Dancerash
Day 3: FMEA
27.03.2019
2610372017 ‘Shreeyash Consulting at
E ‘
{Srreerasn Failure Modes and Effects Analysis
 
 
Failure Moe
=a (Defect) =>] estReal World Scenario
   
    
 
© [ Design: A designer needs to design a new pump to minimize fuel
usage waile maintaining pressure, How do we identify the effect
‘the new pump will have on the fuel usage”
‘Manufacturing: A new screw machine with improved capability is
going to be added to the manufacturing floor, What effect will this
have?
Administrative: A shipping manager needs fo determine how anew
picking process will impact the movement of trucks within the
distribution center. .
How would he know what factors to identify that would impact,
customer deliveries?
 
 
 
[Sieevan In this session you will learn:
«The function of a FMEA
‘+ How to develop a FMEA
«FMEA definitions,
| «Flow to use a Process Map to identify KPIV’s
\d KPOV'sWhat is a FMEA?
aa
AFMEA isa disciplined procedure that allows to
  
antitipate failures and prevent their occurrence in
marjufaetuiting , by Identify ways the product or
 
Ro cee ences
 
Process FMEA
cee |
* Process FMEA: Is an analytical technique utilized
as a means to assure that, to the extent possible,
potential failure modes and their associated
causes / mechanisms have been considered and
addressed in the process stage. It basically deals
with analysis of items that can go wrong based on
experience and past concerns as a process is
developedrecess Important to Understand the
Cause & Effect Relationship iim
 
 
Class Exercise
  
    
 
 
+ Break into groups
« Select a real process or use a common
process such as making coffee
+ Each group will be required to report an
example for each of the three cause
and effect relationshipsFMEA Model
Linking Failure Mode to
Cause and Effect
 
 
 
 
  
 
   
eee Fishbone Model (SM's & E)
  
Materiats = Man Meagurement
 
 
 
x >)Materials Man Mengurement
Ns Ww
Methods Machines < “Environment
 
Goal of FMEA is to understand your process well enough
to anticipate and prevent or detect the Failure Mode,
 
 
 
a
 
 
 
‘ailure Modes-and Effects Analysis Function
as
» Helps to identity potential product/process failure modes early
» Increases the likelihood that all product/process potential
failure modes and their effects will be considered
~ Assists in the analysis of productiprocess design
requirements and alternatives
~ Identifies potential critical characteristics and significant
characteristics
|» Establisties a priority for product/process improvement
| actions:
Documents the rationale behind productiprocess design
| changes
Aids in the development of process control plansWhat do we get from a FMEA?
  
   
 
  
   
 
 
 
 
     
 
 
+ List of potential failure modes
« List of potential critical characteristics and
potential significant characteristics
« List of effects
« List of causes
+ Documentation of current controls
+ Documentation and prioritization of
iinprovement activities
+ Documentation of the history of
 
 
 
Shreevash
Purposes and Benefits of FMEA
+ Improves the quality, reliability, and safety of
products
+ Increase: customer satisfaction
+ Reduces product development timing and cost
+ Documetits and tracks actions taken to reduce risk
 
 
 
 
 
   
 
 
    
‘System FMEA; Used to analyze systems and
‘subsystems in the early concept and design stages.
Focuses on potential failure modes associated with
the functions of a system caused by design.
Design FMEA: Used to analyze products before they
are released to production,
Process FMEA: Used to analyze manufacturing and
assembly processes.
Types of
FMEASSrveova i it
Ss) FMEA Form-Assessing Current Situation
File: Fmeaform,
 
 
 
Rates the Soverit’
‘ofthe Effect tothe
‘Customer on a¥:0
s0 Scale
 
 
 
 
 
 
xls
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Lists tho
 
Effects of each
 
 
Fealluro Mode
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
       
aa
 
 
 
 
 
  
 
15
  
  
 
   
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Lets the Causes for each een
reese ees ieee
ene santa
nee
a pel
Soet mtr
ers Strom
ete ae
: te
6‘Documents action
rocommended base
    
  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
| Designates who is
+ responsible for +
| etion and projected
maetion data
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
7
 
 
‘FMEA Definitions
   
Failure Mode: The! manner in which a part/process can fail tc
meet specification, if
Usually associated with 2 defect or non-conformance.
“How can the process/part fail to meet specifications?” |
“Rexariless of engineering specifiertions, what would
‘a custorter (end user, subsequent operations, or service)
carssider objectionable?”
A failure mode is what we getisee when the process.
deliverable is not correctFailure Effect: Impact on customer if Failure Mode is not prevented
or corrected. Customer can be downstream or the end user.
‘Typical Fuilure Effects: for the end user)
Noisy, Unstable, Rough, Wrong Price
Typical Failure Effects: (for the next operation)
‘Cannot fasten, Cannot bore/tap, Does not fit, Does Hot connect
 
19
 
FMEA Definitions
‘Cause: A deficiency that results in a Failure Mode. Causes are
sourcei:of variability associated with KepProcess Input,
Variables. Causes are described in terms of something that ean
be correeted or controlled.
 
