Esss-Unit 4
Esss-Unit 4
1. Objective
● Traditional Software Testing: The main goal is to ensure that the software functions as
intended and meets specified requirements. It checks for functionality, performance,
usability, and compatibility.
● Security Testing: The primary objective is to identify vulnerabilities, threats, and risks in
the software. It aims to ensure that data and resources are protected from potential
breaches and unauthorized access.
2. Focus Areas
● Traditional Software Testing: Concentrates on validating the application's features, user
interface, and overall user experience. Common types include unit testing, integration
testing, system testing, and acceptance testing.
● Security Testing: Focuses on areas such as authentication, authorization, data encryption,
and protection against common vulnerabilities (e.g., SQL injection, cross-site scripting). It
often involves penetration testing and vulnerability scanning.
3. Methodologies
● Traditional Software Testing: Uses various methodologies like Waterfall, Agile, or
DevOps. Testing phases are often defined, with a clear sequence of testing activities.
● Security Testing: Employs methodologies like threat modeling and risk assessment. It
often includes both automated and manual testing techniques, emphasizing ongoing
security checks throughout the development lifecycle.
4. Tools and Techniques
● Traditional Software Testing: Utilizes tools like Selenium, JUnit, and QTP for functional
testing. Techniques include black-box testing, white-box testing, and regression testing.
● Security Testing: Uses specialized tools like OWASP ZAP, Burp Suite, and Nessus.
Techniques involve static application security testing (SAST), dynamic application security
testing (DAST), and fuzz testing.
5. Timing
● Traditional Software Testing: Typically performed in later stages of development, often
after the majority of coding is completed.
● Security Testing: Should be integrated throughout the software development lifecycle
(SDLC) to catch vulnerabilities early. It is beneficial to conduct security assessments in
every phase, from design to deployment.
6. Stakeholders
● Traditional Software Testing: Primarily involves testers, developers, and project
managers who focus on delivering functional software.
● Security Testing: Involves security analysts, ethical hackers, and compliance officers, in
addition to the usual development team, ensuring that security is a shared responsibility.
7. Outcome
● Traditional Software Testing: Aims for a stable, reliable product that meets user needs
and specifications.
● Security Testing: Seeks to produce a secure application that minimizes risks and
vulnerabilities, ensuring data integrity and confidentiality.
Traditional Software Testing – Comparison
1. Types of Traditional Software Testing
a. Unit Testing
● Focus: Tests individual components or functions for correctness.
● Performed by: Developers.
● Benefits: Early detection of bugs, facilitates code changes.
● Limitations: Does not test interactions between components.
b. Integration Testing
● Focus: Tests interactions between integrated components or systems.
● Performed by: Developers or dedicated testers.
● Benefits: Identifies interface defects and integration issues.
● Limitations: May overlook some functional aspects of the entire system.
c. System Testing
● Focus: Tests the complete and integrated software system.
● Performed by: Independent testing teams.
● Benefits: Validates the system against requirements.
● Limitations: Can be time-consuming and costly.
d. Acceptance Testing
● Focus: Validates the system’s functionality and performance from the user’s perspective.
● Performed by: End-users or clients.
● Benefits: Ensures the product meets user needs.
● Limitations: May not cover all edge cases or technical requirements.
2. Methodologies
a. Waterfall
● Characteristics: Linear and sequential, with defined phases.
● Advantages: Clear structure, easy to manage.
● Disadvantages: Inflexible to changes; late discovery of defects.
b. Agile
● Characteristics: Iterative and incremental, with frequent feedback.
● Advantages: Adapts to changes quickly; encourages collaboration.
● Disadvantages: Requires disciplined project management; can lead to scope creep.
c. V-Model
● Characteristics: Extends the Waterfall model by emphasizing verification and validation.
● Advantages: Early test planning; clear traceability.
● Disadvantages: Still somewhat rigid; can be slow.
3. Tools and Techniques
a. Manual Testing
● Focus: Test execution by humans without automated tools.
● Benefits: Flexible, can adapt to changes quickly.
● Limitations: Time-consuming and prone to human error.
b. Automated Testing
● Focus: Use of tools to execute tests automatically.
● Benefits: Faster execution, reusable test scripts.
● Limitations: High initial setup cost; requires maintenance.
4. Comparison Factors
Risk-Based Security Testing (RBST) is an approach that prioritizes testing efforts based on
the potential risks associated with different parts of a system or application.
