Mefa Unit-5
Mefa Unit-5
Introduction
Finance is the prerequisite to commence and vary on business. It is rightly said to be the
lifeblood of the business. No growth and expansion of business can take place without
sufficient finance. It shows that no business activity is possible without finance. This is
why; every business has to make plans regarding acquisition and utilization of funds.
Function of finance
Investment Decision
The investment decision relates to the selection of assets in which funds will be invested
by a firm. The assets as per their duration of benefits, can be categorized into two groups:
(i) long-term assets which yield a return over a period of time in future (ii) short-term or
current assents which in the normal course of business are convertible into cash usually
with in a year. Accordingly, the asset selection decision of a firm is of two types. The
investment in long-term assets is popularly known as capital budgeting and in short-term
assets, working capital management.
The long-term investment may relate to acquisition of new asset or replacement of old
assets. Whether an asset will be accepted or not will depend upon the relative benefits
and returns associated with it. The measurement of the worth of the investment proposals
is, therefore, a major element in the capital budgeting exercise. The second element of
the capital budgeting decision is the analysis of risk and uncertainty as the benefits from
the investment proposals pertain the future, which is uncertain. They have to be
estimated under various assumptions and thus there is an element of risk involved in the
141
exercise. The return from the capital budgeting decision should, therefore, be evaluated in
relation to the risk associated with it.
The third and final element is the ascertainment of a certain norm or standard against
which the benefits are to be judged. The norm is known by different names such as cut-off
rate, hurdle rate, required rate, minimum rate of return and so on. This standard is
broadly expressed in terms of the cost of capital is, thus, another major aspect of the
capital; budgeting decision. In brief, the main elements of the capital budgeting decision
are: (i) The total assets and their composition (ii) The business risk complexion of the
firm, and (iii) concept and measurement of the cost of capital.
Finance Decision
The second major decision involved in financial management is the financing decision,
which is concerned with the financing – mix or capital structure of leverage. The term
capital structure refers to the combination of debt (fixed interest sources of financing) and
equity capital (variable – dividend securities/source of funds). The financing decision of a
firm relates to the choice of the proportion of these sources to finance the investment
requirements. A higher proportion of debt implies a higher return to the shareholders and
also the higher financial risk and vice versa. A proper balance between debt and equity is
a must to ensure a trade – off between risk and return to the shareholders. A capital
structure with a reasonable proportion of debt and equity capital is called the optimum
capital structure.
The second aspect of the financing decision is the determination of an appropriate capital
structure, which will result, is maximum return to the shareholders and in turn maximizes
the worth of the firm. Thus, the financing decision covers two inter-related aspects: (a)
capital structure theory, and (b) capital structure decision.
The third major decision of financial management is relating to dividend policy. The firm
has two alternatives with regard to management of profits of a firm. They can be either
distributed to the shareholder in the form of dividends or they can be retained in the
business or even distribute some portion and retain the remaining. The course of action to
be followed is a significant element in the dividend decision. The dividend pay out ratio i.
e. the proportion of net profits to be paid out to the shareholders should be in tune with
the investment opportunities available within the firm. The second major aspect of the
dividend decision is the study of factors determining dividend policy of a firm in practice.
142
Working capital analysis
Finance is required for two purpose viz. for it establishment and to carry out the day-to-
day operations of a business. Funds are required to purchase the fixed assets such as
plant, machinery, land, building, furniture, etc, on long-term basis. Investments in these
assets represent that part of firm‟s capital, which is blocked on a permanent of fixed basis
and is called fixed capital. Funds are also needed for short-term purposes such as the
purchase of raw materials, payment of wages and other day-to-day expenses, etc. and
these funds are known as working capital. In simple words working capital refers that part
of the firm‟s capital, which is required for financing short term or current assets such as
cash, marketable securities, debtors and inventories. The investment in these current
assets keeps revolving and being constantly converted into cash and which in turn
financed to acquire current assets. Thus the working capital is also known as revolving or
circulating capital or short-term capital.
Current liabilities are those liabilities, which are intend to be paid in the ordinary course of
business within a short period, normally one accounting year out of the current assets or
the income of the business. Net working capital may be positive or negative. When the
143
current assets exceed the current liabilities net working capital is positive and the negative
net working capital results when the liabilities are more then the current assets.
