Analytical Study of Single Particle Tracking in Both Free and Forced Vortices
Analytical Study of Single Particle Tracking in Both Free and Forced Vortices
Research note
     KEYWORDS                                Abstract Today, the flow of gas–solid, solid–liquid and liquid–liquid mixtures is broadly used in many
     Particle tracking;                      industries such as slurry transportation, propulsion, dredging and power generation equipment. In this
     Free vortex;                            paper, single solid particle motion through free and forced vortices is analytically studied. The equations
     Force vortex;                           are solved for cases in which the drag, pressure gradient, added mass, buoyancy and weight forces
     Drag;                                   are considered individually and simultaneously. Verification has been done for the value of ReP , which
     Added mass;                             confirms the solution for the first t = 0.1 s. The results show that the most important force governing
     Pressure gradient;                      particle motion is the pressure gradient force.
     Buoyancy;                                     © 2013 Sharif University of Technology. Production and hosting by Elsevier B.V.
     Weight.                                        Open access under CC BY license.
   The drag force (FD ) which act on a spherical particle inside                                  The forces which are acted upon by gravity (g) and buoyancy
the flow far from the boundaries has been introduced by                                        effect (FB ) are as follows:
Stokes [14].                                                                                                     
                                                                                                          1
       3 ρF mP                                                                                 FB =           π D3 (ρF − ρP ) g .                              (6)
FD =                 CD (uF − uP ) |uF − uP |                                        (1)                  6
       4 ρP D
where, for Reynolds numbers less than one (ReP < 1), the drag                                  1.5. Other forces
                     24
coefficient is CD = Re   . The quantities m, D, ρ and u are mass,
                       P
diameter, density and velocity respectively. Subscripts, P and F,                                  In this paper, for our analytical study the assumption of a
represent particle and fluid respectively.                                                     tiny particle is made, so the effects of slip-shear lift force and
                                                                                               slip-rotational lift force are neglected. Moreover it is assumed
1.2. Added mass/Basset force                                                                   that the system is under an isothermal condition, and therefore,
                                                                                               the effect of thermophoretic force is not considered. As a
    Unsteady forces due to acceleration of a moving body                                       consequence, the forces that are more effective in the studied
relative to fluid will cause the added mass effect and the                                     case, are as follows.
Basset force. In other words any increase or decrease in particle                                  Drag, added mass, pressure gradient, buoyancy and weight.
velocity causes the fluid near it to accelerate either. This amount
of fluid is called added mass. The force, which appears due to                                 2. Main text
the lagging boundary layer development with changing relative
                                                                                                  In this section, using Newton’s law of motion along three
velocity, is known as the Basset force [15]. The amount of these
                                                                                               directions of cylindrical coordinates, the particle path is
forces acting on an accelerating spherical particle in a viscous
                                                                                               obtained. For this goal, the forces which were introduced in the
fluid was obtained [16,17]. The added mass force (FA ) and Basset
                                                                                               previous section for ReP < 1 are used.
force (FB ) are as follows.
                                                                                                  The problem is broken down into two distinct approaches:
                            − ∂∂utP′ ′
                   t DuF
       3 √            Dt ′
                                                                                                • Considering each force individually, in which the problem is
FB = D π ρF µF
            2
                       √            dt ,                                                            a 2D problem.
     2              0      t − t′
                                                                                   (2)        • Considering all forces simultaneously, in which the problem
                DuF   duP                                                                           is a 3D problem.
FA = 0.5CA mF       −
                         Dt            dt                                                           In all parts, the initial conditions are as follows:
                                                               2
                                0.132
where CA = 2.1 −                         ,   AC =    |uF −uP |      and µ is viscosity.         rt =0 = R
                                                                                                
