7100 Commerce: MARK SCHEME For The May/June 2015 Series
7100 Commerce: MARK SCHEME For The May/June 2015 Series
7100 COMMERCE
This mark scheme is published as an aid to teachers and candidates, to indicate the requirements of
the examination. It shows the basis on which Examiners were instructed to award marks. It does not
indicate the details of the discussions that took place at an Examiners’ meeting before marking began,
Mark schemes should be read in conjunction with the question paper and the Principal Examiner
Cambridge will not enter into discussions about these mark schemes.
Cambridge is publishing the mark schemes for the May/June 2015 series for most
®
Cambridge IGCSE , Cambridge International A and AS Level components and some
Has discussed whether or not Pashbury is concerned with Commerce and has given a
reasoned opinion.
Commerce may be defined as trade and aids to trade. As regards trade, Pashbury has a
range of shops, so it must be involved in the retail trade. There is warehousing in the
industrial area and this implies that there might be a wholesaler there, again part of trade.
The warehousing, however, might be purely a storage facility for a manufacturer but
wholesaling functions such as breaking bulk and packaging will be performed there. There is
As regards aids to trade or commercial services, Pashbury has a bank so financial services
are offered to residents. It has a post office so some communication services are offered.
There will be roads because there is a bus service but no railway. Some transport services
operate in the town but not a full range. The shops are likely to advertise, probably locally
and storage is provided in the warehousing. Businesses and many private householders are
It can, therefore, be shown that Pashbury is concerned with Commerce. Some commercial
services such as banking services are definitely there. People living there make use of trade
Commerce consists of trade and aids to trade. Pashbury has some trade. It has a range of
shops. Pashbury has a bank and a post office and roads for a bus service. It has commercial
(b) (i) Any two points × 1 mark each and 1 mark for an example
(ii) Any example of a warehouse × 1 mark – general, cash and carry, cold storage, regional
description of warehouse.
(c) (i) Any two points × 1 mark each and 2 marks for a well-developed point
assistance from the parent company especially at the start of the franchise
reduces risk of failure as the parent company will not wish to franchise to fail
some of the initial costs are paid for by the parent company e.g. advertising
supplies provided by the parent company so the franchisee does not have to look for
suppliers
may be easier to obtain finance from a bank than being a sole trader
less need for advertising as parent well known and may provide corporate advertising
to provide a record of the transactions between a buyer and seller e.g. statement
catalogue or pricelist
N.B. a candidate may name a document and describe its purpose – please allow this [4]
2 (a) Any three points × 1 mark each or one well developed point × 2 marks
it enables the brand to be put on the product with particular brands regarded as more
it makes the product look more expensive than it is – coloured box/purple/gold wrapping
it makes the product seem bigger than it is and so more money can be charged
(b) Any four points × 1 mark each and up to 2 marks for a well-developed point including
examples
enables Drools Ltd to communicate with many parts of the world using email
enables Drools Ltd to advertise using the Internet which can be seen
by customers worldwide
enables printed catalogues to be sent to potential buyers so that orders can be placed
allow advertising
(c) (i) Any four reasons × 1 mark each and up to 2 marks for a well-developed point
details about the chocolates can be given in magazine and newspaper advertising
each [4]
(ii) Any one advertising device in context × 1 mark – luxury, wealth, affluence, nostalgia,
capital used for the day to day running of the business + example = 2 marks [2]
Has discussed each option and recommended, with reasons, a suitable course of
action.
marks max)
If it asks customers to pay as soon as possible, this will increase its cash and so
increase its current assets. It will probably have to offer some incentives to persuade
customers to do this such as cash discount and so its cash receipts will not be as great.
Some customers may be unable to take advantage of any cash discount offered.
The question implies that Drools Ltd already has an overdraft which is a current liability.
If it asks the bank to increase its overdraft, the bank may refuse. The overdraft will give
It may be possible to negotiate longer periods of trade credit with suppliers. It will depend
on how long Drools Ltd already has and its creditworthiness. If it is able to do this, it will
be able to postpone paying its creditors until it receives payments from debtors to fund
its bills.
I would recommend trying to get customers to pay more quickly and at the same time,
Drools Ltd should ask its customers to pay more quickly. They may refuse. It should ask
Its suppliers if it can pay later. This would help Drools Ltd. It should not borrow money.
