Thread Type & Tension on Cotton Sewability
Thread Type & Tension on Cotton Sewability
Abstract:
Thread plays an important role in the apparel manufacturing process. When the thread is stronger than
the material that it is being used to join and if seams are placed under stress the material may tear
before the thread breaks. Garments are usually sewn with threads of lesser strength than the fabric so
that if stressed the seam will break before the garment.
Tension control is also a very important element that is used to adjust how loose or tight sewing
stitches are. Top thread and bobbin thread should be meeting between the two layers of fabric. If the
top thread is not going into the fabric, the tension should be loosen; and vice versa, if the bobbin
thread is not going into the fabric the tension should be tighten. Thread runs between various tension
disks, and the amount of tension which is set by the regulator will determine how much pressure these
disks put on the thread. In this study five different tensions are applied on four types of thread by using
super imposed seam. These seams examined for thickness, stiffness, seam appearance, seam pucker,
tensile strength and extensibility according to standards. Tests took place into conditioned atmosphere
of 21C and 65% RH. Comparisons have been made among the five different tensions and the four
different thread types this was done with reference to seamed lines durability, efficiency and
appearance.
Keywords:
Thread, spun thread, filament thread, tension control, sew ability
                                                    313
International Design Journal Volume 4 Issue 3                                           Technical Issues
to abrasion, mildew and ultraviolet radiation, and    hemming and surging inexpensive garments and
have less shrinkage.                                  Household textiles. (8)
1.1.3. Blended fibers threads One of the most         1.2.4. Textured threads made of multifilament
common threads in use today is a combination of       that have been crimp textured or bulked by
cotton and polyester, which combines the sew          twisting, crimping and untwisting, textured
ability of cotton with polyester's strength and       threads have a soft land, good coverage and
resistance to abrasion. (3)                           elasticity. (7) The most common use of textured
1.2. Classification of sewing thread according        threads is in the over edge and cover stitch
to construction                                       machines; however, very fine sizes can be used
Although there are a variety of thread                as needle threads on chain stitch and over edge
constructions, most threads used in garments are      machines. They can also be used as bobbin
twisted, core spun, monofilament, or textured. (2)    threads to add moderate stretch to a lock stitched
1.2.1. Twisted threads All natural fibers, with       seam. (9)
the exception of silk, begin with fibers - short      1.3. Classification of sewing thread according
lengths of staple, which are twisted together to      to thread size
make a single-ply thread. Then two or more plies      The thread size is dependent on many factors-
are twisted together in the reverse direction to      such as the fabric weight and type, stitch and
make a sewing thread with a balanced twist.           seam type, machine speed, needle size, end use,
Without this balance, the thread could not be         and seam strength. Most threads are sized using
controlled. Most threads are finished with a "Z"      Tex system or the cotton count system. (2)
or left twist because the action of the lockstitch    1.4. Factors in thread selection
machine would cause threads with an "8" twist to        Garment design, type, quality, end use, and
unwind One exception is the double-needle                 life expectancy.
lockstitch, which has two bobbins one revolving         Desired strength and durability.
to the left and one to the right. This type of          Fabric weight and type.
machine requires threads with both twists. (5)          Stitch and seam type, number of stitches/inch,
Spun cotton thread is manufactured with a great           machine speed, and needle size.
degree of care and professionalism. Its the most       Cost. (10)
widely-used natural fiber; highly-versatile cotton    1.5. Tension control
is known for its strength and comfort and is used     Control and adjust sewing machine tension
in an amazingly wide variety of textile               empower to sew creatively. Sewing thread in
materials. (6)                                        machine must feed through three main points;
In addition to the natural fibers, polyester, silk,   the tension disks, the take-up, and the needle.
and nylon filaments cut or broken into staple         The bobbin must also be threaded properly to
lengths. (5) Spun polyester thread is the most        enable the machine to form a good stitch.
common. Sometimes referred to as PP or PP          Bobbins have their own mechanism for
Spun, are made by spinning 100% polyester            controlling tension on the thread.