                              Ac 2 +0.12              d|uF −uP | 
                                                    D     dt     
                                                                                                  ṙt =0 = 0                                                   (7)
The parameters were introduced previously.                                                        θt =0 = 0.
    In order to determine Basset force, the integral needs to be                                                                              −
                                                                                                                                              →
calculated in the time during which the particle is moving along                               Steady state fluid flow velocity ( uF ) for a general vortex in
the path. As the calculation is time consuming, the Basset force                               cylindrical coordinates (êr , êθ , êz ) is considered as follows:
is usually neglected [18,19].                                                                  −
                                                                                               →
                                                                                               uF = cr α êθ + u0 êz                                          (8)
    Fluid will gain kinetic energy at the expense of the work
done by the accelerating particle. This phenomenon will cause                                  where êθ and êz are tangential and axial unit vectors in
added mass force. For a single spherical particle inside an                                    cylindrical coordinates, respectively. α is +1 for forced vortex
inviscid incompressible fluid, the added mass force is written                                 and −1 for free vortex.
in Eq. (3).                                                                                        In order to study each force individually, tangential and
                                                                                               radial components of the equation of motion are coupled and
       ρ F π D3       Dvrel
                              
                                                                                               need to be solved simultaneously. But, buoyancy and weight are
FA =                               .                                                 (3)       considered an axial component of the equation of motion, and
           12            Dt
                                                                                               can be solved separately. Therefore, to study the effect of each
The added mass force can be simplified for a rigid particle as                                 force on particle motion, the problem is broken into 4 parts. In
follows.                                                                                       each part, a single particle under the influence of only one force
       ρ F π D3       ∂vrel      ∂ uF                                                          in both free and forced vortices is studied. At last, the problem
                                     
FA =                        + uF        .                                            (4)       is solved one more time and all these forces are considered
           12          ∂t         ∂x
                                                                                               simultaneously.
It was studied that the Basset force has only a weak effect                                        Since drag, added mass and pressure gradient forces act on
in the region of a vortex center and gradually becomes more                                    the plane of relative velocity, resultant particle motion would
important near a separatrix. Its principal effect is to change the                             be in the mentioned plane.
magnitude of the drift of particles towards either a vortex center                                 During the solving process, equations of motion are simpli-
or a separatrix [20].                                                                          fied to a level at which the analytical solution can be achieved. In
                                                                                               some cases, where no analytical solution is obtained, a numer-
1.3. Pressure gradient force                                                                   ical second order Runge–Kutta approach is used by MATLAB.
    The force that is a result of pressure gradient along fluid flow                           2.1. Part 1: considering only drag force
around particle is called the pressure gradient force (FP), which
is as follows:                                                                                    The drag force which was introduced in Eq. (1) can be
                                                                                             rewritten for ReP < 1 as follows:
       1                 DuF
FP =       π D3 ρF                 .                                                 (5)       −
                                                                                               →
                                                                                               FD = 3π Dµ ûF − ûP .
                                                                                                                           
       6                 Dt                                                                                                                                    (9)
                                                   A. Salari et al. / Scientia Iranica, Transactions B: Mechanical Engineering 20 (2013) 351–358                                                        353
A 2D particle velocity is considered in Eq. (10).                                                   Substituting Eq. (20) in Newton’s second law yields Eq. (21).
−
→
uP = ṙ êr + r θ̇ êθ                                                                  (10)         ρF π D3 
                                                                                                              −c 2 r 2α−1 − r̈ + r θ̇ 2 êr + −2ṙ θ̇ − r θ̈ êθ
                                                                                                                                                            
where êr is the radial unit vector in cylindrical coordinates.                                        12
                                −
                                →
  And particle acceleration ( aP ) is defined in Eq. (11).
                                                                                                         
                                                                                                           1
                                                                                                                     
                                                                                                             ρP π D3
                                                                                                                         r̈ − r θ̇ 2 êr + 2ṙ θ̇ + r θ̈ êθ .
                                                                                                                                                     
                                                                                                       =                                                                                               (21)
−
→                                                                                                               6
aP = r̈ − r θ̇ 2 êr + 2ṙ θ̇ + r θ̈ êθ .
                                 
                                                                                        (11)
                                                                                                    Eq. (21) can be broken up into tangential and radial components
Substituting Eqs. (9) and (11) in Newton’s second law yields Eq.
                                                                                                    separately
(12).
                                                                                                     
3π Dµ           cr α − r θ̇ êθ − ṙ êr                                                             r̈ − r θ̇ 2 = −ρF c 2 r 2α−1
                                            
                                                                                                                      2ρ P + ρF                                                                      (22)
           1                                                                                                     2ṙ θ̇ + r θ̈ = 0.
                ρP π D3             r̈ − r θ̇ 2 êr + 2ṙ θ̇ + r θ̈ êθ .
                                                                                               