N.B. If candidate states that options do not improve the working capital with reasons –
Level 2 response – reasons are that options only move assets and liabilities within the
25
3 (a) $200 × = $50 (1 mark)
100
OFR applies. If the correct answer is given without working, award full marks. [3]
(b) Any four points × 1 mark each and up to 2 marks for a well-developed point
some retailers want to dispose of old stock to make room for new stock
some retailers sell fashion goods that may go out of fashion quickly e.g. clothing
some retailers may sell goods that deteriorate quickly e.g. food
some retailers may be short of cash and this may enable them to increase cash flow
some retailers may want to increase their trade so reducing prices will encourage sales
to dispose of slow selling lines and so get back some of the purchase price
some retailers stock goods that hold their value e.g. jewellers
some retailers sell goods where there is little change as regards style/type of goods sold
some retailers sell goods that are in constant demand e.g. sweets, newspapers
(1 mark)
price – the amount of money charged when goods are bought/sold (1 mark)
Has assessed the impact of the growth of supermarket chains on other types of
In many countries there are many types of large-scale retailers such as department
stores, supermarkets, hypermarkets, multiple chain stores and variety chain stores.
Many new supermarkets have opened to sell produce to local communities. Although the
main products offered are food and household products, these supermarkets are now
offering a wide range of goods such as electrical goods, household appliances and
clothing. They have huge buying power and so can take advantage of economies of
scale and get goods at heavily discounted prices passing on lower prices to the
consumer. They cater for shoppers who want to obtain all their goods in one place and
so save time.
This development has brought them into competition with multiple chain stores selling
clothing or electrical appliances who have sometimes found that they need to
concentrate on their larger branches and have closed small branches in many smaller
towns.
The development of online retailing has also had an effect on large-scale retailing. All
type of large-scale retailer have developed shopping websites. Otherwise they would be
left behind. Many people now prefer to shop online rather than visit shops. Large-scale
retailers must cater for this trend which may reduce the cost of and need for a physical
Large-scale retailers who offer a different shopping experience may survive but only if
they diversify. This would apply to department stores. Shops who offer a small range of a
large number of products i.e. variety chain stores have often experienced difficulty
although there is considerable demand for low priced goods with other retailers
The growth of supermarket chains has certainly had an effect on other types of large-
scale retailing and often reduced the range of shops available to consumers in shopping
areas.
large-scale retailers.
There are several kinds of large-scale retailers. There are supermarkets and
hypermarkets. There are department stores and multiple chain stores. There is a lot of
competition between retailers. Supermarket chains have opened new stores. Some
chain stores have closed. Others have expanded some of their stores. Do not give credit
(d) (i) Any four reasons × 1 mark each and up to 2 marks for a well-developed point.
they want to expand their markets and cater for new groups of customers
their competitors are offering this service and so they need to compete
they may save on set up costs for new stores which may not be successful
they can locate the warehouse to service online shopping in a low cost area
they save the costs of high rents, labour costs for sales assistants
(ii) Any one cost × 1 mark – set up costs of creating the website, costs of maintaining the
website, increasing charges for web address to come early on list, fees for search
4 (a) Two clear definitions – 1 mark each and one relevant example of visible and invisible item –
1 mark each
visible items are items which are tangible/can be touched or seen/primary or secondary
(b) (i) One mark for reduction in the Balance of Payments [1]
electronic transfer ( if uses term ‘credit transfer 2/3’) – fast, computerised transfer of
bills of exchange – IOUs in which the importer promises to pay the debt at a fixed future
letters of credit – letters of undertaking issued by the importer’s bank and sent by the
bank draft/banker’s cheque – used when the buyer and seller are not known to each
(iii) Any two insurance risks relating to the consignment of machinery × 1 mark each -
goods in transit, fire, aviation insurance, marine insurance, export credit guarantee,
Has discussed both using air freight and container ship and has given a reasoned
recommendation.
(If a candidate has discussed only one option award 4 marks max)
The American company could use both means of transport. This implies that the
machinery is not too bulky and not too heavy. The choice of transport will therefore
depend on other factors. The degree of urgency may be a deciding factor. If the
machinery is needed quickly air freight would be the preferred option. Air freight is likely
to be more expensive than using a container ship. The machinery is quite expensive so
this expense could possibly be justified. Special care would need to be taken if the
machinery is fragile and easily damaged. Careful packing would be necessary. It is often
claimed that air freight would be more suitable for this type of cargo but there is no
The machine could be sent by container ship but it is unlikely to fill a whole container
and so may have to wait until other cargo can be found. The container is likely to be
packed at a freight forwarder’s premises so transhipment can take place by road to the
docks, placed on a ship and unloaded without unpacking in Japan. The container offers
protection against theft and weather and provides storage for the machinery until it is
delivered.