staple fibers into yarns and then plying these        Upper and lower tensions must be balanced to
yarns into a sewing thread. They are normally         produce a perfect stitch. The upper tension varies
made in two or three ply constructions depending      in location on different machines. It may be on
on the yarn size. (6)                                 the faceplate, on the front of the needle-bar
1.2.2. Core spun threads begin with a                 housing, or on the upper arm of the machine
continuous filament of polyester, which is then       head. It is usually adjusted with a dial. The lower
wrapped with a cotton or polyester sheath to          tension, located on the bobbin case, may be
make a single-ply thread. Then the two to four        adjusted by a screw.
plies are twisted together to make the sewing         Lower tension should only be adjusted if the
thread. (7) Cotton/poly threads have the advantage    problem cannot be fixed by adjusting the upper
of better sew ability, while poly/ poly threads can   tension.
be dyed in a one-step process. (8)                    As shown in fig.1 a perfect stitch will have
1.2.3. Monofilament threads are simply a single       threads locked midway between the two layers of
filament of nylon or polyester. It is stiff, wiry,    cloth, with no loops on the top or bottom of the
and unravels easily. It is uncomfortable next to      seam and no puckers in the cloth. If the bobbin
the skin and harsh on machines. (7) Monofilament      thread loops show on the top side of the seam
threads are translucent and reflect the fabric's      and the top thread is straight, the upper tension is
color. They are used primarily for blind              tighter than the lower. If spool thread loops show
                                                  314
International Design Journal Volume 4 Issue 3                                                   Technical Issues
2.1. Sewing thread specifications                          The following table2 illustrates the specifications
This study concerned with spun (cotton &                   of the tested sewing thread.
polyester) thread and filament polyester thread.
                                       Table 2 Sewing thread specifications
          Thread no.         Thread color               Thread type                      Thread size
              1                  Red                Spun polyester thread                 Ne 40/2
              2                Brown                 Spun cotton thread                   Ne 40/3
              3                 Green               Spun polyester thread                 Ne 22/3
              4                 White             Filament polyester thread              Denier150/1
2.3. Sewing specifications                                 volt, 2850 cycles per min., and 5000 stitches per
Tested samples are sewed by using Mitsubishi               min.
sewing machine model LS2-1150 with speed 220
Table3 illustrates the sewing specifications.
                                          Table 3 Sewing specifications
           Stitch type          Seam type              Stitch               Stitch             Needle
                                                     density/cm          length(mm)            number
        Lock stitch 301       Superimposed               5                   2.5                 12
2.4. Thread tension specifications                         or tight is the thread tension (as the number of
Five different tension levels are used as shown in         rounds decreases thread tension increases and
table 4. Number of rounds describe how loosen              vice versa.)
                                       Table 4 Thread tension specifications
              Thread             Thread          Thread tension3         Thread             Thread
             tension 1          tension 2                               tension 4          tension5
             2 rounds           5 rounds             7 rounds           9 rounds          11 rounds
average of five readings has been obtained for                         3.1.1. Effect of thread type at different tension
each property.                                                         levels on seam thickness
3. Results and Discussion                                              Table5 illustrates the effect of thread type at
3.1. Effect of thread type at different tension                        different tension levels on seam thickness
levels on seam properties
                              Table 5 Effect of thread type at different tension levels on seam thickness
                                                                   Seam thickness (mm)
                          Thread             Thread 1         Thread 2           Thread 3            Thread 4
                       tension level
                             1                 0.97             1.03                1.14              0.99
                             2                 0.94             1.01                1.11              0.97
                             3                 0.92             0.98                1.07              0.94
                             4                 1.02             1.06                1.21              1.04
                             5                 1.05             1.12                1.27              1.08
                                                                           indicate that, tension3 scored the least seam
           Effect of thread type at different                              thickness then tension2 then tension1. This
           tension levels on seam thickness                                can be attributed to the occurred seam pucker
                                                                           by increasing the tension which increases
  Seam thickness
                   2                                                       seam thickness.
                                                        Thread 1         Using tension5 and4 make fabric during
      (mm)
                   1
                                                        Thread 2           sewing uncontrolled and gathered bobbin
                   0                                                       thread behind fabric which leads to more
                                                        Thread 3
                                                                      increase in seam thickness.
