontaneous tremoring exercises (Berceli D. , 2007). Animal
studies have shown that after life-threatening events, animals shake and
tremor to calm their nervous systems, which is seen more prominently in
animals experiencing a freezing or immobility response. This spontaneous
recovery has been linked to increased resilience in animals, while not allowing
spontaneous recovery has been linked to early death. Similarities have been
drawn between how animals and humans respond to highly stressful situations
(Berceli D. &., 2006). However, it has been observed that captive animals do
not display this response as strongly as their wild counterparts, and
researchers have noted that caged animals often have impaired health and
shorter lifespan.
GLOSSARY I 975
The theories of (Levine P., 1997) and (Van der Kolk, 1996) suggest that the l<Jck
of recovery from a traumatic event in humans leads to the storage of energy
from the "fight or flight" response, causing hyperarc>usal in the nervous
system. This theory is further supported by Levine's development of Somatic
Experiencing therapy and Scaer's research on whiplash syndrome, which
suggests that traumatic memories can have a profound impact on the body.
The theories propose that if the body is not able to fully recover from a
traumatic event, it may result in PTSD and may explain why some individuc1ls
experience tremors or re-enact traumatic events as a way to complete the
freeze response and normalize the body's state. The theory of neurogenic
tremors, as proposed by (Scaer, 2001) and (Berceli D. , 2007), states that
chronic stress or trauma can be stored in the body, not just in the mind. These
tremors are believed to be an innate adaptive mechanism that helps restore
homeostasis in response 1·0 stress and have a physiological, not psychological,
origin. (Berceli D., 2007) suggests that these tremors can also be activated
therapeutically to discharge an incomplete stress re·sponse.
ALEXANDER TECHNIQUE
The Alexander Technique is a manual therapy that c1ims to help people change
their movement patterns and posture. It is a hands-on therapy that involves
gentle touch, guidance, and verbal ins1·ruction from a therapist. Research has
shown that the Alexander technique can be helpful iin improving balance,
posture and reducing falls in individuals with PD. However, there is a need for
more research to determine the long-term effects of the Alexander technique
on PD. The Alexander technique is a therapy that aims to improve overall body
posture, coordination, and balance by teaching individuals how to move in a
more efficient manner. The therapy emphasizes on <Jwareness, mindfulness,
and proper body mechanics. A review by Deiglmayr and colleagues (2012)
found that Alexander technique had a positive effect on balance, postural
control, and activities of daily living for IwPD. Although, the number of studies
investigating the effects of Alexander technique for IwPD is limited, the few
studies that are available seem to support its efficacy for individuals with PD.
The exact mechanisms of why the Alexander technique might be beneficial are
yet to be determined but some theories suggest thc1t the therapy works by
modifying movement patterns, re-educating the neuromuscular system, and
promoting better body alignment and postur (Cohen, 2015). The Alexander
Technique is an educational therapeutic process aimed at retraining habitual
patterns of movement and posture to improve overnll physical well-being. It
starts with hands-on sessions with a therapist and icJter becomes an
instructional therapy in individual private sessions. The technique has been
reported to reduce or prevent chronic back pain and other problems that
occur in Parkinson's disease, such as poor muscular respiratory function.
Research has shown that the mindful movement approaches used in the
Alexander Technique can improve balance and mobility in individuals with
Parkinson's disease by increasing upright postural c1lignment and decreasing
rigidity, and also improve self-reported disease sev,erity and depression.
The current social and medical view of neurogenic tremors is that they are a
pathological expression of reduced coping abilities with stress. This view has
led to limited research into the potential therapeutic benefits of these tremors,
and it is suggested that until this view changes, the exploration of the
therapeutic value of these tremors will remain limited. Selye's research in the
1970s explored the potential therapeutic effects of tremors as a response to
stress in animals. He found that animals naturally experience tremors after
stressful events and that these tremors appear to have a protective effect,
making the animals more resilient to future stress (Selye, 1973). Selye's work
laid the foundation for the understanding of the human body's non-specific
response to stress. Neuro-physiological studies in animals have shown that
traumatic events can cause physiological shock, leading to an immediate
release of protective hormones and increased energy in the muscles, enabling
the body to respond with a fight/flight or freeze response. This same reaction
has been observed in humans in response to perceived threats.
It has been shown that animals in the wild have an innate "trembling"
mechanism that helps them recover from traumatic events by discharging the
high biochemical and neuromuscular charge. This trembling mechanism
provides them with a built-in immunity to PTSD and enables them to return to
normal life without developing symptoms. According to animal researchers,
this mechanism indicates a survival advantage and has survived the evolution
of the species. Additionally, (Scaer, 2001) theorizes that these tremors involve
an expenditure of energy during a vulnerable time of recovery from physical
stress, indicating that they play a role in the survival process. A study by
(Berceli D. e., 2014) (Scaer, 2001) reveals that musculoskeletal tremors are
tremors experienced before, during, or after stressful events, also known as
enhanced physiologic tremors. They are considered a pathological expression
of stress and are included in the diagnostic criteria for psychological disorders
such as panic attacks, social phobia, generalized anxiety disorder, and PTSD
(Berceli D. e., 2014). Despite their widespread incidence, little research has
been done on the cause, function, and purpose of these tremors.
