Discussion Starters

Climate Change
If you really think the
environment is less important
than the economy, try
holding your breath while
youcountyourmoney.
Guy McPherson, American climate scientist

Pre-Reading
A. Warm-Up Questions

1. How do humans contribute to global warming?

2. Why do some governments

want to ignore climate change?

3. In your opinion, what willbedifferent

about the earthsclimate in 50 years?

B. Vocabulary Preview

Match the words on the left with the correct meanings on the right.

1. greenhouse gas a) not usual, very odd

2. carbon footprint b) a type of gas that contributes to the trapping of heat in the earths atmosphere
3. freakish c) to attack a problem in order to try to solve it
4. tackle d) a person who doesnt believe something is true
5. cover-up e) something that prevents others from seeing the truth
6. cast doubt f) not responsible for
7. skeptic g) needing to be taken care of before a deadline
8. time-sensitive h) to convince other people to question something they thought was true
9. undeniable i) the amount of greenhouse gases contributed by a single person or group
10. off the hook j) unable to be denied, must be true

Copyright 2017, Red River Press Inc. For use by ESL Library members only.( I N T H I G H I N T / V E R S I O N 3 . 2) 1
 Climate Change
Discussion Starters

Reading
CLIMATE CHANGE
Ignoring Mother Natures warnings

1. The majority of scientists around the world agree that humans are
largely to blame for the warming of our planet. Over the past 50 years,
temperatures on earth have increased at a higher rate than ever
recorded. In order to prevent excess greenhouse gases from trapping
heat in our atmosphere, we need to change our lifestyles. By reducing
our carbon footprint and switching to clean forms of energy, we may
be able to save our planet.

2. Despite freakish weather like heat waves, droughts, and hurricanes,

tackling climate change was not a priority for some of Americas
2012 presidential candidates. Four years later, candidate Donald
Trump said he was not a big believer in man-made climate change.
In fact, some Americans, including a handful of scientists, have been
Beware of an
accused of taking part in a climate cover-up. Those who benefit
Irregular Verb
financially from oil, gas, and coal industries deny the need for clean The verb to cast is irregular.
energy alternatives. By casting doubt on science, a few skeptics The past tense of cast is cast,
NOTcasted.
have caused a large number of people to question whether man-
made climate change even exists. Ignoring a time-sensitive topic like
the environment creates a vicious cycle. If the public doesnt rate the
environment as a major concern, world leaders wont, either. How long
can we ignore Mother Natures warning signs?

3. Environmentalists always said that the first place humans would see
undeniable evidence of global warming would be in the Arctic. In
2012, the summer sea ice in the Arctic was at a record low. Ice experts
have warned that sea ice in the Arctic will likely be nonexistent within
a few years. Instead of being concerned by these dangerous signs
of global warming, some business thinkers are already considering
potential opportunities. After all, open waters will lead to new shipping
channels. Well need stronger sunscreen products, too.

4. Climate change affects the whole planet, yet the worlds leaders cant
agree on what to do about it. Many leaders from have-not countries
think they should be off the hook. They dont believe their people
contributed to the problem, and they want wealthy nations to fix it.
Developed nations arent as wealthy as they look. Theyre in debt, at
war, and addicted to consumption. Passing a problem down to future
generations just seems easier, doesnt it?

Copyright 2017, Red River Press Inc. For use by ESL Library members only.( I N T H I G H I N T / V E R S I O N 3 . 2) 2
 Climate Change
Discussion Starters

Comprehension
Discuss these questions inpairs,and write the answers in your notebook.

1. According to the reading, whatlifestyle changes do humans need to make?

2. What examples of freakish weather are mentioned? Canyou think of any others?

3. Why would some people want to ignore or even deny man-made climate change?

4. Paraphrase the vicious cycle mentioned in the reading.

5. Why does the reading mentionsunscreen products?

Vocabulary Review
Complete each sentence with the correct
word from the vocabulary list on page 1.