                         Thread tension level
                                                        Thread 4         The thread type regression equation for
                                                                           thread1 is y= 0.024x + 0.908, for thread2 is
Fig.2. Effect of thread type at different tension levels on                y= 0.023x + 0.971, for thread3 is y= 0.036x
                      seam thickness                                       + 1.052 and for thread4 is y= 0.025x +
                                                                           0.929. Where y= seam thickness & x= thread
 (As shown in table5, fig.2) it can be noticed
                                                                           tension level. The thread type correlation
  that thread1 gives the least seam thickness
                                                                           coefficient on seam thickness is positive but
  then thread4 then thread2 while thread3 gives
                                                                           its significant effect in general is weak, as the
  the highest value as seam thickness increases
                                                                           correlation is strong when the value of R
  by increasing thread size.
                                                                           nearest to 1. For thread1 R = 0.4881, for
 Logically by increasing thread tension seam                              thread2 R = 0.4648, for thread3 R = 0.5063
  thickness decreases and vice versa. Duo to                               and for thread4 R = 0.4992.
  the higher tension that tighten the seams. But                       3.1.2. Effect of thread type at different tension
  this didnt happen as follows.                                       levels on seam stiffness
 Despite tension level1 is very tight, tension2                       Table6 illustrates the effect of thread type at
  is tight, tension3 is middle tension, tension4 is                    different tension levels on seam stiffness
  loose and tension5 is very loose, results
                                 Table 6 Effect of thread type at different tension levels on seam stiffness
                                                                Seam stiffness (mg.cm)
                          Thread              Thread 1          Thread 2           Thread 3           Thread 4
                       tension level
                             1                  215.8              233.7             240.9              216.8
                             2                  211.7              229.6             236.7              212.9
                             3                  204.6              224.9             229.6              207.3
                             4                  216.3               235              241.8              219.3
                             5                  217.8              235.4             242.6              221.5
                                                                   316
International Design Journal Volume 4 Issue 3                                                                          Technical Issues
                             150
                             100                                                   The thread type regression equation for
                              50                                  Thread 2           thread1 is y= 0.86x + 210.66, for thread2 is
                               0
                                                             Thread 3           y= 0.88x + 229.08, for thread3 is y= 0.85x +
                                                                                     235.77 and for thread4 is y= 1.58x + 210.82.
                                                                  Thread 4
                              Thread tension level                                   Where y= seam stiffness & x= thread tension
                                                                                     level. The thread type correlation coefficient
Fig.3. Effect of thread type at different tension levels on
                      seam stiffness                                                 on seam stiffness is positive but its significant
                                                                                     effect in general is too weak, as the
 (As shown in table6, fig.3) it can be noticed                                      correlation is strong when the value of R
  that thread1 gives the least seam stiffness                                        nearest to 1. For thread1 R= 0.065, for
  then thread4 then thread2 while thread3 gives                                      thread2 R= 0.0977, for thread3 R= 0.0624
  the highest value as seam stiffness increases                                      and for thread4 R= 0.198.
  by increasing thread size. (There is direct                                    3.1.3. Effect of thread type at different tension
  relation between thread number and seam                                        levels on seam tensile strength
  stiffness).                                                                    Table7 illustrates the effect of thread type at
 The fact that seam stiffness decreases by                                      different tension levels on seam tensile strength
  decreasing thread tension and vice versa,
  happened in case tension level1,2 and3 while
                                       Table 7 Effect of thread type at different tension levels on seam tensile strength
                                                                      Seam tensile strength (kgf/mm2)
                                  Thread
                                                       Thread 1        Thread 2            Thread 3             Thread 4
                               tension level
                                     1                 0.5494           0.4215              0.7308               0.1869
                                     2                 0.4432           0.4199              0.6874               0.1349
                                     3                 0.4306           0.4094              0.5409               0.1107
                                     4                 0.3984           0.3602              0.4915               0.0876
                                     5                 0.3279           0.2192              0.4497                0.066
                                                                                     increases.
                  Effect of thread type at different
                   tension levels on seam tensile                                   Despite thread1 and2 have the same size,
                               strength                                              thread1 gives higher tensile strength which
     Seam tensile strength
                             0.6                                Thread 1
                             0.4                                                    Thread4 scored the smallest seam tensile
                             0.2                                Thread 2             strength duo to its filament construction,
                               0
                                                                Thread 3             whereas spun construction is more durable
                                                   
                                                                                     than filament construction.
