Proposal writing
Dr. Sara Lavinia Brair
Associate Professor, Community Medicine
          Al Neelain University
            Lecture outlines
   Defining thesis or dissertation
   Determine the main steps for proposal writing
   Identify purpose of a proposal
   Identify a few tips to reduce anxiety while
    preparing the proposal
   Identify the structure of a proposal
            Lecture outlines
   Describe method for writing the methodology
    chapter
   Discuss Gantt chart
   Discuss budget calculation
   Discuss what to include in the appendix/annex
             A thesis is 
 A dissertation or thesis is a document submitted in
  support of candidature for an academic degree or
  professional qualification presenting the author's
  research and findings.
 In some countries/universities, the word "thesis" or a
  cognate is used as part of a bachelor's or master's
  course, while "dissertation" is normally applied to a
  doctorate, while in others, the reverse is true.
            Research proposal
 The first part of the thesis will be the research proposal
 In order to continue on with the thesis, the research
  proposal has to be approved by your supervisor and then
  submitted to the research ethics committee for approval
 The Research Ethics committee (REC) or institutional
  review board (IRB) will review the proposal for ethical
  problems
 Only after IRB approval will you be able to start the
  research
                Writing Proposals
The proposal describes the proposed plan of work:
 What you intend to study (scope and research questions)
 How you intend to study your topic (methodology)
 Why this topic needs to be studied (significance)
 When you will complete this work (timeline)
 How much will it cost to conduct this work (budget)
                  Writing Proposals
Purpose:
 Justify and plan a research project
 Show how your project contributes to existing research
 Demonstrate that you understand how to conduct
  discipline-specific research in an acceptable time-frame
Audience:
 Supervisor and research ethics committee
     Proposal Writing and Anxiety
           General Advice
 Establish a writing schedule
 Begin by free-writing
 Keep a small notebook with you to write down
  relevant thoughts
 Compose different parts in different computer files
  or on different index cards
 Start with more clear cut sections first
Proposal Writing and Anxiety
  Proposal-specific Advice
  Understand that the proposal will be negotiated,
   therefore be prepared to revise!
  Think of the proposal as an introduction to your
   thesis or dissertation
  Remember that the proposal is not a binding
   contract
  Remember that your proposal is not meant to limit
   ideas, but to help you think practically
  Ask colleagues to form a writing group and revise
   each others work
  Talk to your supervisor!
Steps in development of a
    research proposal
             Step 1
Decide on the problem for research
       (problem statement)
             Step 2
    Do some literature search
    and review other studies
             Step 3
     Formation of objectives
           Step 4
Decide your research method
           Step 5
   Discuss and decide your
        Work  plan
           Step 6
Plan for project administration
           Step 7
     Calculate the Budget
Structure of the research Proposal
  Cover page
  Student Declaration page
  Chapter 1: Introduction
    1. Background
    2. Problem Statement
    3. Justification
    4. Objectives
    5. Hypothesis (if any)
  Chapter 2: Literature Review (depends on institutional
   guidelines  this chapter is not a requirement in the proposal
   in some universities)
Structure of the research Proposal
  Chapter 3: Methodology
    Study Design
    Study Population
       Inclusion & exclusion criteria
    Study Area/Study Setting
    Sampling
       Sample size
       Sampling technique
Structure of the research Proposal
    Data collection:
       Data collection tool
       List of variables
       Data Analysis
    Ethical consideration
       Ethical approval from the university, hospital
        administration
       Permission from area where research is conducted
       Consent from patients
Structure of the research Proposal
  Work Plan (Gantt chart)
  Budget
    Budget justification
    Project administration
  References
  Annex
   Submission of the proposal
 Prepare a letter of intent that clearly summarizes your
  research proposal and the estimated resources required, to
  send to potential funding agencies when needed.
 Some universities might require a presentation to the
  research ethics committee
                 1. Cover Page
 Cover page will depend on the institutional guidelines,
  therefore always read those guidelines before embarking
  on your proposal
 This page should not be paginated
 All wording should be single-spaced and in uppercase
 The title at the cover page to be bold and font-size is 14
                   Cover Page
Items will be arranged in the following sequence:
 Name of the institution
 Title: which should be focused, informative and not more
  than 16 words (some institutions have different number of
  wordings)
For Masters
 A Research Proposal submitted in partial fulfilment of the
  Requirements for the Award of the Degree of (specify, e.g.
  Master of Science) in the School of Medicine
                      Cover Page
For PhD
 A Research Proposal submitted in fulfilment of the Requirements
  for the Award of the Degree of (specify, e.g. PhD) in the School of
  Medicine
 Full names of student followed by highest qualification in
  standard abbreviation in brackets
 Registration number of student below the name
 Name of supervisor followed by highest qualification in standard
  abbreviation in brackets
 Month and year of submission comes immediately after (Centred)
          2. Declaration Page
 To have the following writings in font 12, Times New
  Roman ( check institutional guidelines)
A. Student declaration:
    This Proposal is my original work and has not been
     presented for a Degree in any other University. Then
     the student signs above his/her name and registration
     number, followed by the date. E.g.:
    Signature:                 Date:
             Declaration Page
B. Supervisor declaration:
 This proposal has been submitted for review with our
  approval as University supervisors
 Then the supervisors, sign above at least two of their
  names written in full, together with their respective
  departments.