1. The company reduced its by replacing business trips with online meetings.

2. New research on the theory of mass extinction.

3. Please send me a list of all concerns by the end of the day.

4. Its that Hurricane Sandy came late in the season.

5. Due to the freakish snowstorm, the school bus driver was for the field trip.

Copyright 2017, Red River Press Inc. For use by ESL Library members only.( I N T H I G H I N T / V E R S I O N 3 . 2) 3
 Climate Change
Discussion Starters

Grammar Review
DESPITE

Use despite to rewrite the sentences below. Work with a partner to

form the sentences orally, then write the sentences on the lines below.
Experimentwith where you place the word despite. Can you think
ofother ways to describe these unexpected results?

Ex. Though there was damage from Hurricane Sandy, most New Yorkers voted in the election.

Despite the damage from Hurricane Sandy, most New Yorkers voted in the election.

Most New Yorkers voted in the election despite the damage from Hurricane Sandy.

1. There is scientific evidence of man-made climate change, but there are still skeptical people.

2. Regardless of the time-sensitive nature of the presidents flight, it was delayed until Monday.

3. Even though people understand the dangers of climate change, they still buy gas-guzzlers.

4. Polar bears arent listed as endangered although the ice is melting in the Arctic.

Copyright 2017, Red River Press Inc. For use by ESL Library members only.( I N T H I G H I N T / V E R S I O N 3 . 2) 4
 Climate Change
Discussion Starters

Discussion
1. Should government leaders be more
worried about the economy or the environment?

2. What can individuals do to reduce their own carbon footprint?

3. Do you think humans have the ability to reverse the

environmentaldamage we have already done to our planet?

4. At the Paris Climate Change Conference in 2015, Frances president

Franois Hollande said that the worlds most important mission should
be to protect and hand over the planet to the next generation. Do you
think this should be the top priority of todays world leaders?

Critical Thinking
Discuss and debate one of these issues as a class.

1. When Hurricane Sandy flooded much of the highly populated Eastern

Seaboard in 2012, many environmentalists hoped the issue of climate
change would come back into the picture. If a superstorm that put the
BigApple to sleep cant get climate change back on the US agenda,
whatwill?

2. D
 onald Trump has openly denied climate change and has stated that,
as president, he wants to end the Environmental Protection Agency in
the US. Read these two tweets from Trump, and discuss how you think
his administration will tackle matters related to the environment.

The concept of global warming was

created by and for the Chinese in order to
make USmanufacturing non-competitive.
@realDonaldTrump (2012)

 Snowing in Texas and Louisiana, record

setting freezing temperatures throughout
the country and beyond. Global warming
is an expensive hoax!
@realDonaldTrump (2014)

Copyright 2017, Red River Press Inc. For use by ESL Library members only.( I N T H I G H I N T / V E R S I O N 3 . 2) 5
 Climate Change
Discussion Starters

Listening Gap Fill

http://blog.esllibrary.com/2016/10/05/podcast-climate-change/

Fill in the blanks as you listen to the recording.

CLIMATE CHANGE
Ignoring Mother Natures warnings

1. The majority of scientists around the world 3. Environmentalists always said that the first place
agree that humans are largely to blame for the humans would see
warming of our planet. Over the past 50 years, evidence of global warming would be in the
temperatures on earth have increased at a higher Arctic. In 2012, the summer sea ice in the Arctic
rate than ever recorded. In order to prevent excess was at a record low. Ice experts have warned
from trapping heat in that sea ice in the Arctic will likely be nonexistent
our atmosphere, we need to change our lifestyles. within a few years. Instead of being concerned by
By reducing our and these dangerous signs of global warming, some
switching to clean forms of energy, we may be able business thinkers are already considering potential
to save ourplanet. opportunities. After all, open waters will lead to
new shipping channels. Well need stronger
2. Despite weather like
products,too.
heat waves, droughts, and hurricanes, tackling
climate change was not a top priority for Americas 4. Climate change affects the whole planet, yet the
2012 presidential candidates. Four years later, worlds leaders cant agree on what to do about
candidate Donald Trump said he was not a big it. Many leaders from have-not countries think
believer in man-made climate change. In fact, some they should be .
Americans, including a handful of scientists, have They dont believe their people contributed to
been accused of taking part in a climate cover-up. the problem, and they want wealthy nations to
Those who benefit financially from oil, gas, and fix it. Developed nations arent as wealthy as
coal industries deny the need for clean energy they look. Theyre in debt, at war, and addicted
alternatives. By on toconsumption.Passinga problem down to
science, a few skeptics have caused a large number just seems easier,
of people to question whether man-made climate doesntit?
change even exists. Ignoring a time-sensitive topic
like the environment creates a vicious cycle. If the
public doesnt rate the environment as a major
concern, world leaders wont, either. How long can
we ignore Mother Natures warning signs?

