Tema 2 Oposiciones Ingles
Tema 2 Oposiciones Ingles
INDEX
1. INTRODUCTION..................................................................................................................2
2. GENERAL THEORIES ON LEARNING AND ACQUISITION OF A FOREIGN /
SECOND LANGUAGE.............................................................................................................3
2.1. Linguistics........................................................................................................................3
2.2. Sociolinguistics.................................................................................................................5
2.3. Cognitive theory..............................................................................................................8
2.4. Neuroscience....................................................................................................................9
2.4. Monitor Model................................................................................................................10
3. THE CONCEPT OF INTERLANGUAGE........................................................................11
4. THE TREATMENT OF ERROR.......................................................................................13
5. LEGISLATION....................................................................................................................14
6. CONCLUSIONS..................................................................................................................16
7. BIBLIOGRAPHICAL REFERENCES..............................................................................16
1. INTRODUCTION
Language didactics, and methodologies and theories on FLA and SLA are directly
associated with the learning-teaching process, since their success is usually evidenced in
the general process and outcomes shown by the learners throughout time. As new
methodologies and theories emerge, so should the need to update the education system
in order to apply the most successful ones.
The main aim of this study is to (1) outline some general theories related to the
acquisition and learning of a foreign / second language from different perspectives –
linguistics, sociolinguistics, cognitive psychology etc.– Furthermore, I will (2) analyse
the concept of interlanguage and (3) the evolution of the treatment of error. I will finally
wrap up with some general conclusions and add bibliographical references at the end.
This topic can be quite helpful to, among many aspects, reflect in-depth about the
evolution of foreign/ second language didactics over the passage of time and
consequently, the changes that have taken place in the Spanish educational system with
respect to the treatment of foreign languages and that evidence a progress from more
traditional methodologies, which focused on grammar, translation, and a different
treatment of errors, to more modern ones, with use of ICT and access to a broader scope
of the TL culture and community and treating errors as part of the learning process. As
Noam Chomsky said “A language is not just words, it’s a culture, a tradition, a
unification of a community, a whole history that creates what a community is. It’s all
embodied in a language” (2010). Moreover, it may foster some consideration on our
own methodologies as teachers, whether they are helpful or should be modified and
brings about the need to be updated on SLA theories and use the experience of teachers
to keep learning and never settle in our knowledge.
2. GENERAL THEORIES ON LEARNING AND ACQUISITION OF
A FOREIGN / SECOND LANGUAGE
2.1. Linguistics
Among the early theories on SLA in the linguistic field two basic theories are
connected. Behaviourism, which accounts for both first and second language
acquisition and a structuralist approach to the study of language.
In the case of SLA, it occurs in a similar fashion. With positive reinforcement and
correction of wrong imitations. Furthermore, active participation by the learner is
considered a crucial element of the learning process.
The salient characteristic of SLA that differentiates it from child language learning is
that L2 learners already know a first language (L1), which must be overcome in the
process of acquiring a second language. This process is difficult but can be facilitated
by appropriate instruction. Learners should be exposed to a large number of target
examples of language; they should imitate these models repeatedly and receive
appropriate feedback: positive feedback for accurate imitations and correction of
inaccurate ones. This process should be repeated until these behaviours have become
automatic and error-free.
Since the dawn of philosophy, thinkers and linguists have argued whether humans
have innate ideas, as claimed by Plato, or whether the mind is a blank slate on which
experience writes (John Locke). Chomsky gave a twist to this debate in the 1960s by
claiming that children just do not have enough information to speak to form the
complex grammatical manoeuvres that allows to generate unlimited amount of
sentences, yet they do so with ease.
Chomsky’s hypothesis explains there are inborn strategies in our brains: Language
Acquisition Device (LAD) which gives humans a natural propensity to organise the
spoken language we hear in various grammatical patterns: sentences, words, nouns…
According to this theory, there is a universal grammar for all languages, meaning they
share basic grammatical concepts and humans are born with this ability. Therefore, this
theory involves three main ideas: every child knows basic grammar rules, all languages
follow same basic grammar structures and children do not make expected basic
grammar errors, but more complicated, as they already know the basics according to
Chomsky.
2) The learner has a capacity for language use which consists of primary and
secondary discourse and cognitive processes.
2.2. Sociolinguistics
According to Giles, both convergence and divergence can be used depending on the
context, that is, divergence can be used to assert one’s individuality (being British or
Spanish in a context that requires so, for example). However, relationships and personal
communication are built when there is convergence, since the speaker adapts to the
environment they find themselves in.
In the context of SLA/ FLA, progress takes place when the overall predisposition of
the learner is towards convergence, since they try to imitate the TL and have a positive
attitude towards the TL. On the contrary, fossilisation occurs when the overall
predisposition of the learner is towards divergence.