I would recommend using air freight if the machinery is required urgently as it can be
Has commented on using air freight and/or container ship with/without an opinion.
Air freight carries valuable, lightweight cargoes. Container ship carries many kinds of
cargo. Goods can be transhipped. Using container ship is cheaper. I recommend using
(c) Any four points × 1 mark each and up to 2 marks for a well-developed point
introduce/raise import duties to make imported goods more expensive than home-produced
introduce quotas – limits on quantity of a particular product allowed into a country during
impose exchange controls to restrict the amount of foreign currency available to purchase
imports
introduce administrative barriers e.g. more documents, longer procedures to make it more
introduce strict quality control measures so adding to costs of producing the goods
Do not allow credit for encouragement of home produced goods by reduction of their taxes
etc. [4]
5 (a) (i) Any four points × 1 mark each or two points × 2 marks each
the application for insurance which must be completed truthfully forms the basis of the
insurance contract as all information about the insured risk is given on the form may act
as a request for a quotation from the insurance company used by the insurer to assess
the risk and decide whether or not to accept the risk used by the insurer to calculate the
premium to be charged
(ii) Any one insurance principle × 1 mark and 2 marks for explanation
utmost good faith – telling the truth and giving all relevant facts that might affect the risk
insurable interest – the applicant should suffer a financial loss if the risk occurred/ e.g.
ownership of the risk indemnity – the applicant should not over-insure hoping to make a
Has discussed whether or not Comidex will have difficulty obtaining insurance
and has given a reasoned opinion. (If a candidate has discussed only one side of
Comidex will probably not have difficulty obtaining insurance cover for general risks such
as premises insurance and insurance against fire and theft. It will have to have
employer’s liability insurance and is likely to have public liability insurance in case
Comidex will, however, have difficulty obtaining motor insurance for its motor racing
team because the risk of an accident occurring is very high and therefore the premium
will be very large. Comidex is unlikely to obtain motor insurance from general insurers. It
will have to use an insurance broker who specialises in finding insurers for high level
risks. The insurance broker will arrange the insurance and also the documentation.
Comidex is likely to pay high premiums and also likely to have large excesses and
conditions or exclusion clauses on its policy. It will, however, be able to obtain motor
It is possible, however, that Comidex might decide to be its own insurers for the motor
Comidex will find it very difficult to obtaining motor insurance for its motor racing team.
The risk of an accident occurring is very high. The premium will be very large. Comidex
(b) (i) Any one example × 1 mark such as retained profits, selling off unwanted assets,
no security is required
6 (a) One mark for juice, coke, beer, tonic water, soda water
30
(b) (i) 120bn × (1 mark)= 36 bn (1 Mark)
100
OFR applies. If the correct answer is given without working, award full marks [2]
65
(ii) 120bn × (1 mark) = 78bn (1 mark) ÷ 10 = 7.8 bn (1 mark)
100
OFR applies. If the correct answer is given without working, award full marks [3]
(c) Any four points × 1 mark each and up to 2 marks for a well-developed point
demand for drinks comes from all over the world and is large scale
there are a number of drinks made by many companies that are suitable for being
canned
it is easier to supply outlets in different parts of the world by having factories producing
many different outlets sell drinks e.g. supermarkets, cafes, fast food outlets
(If a candidate has discussed only one option, award 4 marks max)
If Sigma opens a factory in Germany it will benefit from location within a trading bloc. It
will not have to pay import duty on any cans sent to member countries of the EU. It will
also be able to obtain any necessary raw materials from member countries without
payment of duty. It will also be located close to its market for beverage cans in Europe.
On the other hand Sigma will have to find a site in Germany and will have the costs of
setting up the factory as well as the ongoing costs such as labour. It will also have to
organise a sales team to operate in Europe. It should also be remembered that not all
countries in Europe are members of the European Union and so it may be difficult to
Using agents will save Sigma the work of locating in Europe and setting up a factory.
The agent will find buyers for Sigma and will overcome some of the difficulties of trading
in other countries such as language and dimensions of the cans. The agent will
represent Sigma and may be better known to potential buyers than Sigma itself.
On the other hand agents work for several clients and so may not sell the beverage cans
as vigorously as they might. Sigma will still have to organise the transporting and
delivery of the cans, probably from Canada and this will be costly. The agent will receive
commission on sales.
