English for Specific Purposes World, ISSN 1682-3257, www.esp-world.info, Issue 44, Vol.
15, 2014
English Language Needs of Engineering Students and their Syllabus: A
Comparative Study of Two Universities in Maharashtra
Ms. Sunanda Patil (Shinde)* and Dr. Tripti Karekatti
*Gharda Institute of Technology, Lavel, Dist.- Ratnagiri-415 708. Maharashtra.
Department of English, Shivaji University, Kolhapur- 416 004. Maharashtra. 1
Email: sunandagpatil@gmail.com
1. Introduction:
The recent boom in the engineering education in India has given rise to new issues and
problems. According to the All India Council for Technical Education (AICTE) every year
approximately four lakh and fifty thousand students get admission for engineering degree course
in the country. As per the report of Multinational Companies, however, there is a mismatch
between the skills students are graduating with and the skills required by the industries. Only
twenty five percent engineering graduates are employable, whereas, the rest of the candidates
dont have proper technical skills, English competency, communication and presentation skills
and the ability to work as a part of a team.
Although engineering graduates are highly qualified academically, employers are hesitant to
hire these graduates due to their poor proficiency in the language. It is a need of time to produce
world class graduates to meet the demands of the changing and competitive engineering
industries. Having realized the status of English as an international language and its importance
as a major communication tool, educationists are taking steps to investigate ways to help and
develop communication skills among engineering students. Hence, understanding the
communication requirements of engineers in Multinational Companies and actual
English Language Needs of Engineering Students and their Syllabus: A Comparative Study of Two Universities in Maharashtra
Ms. Sunanda Patil (Shinde)* and Dr. Tripti Karekatti
English for Specific Purposes World, ISSN 1682-3257, www.esp-world.info, Issue 44, Vol. 15, 2014
communicative situations in which English is essential has become necessary to find out.
Furthermore, it is equally essential to ensure that the English language syllabus that have been
designed and implemented for engineering students at university level matches with the
communicative situations and requirements of Multinational Companies.
This paper discusses the real communicative situations for engineers where effective English 2
is essential. The purpose of this study is to identify communicative situations where English
would be required by the industries. Moreover it intends to compare the syllabuses designed and
implemented for engineering students in two different universities in Maharashtra namely:
Mumbai University, Mumbai and Shivaji University, Kolhapur.
2 Needs Analysis:
Needs analysis has a vital role in the process of designing and carrying out any language
course, whether it be English for Specific Purposes (ESP) or general English course, and its
centrality has been acknowledged by several scholars and authors (Munby, 1978; Richterich and
Chancerel, 1987; Hutchinson and Waters, 1987; Berwick, 1989; Brindley, 1989; Tarone and
Yule, 1989; Robinson, 1991; Johns, 1991; West, 1994; Allison et al. 1994; Seedhouse, 1995;
Jordan, 1997; Dudley-Evans and St. John, 1998; Iwai et al. 1999; Hamp- Lyons, 2001; Finney,
2002). Also, the importance of carrying out a needs analysis for developing EAP tests is
emphasized by Fulcher (1999), McDonough (1984), and Carrol (1980, cited in Fulcher, 1999)
According to Iwai et al. (1999), the term needs analysis generally refers to the activities that are
involved in collecting information that will serve as the basis for developing a curriculum that
will meet the needs of a particular group of students. Brindley (1989) and Berwick (1989) offer
definitions of different types of needs and accounts of various problems and limitations in
English Language Needs of Engineering Students and their Syllabus: A Comparative Study of Two Universities in Maharashtra
Ms. Sunanda Patil (Shinde)* and Dr. Tripti Karekatti
English for Specific Purposes World, ISSN 1682-3257, www.esp-world.info, Issue 44, Vol. 15, 2014
making use of this concept, including ways in which we might usefully distinguish between
needs identified by analysts and those expressed or experienced by learners. In his state-of-the-
art article, West (1994) gives a thorough overview of needs analysis in language teaching,
including its history, theoretical basis, approaches to needs analysis, etc.
It is essential to ensure that our engineering students are equipped with the necessary 3
communication skills to face their challenging professional environment. While designing
syllabus, syllabus designers should consult or solicit necessary information from industries as
well as elicit students needs. The syllabus needs to be more relevant to industry because this
will help enhance human-capital development in the country. We can also seek
recommendations from the private sector on what to include in the syllabus, so that we can equip
students with the knowledge and skills that are needed.
2.1 Workplace Communication Needs:
In todays corporate world engineers are not only required to effectively convey technical
information but they also need to have appropriate communication skills in order to excel in the
workplace. Unfortunately, some engineers are unable to meet these challenges and requirements.