 The name of the main supervisor should appear at the
  top and the other(s) below it. e.g.:
Signature:            Date:
Prof.                    Department
Al Neelain University
           Title of the study
 You can finalize the title of your study after you
  have chosen your problem for study and decided
  what your objectives for the study were
 The title should be in line with your general
  objective
                  The Title
 A good title is defined as the fewest possible
  words that adequately describe the contents of
  the paper
 The title is extremely important and must be
  chosen with great care as it will be read by
  thousands, whereas few will read the entire paper
 Indexing and abstracting of the paper depends on
  the accuracy of the title. An improperly titled
  paper will get lost and will never be read
                Title of the study
Criteria for the title:
1. Aim specific:
  (What is the research about?)
2. Place specific:
  (Where the research will be implemented?)
3. Time specific:
  (When the research is planned to be implemented?)
Example:
NOT: A study on home management of dehydration
BUT: Cost and quality of home management of
 dehydration in Khartoum state during the year 2010"
                     The Title
 Titles should neither be too short nor too long as
  to be meaningless (16  18 words)
 Remove empty phrases (studies on, investigations
  on)
 Words like on, a, an, the etc. should not be used
  unless needed
 Be careful with Joining words like (and, with)
 Word order must be very carefully considered
                   The Title
 It should contain the keywords that reflect the
  contents of the paper
 It should be meaningful and not general
 It should be concise, specific and informative
 Subtitles can be used Exercise and Coronary
  Heart Disease: Framingham Offspring Study
            How to Prepare the Title
 Make a list of the most important keywords
 Think of a title that contains these words
 The title states subject not conclusion of the paper
 The title should be in line with your general
  objective
 The title NEVER contains abbreviations, chemical
  formulas, proprietary names or jargon
 Think, rethink of the title before submitting the
  proposal
 Be very careful of the grammatical errors due to
  faulty word order
       Chapter 1: Introduction
The introduction should start with an introduction which
specifies the subtitles of content covered.
 Four important things to include:
    What is the problem
    Why is it important
    Highlight the gap
    Your research aim
 1. Background to the Study  what is the problem?
 2. Problem Statement and Justification  why is it
  important, highlight the gap
 3. Purpose of the study  your research aim
         Chapter 1: Introduction
1. Background to the Study
Introduces subject area under study and current situation
 The topic is introduced comprehensively
 The research topic strengthened with the relevant literature
  and appropriate statistical data (international, regional &local
  data)
 Information such as back ground information about the
  research topic, problem definition, description & statement
 Introduction should systematically move from the known
  information to the unknown information and knowledge gaps
  to the hypothesis and research questions ending with
  justification
          Chapter 1: Introduction
2. Problem Statement
 A Problem is discrepancy between what should be and what is
  existing  problem under study should be stated clearly, (to be
  precise and focused)
3. Justification
 The justification/rationale -this is the logical reasoning to show why
  the research topic is important and the need to conduct the
  research project
 Justification should be precise and focused on important aspects of
  the research topic which are convincing for acceptance
 Significance - explain the benefits and the beneficiaries of the
  findings of the study
       4. Research objectives
Definition:
The Objectives of a research project summarize
what is to be achieved by the study
The objective answers three main questions
 what, where and why?
       Why should the objectives be
              developed?