                                                                Thread 4
                              Thread tension level                                  As tension level1 refers to very tight tension,
                                                                                     tension2 is tight, tension3 is middle tension,
Fig.4. Effect of thread type at different tension levels on                          tension4 is loose and tension5 is very loose,
                   seam tensile strength
                                                                                     results indicate that, there is an inverse
 (As shown in table7, fig.4) it can be noticed                                      proportional relation between seam tensile
  that thread3 gives the highest seam tensile                                        strength and thread tension level. Hence seam
  strength, as thread size increases durability                                      tensile strength increases by increasing
                                                                             317
International Design Journal Volume 4 Issue 3                                                                       Technical Issues
  thread tension and vice versa. Where tighten                               general is very strong, as the correlation is
  seams are durable than loosen seams.                                       strong when the value of R nearest to 1. For
 The thread type regression equation for                                    thread1 R= 0.9204, for thread2 R= 0.7319,
  thread1 is y= -0.0488x + 0.5762, for thread2                               for thread3 R= 0.9481 and for thread4 R=
  is y= -0.0464x + 0.5053, for thread3 is y= -                               0.9594.
  0.0758x + 0.8075 and for thread4 is y= -                                3.1.4. Effect of thread type at different tension
  0.0289x + 0.204. Where y= seam tensile                                  levels on seam extensibility
  strength & x= thread tension level. The thread                             Table8 illustrates the effect of thread type at
  type correlation coefficient on seam tensile                              different tension levels on seam extensibility
  strength is negative but its significant effect in
                                  Table 8 Effect of thread type at different tension levels on seam extensibility
                                                                     Seam extensibility (%)
                           Thread           Thread 1           Thread 2              Thread 3              Thread 4
                        tension level
                              1                 9.045            6.944                 6.167                 4.778
                              2                 9.833            7.278                 6.209                 5.111
                              3                 9.945            7.889                 6.389                 5.611
                              4                 10.83             8.05                   6.5                 5.833
                              5                 13.89             8.89                  6.94                 5.984
                         5                                Thread 2
                                                                              decreasing thread tension and vice versa.
                         0                                Thread 3            Loosen seams elongates more than tighten
                                                                         seams.
                                                          Thread 4
                          Thread tension level                              The thread type regression equation for
                                                                              thread1 is y= 1.0687x + 7.5025, for thread2
Fig.5. Effect of thread type at different tension levels on                   is y= 0.4664x + 6.411, for thread3 is y=
                     seam extensibility                                       0.1837x + 5.8899 and for thread4 is y=
 (As shown in table8, fig.5) it can be noticed                               0.3134x +        4.5232. Where y= seam
  that thread4 gives the smallest seam                                        extensibility & x= thread tension level. The
  extensibility that can be attributed to its                                 thread type correlation coefficient on seam
  filament      construction,    while     spun                               extensibility is positive but its significant
  construction is more extensible than filament                               effect in general is very strong, as the
  construction.                                                               correlation is strong when the value of R
 Despite thread1 and2 have the same size,                                    nearest to 1. For thread1 R= 0.8013, for
  thread1 gives higher seam extensibility which                               thread2 R= 0.9611, for thread3 R= 0.8786
  can be attributed to fiber type as polyester                                and for thread4 R= 0.9598.
  elongate more than cotton.                                              3.1.5. Effect of thread type at different tension
 Whereas thread1 and3 have the same fiber                                levels on seam pucker
  type and construction, thread1 gives higher                             Table9 illustrates the effect of thread type at
  seam extensibility that can be referred to                              different tension levels on seam pucker
  thread number, as thinner thread is more                                Note: Seam pucker evaluated according to
  extensible.                                                             AATCC where 5 means no pucker and
 Results detect that, there is a direct                                          1 means severely pucker
                                                                      318
International Design Journal Volume 4 Issue 3                                                               Technical Issues
                                                                  319
International Design Journal Volume 4 Issue 3                                                       Technical Issues
                      4                           Thread 2
                                                                4. Conclusions
                      2                                              Thread and tension control are very
                      0                           Thread 3            important elements in apparel manufacturing
                                       
                                                  Thread 4            process.