  =                                                                                     (12)
           6
                                                                                                    The second equation in Eq. (22) can be easily solved by using
                                                                                                    the initial conditions (Eq. (7)), which yields Eq. (23).
2.1.1. Forced vortex
   In case of a forced vortex, α = +1, the tangential component                                     r 2 θ̇ = const = R2 θ̇0 .                                                                          (23)
of equation of motion (Eq. (12)) is neglected. Also, the angular                                    Substituting Eq. (23) into the first equation in Eq. (22) yields
velocity of the particle is assumed to be constant at fluid angular                                 Eq. (24).
velocity.
                                                                                                                    ρF
                                                                                                                                  c 2 r 2α+2 − R2 θ̇0
                                                                                                                                                                       2
                                                                                                    r 3 r̈ +                                                                = 0.
                                                                                                                                                        
                                                                                                                                                                                                       (24)
θ̇ = c .                                                                                (13)                    2ρ P + ρF
The radial component is used to solve particle motion.
    The added mass force introduced in Eq. (3) can be rewritten                                     Then, the angular position is obtained by substituting Eq. (26) in
for cylindrical coordinates as follows.                                                             Eq. (23) and integrating.
           ρF π D3 
                                                                                                                                               
−
→                                                                                                                                   2ρP            c
FA =                   −c 2 r 2α−1 − r̈                                                                    arctan                 2ρ P +ρF        R2
                                                                                                                                                            t
            12                                                                                      θ=                                                           .                                    (30)
                                                                                                                                    2ρP
           + r θ̇ 2 êr + −2ṙ θ̇ − r θ̈ êθ .
                                       
                                                                                        (20)                                      2ρ P +ρF
354                                           A. Salari et al. / Scientia Iranica, Transactions B: Mechanical Engineering 20 (2013) 351–358
2.3. Part 3: considering only pressure gradient force of forces, so we have Eq. (40).
                                                                                                                                   cr α − r θ̇ êθ + ṙ êr
                                                                                                
                                                                                                        Fr ,θ = 3π Dµ
                                                                                                                                                           
   The pressure gradient force introduced in Eq. (5) can be
rewritten for cylindrical coordinates as follows.
                                                                                                        ρF π D3 
                                                                                                                      −c 2 r 2α−1 − r̈ + r θ̇ 2 êr + −2ṙ θ̇ − r θ̈ êθ
                                                                                                                                                                   
             1                 2 2α−1
                                                                                                    +
FP = − π D ρF c r    3
                          êr .                            (31)                                             12
        6                                                                                               1
Substituting Eq. (31) in Newton’s second law yields Eq. (32).                                       − π D3 ρF c 2 r 2α−1 êr .                                                       (40)
                                                                                                        6
   1
 − π D3 ρF c 2 r 2α−1 êr                                                                      Using Newton’s second law and Eq. (40), the equation of motion
   6
                                                                                             is achieved.
             1
                 ρP π D3         r̈ − r θ̇ 2 êr + 2ṙ θ̇ + r θ̈ êθ .
                                                               
     =                                                                             (32)
                                                                                                                              36µ
                                                                                                                                                       
                                                                                                                                                          ρF
                                                                                                                                                                        
             6
                                                                                               r̈ − r θ̇ 2 = −                      ṙ − 3c 2                               r 2α−1   (41)
Eq. (32) can be broken up into tangential and radial components                                                      (ρF + 2ρP ) D2                    ρF + 2ρP
separately                                                                                                               36µ                  α
                                                                                               2ṙ θ̇ + r θ̈ =                                cr − r θ̇ .
                                                                                                                                                       
                                                                                                                                                                                    (42)
r̈ − r θ̇ 2 = −ρF c 2 r 2α−1                                                                                        (ρF + 2ρP ) D2
                ρP                                                                 (33)
      2ṙ θ̇ + r θ̈ = 0.
                                                                                               2.4.1.1. Forced vortex. In order to determine the analytical
The second equation in Eq. (33) can be easily solved by using                                  solution of the equations, the particle velocity is assumed to be
the initial conditions (Eq. (7)), which yields Eq. (34).                                       the same as the fluid flow velocity around it.
r 2 θ̇ = const = R2 θ̇0 .                                                          (34)
                                                                                               r θ̇ = cr α .                                                                         (43)
Substituting Eq. (34) into the first equation in Eq. (33) yields
Eq. (35).                                                                                      By substituting α = +1 in Eqs. (41), (42) and solving the
       ρF 2 2α+2  2 2                                                                        equations with initial conditions stated in Eq. (7), the solution
 3
r r̈ +    c r   − R θ̇0 = 0.                                                       (35)        is obtained.
       ρP
The general form of Eq. (35) is the same as Eq. (24), so only the
                                                                                                
