Wu 2011
Wu 2011
Jatropha curcas L. produces seed oil that is viewed as having tremendous potential as an economical
alternative for diesel fuel. Seed yield, the main factor determining jatropha oil production, is highly
associated with flower development, especially with the number of female flowers. However, little was
known regarding floral development in this species. Accordingly, studies were undertaken to develop
more information on the developmental process of floral organs. The early floral development was
divided into 12 phases. The present study illustrated that, the sex differentiation of male or female
flowers occurred in phase-VII; earlier phases presented unapparent structural differences. The male
flowers always had unisexual tissues during floral development. In contrast, early development of
female flowers presented bisexual tissues, with male sexual degradation occurring at the later
developmental phases. There was significant location specificity with respect to the inflorescence of
male and female flowers. Based on this, the present study combined the total number of female flowers,
and divided the inflorescence into three types, which had significant differences in the number of
female flowers; they likewise presented different probabilities of occurrence in terms of different
growing seasons.
Key words: Biofuel, flower, inflorescence, Jatropha curcas, sex differentiation, scanning electron microscopy.
INTRODUCTION
It has been increasingly apparent that the production of non-domesticated nature. Thus, although jatropha grows
biofuels must originate from non-food crops dedicated abundantly in the wild, its seed and oil yields are
solely to energy production. These crops should not considered unpredictable for production. The conditions
compete with food crop production. Genetic improvement that best suit its growth remain largely undefined, and the
of such potential bio-energy-producing crops, such as potential environmental impacts of large-scale cultivation
switchgrass, poplar, and Jatropha curcas L. (jatropha) is are not at all fully understood (Chikara, 2007).
currently being pursued (Koonin, 2006; Kaushik, 2007; J. curcas L. (Euphorbiaceae) originated in Central
Ranade et al., 2008). Many countries hold high America. It is a perennial softwood shrub or small tree
expectations for jatropha as a biofuel source, as it grows that is now fairly well established in most tropical and
well on lands poorly suited for cultivation of food crops. subtropical areas of the world. The vegetable oil from the
However, although there is reason to be enthusiastic oil-rich seeds produced by this plant is known for its
about jatropha’s potential as a biodiesel feedstock, one medicinal value (Wei et al., 2005), and has long been
major obstacle to its current widespread cultivation is its used around the world as a source of lamp oil and for
producing soap (Chikara, 2007). Recently, jatropha oil
has been recognized for its suitability for conversion into
biodiesel (Solomon, 2002). The plant thrives in a wide
*Corresponding author. E-mail: wqh1019@yahoo.cn. Tel: +86 range of environmental conditions, from eroded land to
28 8541 7281. Fax: +86 28 8541 7281. reclaimed land. It likewise grows well with limited
276 Afr. J. Agric. Res.
Figure 1. The character of J. curcas flowers. (A) and (B) A male flower: ten stamens
(s), five petals (p), five sepals (se) and five glands (g). (C) and (D) A female flower:
ovaries (o), three styles, two splits each (arrowhead) five petals (p), five sepals (se)
and three of five glands (g). (E) Structure of an inflorescence (arrowheads show the
pedicels of the fallen male flowers, :female flower, :male flower )
process forms a number of branches when the female structure (Figures 3A and B). Therefore, the
inflorescences are matured (Figure 1E). formation patterns of female and male organs in phase-III
and phase-VI are the same, specifically, from the calyx to
the petal and stamen gland formation.
Phase-III to phase-VI
Figure 2. Scan of J. curcas L. flowers of phase-I to phase-VI. (A) The main inflorescence
primordia emerges, bracketed by a pair of stipules in phase-I. (B) A branch of inflorescence
composed of two lateral inflorescences (arrowheads) and a central flower (*) in phase-II. (C)
Sepal primordia enclose a near spheroid meristem in phase-III. (D) Reproductive meristem like
pentagram as five-petal primordia (*) arise in phase-IV. (E) Five glands primordia (*) arise at the
base of circular-truncated-cone-like floral meristem in phase-V. (F) Stamen primordia arise in
phase-VI. a: apical meristem, st: stipule primordium, se: sepal primordium, p: petal primordium.
Bars = 50 m.
female flowers (Figure 3C). This period is defined as the Sexual differentiation
formation of ovule primordia, and a female flower usually
is shown to have three ovules. In phase-IX, male flowers According to the above-mentioned division of
transform their stamen primordia from heart-shaped to developmental phases of early flowers of J. curcas, no
shallow cleft-shaped (Figure 3F). The formation of each obvious structural difference between male and female
carpel’s top central protuberance (developing into style in flowers can be observed before phase-VII, as similar
the future) is defined as phase-X of female flowers tissues and organs are formed, such as the sepals,
(Figure 4A). In this period, the stamens of male flowers petals, glands, and stamen primordia. In the latter period
develop from shallow cleft-shaped into strips, while their of phase-VI, the flowers whose top starts to elongate
pollen sac begins to take shape and each stamen takes (Figure 3A) will grow as female flowers, while those
on the formation of four pollen sacs (Figure 4D). without further differentiation and development (Figure
At phase-XI, a distinctive developmental feature of both 3D) will grow into male flowers. Thus, in the early stage of
female and male flowers emerges, particularly, their development of female flowers, bisexual tissues are
quickly growing glands (Figures 4B and E). The female prominent (Figure 3A, B and C). In the subsequent
flowers’ stigma is formed and carpel development allows development, male tissues undergo abortion (Figure 4A
the relative separation of the ovule and the surrounding and B), and traces of the stamens of abortion can still be
tissues (Figure 5A). Meanwhile, each anther of the male seen in the nearly mature female flowers (Figure 4C).