Lack of communication skills is one of the most prominent reasons of failure. It has resulted in
collaboration between engineering education, the industry and communication educators. Now a
day, it is very much essential for communication and language educators to adapt new
approaches to teach ESP. They need to know in what manner they can better equip the
engineering students so that they can function well in their professional life.
This paper, therefore, describes an effort to identify and evaluate the needs of engineering
students and to study whether the syllabus addresses their needs.
English Language Needs of Engineering Students and their Syllabus: A Comparative Study of Two Universities in Maharashtra
Ms. Sunanda Patil (Shinde)* and Dr. Tripti Karekatti
English for Specific Purposes World, ISSN 1682-3257, www.esp-world.info, Issue 44, Vol. 15, 2014
3. The Study:
This study utilized a self developed open-ended questionnaire to identify the importance of
English for engineers, their needs and problems they face while using English. It includes
interviews of in-service engineers to know the English language skills and the communicative
situations in which English is essential. The need to know what is actually being practiced in 4
companies and industries will definitely help educators, language practioners and content
developers/ syllabus designers to prepare their students to face the working world.
3.1 Samples:
The participants were fifty engineering students from engineering colleges under two
different universities. Twenty five students were from Mumbai University and twenty five
students were from Shivaji University Kolhapur. Open-ended questionnaire consisting three
statements was given to the fifty students. The students were asked to write their views on the
following statements:
1. English as a global language
2. Needs of English for Engineering students
3. Problems I face while using English
Interviews are a direct way of finding out of what people think or do (Long, 2005). So, ten in-
service engineers were interviewed to know actual oral and written communicative situations in
which effective use of English is inevitable.
3.2 Data Analysis:
In-service engineers interview data was analysed to find actual communicative situations in
which they have to use English. The responses to questionnaire were analysed qualitatively. The
English Language Needs of Engineering Students and their Syllabus: A Comparative Study of Two Universities in Maharashtra
Ms. Sunanda Patil (Shinde)* and Dr. Tripti Karekatti
English for Specific Purposes World, ISSN 1682-3257, www.esp-world.info, Issue 44, Vol. 15, 2014
data was analysed to discover students communicative needs, their views on English as a global
language and problems they face while using language. Later on, English syllabuses of both the
universities were studied comparatively. Finally the findings were interpreted and conclusions
drawn.
4. Findings and Discussion: 5
4.1. Communicative situations:
Ten in-service engineers were interviewed for the present study. They were asked questions
related to situations where English is essential. Following are some communicative situations
identified after discussion with in-service engineers.
Sr. No. Communicative Situations Category
1 Reading written instructions/advice
2 Reading abstract of projects READING
3 Reading journals and publications
4 Reading manuals
5 Reading office documents
6 Recording equipment and safety checklist
7 Communicating through E-mails
8 Writing minutes of the meetings
WRITING
9 Writing daily/periodic reports
10 Writing abstracts of projects
11 Writing business letters
12 Delivering oral presentations
13 Attending meetings/ occasional visits
SPEAKING
14 Talking about daily life situations
15 Telephonic conversations with boss/ clients
English Language Needs of Engineering Students and their Syllabus: A Comparative Study of Two Universities in Maharashtra
Ms. Sunanda Patil (Shinde)* and Dr. Tripti Karekatti
English for Specific Purposes World, ISSN 1682-3257, www.esp-world.info, Issue 44, Vol. 15, 2014
16 Facing interviews
17 Public Speeches: formal/ informal
18 Listening in international seminars LISTENING
19 Doing post graduate study
20 Joining field trips abroad
21 Training abroad
MULTI SKILLS
22 Resolving conflicts
23 Negotiating with team members
24 Teleconferencing
25 Working in a team
4.2 English as a global language:
According to engineering students from Mumbai University in 21st century its most
important to step forward with the rapid change and they are aware that in this competitive world
English is the only language of opportunity. They also know that dealing with foreign clients and
customers English is essential. They think English is the powerful language with adequate
vocabulary and now a day speaking in English has been considered prestigious. All technical
books, books related to laws, commerce and medical are available in English. It is also a
language of internet. Not only in engineering but in all profession English is needed and it has
become language of business. All students are agreeing that English is the link language which
links people from different religion, caste, culture.
English Language Needs of Engineering Students and their Syllabus: A Comparative Study of Two Universities in Maharashtra
Ms. Sunanda Patil (Shinde)* and Dr. Tripti Karekatti
English for Specific Purposes World, ISSN 1682-3257, www.esp-world.info, Issue 44, Vol. 15, 2014
Engineering students from Shivaji University have same opinions and views. According to
them English is easy language and it is a window to the world.
