Marketing Practices of Indian Medical Tourism-A Review: Sangeeta
Marketing Practices of Indian Medical Tourism-A Review: Sangeeta
                                                                                                                       186
  
                        IRACST- International Journal of Research in Management & Technology (IJRMT), ISSN: 2249-9563
                                                                                           Vol. 5, No.1, February 2015
 broader notion having longstanding historical                 Medical tourism industry is ever under pressure to
background in country like India, including spas,              justify their marketing practices and expenditures
Ayurveda therapy, and Homeopathic treatments.                  carried out in response. What are the major indicators
Medical tourism has been stated as                             that affect the medical tourism and what are the
                                                               strategies obligatory to opt has a major issue.
‘….when consumers elect to travel across                       Marketing strategies helps in achieving increased
international borders with the intention of receiving          sales in an organisation with a sustainable
some form of medical treatment. This treatment may             competitive advantage by focusing on the limited
span the full range of medical services, but most              resources. Marketing practices like promotion of
commonly includes dental care, cosmetic surgery,               health care service, physical evidence, price
elective surgery, and fertility treatment.’(OECD,              effectiveness etc. have contributed in medical tourism
2010).                                                         development most. Price and promotional sensitivity
                                                               is expected to increase as downturn depreciates the
‘….to people who live in one country and travel to             value of rupee. Sales sensitivity in medical tourism
another country in order to receive medical, dental            signify the receipts from medical tourist in form of
and surgical care while at the same time receiving             selling services and price sensitivity deals with the
equal to or greater care than they would have in their         change in price of services with effect to fluctuations.
own country, and are traveling for medical care                Most of the studies have been undertaken in USA,
because of affordability, better access to care or a           UK and developed nations to find out the marketing
higher level of quality of care.’ (Medical Tourism             practices opted in healthcare industry. However
Association, 2011).                                            different possible mechanisms should be explored to
                                                               understand the ways through which service providers
Broadly speaking, medical tourism is the act of                can rebuild the strategies for attracting large no. of
traveling to obtain medical care among three                   patients inbound or outbound. The paper is structured
categories as outbound, inbound and intrabound                 in three parts and next section covers the research
(Deloitte, 2008; USAID, 2009). As travel with the              methodology and objectives of study. The third part
aim of improving one’s health, medical tourism is an           considers broader literature pertinent to propositions
economic activity that entails trade in services and           formed in respect of marketing practices opted by
represents the splicing of at least two sectors:               medical tourism and findings pertaining to same.
medicine and tourism (Bookman & Bookman, 2007;
Deloitte, 2009; Rath et al., 2012).
                                                               II.            OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY
General agreement on Trade in services (GATS) has              This paper aims to scrutinize how India could
defined the health service through four modes of               become a magnet for medical tourists by streamlining
supply examine by Chanda (2002) as Cross-border                marketing practices in this regard. So present study
delivery of trade (mode 1), Consumption of health              try to explore the marketing practice opted for
services abroad (mode 2), Commercial presence                  restructuring of medical units in India.
(mode 3), Movement of health personnel (mode 4).
Medical tourism falls under mode 2 which considers             III.           RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
the movement of persons to the service providing               The framework mainly considers the marketing
countries. Here patient’s home country is considered           practices of Indian medical tourism. The focus of this
as ‘importer’ of the medical services while country            article is on the major marketing practices like
that offer medical tourism services is termed as               promotion of health care service, physical evidence,
destination country, hence, ‘exporter’ of services.            price effectiveness, price competitiveness. The paper
Over 35 countries are serving around a million                 review relevant literature from respective journals
medical tourists annually. World medical tourism               which are most important source of study. The paper
market is estimated to be around $60 billion currently         covers wide collection of academic literature on
(Deloitte, 2008; IITM, 2011)                                   medical tourism which specifies different approaches
                                                               and emphases of research in diverse disciplines.
