2/16/2015
Q :- What is the suit of a civil nature ? What is the nature of the suit in which right to property or to an office is contested ? Will it make any differ
Q :- What is the suit of a civil nature ? What is the nature of the
suit in which right to property or to an office is contested ? Will it
make any difference if such right depends entirely on the decision
of questions as to religious rites or ceremoni
| Print |
Q :- What is the suit of a civil nature ?
What is the nature of the suit in which right to property or to an office is contested ?
Will it make any difference if such right depends entirely on the decision of questions as to
religious rites or ceremonies ?
Will a suit lie against an intruder for a declaration that the office of a religious order is vested in
the plaintiff ?
Answer :-
Section 9 of the Civil Procedure Code confers jurisdiction on the civil courts .
Section 9 of CPC provides that the civil courts shall have jurisdiction to try all suits of a civil
nature excepting suits of which their cognizance is expressly or impliedly barred.
What are the suits of civil nature has been explained by the Explanation I and II of section 9 .
According to the explanation I , a suit in which right to property or to an office is contested is a suit
of civil nature notwithstanding that such rights may depend entirely upon the decision of question
as to religious rites or ceremonies .
Explanation II says that for the purpose of this section , it is immaterial whether or not any fees are
attached to the office referred to in Explanation I or whether or not such office is attached to a
http://lawstudentshelpline.com/index.php/civil-procedure-code/2-uncategorised/113-q-what-is-the-suit-of-a-civil-nature-what-is-the-nature-of-the-suit-in-
1/3
2/16/2015
Q :- What is the suit of a civil nature ? What is the nature of the suit in which right to property or to an office is contested ? Will it make any differ
particular place .
Therefore , it is clear from the Explanation I of section 9 that it will not make any difference if such
right to property or to an office depends entirely on the decision of questions as to religious rites
or ceremonies .
In the case of Vanamalia Ramanuja Jeer Vs. Shri Ranga Ramanuja Jeer , Honble Supreme Court
of India laid down that the following principles are to be borne in mind when deciding the
question as to whether a right to a religious office would be a right of a civil nature :i) A declaratory suit simpliciter for religious honour and privileges is not a suit of a civil nature.
ii) A suit for a declaration and to establish ones right to an office in a temple and to honours ,
privileges , remuneration or requisites attached to such an office , is a suit of civil nature .
iii) In order to mean an office the holder of the office should be under a legal obligation to
discharge the duties attached to the said office and for non-observance of which penalties can be
inflicted on him .
The general rule of law is that when a religious office is situated in a temple , shrine , etc. , the
right to such office is a right of a civil nature , even though no fees are attached to it but when such
an office is not attached to any place the right will not be of a civil nature unless a fee is attached to
the office .
The caste question is related to social privilege and so it is not a legal right but when it relates to
the property of a caste , the civil court will have jurisdiction to interfere .The suits for vindication
of dignity attached to an office are not suits of a civil nature . The right to bury a corpse is a civil
right , therefore , a suit to establish such right is a suit of civil nature .
By the words suits expressly barred section 9 of CPC means to say that there are certain types
of suits which are barred by the code itself , such as
http://lawstudentshelpline.com/index.php/civil-procedure-code/2-uncategorised/113-q-what-is-the-suit-of-a-civil-nature-what-is-the-nature-of-the-suit-in-
2/3
2/16/2015
Q :- What is the suit of a civil nature ? What is the nature of the suit in which right to property or to an office is contested ? Will it make any differ
i) Section 11 of CPC or resjudicata barred the trial of a suit , in which the matter or issue of the
parties has already been decided by a competent court .
ii) Section 47 barred the determination of all questions relating to execution , satisfaction , and
discharge of decrees .
iii) Section 10 , Section 95 , Order 2 Rule 2 , Order 9 Rule 9 and Order 22 Rule 11 also barred to
file fresh suit .
And by the words Suits impliedly barred section 9 of CPC means to say that there are certain
types of suits which are --i) barred by general principles of law , and
ii) barred on the ground of public policy .
Some statutes also barred the jurisdiction of civil courts and conferred the jurisdiction on
Tribunals.
Suit against intruder :-
According to the Explanation I of section 9 of CPC a suit in which the right to property or to an
office is contested is a suit of a civil nature . An office may be either secular or religious . Fees may
be or may not be attached to the religious office. Explanation II to section 9 of CPC says that it is
immaterial whether or not i) any fees are attached to the office , or ii) such office is attached to any
particular place . Therefore a suit , according to the explanations I and II of section 9 of the CPC ,
against an intruder for a declaration that the office of a religious order is vested in the plaintiff is
a suit of civil nature and so such suit lies in the civil court .
*****
http://lawstudentshelpline.com/index.php/civil-procedure-code/2-uncategorised/113-q-what-is-the-suit-of-a-civil-nature-what-is-the-nature-of-the-suit-in-
3/3