1. Bills payable
2. Sundry Creditors or Accounts Payable.
3. Accrued or Outstanding Expanses.
4. Short term loans, advances and deposits.
5. Dividends payable
6. Bank overdraft
7. Provision for taxation etc.
On the basis of concept, working capital is classified as gross working capital and net
working capital is discussed earlier. This classification is important from the point of view
of the financial manager. On the basis of time, working capital may be classified as:
Temporary working capital differs from permanent working capital in the sense that it is
required for short periods and cannot be permanently employed gainfully in the business.
Figures given below illustrate the different between permanent and temporary working
capital.
144
Importance of working capital
Working capital is refereed to be the lifeblood and nerve center of a business. Working
capital is as essential to maintain the smooth functioning of a business as blood circulation
in a human body. No business can run successfully with out an adequate amount of
working capital. The main advantages of maintaining adequate amount of working capital
are as follows:
The need for working capital arises mainly due to the time gap between production and
realization of cash. The process of production and sale cannot be done instantaneously
and hence the firm needs to hold the current assets to fill-up the time gaps. There are
time gaps in purchase of raw materials and production; production and sales: and sales
and realization of cash. The working capital is needed mainly for the following purposes:
145
2. To pay wages, salaries and other day-to-day expenses and overhead cost such as
fuel, power and office expenses, etc.
3. To meet the selling expenses such as packing, advertising, etc.
4. To provide credit facilities to the customers and
5. To maintain the inventories of raw materials, work-in-progress, stores and spares
and finishes stock etc.
Generally, the level of working capital needed depends upon the time gap (known as
operating cycle) and the size of operations. Greater the size of the business unit generally,
larger will be the requirements of working capital. The amount of working capital needed
also goes on increasing with the growth and expansion of business. Similarly, the larger
the operating cycle, the larger the requirement for working capital. There are many other
factors, which influence the need of working capital in a business, and these are discussed
below in the following pages.
There are a large number of factors such as the nature and size of business, the character
of their operations, the length of production cycle, the rate of stock turnover and the state
of economic situation etc. that decode requirement of working capital. These factors have
different importance and influence on firm differently. In general following factors
generally influence the working capital requirements.
146
Generally, during the busy season, a firm requires larger working capital then in the
slack season.
6. Working capital cycle: In a manufacturing concern, the working capital cycle
starts with the purchase of raw material and ends with the realization of cash from
the sale of finished products. This cycle involves purchase of raw materials and
stores, its conversion into stocks of finished goods through work–in progress with
progressive increment of labour and service costs, conversion of finished stock into
sales, debtors and receivables and ultimately realization of cash. This cycle
continues again from cash to purchase of raw materials and so on. In general the
longer the operating cycle, the larger the requirement of working capital.
7. Credit policy: The credit policy of a concern in its dealings with debtors and
creditors influences considerably the requirements of working capital. A concern
that purchases its requirements on credit requires lesser amount of working capital
compared to the firm, which buys on cash. On the other hand, a concern allowing
credit to its customers shall need larger amount of working capital compared to a
firm selling only on cash.
8. Business cycles: Business cycle refers to alternate expansion and contraction in
general business activity. In a period of boom, i.e., when the business is
prosperous, there is a need for larger amount of working capital due to increase in
sales. On the contrary, in the times of depression, i.e., when there is a down swing
of the cycle, the business contracts, sales decline, difficulties are faced in collection
from debtors and firms may have to hold large amount of working capital.
9. Rate of growth of business: The working capital requirements of a concern
increase with the growth and expansion of its business activities. The retained
profits may provide for a part of working capital but the fast growing concerns need
larger amount of working capital than the amount of undistributed profits.
Source of finance
Incase of proprietorship business, the individual proprietor generally invests his own
savings to start with, and may borrow money on his personal security or the security of
his assets from others. Similarly, the capital of a partnership from consists partly of funds
contributed by the partners and partly of borrowed funds. But the company from of
organization enables the promoters to raise necessary funds from the public who may
contribute capital and become members (share holders) of the company. In course of its
business, the company can raise loans directly from banks and financial institutions or by
issue of securities (debentures) to the public. Besides, profits earned may also be
reinvested instead of being distributed as dividend to the shareholders.
Thus for any business enterprise, there are two sources of finance, viz, funds contributed
by owners and funds available from loans and credits. In other words the financial
resources of a business may be own funds and borrowed funds.