                                                                                                                 R
                                                                                                    r =                  (β2 exp (β1 t ) − β1 exp (β2 t ))
                                                                                                
final solution is presented.
                                                                                                            β2 − β1                                                                  (44)
                                                                                                                                  θ = ct
2.3.1. Forced vortex
                                                                                                                      18ρF uF
                                                                                               β1,2 = −
                                                                                                                F + 2ρP ) D
                                                                                                               (ρ
                                                                                                                        2
     
      ρP + ρF  ρP − ρF             4ρF
                                                                                                                      18ρF uF              ρP − ρF
                                                                                                                                  2
r =R                −        cos         ct                                        (36)
                                                                                                                                                 
            2ρF         2ρF          ρP                                                                      ±                       + 2              c2.                            (45)
                                                                                                                   (ρF + 2ρP ) D2          ρF + 2ρP
                ρP      1 ρF
                            
θ = 2arctan        tan       ct    .                                               (37)
                ρF      2 ρP                                                                   2.4.1.2. Free vortex. In this case, particle velocity is assumed
                                                                                               to be the same as the fluid flow velocity around it, too. By
2.3.2. Free vortex                                                                             substituting α = −1, the equation of motion is simplified to
                                                                                               Eq. (46).
         
                    ρP − ρF c 2 2                                                                              36µ                              ρF − ρP
                                                                                                                                                           
r =R 1+                         t                                                  (38)        r̈ +                    ṙ + 2c 2                                  r −3 = 0.          (46)
                       ρP   R4                                                                          (ρF + 2ρP ) D2                          ρF + 2ρP
                           
                           ρP −ρF     c                                                        Unfortunately, this equation cannot be analytically solved at all.
         arctan              ρP      R2
                                          t
θ=                                           .                                    (39)        A numerical solution must be used instead.
                           ρP −ρF
                             ρP
                                                                                               2.4.2. Axial
                                                                                                  For the axial direction of motion, buoyancy and weight
2.4. Part 4: considering all forces simultaneously
                                                                                               forces are included. Also, the solution is independent of the fluid
   By assuming the axial component of cylindrical coordinates                                  flow regime (forced or free vortex).
along with gravitational force, the effects of buoyancy and                                       The axial component of the equation of motion is as follows:
weight forces on tangential and radial components are elimi-                                                                          
                                                                                                                             1
nated. Therefore, in cases where all forces act on a particle, the                                      Fa =         mP +         mF       z̈ + 3π Dµż
problem should be solved in a 2 dimensional plane. Then, tan-                                                                 2
gential and radial components will be solved independent of the                                                      
                                                                                                                         1
                                                                                                                                 
axial component.                                                                                                 +           π D3 (ρP − ρF ) g .                                     (47)
                                                                                                                         6
2.4.1. Radial & tangential                                                                     Initial conditions are as follows:
   The resultant forces in a radial direction are achieved from                                 
Eq. (40). It should be noted that the buoyancy and weight                                            z = z0
                                                                                                                                                                                     (48)
forces are not considered in radial and tangential components                                       ż = u0 .
                                             A. Salari et al. / Scientia Iranica, Transactions B: Mechanical Engineering 20 (2013) 351–358                                  355
                                        FP
Pressure gradient ratio =
                                      Ftotal
                    −mF c 2 r 2α−1
  =                                                   .                           (52)
      −3π Dµṙ − 21 mF r̈ − r θ̇ 2 − 32 mF c 2 r 2α−1
                                 