Key Principles of RBST
1. Risk Assessment: Identify and evaluate potential security risks by considering factors like
threat likelihood, impact, and existing vulnerabilities.
2. Prioritization: Focus on testing areas that pose the highest risk to the organization. This
often includes critical business functions, sensitive data, and high-traffic components.
3. Resource Allocation: Optimize the use of testing resources by directing them toward the
most critical areas rather than conducting uniform testing across the entire system.
4. Continuous Monitoring: Implement a feedback loop that allows for ongoing assessment of
risk as new vulnerabilities and threats emerge.
5. Integration with Development: Incorporate RBST into the software development lifecycle
(SDLC) to address security early in the process.
Benefits of RBST
● Efficiency: Reduces the time and cost associated with testing by focusing efforts where they
matter most.
● Improved Security Posture: Helps organizations proactively address high-risk areas before
they can be exploited.
● Enhanced Decision-Making: Provides a clear rationale for security investments based on
assessed risks.
Steps in Risk-Based Security Testing
1. Identify Assets: Catalog the assets that need protection (e.g., applications, databases).
2. Identify Threats and Vulnerabilities: Analyze potential threats and existing vulnerabilities
associated with each asset.
3. Assess Risks: Determine the likelihood and impact of each identified risk.
4. Prioritize Testing Activities: Based on the risk assessment, prioritize which tests to conduct.
5. Execute Testing: Carry out the testing activities on prioritized areas.
6. Report Findings: Document and report the results, focusing on critical vulnerabilities.
7. Remediation and Retesting: Address identified issues and retest to ensure they have been
resolved.
8. Continuous Improvement: Regularly update the risk assessment and testing processes to
adapt to changing threats.
Tools and Techniques
● Static and Dynamic Analysis: Use tools that analyze code and application behavior to
identify vulnerabilities.
● Penetration Testing: Simulate attacks to evaluate the effectiveness of security controls.
● Threat Modeling: Identify potential threats and vulnerabilities during the design phase.
Prioritizing Security Testing With Threat Modeling
Prioritizing security testing through threat modeling is an effective strategy that helps
organizations focus their efforts on the most critical vulnerabilities and potential attack
vectors.
Threat modeling is a structured approach for identifying and assessing potential threats to a system
or application. It helps teams understand security risks and prioritize them based on factors such as
impact, likelihood, and the value of assets at risk.
1. Identify Assets:
○ List all assets, including data, applications, hardware, and user interfaces.
○ Determine the value of each asset to the organization.
2. Identify Threats:
○ Use frameworks like STRIDE (Spoofing, Tampering, Repudiation, Information
Disclosure, Denial of Service, Elevation of Privilege) to categorize potential threats.
○ Consider both external and internal threats.
3. Identify Vulnerabilities:
○ Conduct vulnerability assessments to find weaknesses in the system.
○ Leverage past incident data, penetration testing reports, and security frameworks.
4. Assess Risks:
○ Evaluate the likelihood of each threat exploiting a vulnerability.
○ Determine the potential impact on the organization if the threat were realized.
○ Use a risk matrix to categorize risks as high, medium, or low.
5. Prioritize Testing:
○ Focus on high-risk areas first, ensuring that critical assets and high-impact
vulnerabilities are addressed promptly.
○ Consider the business context and regulatory requirements that may influence
prioritization.
6. Develop Testing Strategy:
○ Based on prioritized risks, create a security testing plan that includes:
■ Static and dynamic analysis
■ Penetration testing
■ Code reviews
■ Configuration audits
7. Execute Testing:
○ Perform security tests according to the developed strategy.
○ Utilize automated tools where possible to increase efficiency.
8. Review and Remediate:
○ Document findings and categorize vulnerabilities based on severity.
○ Work with development teams to address identified vulnerabilities, focusing first on
high-risk items.
9. Continuous Improvement:
○ Regularly revisit the threat model as new assets, threats, or vulnerabilities emerge.
○ Update the testing strategy accordingly to ensure it remains relevant.
Benefits of Integrating Threat Modeling with Security Testing
● Focused Resources: Helps allocate limited testing resources to the areas of greatest risk.
● Proactive Defense: Identifies and mitigates threats before they can be exploited.
● Improved Communication: Facilitates discussions among stakeholders about security
priorities and risks.