flowers is divided into two parts, each part having two Since there is no emergence of female tissues in male
rooms with pollen grains separated from each other flowers, their development process has always been
(Figures 4E and 5B). Growing to phase-XII, the female unisexual (Figures 1A, 3D, E, F; 4D, E and F). Thus,
flowers’ stigma is observed to grow towards development there are mainly two modes for the formation of unisexual
and maturation (Figure 4C), while the male flowers’ flowers of J. curcas: one is the formation of female
filament grows toward elongation and most pollen grains flowers after the later abortive development of male
present are round (Figures 4F and 5C). Not long after this tissues, and the other is the formation of male flowers
period, elongation of flowers, maturity of gametophytes, subject to the early adolescence when there is no
and blossoming of flowers occur. occurrence of female primordia.
Wu et al. 279
Figure 3. Sex differentiation of J. curcas L. flowers in phase-VII to phase-IX. (A) The apical
meristem is elongated during phase-VII of a female flower. (B) Three carpels are established with
ten stamens on the base in phase-VIII of a female flower. (C) Three ovule primordia (arrowhead)
emerge in phase-IX. (D) The apical meristem (asterisk) is arrested and only stamen primordia exist
of the two gender organs in phase-VII of a male flower. (E) The heart-shaped stamen primordia are
formed in phase-VIII of a male flower. (F) Stamen primordia are transformed from heart-shaped to
shallow cleft-shaped structure in phase-IX of a male flower. a: apical meristem, p: petal, s: stamen,
c: carpel. Bars = 50 m
Figure 5. The sections of J. curcas L. flowers in phase-X and phase-XI. (A) The stigma is formed and the ovule
(the future seed) is relatively separated from surrounding tissues; the aborted stamen is visible at the base of the
ovary outside. (B) The pollen grains (arrowhead) start to be formed in phase-X of male flowers. (C) Most pollen
grains (arrowhead) develop into round shape in phase-XI of male flowers. p: petal, s: stamen, gl: gland, ov:
ovule bars = 500 m.
Figure 6. The configuration of J. curcas inflorescences. (A) male-type inflorescence: all flowers are male. (B) A
middle-type inflorescence. (C) A female-type inflorescence: all the places of female sites are occupied by
female flowers. : female flower, : male flower.
Inflorescence classification and ratio The top of the main inflorescence rachis and the central
location where the first and second sub-branches start
As mentioned above, male and female flowers of J. may form the female flowers (Figures 1E and 2B), and
curcas have their significant location features with are thus defined as the female sites. Based on the
respect to their distribution on inflorescence. For the early gender of female sites of inflorescence, the present paper
inflorescence development, the main inflorescence rachis divides inflorescence into three types that can, to some
is divided into a few branches, with each branch extent, reflect the proportion of male and female flowers
composed of a central flower and two sub-branches of of inflorescence, especially the number of female flowers,
inflorescence meristem generated in their maturation as well as reflect the number of their final fruits. When all
(Figure 2B). Then, sub-branches of inflorescence are the female sites of inflorescence are presented as female
differentiated into another central flower and lower sub- flowers, then such inflorescence should be divided into
branches of inflorescence meristem, which no longer female-type inflorescence (Figure 6C). When all of these
appears to be differentiated in inflorescence branches; its sites are presented as male flowers, then all the flowers
end part presents the formation of three to six flowers of such inflorescence are male flowers, referred to as
(Figures 1E and 6B). In this way, mature inflorescence is male-type inflorescence (Figure 6A). When the number of
developed with obviously branched inflorescence rachis. female flowers at the female sites is between the female-
A large number of observations indicate that, the flowers type inflorescence and the male-type inflorescence (that
formed on the third branch of the sub-branched is, the female sites of female flowers at an inflorescence,
inflorescence rachis would only grow into male flowers do not grow all female flowers or male flowers), then such
(Figures 1E, 6B and C), and the locations of intermediate type is called middle-type inflorescence
inflorescence growing flowers are defined as male sites. (Figure 6B).
Wu et al. 281
Table 1. Variance analysis of the female flower number per inflorescence between the
female-type and middle-type inflorescences.
Table 2. Variance analysis of the male: female flower ratio per inflorescence between the
female-type and middle-type inflorescence.