The ownership capital is also known as „risk capital‟ because every business runs the risk
of loss or low profits, and it is the owner who bears this risk. In the event of low profits
they do not have adequate return on their investment. If losses continue the owners may
be unable to recover even their original investment. However, in times of prosperity and
in the case of a flourishing business the high level of profits earned accrues entirely to the
owners of the business. Thus, after paying interest on loans at a fixed rate, the owners
may enjoy a much higher rate of return on their investment. Owners contribute risk
capital also in the hope that the value of the firm will appreciate as a result of higher
earnings and growth in the size of the firm.
147
The second characteristic of this source of finance is that ownership capital remains
permanently invested in the business. It is not refundable like loans or borrowed capital.
Hence a large part of it is generally used for a acquiring long – lived fixed assets and to
finance a part of the working capital which is permanently required to hold a minimum
level of stock of raw materials, a minimum amount of cash, etc.
Merits:
Arising out of its characteristics, the advantages of ownership capital may be briefly stated
as follows:
Limitations:
There are also certain limitations of ownership capital as a source of finance. These are:
The amount of capital, which may be raised as owners fund depends on the number of
persons, prepared to take the risks involved. In a partnership confer, a few persons
cannot provide ownership capital beyond a certain limit and this limitation is more so in
case of proprietary form of organization.
A joint stock company can raise large amount by issuing shares to the public. Bus it leads
to an increased number of people having ownership interest and right of control over
management. This may reduce the original investors‟ power of control over management.
Being a permanent source of capital, ownership funds are not refundable as long as the
company is in existence, even when the funds remain idle.
A company may find it difficult to raise additional ownership capital unless it has high
profit-earning capacity or growth prospects. Issue of additional shares is also subject to so
many legal and procedural restrictions.
Borrowed funds and borrowed capital: It includes all funds available by way of loans or
credit. Business firms raise loans for specified periods at fixed rates of interest. Thus
borrowed funds may serve the purpose of long-term, medium-term or short-term finance.
The borrowing is generally at against the security of assets from banks and financial
institutions. A company to borrow the funds can also issue various types of debentures.
Interest on such borrowed funds is payable at half yearly or yearly but the principal
amount is being repaid only at the end of the period of loan. These interest and principal
payments have to be met even if the earnings are low or there is loss. Lenders and
creditors do not have any right of control over the management of the borrowing firm. But
148
they can sue the firm in a law court if there is default in payment, interest or principal
back.
Merits:
From the business point of view, borrowed capital has several merits.
1. It does not affect the owner‟s control over management.
2. Interest is treated as an expense, so it can be charged against income and amount
of tax payable thereby reduced.
3. The amount of borrowing and its timing can be adjusted according to convenience
and needs, and
4. It involves a fixed rate of interest to be paid even when profits are very high, thus
owners may enjoy a much higher rate of return on investment then the lenders.
Limitations:
There are certain limitations, too in case of borrowed capacity. Payment of interest and
repayment of loans cannot be avoided even if there is a loss. Default in meeting these
obligations may create problems for the business and result in decline of its credit
worthiness. Continuing default may even lead to insolvency of firm.
Secondly, it requires adequate security to be offered against loans. Moreover, high rates
of interest may be charged if the firm‟s ability to repay the loan in uncertain.
Based upon the time, the financial resources may be classified into (1) sources of long
term (2) sources of short – term finance. Some of these sources also serve the purpose of
medium – term finance.
1. Issue of shares
2. Issue debentures
3. Loan from financial institutions
4. Retained profits and
5. Public deposits
1. Trade credit
2. Bank loans and advances and
3. Short-term loans from finance companies.
1. Issue of Shares: The amount of capital decided to be raised from members of the
public is divided into units of equal value. These units are known as share and the
aggregate values of shares are known as share capital of the company. Those who
subscribe to the share capital become members of the company and are called
shareholders. They are the owners of the company. Hence shares are also
described as ownership securities.
149
2. Issue of Preference Shares: Preference share have three distinct characteristics.
Preference shareholders have the right to claim dividend at a fixed rate, which is
decided according to the terms of issue of shares. Moreover, the preference
dividend is to be paid first out of the net profit. The balance, it any, can be
distributed among other shareholders that is, equity shareholders. However,
payment of dividend is not legally compulsory. Only when dividend is declared,
preference shareholders have a prior claim over equity shareholders.