GLOSSARY I 977
Dr. David Berceli developed Tension and Trauma Releasing Exercises™ (TRE),
an integrative neurophysiological approach that rec:ognizes the therapeutic:
value of musculoskeletal tremors in reducing stress (Berceli D. e., 2014). By
inducing a self-induced tremor to discharge physicc1l tension, TRE helps
mitigate the effects of stress. The tremor induced by TRE has not been
classified according to the 1998 consensus statement on tremors by the
Movement Disorder Society and is referred to as self-induced unclassified
therapeutic tremor (SUTT) (Berceli D. &., 2006). Tension and Trauma Releasing
Exercises™ (TRE) induce a unique type of tremor known as self-induced
unclassified therapeutic tremor (SUTT). The SUTT is similar to enhanced
physiologic tremors but has distinct activation conditions, topography,
frequency, and amplitude. It is an action tremor with both postural and
isometric activation, augmented at rest, widely distributed, and has variable
amplitude and frequency (Berceli D. e., 2014). TRE was designed for use in
high-stress areas and is taught in group settings as a self-directed somatic
modality that is easily learned and practiced. It is widely accepted that
chronic stress negatively impacts health-related qu<llity of life. South Africa
experiences high levels of stress due to factors such as interpersonal violence,
poverty, unemployment, and high HIV infection ratE~s, compounded by limited
access to mental health services (Berceli D. , 2007). 'With only nine mental
health professionals per 100,000 population, there is a need for effective,
accessible, and culturally adaptive me1·hods of stress reduction in South
Africa's diverse population.
Over the past years, TRE has shown promise in improving the quality of life
and reducing mental health disorders in non-professional caregivers and
adolescents. While further research is needed, its ease of use and ability to
access the body's innate relaxation response make it a promising technique
for both first responders and their family members (Atterbury, Doctor
dissertation 2019).
Research on TRE suggests that it has been shown to have a positive impact on
a wide range of populations and in various settings (Berceli D. , 2007). It has
been found to help reduce anxiety levels, improve family relationships, reduce
conflicts and domestic violence, relieve psychosocial symptoms, reduce stress
and burnout, improve quality of life, reduce mental health disorders, and
promote occupational health (Cohen, 2015) (Berryman, Exercise is medicine: a
historical perspective , 2010) (Berceli D. , 2007) . Additionally, research is
ongoing and investigating the effects of TRE in various other settings and
populations. The evaluations of TRE Resilience Training in Australia have
GLOSSARY I 979
shown positive results. According to the data provided, in the case of health
and welfare staff in the NT, 19 out of 20 reported fe1~ling significantly calmer
after the training and all 20 stated they were highly likely to continue
practicing TRE. The same results were reported by survivors of the Black
Saturday Bushfires who participated in two TRE workshops (Atterbury, Doctor
dissertation 2019). The follow-up to the Victorian Government TRE was
highlighted as playing a positive role in individual and community wellbeinq. A
submission was made in 2013 to a parliamentary inquiry regarding the use of
TRE for care of wounded and injured personnel in the ADF. There was also
research conducted in 2016 by a physiotherapy student at Monash University
that investigated the use of TRE for treating Restless Leg Syndrome, a
common co-morbid condition of PTSD (Atterbury, Doctor dissertation 2019).
Although the study was small and inconclusive, it w,Js published in the Journal
of the American Board of Family Medicine and suggested that both TRE and
facilitated group discussions had a positive impact on reducing RLS
symptoms.
The techniques used in TRE are similar to those used in ancient martial arts
practices, such as Katsugen Undo and Seiki Jutsu, that trained the mind and
body of Samurai Warriors. The spontaneous movements in these practices
helped them to become lethal warriors and then to switch to a relaxed stat,~
(Berceli D. e., 2014). TRE offers a solution to this issL1e by providing a means for
First Responders to release residual tension and stn~ss through the body's
natural relaxation response of tremors and shaking. This process can help
restore their nervous system to a state of resilience,, reducing the risk of
cumulative trauma and burnout (Berceli D. &., 2006). By incorporating TRE into
training programs, First Responders can be equippeid with the skills necess<Jry
to effectively manage the stress and trauma they encounter in their work.
(Berceli D. e., 2014) have further advocated for the use of shakes and tremors
as a technique to prevent stress and trauma in first responders and
emergency service workers, drawing on examples from traditional cultures
and practices. However, they have faced resistance from the mental health
system, which only recognizes evidence-based treatments within their
professional expertise. Despite this, the author belie,ves that the government
CONCLUSION
In conclusion, the findings of this paper reveals that therapeutic tremors can
address the biological and psychological aspects of stress linked to the
development of several diseases by utilizing the biopsychosocial model of
illness. The biopsychosocial approach has been recommended for the
management of Parkinson's disease and other illnesses as it can improve
clinical outcomes and equip individuals with better mind-body management
of stress. This paper further shows that TRE (Trauma and Tension Release
Exercises™) is a body-based practice aimed at addressing stress, anxiety,
trauma, and PTSD. The paper reveals that people who practice TRE regularly
often report feeling more relaxed, grounded, and calm, and may experience
relief from physical and emotional pain after several months of practice. It can
be helpful for people with a wide range of stress-related issues and can be
used as a self-help tool for good health and resiliency. It does not require
talking about traumatic events and can be useful for overcoming language
barriers. The frequency of practice can vary based on individual history of
trauma and stress.