                                                                                                                   187
 
                         IRACST- International Journal of Research in Management & Technology (IJRMT), ISSN: 2249-9563
                                                                                            Vol. 5, No.1, February 2015
To promise high quality health care hospitals are               Medical destination countries, by providing access to
looking for accreditation from JCI as more than 200             a set of service packages, encourage patient’s
hospitals worldwide have been accredited.                       preference with alternative costs and unfound quality
Accreditation is predominantly essential because it             in developed nations (Turner, 2007; Hadi, 2009; Rath
can offer consumers and employers a level of                    et al., 2012). Thus, India is on the edge to play an
assurance that the services provided are comparable             essential role in medical tourism, fastest growing
to those available in their respective home countries           industry, of extensive repute in surgical treatments.
(Leng, 2007; Deloitte, 2008; Grail Research, 2009;              *ECLAC stands for Economic Commission for Latin
Medical Tourism Association, 2011). In the health               America and the Caribbean.
                                                                                                                   188
 
                         IRACST- International Journal of Research in Management & Technology (IJRMT), ISSN: 2249-9563
                                                                                            Vol. 5, No.1, February 2015
                                                                                                                    189
 
                         IRACST- International Journal of Research in Management & Technology (IJRMT), ISSN: 2249-9563
                                                                                            Vol. 5, No.1, February 2015
providers are using internet; the most effective way            units (Suthin et al., 2007; Apollo Healthcare Annual
to reach the product to its target customers (Lunt,             Report, 2011; Crooks et al., 2011). Hence here it
Hardy & Mannion, 2010; Turner, 2012). Interactive               could be concluded that channel decisions have a
communications, full description of treatment and               unified role among marketing practices. So hereby
quality assurance have been put on the website so               study proposes that
that potential patients may easily locate the desire            P3- Channel decisions (facilitate to consumers)
medical services (Bezruchka, 2002; ECLAC, 2010;                 have direct impact on growth of medical tourism in
Laesser, 2011). Along with internet, medical travel             India
agents are major link between hospitals and patients,
who recommend patients about best treatment
facilities available in destination country (Peters &                D. Promotional Effectiveness
Sauer, 2011; Turner, 2012). Foreign tour operators,             Health care service providers adopted an approach
insurance companies, travel agents, local tour                  that most multinational and corporate business
operators, and independent medical referral                     enterprises follow in terms of designing marketing
companies are the chief channels which facilitate               strategies, pricing, branding, management and
consumers to avail medical facilities with best care            maintaining the quality of services (Bookman &
and affordable prices (SINET, n.d.; Lunt et al., 2010).         Bookman, 2007; Turner, 2007; Rerkrujipimol &
                                                                Assenov, 2009). This approach, along with increasing
Although medical tourism agents and travel                      global integration of businesses, and the cost & wait-
professionals facilitates the tourism aspect of                 time crises in western health care systems, created
offshore care by managing the channel decision                  opportunities for many health facilities in developing
because the recreational value of travel has                    countries (Bezruchka, 2002; Emerging Market
decreasing importance to patients with complex                  Report, 2007). Advanced communication technology
medical problems (Voigt, Brown & Howat, 2011;                   made crucial changes in the development of medical
Martin et al., 2011; Fortis Healthcare Annual Report,           tourism industry as it becomes quite unproblematic to
2012 ). The primary reason that medical centers in              locate the best medical facility over the world. Travel
developing countries are able to provide healthcare             agencies provide reassurance, legitimacy and a
services inexpensively is directly related to the               proper check out for right medical care according to
nation's economic status. India’s corporate hospitals           patient’s conditions (Khan, 2010; Tourani et al.,
such as Fortis, Apollo, Max Care, AIIMS, Escorts                2010; Lam, Cros & Vong, 2011). Crooks et al. (2011)
hospitals etc are honored to make country a medical             argued that best medical practices is to inform the
destination by offering world class treatments’ (a              patients each and everything about the medical
combination of traditional and modern medical                   procedures, medical treatments, tourism opportunities
practices) and less waiting time (Eggertson, 2006;              and travel arrangement and justify the cost in this
Jagyasi, 2010). Overstretched health plans in                   regard as