Preference shareholders also have the preferential right of claiming repayment of capital
in the event of winding up of the company. Preference capital has to be repaid out of
assets after meeting the loan obligations and claims of creditors but before any amount is
repaid to equity shareholders.
Holders of preference shares enjoy certain privileges, which cannot be claimed by the
equity shareholders. That is why; they cannot directly take part in matters, which may be
discussed at the general meeting of shareholders, or in the election of directors.
Depending upon the terms of conditions of issue, different types of preference shares may
be issued by a company to raises funds. Preference shares may be issued as:
1. Cumulative or Non-cumulative
2. Participating or Non-participating
3. Redeemable or Non-redeemable, or as
4. Convertible or non-convertible preference shares.
In the case of cumulative preference shares, the dividend unpaid if any in previous years
gets accumulated until that is paid. No cumulative preference shares have any such
provision.
Participatory shareholders are entitled to a further share in the surplus profits after a
reasonable divided has been paid to equity shareholders. Non-participating preference
shares do not enjoy such right. Redeemable preference shares are those, which are repaid
after a specified period, where as the irredeemable preference shares are not repaid.
However, the company can also redeem these shares after a specified period by giving
notice as per the terms of issue. Convertible preference shows are those, which are
entitled to be converted into equity shares after a specified period.
Merits:
Many companies due to the following reasons prefer issue of preference shares as a
source of finance.
Limitations:
150
2. Even through payment of dividend is not legally compulsory, if it is not paid or
arrears accumulate there is an adverse effect on the company‟s credit.
3. Issue of preference share does not attract many investors, as the return is
generally limited and not exceed the rates of interest on loan. On the other than,
there is a risk of no dividend being paid in the event of falling income.
1. Issue of Equity Shares: The most important source of raising long-term capital for a
company is the issue of equity shares. In the case of equity shares there is no promise to
shareholders a fixed dividend. But if the company is successful and the level profits are
high, equity shareholders enjoy very high returns on their investment. This feature is very
attractive to many investors even through they run the risk of having no return if the
profits are inadequate or there is loss. They have the right of control over the
management of the company and their liability is limited to the value of shares held by
them.
From the above it can be said that equity shares have three distinct characteristics:
1. The holders of equity shares are the primary risk bearers. It is the issue of equity
shares that mainly provides „risk capital‟, unlike borrowed capital. Even compared
with preference capital, equity shareholders are to bear ultimate risk.
2. Equity shares enable much higher return sot be earned by shareholders during
prosperity because after meeting the preference dividend and interest on borrowed
capital at a fixed rate, the entire surplus of profit goes to equity shareholders only.
3. Holders of equity shares have the right of control over the company. Directors are
elected on the vote of equity shareholders.
Merits:
From the company‟ point of view; there are several merits of issuing equity shares to raise
long-term finance.
Limitations:
Although there are several advantages of issuing equity shares to raise long-term capital.
1. The risks of fluctuating returns due to changes in the level of earnings of the
company do not attract many people to subscribe to equity capital.
2. The value of shares in the market also fluctuate with changes in business
conditions, this is another risk, which many investors want to avoid.
151
2. Issue of Debentures:
When a company decides to raise loans from the public, the amount of loan is dividend
into units of equal. These units are known as debentures. A debenture is the instrument or
certificate issued by a company to acknowledge its debt. Those who invest money in
debentures are known as „debenture holders‟. They are creditors of the company.
Debentures are therefore called „creditor ship‟ securities. The value of each debentures is
generally fixed in multiplies of 10 like Rs. 100 or Rs. 500, or Rs. 1000.
Debentures carry a fixed rate of interest, and generally are repayable after a certain
period, which is specified at the time of issue. Depending upon the terms and conditions of
issue there are different types of debentures. There are:
It debentures are issued on the security of all or some specific assets of the company,
they are known as secured debentures. The assets are mortgaged in favor of the
debenture holders. Debentures, which are not secured by a charge or mortgage of any
assets, are called unsecured debentures. The holders of these debentures are treated as
ordinary creditors.