4. off the hook, future generations

3. undeniable, sunscreen
2. freakish, casting doubt
1. greenhouse gases, carbon footprint

ANSWERS:

Copyright 2017, Red River Press Inc. For use by ESL Library members only.( I N T H I G H I N T / V E R S I O N 3 . 2) 6
 Climate Change
Discussion Starters

Answer Key
LESSON DESCRIPTION: LEVEL: Int High Int

Students read a brief definition of global warming. They learn TIME: 12 hours
anddiscuss why governments around the world are ignoring the
TAGS: 
environment, climate change, global warming,
issue of climate change. The lesson includes vocabulary review
Earth,Earth Day, discussion, irregular verb, despite
exercises anddiscussion questions.

Pre-Reading Comprehension

A. WARM-UP QUESTIONS 1. According to the reading, humans need to reduce

their carbon footprint and find clean energy alternatives.
Answers will vary. Discuss the quote.
2. Examples of freakish weather mentioned include hurricanes,
droughts, and heat waves. They may also think of forest fires,
B. VOCABULARY PREVIEW
tornados, flash floods, cyclones, tsunamis, and earthquakes.
1. b 3. a 5. e 7. d 9. j 3. Some people want to ignore or even deny man-made climate
2. i 4. c 6. h 8. g 10. f change because they have investments in oil, coal, or gas.
4. According to the reading, when leaders dont make something

Reading (and/or Listening) like the environment a top priority, the public wont rate it as
an important issue. Leaders dont tackle issues that the public

Read individually, in small groups, or as a class. Discuss the quote. doesnt consider important. This is a vicious cycle when you

You can also play the listening as your students read along. A gap- have a time-sensitive issue like climate change.

fill version of the reading is available on page 6. Help your students 5. The reading mentions sunscreen products because

with vocabulary and expressions that they are unfamiliar with. some business-oriented people are already thinking
about how they can cash in on global warming.

Vocabulary Review

1. carbon footprint 4. undeniable

2. casts doubt 5. off the hook
3. time-sensitive

(continued on the next page...)

Copyright 2017, Red River Press Inc. For use by ESL Library members only.( I N T H I G H I N T / V E R S I O N 3 . 2) 7
 Climate Change
Discussion Starters

Answer Key cont.

Grammar Review Discussion

Do your students know how to use despite to show unexpected Answers will vary.
results? Review the grammar with your students before they
begin. Remind your students that despite goes in front of nouns
Critical Thinking
or gerunds. When used in an introductory phrase, a comma is
needed. You may also want to remind students that despite can
Encourage your students to dig deeper! After they have chatted
go in the middle of the sentence (no comma is needed in this case).
for a while, you can put a few groups together and tell them to
Your students may ask you about in spite of and despite the fact
pretend they are the UN. Assign each student a leadership role
that. Explain that in spite of is interchangeable with despite,
(e.g.,president of US). Make sure there are leaders from some have-
but is simply less common. Despite the fact that is wordy. Remind
not countries, too. What can be done to combat climatechange?
your students of the common error many students make (despite
+ of). Some students also make the mistake of using despite the
SPELLING NOTE
fact (without that). The patterns below may help your students
keepitall straight (SVO = a SubjectVerbObject clause). See our The North American spelling is Skeptic,
editors blog post, How to Explain Despite Vs. Although, for more while the British spelling is Sceptic.
tips and examples: http://blog.esllibrary.com/2012/11/08/how-to-
explain-despite-vs-although/

despite / in spite of + noun / noun phrase:

Despite + noun, SVO. / SVO despite + noun.

despite / in spite of + gerund:

Despite + gerund, SVO. / SVO despite + gerund.

despite / in spite of + the fact that:

Despite the fact that + SVO, SVO. / SVO despite the fact that SVO.

although / even though / though + clause:

Even though SVO, SVO. / SVO even though SVO.

Copyright 2017, Red River Press Inc. For use by ESL Library members only.( I N T H I G H I N T / V E R S I O N 3 . 2) 8