2. Attitudes/ Motivation.
In their study of the good language learner, Naiman et al. (1978) conclude that
attitude plays a more important role in language learning than Gardner & Lambert’s
(1972) integrative and instrumental orientations. They also claim that a positive attitude
is a necessary, although not sufficient, condition for success, being the most important
condition at early stages.
a) Brown (1987), who alluded directly to the importance of the context to determine
a type of motivation:
“... Some learners in some contexts are more successful in learning a language
if they are integratively oriented, and others in different contexts benefit from an
instrumental orientation.” (Brown 1987:116)
In relation to motivation in-depth, scholars agree with the idea that there are different
types of motivation:
2) Need for achievement is very powerful in academic fields vs fear of failure which
is rooted in general anxiety.
H.D. Brown (1987) distinguishes as well three levels of motivation, all of which
need to be present for efficient L2 learning. These are: global, towards learning a
particular L2; situational, related to the context of learning and task-oriented, related to
specific activities.
Finally, Entwistle (1981) identified four types of students according to the type of
motivation they exhibit:
Entwistle (1987) also distinguishes through Béla Kozéki (1985) different styles of
motivation related to the type of reward the student is seeking, these are: affective
motivation, who requires a reward by relevant ‘others’; cognitive motivation, who
follows academic success and moral motivation, which requires a balanced personality
with clear moral values. A mixture of the three of them seems to be the path for a clear
academic success, but it is important to point out that parents and teachers should not
encourage an exclusive cognitive motivation, since it may foment cold, aloof and
possibly amoral students.
2.3. Cognitive theory
One of the most interesting lines of study in this field is the skill acquisition theory,
which can be found in various fields such as psychology, behaviourism or cognitivism.
This theory (developed, among others, in John Robert Anderson’s Adaptive Control of
Thought- Rational theory) claims that learning a wide variety of skills usually shows a
similar pattern in the development from initial representation of the knowledge, through
changes in behaviour to an eventual spontaneous and effortless performance of that
activity. Furthermore, there are two types of knowledge:
2) Procedural knowledge refers to the knowledge that can only be performed, such as
how to swim, to do mental arithmetic, or to speak fluently. Sometimes called task
knowledge, or also knowledge how as opposed to knowledge that.
Faerch and Kasper (1985) were the first to apply this concept in the field of SLA,
stating that declarative knowledge consists of internalised interlanguage rules and
memorised chunks of language, whereas procedural knowledge refers to those strategies
and procedures used to process L2 information. As they suggest, most declarative
knowledge is activated in a conscious manner, while procedural knowledge tends to be
more automatic and is activated without awareness, except when the language user has
interruptions in communication.
Generally speaking, researchers claim there are three stages of development, usually
named as cognitive stage, associative stage and autonomous stage. In the cognitive
stage, the student or learner may acquire a bit of knowledge about the skill, in the case
of second languages. This knowledge is usually acquired through perceptive
observation and analysis of others doing the skill or with a combination of both. During
the associative stage declarative knowledge turns into procedural knowledge, that is,
provided that relevant declarative knowledge is available and used in the execution, this
turn into procedural knowledge can be achieved after a few trials. However, a large
amount of practice is needed to decrease the time required to execute the task, the
percentage of errors and the amount of attention required. This practice leads to the
autonomous stage, when performance is done autonomously, effortlessly and less
consciously.
As some scholars have argued, in the field of SLA, simply knowing 'about' the
language is insufficient if the learner wants to be able to use the language for successful
communication. To use the L2 functionally the learner must have acquired the necessary
procedural knowledge, which, in Anderson's terms, can only be mastered slowly and after
a great deal of practice. With this in mind it becomes clear that L2 teachers need to
concentrate on providing learners with communicative activities which focus on language
as the acquisition of a skill rather than as an object of study
2.4. Neuroscience
The most interesting lines of research in this field are based on clinical examinations
of aphasics. Two important objectives became the establishment of hemisphere
dominance and finding a critical age in language learning.
1. Hemisphere dominance
Research supports that some language components are processed by the left
hemisphere, while others are processed by the right hemisphere. It is language learning
strategies which determine right or left hemisphere processing. Moreover, two types of
bilingual speakers have been identified according to some studies, compound
bilingualism, in which left hemisphere is the dominant, and co-ordinate bilingualism,
where left and right hemispheres are balanced. Also, according to the type of SLA there
is a different activation of the brain: informal learning is related to right hemisphere
activity, while the left hemisphere is more active in formal learning e.g. school learning.
The Critical Period Hypothesis of Lenneberg (1967) comprises two related ideas,
The first idea is that certain biological events related to language development can only
happen in an early critical period. In particular, hemispheric specialization takes place
during the critical period, and during this time children possesses a degree of flexibility
that is lost when the critical period is finished. The second component of the Critical
Period Hypothesis is that certain linguistic events must happen to the child during this
period for development to proceed normally. Proponents of this theory argue that
language is acquired most efficiently during the critical period.