Sometimes under the terms of issue debenture holders are given an option to covert their
debentures into equity shares after a specified period. Or the terms of issue may lay down
that the whole or part of the debentures will be automatically converted into equity shares
of a specified price after a certain period. Such debentures are known as convertible
debentures. If there is no mention of conversion at the time of issue, the debentures are
regarded as non-convertible debentures.
Merits:
Debentures issue is a widely used method of raising long-term finance by companies, due
to the following reasons.
1. Interest payable on Debentures can be fixed at low rates than rate of return on
equity shares. Thus Debentures issue is a cheaper source of finance.
2. Interest paid can be deducted from income tax purpose; there by the amount of
tax payable is reduced.
3. Funds raised for the issue of debentures may be used in business to earn a much
higher rate of return then the rate of interest. As a result the equity shareholders
earn more.
4. Another advantage of debenture issue is that funds are available from investors
who are not entitled to have any control over the management of the company.
5. Companies often find it convenient to raise debenture capital from financial
institutions, which prefer to invest in debentures rather than in shares. This is due
to the assurance of a fixed return and repayment after a specified period.
Limitations:
Debenture issue as a source of finance has certain limitations too.
1. It involves a fixed commitment to pay interest regularly even when the company
has low earnings or incurring losses.
2. Debentures issue may not be possible beyond a certain limit due to the inadequacy
of assets to be offered as security.
152
Methods of Issuing Securities: The firm after deciding the amount to be raised and the
type of securities to be issued, must adopt suitable methods to offer the securities to
potential investors. There are for common methods followed by companies for the
purpose.
When securities are offered to the general public a document known as Prospectus, or a
notice, circular or advertisement is issued inviting the public to subscribe to the securities
offered thereby all particulars about the company and the securities offered are made to
the public. Brokers are appointed and one or more banks are authorized to collect
subscription.
Some times the entire issue is subscribed by an organization known as Issue House, which
in turn sells the securities to the public at a suitable time.
The company may negotiate with large investors of financial institutions who agree to take
over the securities. This is known as „Private Placement‟ of securities.
When an exiting company decides to raise funds by issue of equity shares, it is required
under law to offer the new shares to the existing shareholders. This is described as right
issue of equity shares. But if the existing shareholders decline, the new shares can be
offered to the public.
Government with the main object of promoting industrial development has set up a
number of financial institutions. These institutions play an important role as sources of
company finance. Besides they also assist companies to raise funds from other sources.
Often, the financial institutions subscribe to the industrial debenture issue of companies
some of the institutions (ICICI) and (IDBI) also subscribe to the share issued by
companies.
All such institutions also underwrite the public issue of shares and debentures by
companies. Underwriting is an agreement to take over the securities to the extent there is
no public response to the issue. They may guarantee loans, which may be raised by
companies from other sources.
Loans in foreign currency may also be granted for the import of machinery and equipment
wherever necessary from these institutions, which stand guarantee for re-payments. Apart
from the national level institutions mentioned above, there are a number of similar
institutions set up in different states of India. The state-level financial institutions are
known as State Financial Corporation, State Industrial Development Corporations, State
Industrial Investment Corporation and the like. The objectives of these institutions are
similar to those of the national-level institutions. But they are mainly concerned with the
development of medium and small-scale industrial units. Thus, smaller companies depend
on state level institutions as a source of medium and long-term finance for the expansion
and modernization of their enterprise.
4. Retained Profits:
153
Successful companies do not distribute the whole of their profits as dividend to
shareholders but reinvest a part of the profits. The amount of profit reinvested in the
business of a company is known as retained profit. It is shown as reserve in the accounts.
The surplus profits retained and reinvested may be regarded as an internal source of
finance. Hence, this method of financing is known as self-financing. It is also called
sloughing back of profits.
Since profits belong to the shareholders, the amount of retained profit is treated as
ownership fund. It serves the purpose of medium and long-term finance. The total amount
of ownership capital of a company can be determined by adding the share capital and
accumulated reserves.
Merits:
This source of finance is considered to be better than other sources for the following
reasons.
Limitations:
1. Only well established companies can be avail of this sources of finance. Even for
such companies retained profits cannot be used to an unlimited extent.
2. Accumulation of reserves often attract competition in the market,
3. With the increased earnings, shareholders expect a high rate of dividend to be paid.
4. Growth of companies through internal financing may attract government
restrictions as it leads to concentration of economic power.