For ease of calculation, the branching inflorescence flower number is zero and the proportion of staminate
generated from the sub-branches of the main flowers and female flowers is infinity. Therefore, there is
inflorescence rachis is called secondary inflorescence extremely remarkable difference with respect to a single
(Figure 1E), which can further branch several times inflorescence’s female flower number and the proportion
during the development. Each secondary inflorescence of female and male of the three types of inflorescences.
has three female sites (Figures 1E and 6C), while the The female flower number and the proportion of female
number of the secondary inflorescence’s male sites are and male flowers for three types of inflorescences are
different on different inflorescences. The statistical shown in Table 3. Herein, the proportion of male and
analysis of the present study has indicated that, the female flowers is 25:1 on average. The proportion of male
secondary inflorescence has an average of 20 male sites. and female flowers and the female floral number of the
Statistics also show that a single inflorescence has an female-type inflorescence are about 15:1 and 16.5,
average of six secondary inflorescences. The variance respectively, while these are 20:1 and 7.2 for the middle-
analysis indicated that there are great differences, type inflorescence.
reaching to an extremely remarkable level (Pr > F, Through the observation for more than two years, it has
<0.0001), between the female-type and the middle-type been discovered that different types of inflorescences
inflorescences with respect to the number of female have different proportions (Table 3). To illustrate, female-
flowers and the proportion of female and male flowers of type inflorescence presents the smallest (0.09%)
a single inflorescence (Tables 1 and 2). However, for proportion, while middle-type presents the largest
different years and different sites, there is no obvious (74.9%). Moreover, different proportions occur in different
difference (Pr > F = 0.56 and 0.56) between the female- seasons for the same type of inflorescence. Since
type and the middle-type inflorescences with respect to jatropha is expected to blossom several times in a year,
the number of female flowers and the proportion of for ease of research, the average of three times of
female and male flowers per inflorescence (Tables 1 and blossoms per year was assumed for the analysis. Based
2). Meanwhile, the male-type inflorescence’s female on this assumption, it is found that female-type and
282 Afr. J. Agric. Res.
Middle-type
3475 0.749 25020 674100 26.94 7.2
inflorescence
Male-type
1075 0.215 0 218225 0
inflorescence
middle-type inflorescences reach the highest proportion functions (Dellaporta and Calderon-Urrea, 1993). Such
of “one-time blossom” during the middle period, while the as in Spinacia oleracea, Mercurialia annua and Pistacia
proportion for the “first-time blossom” reaches the highest vera, only one kind of sex primordia are formed during
for the male-type inflorescence (Figure 7). the flower development process (Durand and Durand,
1984; Sherry et al., 1993; Wannan and Quinn, 1991).
Our results show that there are two modes of formation
DISCUSSION of unisexual flowers in jatropha. In female flowers,
bisexual tissues are present and the androecium
The development of flowering plants is an orderly selectively arrests its future development. In male
progression from the embryo to the mature plant through flowers, only one kind of sex tissue is present, and thus,
continuous organ formation from meristems (Krizek and there is no selective arrest of stamens or pistils. Besides,
Fletcher, 2005). Most studies indicate that both sex organ male and female flowers have similar tissues and organs
primordia occur in the early developmental stages in before female primordia emergence, and these
unisexual flowers (dioecious or monoecious); the development characteristics were also reported in Clusia
selective developmental arrest of preformed organ valerioi (Hochwallner and Weber, 2006). Based on this
primordia is the most common method for generating organization of the flower sexes in jatropha, we propose
unisexual flowers (Delong et al., 1993; Grant et al., that there are factors that regulate sex differentiation in
1994). However, some studies do not support the idea this plant, which may selectively affect the action of
that the production of unisexual flowers is controlled by homeotic genes in one whorl, such as only restraining the
selectively activating or inactivating homeotic gene initiation of a gynoecium meristem in male jatropha
Wu et al. 283
unfulfilled promise. Biomass and Bioenergy 19: 1-15. Wang H, Meng A, Li J, Feng M, Chen Z, Wang W (2006). Floral
Ranade SA, Srivastava AP, Rana TS, Srivastava J, Tuli R (2008). Easy organogenesis of Cocculus orbiculatus and Stephania dielsiana
assessment of diversity in Jatropha curcas L. plants using two (menispermaceae). Inter. J. Plant Sci., 167: 951-960.
single-primer amplification reaction (SPAR) methods. Biomass Wannan BS, Quinn CJ (1991). Floral structure and evolution in the
Bioenergy 32: 533-540. Anacardiaceae. Bot. J. Linnean Soc., 107: 349-385
Sherry RA, Eckard KJ, Lord EM (1993). Flower development in Wei Q, Liao Y, Chen Y, Wang SH, Xu Y, Tang L, Chen F (2005).
dioecious Spinacia oleracea (Chenopodiaceae). Amer. J. Bot., 80: Isolation, characterization and antifungal activity of -1,3-glucanase
283-291. from seeds of Jatropha curcas. South Afr. J. Bot., 71: 95-99.
Smyth DR, Bowman JL, Meyerowitz EM (1990). Early Flower
Development in Arabídopsis. Plant Cell 2: 755-767.
Solomon Raju AJ, Ezradanam V (2002). Pollination ecology and fruiting
behaviour in a monoecious species, Jatropha curcas L.
(Euphorbiaceae). Current Sci. 83: 1395-1398.