industrialized nations push patients to move to more            ‘Promotional costs are likely to be more manageable
relax planned countries likewise India where                    if brochures, booklets, and flyers can be produced for
corporate hospitals provide elective surgery in                 all markets, rather than separate sets for potential
minimal waiting period (Garg & Bhardwaj, 2012).                 international patients from developed nations and
                                                                those from developing nations.’ (Crooks et al., 2011)
Around the world, various medical travel companies
have set up linkages with the hospitals in India
(Grewal et al., 2009; Rath et al., 2012). Delhi,                To better inform the potential patients, corporate
Mumbai, Bangalore and Chennai gratify more no. of               hospitals of developing nations participate in trade
patients by enhancing infrastructural facilities,               fairs, travel marts, exhibitions, conferences and
coordinating facilities, hospitality services, and              advertised in travel magazines (Rerkrujipimol &
medical transportation. Many hospitals in India are             Assenov, 2009; Dawn & Pal, 2011). Healthcare
expanding their business abroad so that follow up               service providers advertise in both local & global
care of foreign patients may carry out in operating             media and attempt to create awareness with the help
                                                                                                                   190
 
                         IRACST- International Journal of Research in Management & Technology (IJRMT), ISSN: 2249-9563
                                                                                            Vol. 5, No.1, February 2015
of articles or news related to latest accreditation,            skills and less understanding of patients’ culture has
medical treatments. Moreover, hospitals and health              remained unsolved challenges in front of healthcare
care service providers’ collaborate with the medical            service providers.
schools/universities to exchange knowledge and to
promote medical facilities (Boga & Weiermair, 2011;             Health care service providers must ensure state of art
Crooks et al., 2011).                                           in medical technology and procedures. To remain in
                                                                market place, service providers take initiatives by
Government of destination countries has also take               marketing the best health services (Kangas, 2010;
initiatives in promotion of medical tourism as                  Crooks et al., 2011). Regarding the marketing
destination countries established medical travel                strategies government should encourage cheaper
associations and websites so that potential patients            transport and accommodation, special training for
can approach easily desired treatment (Lunt et al.,             service providers and there should be round the clock
2010; Lunt & Carrera, 2011; Turner 2012).                       services for communication and promotion of health
Government provides various value added measures                services inbound or outbound (Lee, 2007; Grewal et
for the development of health service (Whittaker,               al., 2009).
2008). Reforms of medical benefits scheme in India
by providing 1 year’s visa validity to the foreign              Kangas (2010) has illustrated four models of medical
patients make eager to the private owned hospitals to           journey as the market, resources, government, and
attract patients from abroad (Chinai & Goswami,                 individuals.     These     models     depicted    the
2007; IITM, 2011). Promotional elasticity has been              interconnection of four factors that individuals,
defined by the George & Swamy (2006) by doing                   government, resources of healthcare and health
case study of three major hospitals in India (Apollo,           providers must work together for placing country as
Kerala Tourism Development Council and Amrita                   one of the most preferred destination for healthcare.
Institute of Medical Science and Global Health                  To create USP (unique selling proposition) of Indian
Tours) providing services of medical consultants,               medical tourism, healthcare service providers need to
brokers and establishing rejuvenation centers so that           team up with government and need to adopt country
customers need to visit over again. It, therefore,              specific marketing strategies. Commodification of
implies that promotional effectiveness catches the              health services, physical evidence, and drawing up a
attention of local and international patients. So study         price band, opening up facilitation centers, and tie
purposes that                                                   ups with overseas insurance companies enlightens the
P4- Promotional effectiveness has direct impact on              way towards a more proactive approach. Therefore,
growth of medical tourism in India                              the study concludes that integrated marketing
                                                                practices has a direct impact on the medical tourism
                                                                industry and healthcare service providers should
V.                  FINDINGS                                    propose effective marketing practices as
                                                                P5- The integration of marketing practices lead
Medical tourism is a source of hard currency for the            medical tourism towards proactivity.