5. Public Deposits:
An important source of medium – term finance which companies make use of is public
deposits. This requires advertisement to be issued inviting the general public of deposits.
This requires advertisement to be issued inviting the general public to deposit their
savings with the company. The period of deposit may extend up to three yeas. The rate of
interest offered is generally higher than the interest on bank deposits. Against the deposit,
the company mentioning the amount, rate of interest, time of repayment and such other
information issues a receipt.
Since the public deposits are unsecured loans, profitable companies enjoying public
confidence only can be able to attract public deposits. Even for such companies there are
rules prescribed by government limited its use.
154
Sources of Short Term Finance
It is readily available according to the prevailing customs. There are no special efforts to
be made to avail of it. Trade credit is a flexible source of finance. It can be easily adjusted
to the changing needs for purchases.
Where there is an open account for any creditor failure to pay the amounts on time due to
temporary difficulties does not involve any serious consequence Creditors often adjust the
time of payment in view of continued dealings. It is an economical source of finance.
However, the liability on account of trade credit cannot be neglected. Payment has to be
made regularly. If the company is required to accept a bill of exchange or to issue a
promissory note against the credit, payment must be made on the maturity of the bill or
note. It is a legal commitment and must be honored; otherwise legal action will follow to
recover the dues.
The advantage of bank credit as a source of short-term finance is that the amount can be
adjusted according to the changing needs of finance. The rate of interest on bank credit is
fairly high. But the burden is no excessive because it is used for short periods and is
compensated by profitable use of the funds.
155
3. Short term loans from finance companies: Short-term funds may be available
from finance companies on the security of assets. Some finance companies also
provide funds according to the value of bills receivable or amount due from the
customers of the borrowing company, which they take over.
Capital Budgeting
Capital budgeting is the planning of expenditure and the benefit, which spread over a
number of years. It is the process of deciding whether or not to invest in a particular
project, as the investment possibilities may not be rewarding. The manager has to choose
a project, which gives a rate of return, which is more than the cost of financing the
project. For this the manager has to evaluate the worth of the projects in-terms of cost
and benefits. The benefits are the expected cash inflows from the project, which are
discounted against a standard, generally the cost of capital.
Capital Budgeting Process:
1. Project generation
2. Project evaluation
3. Project selection
4. Project execution
1. Project generation: In the project generation, the company has to identify the
proposal to be undertaken depending upon its future plans of activity. After identification
of the proposals they can be grouped according to the following categories:
156
to be received are measured in terms of cash in flows, and costs to be
incurred are measured in terms of cash flows.
b. Selection of an appropriate criterion to judge the desirability of the project.
4. Project Execution: In the project execution the top management or the project
execution committee is responsible for effective utilization of funds allocated for the
projects. It must see that the funds are spent in accordance with the appropriation made
in the capital budgeting plan. The funds for the purpose of the project execution must be
spent only after obtaining the approval of the finance controller. Further to have an
effective cont. It is necessary to prepare monthly budget reports to show clearly the total
amount appropriated, amount spent and to amount unspent.
1. Traditional methods
2. Discounted Cash flow methods
1. Traditional methods
These methods are based on the principles to determine the desirability of an investment
project on the basis of its useful life and expected returns. These methods depend upon
the accounting information available from the books of accounts of the company. These
will not take into account the concept of „time value of money‟, which is a significant factor
to determine the desirability of a project in terms of present value.
A. Pay-back period method: It is the most popular and widely recognized traditional
method of evaluating the investment proposals. It can be defined, as „the number of years
required to recover the original cash out lay invested in a project‟.
According to Weston & Brigham, “The pay back period is the number of years it takes the
firm to recover its original investment by net returns before depreciation, but after taxes”.
157
According to James. C. Vanhorne, “The payback period is the number of years required to
recover initial cash investment.
The pay back period is also called payout or payoff period. This period is calculated by
dividing the cost of the project by the annual earnings after tax but before depreciation
under this method the projects are ranked on the basis of the length of the payback
period. A project with the shortest payback period will be given the highest rank and
taken as the best investment. The shorter the payback period, the less risky the
investment is the formula for payback period is
Merits:
1. It is one of the earliest methods of evaluating the investment projects.
2. It is simple to understand and to compute.
3. It dose not involve any cost for computation of the payback period
4. It is one of the widely used methods in small scale industry sector
5. It can be computed on the basis of accounting information available from the
books.