● Alignment with Business Goals: Ensures that security efforts support overall business
objectives and compliance requirements.
Penetration Testing
Define Objectives
● Determine Goals: Clarify what you want to achieve with the test, such as identifying
vulnerabilities, assessing security controls, or testing incident response capabilities.
● Stakeholder Engagement: Involve relevant stakeholders (e.g., IT, security, compliance) to
align on objectives and expectations.
2. Identify Scope
● In-Scope Assets: Clearly define which systems, applications, and networks are included in
the test. This may include:
○ Web applications
○ Internal and external networks
○ APIs
○ Mobile applications
● Out-of-Scope Assets: Specify any systems or components that should not be tested to avoid
unintended disruptions.
3. Determine Testing Type
● Black Box: The tester has no prior knowledge of the system. This simulates an external
attacker.
● White Box: The tester has full access to information about the system, such as source code
and architecture. This allows for a more thorough assessment.
● Gray Box: The tester has partial knowledge, combining aspects of both black and white box
testing.
4. Establish Rules of Engagement
● Testing Window: Define when the test will take place (e.g., during business hours, off-
hours).
● Communication Protocols: Set up clear lines of communication between the testing team
and internal staff to report findings or address issues in real time.
● Limitations: Specify any actions that are off-limits (e.g., social engineering, denial-of-service
attacks).
5. Identify Resources and Team
● Testing Team: Determine who will conduct the test (in-house team or external vendor) and
ensure they have the necessary skills and experience.
● Tools and Techniques: Identify tools that will be used for scanning, exploitation, and
reporting.
6. Risk Assessment
● Evaluate Potential Impact: Consider the potential impact of the testing on business
operations, especially for critical systems.
● Mitigation Strategies: Develop strategies to minimize risks, such as backups or failover
plans.
7. Compliance and Legal Considerations
● Authorization: Ensure proper authorization is obtained from relevant stakeholders before
testing begins.
● Legal Requirements: Consider any legal or regulatory requirements that may impact the
testing (e.g., data protection laws).
8. Reporting and Deliverables
● Report Structure: Define what the final report should include, such as:
○ Executive summary
○ Technical findings
○ Risk ratings and recommendations
○ Remediation guidance
● Presentation of Findings: Plan for how results will be communicated to stakeholders,
including follow-up discussions.
9. Post-Testing Activities
● Remediation Planning: Discuss how vulnerabilities will be addressed after the test.
● Retesting: Consider whether a follow-up test is necessary to verify that vulnerabilities have
been resolved.
Enumeration – Remote Exploitation
Enumeration is a crucial phase in penetration testing and ethical hacking, where an attacker
gathers detailed information about a target system or network to identify potential vulnerabilities
that can be exploited remotely. This process typically follows initial reconnaissance and is essential
for planning further attacks.
Web application exploitation involves identifying and taking advantage of vulnerabilities in web
applications to compromise their security. This can lead to unauthorized access, data breaches, and
other malicious outcomes. Below is an overview of the common types of web application
vulnerabilities, exploitation techniques, and best practices for securing web applications.
Common Vulnerabilities
1. SQL Injection (SQLi):
○ Description: Attackers inject malicious SQL queries into input fields to manipulate
the database.
○ Exploitation: Can be used to retrieve, modify, or delete data.
○ Tools: SQLMap, manual testing with crafted queries.
2. Cross-Site Scripting (XSS):
○ Description: Allows attackers to inject malicious scripts into web pages viewed by
other users.
○ Types:
■ Stored XSS: Scripts are stored on the server.
■ Reflected XSS: Scripts are reflected off a web server.
○ Exploitation: Can steal cookies, session tokens, or redirect users to malicious sites.
○ Tools: Burp Suite, OWASP ZAP.
3. Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF):
○ Description: Tricks users into executing unwanted actions on a web application
where they're authenticated.
○ Exploitation: Can change user settings, initiate transactions, or perform actions
without user consent.
○ Tools: Custom scripts or tools like Burp Suite.
4. Remote File Inclusion (RFI) / Local File Inclusion (LFI):
○ Description: Allows attackers to include files from remote or local servers.
○ Exploitation: Can lead to code execution or disclosure of sensitive information.
○ Tools: Manual testing with crafted URLs.
5. Command Injection:
○ Description: Allows attackers to execute arbitrary commands on the server.
○ Exploitation: Can lead to full server compromise.