The most important idea of Critical Period Hypothesis is that unless children receive
linguistic input during the critical period, they will be unable to acquire language
normally. One of the most famous of these cases was the Wild Boy of Aveyron, a child
found in isolated woods in south of France in 1800. Despite attempts by an
educationalist named Dr Itard to socialize the boy, given the name Victor, and to teach
him language, he never learned more than two words.
It is less easy to apply this argument to the unfortunate child known as “Genie”.
Genie was a child who was apparently normal at birth, but suffered severe linguistic
deprivation. From the age of 20 months until she was 13 years and 9 months, when she
was found, she had been isolated in a small room. Not surprisingly, Genie’s linguistic
abilities were virtually non-existent.
1) Free variation, the most common among beginners, when students are still trying
to figure out the rules that govern the language.
3) Other factors, e.g. the time to prepare their speech, the accommodation to the
interlocutor, the affective filter…
In order to acquire and learn a second language, a process with several stages takes
place:
2. Forming a hypothesis based on that identification, that is, they form questions
using that same chunk as they believe it is used for every type of question.
3. Testing the hypothesis by means of receptive skills e.g. the speaker will break the
chunk “do you” and use it correctly when the rules are explained.
4. Receiving feedback by means or productive skills, that is, when they express
themselves in written and oral forms.
5. Delaying the decision on the rule until more feedback is provided, or either
accepting or rejecting the hypothesis.
There are several fields of research that have come up with ideas on how to analyse
errors when they come up in a second language learning. Some of them are the
following ones, explained in a chronological order:
Therefore, results from the SLA research reveal that errors are inevitable as part of
the learning process, they signals of progression and affective variables should be taken
into account, for instance, providing students with positive feedback.
Errors are classified according to the stage of learning and type of error:
a) Transfer, the most common error during the first stages in language learning. It
happens when learners use their L1 to organise L2 data. As a learning strategy, transfer
is economical and productive in those aspects where the two languages have similar
rules. However, learners must set the limits to this strategy and start applying the L2
rules that have been acquired.
c) Simplification. It happens when learners omit language items or rules. Its two
main types of simplification are:
According to some research on the issue, the higher percentage of errors vary
according to the learning stages, i.e., interference errors are more frequent among
beginners, while developmental errors are more common in intermediate and advanced
learners.
5. LEGISLATION
This topic can be applicable to the curriculum for teaching second languages in
Secondary Education in Spain following the different education laws and their contents.
A great part of the theories mentioned throughout this topic discuss the importance of
acquiring a language through communication and in different types of discourses, such
as the variable competence model, the accommodation theory or the monitor model.
Their ideas are correlated with some of the ideas contemplated in LOE (Article 19) and
previous legislation, which states that teachers should give importance to oral
expression and comprehension rather than focusing explicitly on the rules and grammar,
i.e. a focus on unconscious learning rather than conscious learning, the latter of which is
more prone to be forgotten or fossilized.
The different education laws also imply the importance of learning a second
language taking not only into consideration the language itself, but everything that
surrounds it: culture, geography, community… The social and civic competence
bolsters an open and positive vision of respect to other cultures and people and fosters
the capacity of the students to adapt themselves to different kinds of situations.
6. CONCLUSIONS
To sum up, the majority of the theories exposed in the previous chapters provide
teachers and researchers on SLA of helpful ideas on how to approach second language
teaching, not only in Secondary education, but in every teaching field. Some of these
ideas are interesting to be pointed out:
The importance given to Second language culture and its community, as explained
by researchers belonging to behaviourism or sociolinguistics. It is of great significance
to provide students with a proper input that is adapted but also that is real, and to teach
students how to behave like the TL culture, to imitate them, since the acquisition will be
much easier. Moreover, neurolinguistics shows that teenagers especially are students
that can acquire much more information with a proper input. A good way to achieve this
is through realia, real materials taken from the TL culture, such as videos, pieces of
newspapers, extracts from novels…
Finally, the attention paid to motivation and attitude plays an important role in SLA
nowadays. As the different researches on this topic show, students have different
attitudes towards learning a language depending on their backgrounds, their fear of
committing errors, their past experiences learning a language… Therefore, teachers
need to take them into account and act according to that. Furthermore, they need to
create a positive environment in classroom with a proactive attitude in order to foster
their interest for the language and culture of the TL, as Deci and Ryan (1985: 245)
explain:
Chomsky, Noam (1957) Syntactic structures in Language, vol.33 nº3, pp. 375-408.
Ellis, Rod (1985) Understanding Second Language Acquisition. Oxford. Oxford University
Press.
Gardner, Robert C & Lambert, Wallace E. (1972) Attitudes and motivation in second-
language learning. Newbury House Publishers.