    
    
 
  
 
| ‘Typical failure causes;
Improper settings — e.
Software coding error
Inadequate operator knowledge
Inadequate or n3 lubrication
Inadequate or no preventive maintenance
for welding: current, time, pressurersh
 
ions
 
" Currené Controls: The mechanisms that prevent or
detect the Fallure Mode before it reaches your
customer.
‘Typical Current Controls
Statistical Process Control - SPC
Inspections
Monitoring
‘Comps tency Training/Certification
Preventive Maintenance
 
  
 
 
 
 
Sree FMEA Definitions
 
   
Recommended Actions: Corrective actions to reduce
loccurrence, and/or detection rankings. Directed atthe
Ihighest RPN and critical severity items.
    
 
Note: You san not reduce severity ranking. Your
improvement actlons can only reduce the occurrence of the
|defect and / or the detection of the defect.
 
 
  
2FMEA Definitions
Critical characteristics are those items which affect
customer safety and/or could result in non-
compliance to regulations and thus require controls to
ensure 100% compliance. These are usually process
“settings” such as temperature, time, speed, etc.
Significant Characteristics are those items that
require SPC and Quality planning to ensure
acceptable levels of Quality (Key Process Input
Variables),
 
A
Srceres Steps in the FMEA Process
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
11 Saeet the Process tm 7 Sart the process FMEA by
2. Develop a Process Map and ‘entiying what wil be the
ienay al proces steps fuipat if exch KPOV
3. List all the Key Process Outputs requirement is not satisfied
{o satistyintgraal and external (Failure Modes)
ustomer requirements 8. For exch Failure Mode, identity
4. For each Process Step, list Key the Effects and Causes
races ln 9, Assign Severity to ench Effect
5, Develop CSE matrix eating and an Occurrence and
Product Outputs to Detestion rating t each Cause
Process Inputs 10, Calelate the risk prionity
|6Rantctheinputs according to number foreach potenti failure
Importance meu Z .
. i 11. Determine commended actions | | «
 
 
to reduce high RPNs
12. Take appropriate actions
13. Re-caleulate appropriate RPNs€ Coffee Exercise
"&Smnplete FMEA for Coffee Making Process
Zainal
+ For each important Process Step / Input Variable, jist ways
it can go wrong |
+ Enter thesie into the Failure Mode column of the FMEA. |
work sheet (file: FMEA form.xis)
« For each Failure Mode Identify the Effect, Cause and
Current Control
+ Assign Severity, Occurrence and Detection ratings
+ Calculate RPN’s for each Cause
* Determine recommended actions based on RPN's.
* Group Report:
= Review FMEA
~ Recommend actions for process improvement
 
 
 
 
 
 
2
 
 
 
 
Who Prepares a FMEA?
 
 
     
 
© The team approach to preparing FMEA‘s is recommended.
~ The responsible system, product or manufacturing!
assembly expert leads the FMEA team.
~The responsible design or process expert is expected to
involve representatives from all affected activitiés. Team
‘members should include Design, Manufacturing,
Assembly, Quality, Reliability, Service, Purchasing,
Testing; Supplier, and other subject matter experts as
|__appropiiate. J
Who Updates aFMEA? |
"fete responsible System, Product, or
Manufacturing/ Assembly expert is responsible
for keeping the FMEA up to date.
+ Suppliers keep their own FMEA's up to date.
roShee When is a FMEA Started?
When new systems, products, and processes are being.
designed,
» When existing designs or processes are being changed.
» When carry-over designs/processes will be used in new
applications, or new environments.
| » After completing a Problem Solving Study (to prevent
 
    
    
     
  
  
recutrence of problem) or doing a Six Sigma Project.
» Fora System FMEA, after System “unctions are defined,
but before specific hardware is selected.
» Fora Design FMEA, after product functions are defined,
but before the design is approved and released to
operations.
For a Process FMEA, when preliminary drawings of the
product are available,
 
 
 
 
 
7
 
  
When is aFMEA Updated? |e!
ee
 
+ Wherever a change is being considered to a product's
[ desiga, application, environment, material or its
7 ‘mantifaeturing / service process.
 
 
When is 2 FMEA Completed?
 
 
+ A Design FMEA. is considered completed when the design is
rrelease:l for product
 
+ A Prociss FMEA iv lever completed unless the process is
eliminated.
 
2Grater Process FMEA
 
+ Second step of a Process Review
+ Benefits of a Process FMEA:
— Aid in the analysis of new processes
— Ensute that potential process failure modes and effects will
be considered .
— Identify process deficiencies and provide for the
development of controls to resolve the problems
~ Identify critical characteristics and significant
charecteristics contributing to the development of a
complete Control Plan
— By risk analysis, establish priorities for process
improvement activitiesa |
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Failure Modes and Effe
 
 
 
ts Analy:
Learnings of .......
 
+ Funetion ofa FMEA
+ How to develop a FMEA.
+ FMEA definitionsSeverity rating
    
 
ay,
Severity: Is an assessment of the seriousness of the
effect of the potential failure mode to the customer
+ List dovin potential causes of failure for these effects.
Identify the occurrence for these causes of failuresOccurrence
mechanism is projected to occur.
‘
Put down current process controls to either prevent to
the extent possible the failure mode from occurring or
detect the failure mode should it occur. These controls
can be voke yoke, SPC etc. of post process evaluation.
Sinseyash Consng 36‘Suggested PFMEA OCCURANCE Evaluation Criteria
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
robot tare ‘ety Fate ale — easly
[Very igh: PenonalFolrer [> 100 periRovrand Pieces