‘destination countries’ facilitating health care
services (Johnston et al., 2010). Earlier medical               In summary, it is imperative to appraise the potential
tourism was generally regarded as travel to rich                in each and every segment by shared value
nations from developing countries, now it goes in               proposition, information and quality care. Hospitals
both directions (Smith, 2008; Hadi, 2009).                      need to maximise strengths, maintain consumer
Developing nations are engaging in developing                   choice and improve quality standards. Price
integrated marketing practices to capture the attention         transparency efforts like low cost of labour, cost
of patients. Well trained doctors and medical staff             associated with malpractices litigation & insurance
have been promoted on the website of hospitals as               and limited association with third payers are essential
specialized doctors proved competitive advantages               to articulate. It can be concluded that Indian medical
(Suthin et al., 2007; Mainil, Platenkamp &                      tourism ought to be proactive and focus on integrated
Meulemans, 2011). Furthermore, communication
                                                                                                                   191
 
                         IRACST- International Journal of Research in Management & Technology (IJRMT), ISSN: 2249-9563
                                                                                            Vol. 5, No.1, February 2015
marketing practices     in   order   to   survive   the             •    Chanda, R. (2002). Trade in health services.
competitive pressure.                                                    Bulletin of the World Health Organization.
                                                                         Commission on Macroeconomics and
VI.       LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY
                                                                         Health, 80 (2), 158-163.
The study has presented a vision of the trends in                   •    Chinai, R., & Goswami, R. (2007). Medical
medical tourism. The study confined to marketing                         visas mark growth of Indian medical
practices opted by medical tourism industry. Most of                     tourism. Bulletin of the World Health
the studies available on medical tourism are of                          Organization, 85(3), 164-165.
qualitative nature and very few (n=5) are empirical                 •    Connell, J. (2006). Medical tourism: sea,
studies. Most information has been generated online                      sun, sand and …surgery. Tourism
and very little from the academic journals. That’s                       Management, 27(6), 1093-1100.
why it is essential to explore unified data to                      •    Crooks, V.A., Turner, L., Snyder, J.,
undertake logical studies in growth of medical                           Johnston, R., & Kingsbury, P. (2011).
tourism industry.                                                        Promoting medical tourism to India:
                                                                         Messages, images, and the marketing of
                                                                         international patient travel. Social Science,
                        References                                       72, 726-732.
      •   Ambani, M., & Birla, K. (2000). A policy                  •    D’Essence Consulting (2004). Curing the
          framework for reforms in health care.                          World: An Opportunity for Medical Tourism
          Special Subject Group on Policy Framework                      in        India.        Retrived        from
          for private Investment in Education, Health                    www.dessenceconsulting.com.
          and Rural Development. Prime Minister’s                   •    Dawn, S.K., & Pal, S. (2011). Medical
          Council on Trade and Industry, Government                      Tourism in India: Issues, Opportunities and
          of         India.       Retrieved       from                   Designing Strategies for Growth and
          http://indiaimage.nic.in/pmcouncils/reports/                   Development. International Journal of
          health/.                                                       Multidisciplinary Research, 1(3), 185-202.
      •   Apollo Healthcare Annual Report (2011).                   •    Deloitte Center for Health Solutions (2008).
          Vision 20.6 a blueprint for smarter                            Medical tourism: consumers in search of
          healthcare.           Retrived          from                   value.                  Retrived        from
          www.apollohospitals.com.                                       http://www.deloitte.com/dtt/article/html.
      •   Bezruchka, S. (2002). Medical tourism as                  •    ECLAC Report (2010). Medical tourism: a
          medical harm to the third world: why? For                      survey. United Nations Publication.
          whom. Wilderness and Environmental                             Washington, D.C.
          Medicine, 11, 77-78.                                      •    Eggertson, L. (2006). Wait-list weary
      •   Bhat, R., & Jain, N. (2006). Financial                         Canadians seek treatment abroad. CMAJ,
          performance of private sector hospitals in                     174(9), 1247.
          India: some further evidence. IIM–                        •    Emerging Market Report (2007). Healthcare
          Ahmadabad: India.                                              in India. Mumbai: India. Retrived from
      •   Boga, T.C., & Weiermair, K. (2011).                            http://www.pwc.com/en_GX/gx/healthcare/
          Branding new services in health tourism.                       pdf/emerging-market-report-hc-in-india.pdf.