4.3 Needs of English for engineering students:
Students from Mumbai University accept that English is globally recognized and approved
language. So to work with various foreign companies and even Indian companies English 7
communication skill is essential. For presentation (Oral and Written), writing projects, group
discussions, public speaking, interviews, aptitude tests, viva, seminars, workshops English is
important. Writing reports, e-mails, letters, giving details of work, reporting on various projects
English is necessary. As per the views of Shivaji University students English is needed to
converse with boss and clients. For writing exam papers, facing interviews, presentations, group
discussion English is must.
Students from both the universities have almost same opinions about English and needs of
English for engineers.
4.4 Problems I face while using English:
As per the data collected from engineering students of Mumbai University they face
problems related to grammar and vocabulary. While speaking they dont get right word at right
place. As some of them are from vernacular background, they face problem of understanding
difficult words. They stumble, stutter when they start speaking. Most of them have lack of self
confidence and stage fright. Some of them face problem of gap fillers. While writing they make
mistakes in framing sentences, using tenses and prepositions.
English Language Needs of Engineering Students and their Syllabus: A Comparative Study of Two Universities in Maharashtra
Ms. Sunanda Patil (Shinde)* and Dr. Tripti Karekatti
English for Specific Purposes World, ISSN 1682-3257, www.esp-world.info, Issue 44, Vol. 15, 2014
Shivaji University students also have the same problems. Lack of confidence, stage fright,
problems of using correct tenses, phrases, idioms, proper use of pronunciations these are some of
them. The core problem is they dont get enough exposure from teachers and from society.
4.5 Syllabi:
4.5.1 Mumbai University: 8
Realizing the need to improve the communication skills of engineering students, English
syllabus of Mumbai University focuses on both oral and written forms of communication. In
their second semester these engineering students have Communication Skills subject which
includes modules like communication theory; techniques to improve communication;
vocabulary, grammar and aptitude test; summarization and comprehension; basic official
correspondence (Business letter writing); basic technical writing etc. Presentation and
Communication Techniques subject is prescribed in third semester which includes modules like
business communication; advanced technical writing (report writing, technical paper writing,
writing business proposals etc.); interpersonal skills; presentation skills; career skills (resume and
cover letter writing, interview techniques); group discussion etc. For Communication Skills there
is university paper of seventy five marks. Also, there is term work for fifty marks. These fifty
marks have been segregated into two parts; term work twenty five marks and oral twenty five
marks. In term work five marks are for attendance; ten marks are for assignments and ten marks
are for unit test. In oral fifteen marks are for GD and ten marks are for public speech. For
Presentation and Communication Techniques there is no university paper; it has only term
work for fifty marks. In it project report writing is for fifteen marks, GD is for ten marks, five
marks are for attendance; ten marks are for assignments and ten marks are for unit test.
English Language Needs of Engineering Students and their Syllabus: A Comparative Study of Two Universities in Maharashtra
Ms. Sunanda Patil (Shinde)* and Dr. Tripti Karekatti
English for Specific Purposes World, ISSN 1682-3257, www.esp-world.info, Issue 44, Vol. 15, 2014
4.5.2 Shivaji University:
To develop communication abilities of students, Shivaji University has prescribed two
subjects for engineering students: Professional Communication I and Professional
Communication II in first and second semester respectively. Professional Communication I
consists modules like communication (Nature, process and barriers, form); techniques of 9
communication (verbal and non verbal); rapid review of grammar and prcis writing. Theory
lectures allotted to whole syllabus are fourteen and practical hours are twenty eight for a batch of
twenty students. There is no university paper for this subject but only term work is for twenty
five marks. For term work teachers are informed to take formal speeches, GD, vocabulary
exercise, language lab sessions on phonetics and grammar, prcis writing exercises, exercises of
summarizing, English articles and news, games on team building, communication and public
speaking. Teachers are not given any evaluation scheme; they are told to give overall twenty five
marks to all the above tasks.
Professional Communication II comprises techniques of professional correspondence, types
of professional correspondence; report writing (importance and techniques of report writing);
investigation reports (losses, strikes, declines); survey reports (examining feasibility of
proposals); inspection reports of department, branches, factory etc. For this subject also fourteen
lectures are allocated. One tutorial of one hour per week for twenty students batch is allotted.
Term work includes practice of report writing, technical paragraph writing, and presentation
techniques. Term work is for twenty five marks and here also no evaluation scheme is given.