Demerits:
1. This method fails to take into account the cash flows received by the
company after the pay back period.
2. It doesn‟t take into account the interest factor involved in an investment
outlay.
3. It doesn‟t take into account the interest factor involved in an investment
outlay.
4. It is not consistent with the objective of maximizing the market value of
the company‟s share.
5. It fails to consider the pattern of cash inflows i. e., the magnitude and timing of cash in
flows.
158
Average investment = ----------------------
2
On the basis of this method, the company can select all those projects who‟s ARR is higher
than the minimum rate established by the company. It can reject the projects with an ARR
lower than the expected rate of return. This method can also help the management to
rank the proposal on the basis of ARR. A highest rank will be given to a project with
highest ARR, where as a lowest rank to a project with lowest ARR.
Merits:
Demerits:
The traditional method does not take into consideration the time value of money. They
give equal weight age to the present and future flow of incomes. The DCF methods are
based on the concept that a rupee earned today is more worth than a rupee earned
tomorrow. These methods take into consideration the profitability and also time value of
money.
The NPV takes into consideration the time value of money. The cash flows of different
years and valued differently and made comparable in terms of present values for this the
net cash inflows of various period are discounted using required rate of return which is
predetermined.
According to Ezra Solomon, “It is a present value of future returns, discounted at the
required rate of return minus the present value of the cost of the investment.”
NPV is the difference between the present value of cash inflows of a project and the initial
cost of the project.
According the NPV technique, only one project will be selected whose NPV is positive or
above zero. If a project(s) NPV is less than „Zero‟. It gives negative NPV hence. It must be
rejected. If there are more than one project with positive NPV‟s the project is selected
whose NPV is the highest.
The formula for NPV is
159
Co- investment
C1, C2, C3… Cn= cash inflows in different years.
K= Cost of the Capital (or) Discounting rate
D= Years.
Merits:
Demerits:
The IRR for an investment proposal is that discount rate which equates the present value
of cash inflows with the present value of cash out flows of an investment. The IRR is also
known as cutoff or handle rate. It is usually the concern‟s cost of capital.
According to Weston and Brigham “The internal rate is the interest rate that equates the
present value of the expected future receipts to the cost of the investment outlay.
When compared the IRR with the required rate of return (RRR), if the IRR is more than
RRR then the project is accepted else rejected. In case of more than one project with IRR
more than RRR, the one, which gives the highest IRR, is selected.
The IRR is not a predetermine rate, rather it is to be trial and error method. It implies that
one has to start with a discounting rate to calculate the present value of cash inflows. If
the obtained present value is higher than the initial cost of the project one has to try with
a higher rate. Like wise if the present value of expected cash inflows obtained is lower
than the present value of cash flow. Lower rate is to be taken up. The process is continued
till the net present value becomes Zero. As this discount rate is determined internally, this
method is called internal rate of return method.
P1 - Q
IRR = L+ ---------- X D
P1 –P2
160
Merits:
1. It consider the time value of money
2. It takes into account the cash flows over the entire useful life of the asset.
3. It has a psychological appear to the user because when the highest rate of return
projects are selected, it satisfies the investors in terms of the rate of return an
capital
4. It always suggests accepting to projects with maximum rate of return.
5. It is inconformity with the firm‟s objective of maximum owner‟s welfare.
Demerits:
The method is also called benefit cost ration. This method is obtained cloth a slight
modification of the NPV method. In case of NPV the present value of cash out flows are
profitability index (PI), the present value of cash inflows are divide by the present value of
cash out flows, while NPV is a absolute measure, the PI is a relative measure.
It the PI is more than one (>1), the proposal is accepted else rejected. If there are more
than one investment proposal with the more than one PI the one with the highest PI will
be selected. This method is more useful incase of projects with different cash outlays cash
outlays and hence is superior to the NPV method.
Merits:
1. It requires less computational work then IRR method
2. It helps to accept / reject investment proposal on the basis of value of the index.
3. It is useful to rank the proposals on the basis of the highest/lowest value of the
index.
4. It is useful to tank the proposals on the basis of the highest/lowest value of the
index.
5. It takes into consideration the entire stream of cash flows generated during the
useful life of the asset.
Demerits:
161