          Tourism Review, 66(1), 90-106.
      •   Bookman, M.Z., & Bookman, K.R. (2007).                    •    Faidon, T., & Vasiliki, P. (2012). Exploring
          Medical Tourism in Developing Countries.                       and exploiting medical tourism opportunities
          New York: Palgrave Macmillan.                                  in       Greece.        Retrieved      from
                                                                         http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstr
      •   Bristow, R.S., Yang, W.T., & Lu, M.T.
                                                                         act_id=2091001.
          (2011). Sustainable medical tourism in
          Costa Rica. Tourism Review, 66(1), 107 –
          117.
                                                                                                                   192
 
                        IRACST- International Journal of Research in Management & Technology (IJRMT), ISSN: 2249-9563
                                                                                           Vol. 5, No.1, February 2015
    •   Fortis Health Care Annual Report (2012).                        Marketplace. Medscape General Medicine,
        Healthcare beyond borders. Retrived from                        9(4).
        www.fortishealthcare.com.
                                                                   •    Hult, K.J., & Philipson, T.J. (2012). Health
    •   Garg, S.R., & Bhardwaj, A. (2012). Indian
                                                                        care reforms and the value of future public
        medical      tourism     industry:     growth
                                                                        liabilities. W.p. no. 18571. Retrived from
        opportunities     and    challenges.     Multi
                                                                        http://www.nber.org/papers/w18571.
        Disciplinary Edu Global Quest (Quarterly),
                                                                   •    Indian Institute of Tourism and Travel
        1(1), 115-135.
                                                                        Management-Indian Chamber of Commerce
    •   George, B.P., & Swamy, G.A. (2006).
                                                                        Report (2011). Travel and tourism industry
        Medical Tourism: An analysis with special
                                                                        in India-Looking East. Kolkata: India.
        reference to India. Journal of Hospitality
                                                                        Retrived                                from
        Application and Research (JOHAR).
                                                                        http://www.iittm.org/doc/IITTM_ITC_Repo
        Publishing India Group. Retrived from
                                                                        rt-2011-rev..pdf.
        www.publishingindia.com.
                                                                   •    Jagyasi, P. (2010). Medical tourism impact
    •   Grail Research (2009). Rise of medical
                                                                        it’s         more        than        obvious,
        tourism.       Retrived      from       http://
                                                                        http://www.medicaltourismmag.com/article/
        grailreserach.com.
                                                                        medical-tourism-impact-it-s-more-than-
    •   Grewal, I., Das, J.K., Nandan, D., &                            obvious.html.
        Kishore, J. (2009). Promotion of medical
                                                                   •    Johnston, R., Crooks, V.A., Snyder, J., &
        tourism in tertiary care hospitals of Delhi:
                                                                        Kingsbury, P. (2010). What is known about
        opinion of medical administrators and
                                                                        the effects of medical tourism in destination
        managers.      Health     and     Population:
                                                                        and departure countries? A scoping review.
        Perspectives and Issues, 32 (3), 159-165.
                                                                        International Journal for Equity in Health,9
    •   Hadi, A. (2009). Globalization, medical                         (24),
        tourism and health equity. Symposium on
                                                                   •    Kalshetti, P., & Pillai, D. (2008). Tourism
        Implications of Medical Tourism for
                                                                        products development and management
        Canadian Health and Health Policy.
                                                                        medical tourism –a shifting paradigm.
        Ottawa: Canada.
                                                                        Conference on Tourism in India –
    •   Hazarika, I. (2010). Medical tourism: its                       Challenges Ahead, 15-17 May 2008, IIMK.
        potential impact on the health workforce and
                                                                   •    Kangas, B. (2010). Traveling for medical
        health systems in India. Health Policy and
                                                                        care in a global world. Medical
        Planning, 25, 248-251.
                                                                        Anthropology: Cross-Cultural Studies in
    •   Hall, C. M. (2011). Health and medical                          Health and Illness, 29(4), 344-362.
        tourism: a kill or cure for global public
                                                                   •    Karmakar, M. (2011). Medical tourism in
        health? Tourism Review, 66 (1), 4-15.