                       Thread tension level                          Sewing thread which is described by fiber
                                                                      type, construction, and size, has a significant
Fig.7. Effect of thread type at different tension levels on           effect on seam properties.
                     seam appearance
                                                                     Thread 1 gives best result, due to its small
 There is an inverse relation between seam                           size as well as its polyester fiber type in
  appearance and seam pucker as seam                                  addition to its spun construction. So the
  appearance increases when seam pucker                               authors recommend using it for its best sew
  decreases.                                                          ability.
 (As shown in table10, fig.7) it can be noticed                     Thread tension has a significant effect on
  that thread4 gives the lowest seam                                  seam properties.
  appearance that can be attributed to its high                      Tightened thread tension causes seam pucker
  pucker resulted from its               filament                     that raises seam thickness which effect
  construction, while spun construction gives                         inversely on aesthetic appeal.
  lower pucker thus better aesthetic appeal.                         By loosen the thread tension fabric during
 Despite thread1 and2 have the same size,                            sewing became uncontrolled and bobbin
  thread1 gives higher seam appearance which                          thread was gathered behind fabric that leads
  can be attributed to fiber type as polyester                        to worst seam properties.
  puckers less than cotton therefore appears                         The authors recommend using the middle
  better.                                                             tension (tension control 3) that gives the best
 Whereas thread1 and3 have the same fiber                            seam properties.
  type and construction, thread1 gives better                   5. References
  seam appearance that can be referred to                           1- Garment Making, Sewing Thread &
  thread number, as thinner thread makes fewer                         Selection Criteria, New Cloth Market
  pucker thus better appearance.                                       Magazine, Thursday, August 22, 2013.
 Seam appearance increases by decreasing                           2- Shaeffer, Claire, Sewing for the industry,
  thread tension in case tension level1, 2 and3,                       2nd, Preason, 2013.
  while tension4 and5 differed as seam                              3- Ukponmwan, J.O., Mukhopadhyay, A. and
  appearance decreased by decreasing thread                            Chatterjee, K.N., Sewing threads, Textile
  tension. This can be referred to the gathered                        Progress, The Textile Institute, Vol. 30,
  bobbin thread behind fabric in addition to                           2000.
  open stitches occurred which decreased                            4- Hearle J. W. S., High-Performance Fibers,
  appearance.                                                          Woodhead Publishing, Ltd., Cambridge,
 The thread type regression equation for                              England, 2001.
  thread1 is y = -0.68x + 10.28 , for thread2 is                    5- Carr, H.,& Latham B., The technology of
  y = -0.52x + 9.24, for thread3 is y = -0.24x +                       clothing manufacturing, 3rd, ed. BSP.
  7.12 and for thread4 is y = -0.44x + 5.88.                           Professional books, London, 2000.
  Where y= seam appearance & x= thread                              6- Eberle, H., Hornberger, M., Menzer, D.,
  tension level. The thread type correlation                           Hermeling. Clothing technology from fiber
  coefficient on seam appearance is negative                           to fashion, 3rd ed., Verlag Europa-
  but its significant effect in general is                             Lehrmittel, 2002.
                                                              320
International Design Journal Volume 4 Issue 3                                            Technical Issues
7- Rudolf, A., Gersak, J., Influence of twist on              sewing thread at different sewing stages,
    alterations in fibers mechanical properties,             Textile Research Journal, 2009.
    Textile Research Journal, 2006.                       11- Marjorie M. Baker, M.S., Extension
8- Walter R. Hall, III, Warren F. Knoff, Ph.D.,               Associate for Textiles and Clothing,
    Tensile Strength Retention of Sewing                      September 2006.
    Thread, Journal of Engineered Fibers and              12- B.S.-2544: Method of test for determination
    Fabrics, Volume 3, Issue 4  2008.                        of thickness.
9- Lojen, D.Z., Gersak, J., Thread loading in             13- ASTM D 1388: Method of Test for
    different positions on the sewing machine,                Determination of Stiffness.
1. Textile Research Journal, 2005, 75, 498-               14- BS 3320:1988: Method for Determination
    506.                                                      of Tensile strength and extensibility.
10- Midha, V.K., Mukhopadhyay, A.,                        15- AATCC 88B-1978: Method for
    Chattopadhyay, R., Kothari, V.K., Studies                 Determination of Seam Pucker.
    on the changes in tensile properties of
321