It is recommend that Sigma sets up the factory together with a sales office so that it can
The European Union is a trading bloc. If Sigma opens a factory in Germany it will benefit
from this. It will not have to pay import duty on cans sold to other countries. It will also
Sigma will, however, have to find a site in Germany. It will have the costs of setting up
Sigma will have to pay agents commission. I would recommend that Sigma sets up the
factory so that it can expand its market for cans in Europe itself. [6]
(ii) Any four points × 1 mark each and up to 2 marks for a well-developed point
the cans will have to be shipped using container ship – this could be costly and also take
some time, other forms of transport will be needed to deliver the container to the port in
Canada and from the port in Australia.Sales people may have to travel from Canada to
Australia – cost as well as time consuming communication may break down between
buyer and seller but, with improved communication e.g. email, this is not such a problem
no insurance costs may be greater than for a short distance if a consignment is urgent
container ship may not be suitable and air freight would be expensive the use of air
freight would not generally be suitable as cans are likely to be transported in bulk and
individually are of low value there may be greater risks of cargoes being lost or stolen
because of distance as they are in other people’s hands for longer the product has a low
value to weight.
ATM advice
offer to replace
contact manufacturer
(d) (i) One mark for pay before the due date on the credit card statement [1]
(ii) One advantage explained × 2 marks and one disadvantage explained × 2 marks
likely to increase sales as most people use credit cards to postpone payment
may give a competitive edge over some other companies who may levy a charge for
the retailer does not have to hold too much cash on its premises so less security risks
means increased paper work and record keeping as well as the card readers
delays in payment from credit card companies may result in cash flow problems
Has discussed whether or not Salima should sell directly to consumers and has given
a reasoned opinion.
(If a candidate has discussed only one side of the argument, award 4 marks max)
If Salima sells directly to consumers, she might make more profit as she is cutting out the
retailer. She will not be delivering bulk quantities to retailers and so will need to review her
Salima sells in bulk to retailers. If she were to sell directly to consumers, she would be selling
individual computers and would probably have to provide after sales service for these
computers. If she started selling directly to consumers she would be selling to the customers
of the retailers who are buying from her. She would have to change the whole emphasis of
her business and set up an online ordering service for consumers as well as a reliable
delivery network. She would also have to prepare each computer individually for customers.
I would recommend that Salima continues to sell in bulk for retailers. If this is successful, why
change? But she may be selling less to retailers who are buying direct from manufacturers
and that is why she is considering direct selling. Perhaps she should investigate selling direct
Salima should sell directly to consumers. She may make more sales. She may make more
profit. Retailers will no longer take part of the profit. She will have to review how she sells.
[6]
goods need to be moved from seller to buyer so that orders can be satisfied
raw materials need to be moved from where they are obtained to manufacturers
some goods need specialised transport in order to be sent to another country such as
container transport/refrigeration
transport services provide invisible earnings for some countries e.g. shipping services
transport enables buyers and sellers to meet to do business e.g. air travel
(b) Any two points × 1 mark each or one well explained point × 2 marks
the movement of goods from where they are produced to where they are sold/or direct to
consumers
(c) Any four points × 1 mark each and up to 2 marks for a well explained point
may wish to send goods abroad but does not have the expertise to do so
Has discussed whether or not Gupta needs warehousing as part of its business and
(If a candidate has discussed only one side of the argument, award 4 marks max)
Gupta International Transport moves goods both within its own country and also abroad.
Some of the goods it moves may have to be stored before transporting. This storage may be
by the manufacturer after production especially if buyers have not been found or the
transport is not available. Gupta is unlikely to provide storage on a large scale for such
goods.
Gupta does provide some storage for goods in the form of containers. Containers act as
small warehouses and can be stacked in a small space. Gupta is likely to move these
containers from the seller’s premises where they would be packed, may use at least two
means of transport, and deliver them to the buyer’s premises where they will be unpacked
and stored. Some goods need to be stored pending payment of duty. Gupta may deliver
Gupta operates some refrigerated transport. It is likely to load such cargo from refrigerated
storage at the producer’s premises. The goods are protected whilst in the truck and then
Gupta will need some storage for itself. It may need to store its vehicles to protect them when
not in use. It will need some storage/warehousing for vehicle parts and the maintenance of
its vehicles.
Gupta, therefore, is unlikely to need much warehousing and storage. It does not advertise
opinion.
Gupta is a transport business. It moves goods in its own country and to other countries. It