                                                                        India: its present trends, status and ethical
    •   Hall, C. M., & James, M. (2011). Medical                        issues. Geo-Analyst, 1(2), 100-107.
        tourism:     emerging      biosecurity     and
                                                                   •    Khan, M. (2010). Medical tourism:
        nosocomial issues. Tourism Review, 66 (1),
                                                                        outsourcing of healthcare. International
        118 – 126.
                                                                        CHRIE Conference-Refereed Track. Paper
    •   Helble, M. (2011). The movement of                              23.               Retrived              from
        patients across borders: challenges and                         http://scholarworks.umass.edu/refereed.
        opportunities for public health. Bull World
                                                                   •    Kotler, P., & Keller, K. (2008). Marketing
        Health Organ, 89, 68–72.
                                                                        Management. 12th ed. India: Pearson
                                                                        Education.
    •   Horowitz, M.D., Rosensweig, J.A., & Jones,
        C.A.     (2007).    Medical       Tourism:                 •    Kumar, S. (2009). Designing promotional
        Globalization    of    the     Healthcare                       strategies for medical tourism in India: a
                                                                        case study of an ophthalmic hospital in
                                                                                                                  193
 
                       IRACST- International Journal of Research in Management & Technology (IJRMT), ISSN: 2249-9563
                                                                                          Vol. 5, No.1, February 2015
                                                                                                                 194
 
                         IRACST- International Journal of Research in Management & Technology (IJRMT), ISSN: 2249-9563
                                                                                            Vol. 5, No.1, February 2015
    •    Suthin, K., Assenov, I., & Tirasatayapitak,                     medical travel. Globalization and Health,
         A. (2007). Medical Tourism: Can Supply                          8(16).            Retrieved           from
         keep up with the Demand. Proceedings,                           http://www.globalizationandhealth.com/cont
         APAC-CHRIE & Asia Pacific Tourism                               ent/8/1/16.
         Association Joint Conference 2007, May 23-                  •   USAID Report (2009). Market demand
         27, Beijing: China.                                             assessment and marketing strategy for
    •    Tourani, S., Tabibi, S.J., Tofighi, S., &                       medical tourism. Jordan. Retrieved from
         Zadeh, N.S. (2010). Medical tourism in Iran:                    http://www.SABEQ-Jordan.org.
         Analysis of opportunities and challenges                    •   Voigt, C., Brown, G., & Howat, G. (2011).
         with MADM approach. Research Journal of                         Wellness     tourists:   in   search     of
         Biological Science, 5(3), 251-257.                              transformation. Tourism Review, 66 (1), 16
    •    Turner, L. (2007). First world health care at                   – 30.
         third world prices: globalization, bioethics                •   Whittaker, A. (2008). Pleasure and pain:
         and medical tourism. BioSocieties, 2(3),                        Medical travel in Asia. Global Public
         303-325.                                                        Health: An International Journal for
    •    Turner, L. (2012). Beyond “medical                              Research, Policy and Practice, 3(3), 271-
         tourism”: Canadian companies marketing                          290.
    Annexure
    Table 1. Cost Structure
Treatments            USA          India      Koreo        Mexico        Singapore        Thailand        Jorden
Heart Bypass          $1,44,000    $8,500     $24,000      $20,000       $13,500          $24,000         $10,000
Heart valve           $1,70,000    $1,200     $36,000      $30,000       $13,500          $22,000         $12,000
Replacement
Hip Replacement       $50,000      $8,000     $16,450      $13,125       $11,100          $14,000         $8,000
Hip Resurfacing       $50,000      $8,000     $20,900      $12,800       $12,100          $16,000         $8,000
Dental Implant        $2,000-      $12,000    $3,400       $9,10         $2,900           $3,000          $5,00
                      1,000
Face Lift             $15,000      $7,000     $3,000       $7,200        $4,000           $6,600          $3,000
Knee                  $50,000      $7,000     $17,800      $10,650       $10,800          $12,000         $7,000
Replacement
Source- Indian Medical Tourism Association, 2011
                                                                                                                    195