○ Tools: Custom scripts, Burp Suite.
6. Insecure Direct Object References (IDOR):
○ Description: Occurs when an application exposes references to objects, such as files
or database entries, without proper authorization checks.
○ Exploitation: Attackers can access or modify data they should not be able to.
Exploitation Techniques
1. Input Validation Bypass:
○ Craft input to bypass validation checks (e.g., using special characters or SQL
queries).
2. Session Hijacking:
○ Steal session tokens through XSS or insecure cookie handling.
3. Parameter Manipulation:
○ Alter URL parameters, POST data, or headers to exploit vulnerabilities.
4. Brute Force Attacks:
○ Attempt to gain access through credential stuffing or password guessing.
5. Social Engineering:
○ Use deceptive techniques to trick users into providing sensitive information.
Tools for Web Application Exploitation
● Burp Suite: A comprehensive tool for web application security testing, including
interception, scanning, and exploitation.
● OWASP ZAP: An open-source web application security scanner that helps identify
vulnerabilities.
● SQLMap: An automated tool for SQL injection and database takeover.
● Metasploit: A penetration testing framework that includes modules for web application
exploitation.
Best Practices for Securing Web Applications
1. Input Validation and Sanitization:
○ Always validate and sanitize user inputs to prevent injection attacks.
2. Use Prepared Statements:
○ For SQL queries, use prepared statements or parameterized queries to prevent SQL
injection.
3. Implement Content Security Policy (CSP):
○ Helps prevent XSS by restricting the sources from which scripts can be loaded.
4. Secure Session Management:
○ Use secure cookies, set proper expiration, and regenerate session IDs after login.
5. Regular Security Audits:
○ Conduct regular security assessments and penetration testing to identify
vulnerabilities.
6. Educate Users:
○ Train users on recognizing phishing attempts and practicing good security hygiene.
Exploits and Client Side Attacks
1. Types of Firewalls:
○ Packet Filtering Firewalls: Inspect packets and allow or block
them based on IP addresses, ports, and protocols.
○ Stateful Inspection Firewalls: Track the state of active
connections and make decisions based on the context of the
traffic.
○ Application Layer Firewalls: Monitor traffic at the application
layer, providing deeper inspection of web traffic and other
protocols.
○ Next-Generation Firewalls (NGFW): Combine traditional
firewall capabilities with additional features such as intrusion
prevention, application awareness, and threat intelligence.
2. Functionality:
○ Traffic Filtering: Allow or deny traffic based on security rules.
○ Logging and Monitoring: Record traffic patterns and alert on
suspicious activities.
○ Network Address Translation (NAT): Hide internal IP
addresses from external entities.
Strategies for Avoiding Detection
1. Evasion Techniques:
○ Packet Fragmentation: Break malicious payloads into smaller
packets that may not trigger alerts when inspected.
○ Protocol Tunneling: Encapsulate data in a protocol that is
permitted by the firewall (e.g., using HTTPS or DNS).
○ HTTP/S Tunneling: Use common web protocols to disguise
malicious traffic as normal web traffic.
2. Using Non-Standard Ports:
○ Description: Many firewalls focus on standard ports (like 80 and
443). Using non-standard ports can help evade detection.
○ Example: Running services on ports like 8080 or others that are
not commonly monitored.
3. Traffic Obfuscation:
○ Description: Modify the payload or encrypt it to make it less
recognizable by security systems.
○ Techniques: Base64 encoding, encryption, or using legitimate
tools to execute commands.
4. Slow and Low Attacks:
○ Strategy: Conduct actions at a slow pace to avoid triggering
alarms set for unusual activity patterns.
○ Implementation: Space out scanning attempts or data
exfiltration actions over a longer time frame.
5. Avoiding Signature-Based Detection:
○ Description: Change known attack patterns to evade signature-
based detection mechanisms.
○ Techniques: Use polymorphic payloads that alter their
appearance each time they are executed.
6. Using VPNs and Proxies:
○ Description: Route traffic through VPNs or proxies to mask the
source IP address and encrypt the data.
○ Considerations: Choose reputable services to maintain
anonymity.
7. Employing Legitimate Services:
○ Description: Use legitimate applications or services (like cloud
services) to perform actions that may appear normal to the
firewall.
○ Example: Utilizing remote management tools for administrative
tasks.
Tools for Penetration Testing