DISCLOSURES
The author has had personal experience through the Department of Defense
with TRE, and the effects were exceedingly positive. The author also uses
neurogenic tremors as part of his work with clients. No business or other
associations with TRE, or Dr. Berceli exist at the time of publication.
REFERENCES
Berceli, D., Salmon, M., Bonifas, R., & Ndefo, N. (2014). Effects of self-induced
unclassified therapeutic tremors on quality of life among non-
professional caregivers: A pilot study. Global advances in health and
medicine, 3(5), 45-48.
GLOSSARY I 981
Berryman, J. W. (2010). Exercise is medicine: a historical perspective. Current
sports medicine reports, 9(4), 195-201.
Brom, D., Stokar, Y., Lawi, C., Nuriel-Porat, V., Ziv, Y., Lerner, K., & Ross, G.
(2017). Somatic experiencing for posttraumatic stress disorder: A
randomized controlled outcome study. Journal of traumatic
stress, 30(3), 304-312.
Chou, K. L., Gilman, S., & Bohnen, N. I. (2017). Assoclation between autonomic
dysfunction and fatigue in Parkinson disease. Journal of the
neurological sciences, 377, 190-192.
Cohen, R. G., Gurfinkel, V. S., Kwak, E., Warden, A. C., & Horak, F. B. (2015).
Lighten up: specific postural instructions affect axial rigidity and step
initiation in patients with Parkinson's disease. Neurorehabilitation ,and
neural repair, 29(9), 878-888.
Gaffey, A. E., Bergeman, C. S., Clark, L.A., & Wirth, M. M. (2016). Aging and the
HPA axis: Stress and resilience in older adults. Neuroscience &
Biobehavioral Reviews, 68, 928-945.
Harbourne, R. T., & Stergiou, N. (2009). Movement variability and the use of
nonlinear tools: principles to guide physical therapist
practice. Physical therapy, 89(3), 267-282.
Harrison, M. B., Wylie, S. A., Frysinger, R. C., Patrie, J. T., Huss, D. S., Currie, L.. J.,
& Wooten, G. F. (2009). UPDRS activity of a'aily living score as a
marker of Parkinson's disease progression. Movement disorders:
official journal of the Movement Disorder Society, 24(2), 224-230.
Hemmerle, A. M., Herman, J.P., & Seroogy, K. B. (2012). Stress, depression crnd
Parkinson's disease. Experimental neurolo,~y, 233(1), 79-86.
Horowitz, N. H., Bonner, D., Mitchell, H. K., Tatum, E. L., & Beadle, G. W. (194S).
Genie control of biochemical reactions in Neurospora. The American
Naturalist, 79(783), 304-317.
Kwok, J. Y. Y., Choi, K. C., & Chan, H. Y. L. (2016). Effects of mind-body exercises
on the physiological and psychosocial we/I-being of individuals with
Parkinson's disease: A systematic review and meta-
analysis. Complementary therapies in medicine, 29, 121-131.
Kwok, J. Y. Y., Kwan, J.C. Y., Auyeung, M., Mok, V. C. T., & Chan, H. Y. L. (2017).
The effects of yoga versus stretching and resistance training
exercises on psychological distress for people with mild-to-moderate
Parkinson's disease: Study protocol for a randomized controlled
trial. Trials, 18(1), 1-13.
Levine, P.A. (1997). Waking the tiger: Healing trauma: The innate capacity to
transform overwhelming experiences. North Atlantic Books.
Levine, P.A. (2010). In an unspoken voice: How the body releases trauma and
restores goodness. North Atlantic Books.
Liston, C., McEwen, B. S., & Casey, B. J. (2009). Psychosocial stress reversibly
disrupts prefrontal processing and attentional control Proceedings of
the National Academy of Sciences, 106(3), 912-917.
Marx, B. P., Forsyth, J. P., Gallup, G. G., & Fuse, T. (2008). Tonic immobility as an
evolved predator defense: Implications for sexual assault
survivors. Clinical psychology: science and practice, 15(1), 74.
Morris, M. E., Martin, C. L., & Schenkman, M. L. (2010). Perry Issue: Gait
Rehab. PHYS THER, 90, 280-288.
Ogden, P., Pain, C., & Fisher, J. (2006). A sensorimotor approach to the
treatment of trauma and dissociation. Psychiatric Clinics, 29(1), 263-
279.
Piazza, J. R., Charles, S. T., Sliwinski, M. J., Mogle, J., & Almeida, D. M. (2013).
Affective reactivity to daily stressors and long-term risk of reporting
a chronic physical health condition. Annals of Behavioral
Medicine, 45(1), 110-120.
GLOSSARY I 983