Objectives will help to:
 Focus the study (narrowing it down to essentials)
 Avoid collection of unnecessary data
 Organize the study in clearly defined parts or
  phrases
 Select the right type of design
 Orient the collection, analysis, interpretation and
  utilization of data
Properly formulated specific objectives will
           help in the following
1. Selection of the right type of study design
2. Orientation of data collection
3. Evaluation of the study
 When the research project is evaluated the results will be
  compared to the objectives
 If the objectives have not been spelled out clearly, the
  project cannot be evaluated
  Structure of the research proposal
 Chapter 2 : Literature Review (optional) - will be discussed in
  the write up of the research
 Chapter 3: Methodology
   1. Study Design
   2. Study Population
      Inclusion & exclusion criteria
   3. Study Area/Study Setting
   4. Sampling
      Sample size
      Sampling technique
Structure of the research proposal
 5. Data collection:
    Data collection tool
    List of variables
    Data Analysis
 6. Ethical consideration
     Ethical approval from the university, hospital
       administration
     Permission from area where research is conducted
     Consent from patients
                  1. Study designs
 A study design is a specific plan or protocol for conducting
  the study, which allows the investigator to translate the
  conceptual hypothesis into an operational one
 The study design of the research should be described in
  detail
 You should describe both the study design and where it will
  be conducted (facility or community)
Example:
   A cross sectional community based study
   Analytic - case control, facility (or hospital) based study
             2. Study population
The general characteristics of the study population:
 The health status
 Demographic data
 Census of the population
 Social and cultural data
 Inclusion & exclusion criteria if present (not all
  studies need an inclusion and exclusion criteria)
   3. The study area/study setting
 The geographical location and land marks of the study area
 The geographical and administrative borders
 A map of the study area could be included in the annex
 You are trying to set the scene for the reader regarding the
  area where you are conducting your research; whether
  community or facility
 If study is conducted in a community  we say study area
 If study is conducted in a facility  we say study setting
4. Sample size and sampling technique
             5. Data collection
Data collection tool:
1. The method for data collection are to be
   included:
    Questionnaire
    Interviews
    Focused group discussions
    Check list
    Review of documents, reports
 2. Number of questions, domains on the method
 of data collection are to be specified
                List of variables
 A Variable is a characteristic of a person, object or
  phenomenon which can take on different values. These may
  be in the form of numbers or non-numerical characteristics
 Variables are:
   Qualitative (categorical)
      Nominal e.g.: red, blue
      Ordinal e.g.: severe, moderate, mild
   Quantitative (numerical)
      Continuous e.g.: temperature
      Discrete e.g.: number of children
 List of variables are obtained from the specific objectives, and
  the list of variables yield question on the questionnaire
                  Data analysis
The data analysis plan:
  Manual
  By an appropriate computer program
  Write the version of the program
Example:
SPSS version 16
Type of analysis:
  Uni-variate analysis
  Bivariate analysis
  Multivariate analysis
       6. Ethical consideration
 Ethical approval from the university, hospital
  administration
 Permission from area where research is conducted
 Consent from participants
 Privacy and confidentiality as well as the right to
  withdraw was explained to participants
                    Work plan
 A work plan is a schedule, chart or graph that summarizes
  the different components of a research project and how
  they will be implemented in a coherent way within a
  specific time-span
   It may include:
   The tasks to be performed
   When and where the tasks will be performed
   Who will perform the tasks and the time each person will
    spend on them  training of data collectors
 The Gantt chart
 A Gantt chart is a planning tool that depicts graphically the
  order in which various tasks must be completed and the
  duration of each activity
                         The Gantt chart
Work         Jan   Feb   Mar   Apr   May   Jun   Jul   Aug   Sep   Oct   Nov   Dec
activities
Hire
personnel
Pre test
methods
Print
forms
Data
collection
Data entry
Data
analysis
-Interpre
tation
Report
writing
                 Gantt chart
Check this website for a free Gantt chart template download
 http://www.vertex42.com/ExcelTemplates/excel-gantt-
  chart.html
                           Budget
Why do we need to design a budget?
A detailed budget will help you to identify which resources
  are already locally available and which additional resources
  may be required
The process of budget design will encourage you to consider
  aspects of the work plan you have not thought about before
  and will serve as a useful reminder of activities planned, as
  your research gets underway
When should budget preparation begin?
A complete budget is not prepared until the final stage of
  project planning, the use of locally available resources
  increases the feasibility of the project from a financial point
  of view
  How should a budget be prepared?
a) It is necessary to use the work plan as a starting
  point
b) Specify, for each activity in the work plan, what
 resources are required
c) Determine for each resource needed the unit cost
  and the total cost
This is a link for a yearly budget calculator:
http://www.vertex42.com/Calculators/budget-
calculator.html
              Budget justification
a) It is not sufficient to present a budget without explanation
b) The budget justification follows the budget as an
  explanatory note justifying briefly, in the context of the
  proposal, why the various items in the budget are required
c) Make sure you give clear explanations concerning why
  items that may seem questionable or that are particularly
  costly are needed and discuss how complicated expenses
  have been calculated
d) If a strong budget justification has been prepared, it is less
  likely that essential items will be cut during proposal
  review
             Project administration
Project administration: is the term for all the
 activities involved in managing the human,
 material, financial and logistical resources of a
 project
Presenting the research proposal to the relevant
 authorities:
Before a research project can be implemented, the
 research proposal has to be approved by the
 relevant health authorities. In addition, the
 researchers may be requested to make a brief
 verbal presentation or defend the proposal in
 person
                References
 References will be discussed separately
             Annex/appendix
 Only important documents supporting the content of the
  text should be appended to the thesis
 Each appendix must be referred to in the body of the text
   Example: see template 1 for map of the area
 The appendices are listed in the table of contents
                         Conclusion
 Title of the study
 A brief description of the problem, why the study is needed, what
  information is needed and how such information will be used
 Objectives of the study
 A brief statement on the type of study design, sample(s) and
  methods of data collection
 A summary of how and when the study will be implemented
  (where, by whom, when, etc.)
 A summary of how data will be analyzed to provide the required
  information
 A summary of the main resources required (e.g.: manpower,
  budget, transport)
 A brief summary of ethical considerations, and plan for project
  administration, monitoring and utilization of results