In discussion with few teachers from Shivaji University, it is found that students do not take
this subject seriously as there is no university paper. Consequently, many colleges do not appoint
English Language Needs of Engineering Students and their Syllabus: A Comparative Study of Two Universities in Maharashtra
Ms. Sunanda Patil (Shinde)* and Dr. Tripti Karekatti
English for Specific Purposes World, ISSN 1682-3257, www.esp-world.info, Issue 44, Vol. 15, 2014
regular teachers for this subject. As a result, these prospective engineers lag behind in global
competition only because of lack of sufficient English Skills.
5. Comparison:
After studying syllabus of both the universities, knowing the problems of engineering
students and analysing communicative situations identified from the interviews of in-service 10
engineers, researchers have found that in Mumbai University syllabus almost all the
communicative situations have been included. In Shivaji University syllabus also many of the
situations have been covered; but still some important situations have not been considered. For
example, writing notice, agenda and minutes; email writing; project report writing; resolving
conflicts; negotiating; etc. In Mumbai University Presentation and Communication Techniques
subject Interpersonal Skills module is prescribed in which team building, negotiation, time
management, decision making, conflict resolution, emotional intelligence, all these skills have
been included which are very useful for engineers. To teach students importance of
teambuilding, syllabus designers have included technical project report writing and presentation
of the same with the help of PowerPoint. Such activities motivate students to learn new things
interestingly. Shivaji University should also include such modules which help students to
develop their overall personality. Furthermore, there should be a proper evaluation scheme to
increase seriousness about the subject. Like Mumbai University, Shivaji University should also
have university paper at least for one semester. Term work marks segregation should be given
clearly.
English Language Needs of Engineering Students and their Syllabus: A Comparative Study of Two Universities in Maharashtra
Ms. Sunanda Patil (Shinde)* and Dr. Tripti Karekatti
English for Specific Purposes World, ISSN 1682-3257, www.esp-world.info, Issue 44, Vol. 15, 2014
6. Conclusion:
This paper tried to highlight the needs of English for engineering students, identify the
communicative skills required by the industry as well as the various types of communicative
situations engaged in by professional engineers in the workplace, and evaluate English syllabus 11
of two different universities. To develop a more comprehensive engineering educational program
that meets and exceeds the real needs of students and industry, feedback from both is useful. As
well as, while choosing respondents for the need analysis, multinational companies and
industries where English is used as the international language, should be approached instead of
the national industries. This is because once students are trained in the standard requirements of
multinational industries; they could survive the challenges of the national companies.
Engineering education committee and syllabus designers should take into consideration the
needs of students while framing syllabus. Focus of the syllabus should be on theoretical as well
as practical knowledge. They should try to include all the useful communicative situations to
engineers. Equal importance should be given to all language skills i.e. listening, speaking,
reading, and writing.
References:
Burapa University. (2009). Program of study: English for engineering.
<http://reg.buu.ac.th/registrar/program_info_1> Retrieved 05.01.09.
English Language Needs of Engineering Students and their Syllabus: A Comparative Study of Two Universities in Maharashtra
Ms. Sunanda Patil (Shinde)* and Dr. Tripti Karekatti
English for Specific Purposes World, ISSN 1682-3257, www.esp-world.info, Issue 44, Vol. 15, 2014
Chang, M. (2004). Why some graduates are more marketable than others [PowerPoint slides].
Retrieved from: <http://www.epu.gov.my/seminars>.
Crosling, G., & Ward, I. (2002). Oral communication: The workplace needs and uses of business
graduate employees. English for Specific Purposes, 21, 4157.
12
Darling, A. L., & Dannels, D. P. (2003). Practicing engineers talk about the importance of talk:
A report on the role of oral communication in the workplace. Communication Education, 52(1),
116.
Dudley-Evans, T., & St John, M. J. (1998). Developments in ESP: A multi-disciplinary
approach. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Khon Kaen University. (2009). 11107 English for science and technology I.
<http://reg.kku.ac.th/registrar/course_infomain> Retrieved 01.01.09.
Long, M. H. (2005). Methodological issues in learner needs analysis. In M. H. Long (Ed.),
Second language needs analysis (pp. 1976). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Splitt, F. G. (Ed.). (1993). The industrial needs of the engineer in the 21st century: An update. In
Proceedings from 71st annual fall conference. Boston, MA: Northeastern University.
English Language Needs of Engineering Students and their Syllabus: A Comparative Study of Two Universities in Maharashtra
Ms. Sunanda Patil (Shinde)* and Dr. Tripti Karekatti