Figure 3: Drag ratio as a function of time for free & forced vortices (Case 1).
                                                                                          Figure 6: Pressure gradient ratio as a function of time for free & forced vortices
                                                                                          (Case 2).
Figure 4: All forces ratio as a function of time for forced vortex (Case 1).
                                                                                          Figure 7: Added mass ratio as a function of time for free & forced vortices
                                                                                          (Case 2).
Figure 8: Drag ratio as a function of time for free & forced vortices (Case 2).
                                                                                          Figure 11: ReP changes as a function of time for forced vortex (Case 1).
                                                                                           Figure 12: ReP changes as a function of time for free vortex (Case 1).
 Figure 9: All forces ratio as a function of time for forced vortex (Case 2).
  Figure 10: All forces ratio as a function of time for free vortex (Case 2).             Figure 13: ReP changes as a function of time for forced vortex (Case 2).
358                                      A. Salari et al. / Scientia Iranica, Transactions B: Mechanical Engineering 20 (2013) 351–358
                                                                                           [8] EL-Naggar, B.B. and Kholeif, I.A. ‘‘Motion of a small spherical particle in a
                                                                                               fluid vortex’’, J. Basic Appl. Sci. Res., 2(4), pp. 3631–3635 (2012).
                                                                                           [9] Domon, K.O. and Watanabe, S. ‘‘Mass transport by a vortex ring’’, J. Phys.
                                                                                               Soc. Japan, 69, pp. 120–123 (2000).
                                                                                          [10] Uchiyama, T. and Yagami, H. Vortex simulation for the interaction between
                                                                                               a vortex ring and solid particles, Proc. 6th Int. Conf. Multiphase Flow, Leipzig,
                                                                                               on CD (2007).
                                                                                          [11] Uchiyama, T. and Yagami, H. ‘‘Numerical simulation for the collision
                                                                                               between a vortex ring and solid particles’’, Powder Technol., 188, pp. 73–80
                                                                                               (2008).
                                                                                          [12] Gan, L., Dawson, J.R. and Nickels, T.B. ‘‘On the drag of turbulent vortex
                                                                                               rings’’, J. Fluid Mech., 709, pp. 85–105 (2012).
                                                                                          [13] Candelier, F., Angilella, J.R. and Souhar, M. ‘‘On the effect of the Boussinesq-
                                                                                               Basset force on the radial migration of a Stokes particle in a vortex’’, Phys.
                                                                                               Fluids, 16(5), pp. 1765–1777 (2004).
                                                                                          [14] Stokes, G.G. On the effect of the internal friction of fluids on the motion
                                                                                               of pendulums, Transactions of the Cambridge Philosophical Society, 4 p. 8
                                                                                               (1850).
                                                                                          [15] Crowe, C.T., Sommerfeld, M. and Tsuji, Y., Multiphase flows with droplets
                                                                                               and particles, 81, CRC Press (1998).
                                                                                          [16] Michaelides, E.E. ‘‘Hydrodynamics force and heat/mass transfer from
                                                                                               particles, bubbles, and drops’’, J. Fluids Eng., 125(2), pp. 209–238 (2003).
                                                                                          [17] Basset, A.B., A Treatise on Hydrodynamics, Deighton& Bell and Co.,
                                                                                               Cambridge 2, Ch. 22 (1961).
                                                                                          [18] Sommerfeld, M. Modelling and numerical calculation of particle-laden
      Figure 14: ReP changes as a function of time for free vortex (Case 2).                   turbulent flows using the Euler/Lagrange-method (Modellierung und
                                                                                               numerische berechnung von partikel beladenen turbulenten strömungen
                                                                                               mithilfe des Euler/Lagrange-verfahrens), Berichteaus der Strömungstechnik
   A brief look at Figures 5 and 10 shows that in Case 2, more                                 (1996).
time is needed in order for the forces to acheive the same values                         [19] Sommerfeld, M., Kohnen, G. and Ruger, M. Some open questions and
as Case 1.                                                                                     inconsistencies of lagrangian particle dispersion models, Proc. Ninth Symp.
                                                                                               On Turbulent Shear Flows, Paper 15.1, Kyoto (1993).
                                                                                          [20] Yannacopoulos, A.N., Rowlands, G. and King, G.P. ‘‘Influence of particle
4. Conclusions                                                                                 inertia and Basset force on tracer dynamics: analytic results in the small-
                                                                                               inertia limit’’, Phys. Rev. E, 55(4), pp. 4148–4157 (1997).
    In this paper, single solid particle motion through free and
forced vortices is studied. Though the results are not limited
                                                                                          Alinaghi Salari received his first MS degree in Mechanical Engineering from
to particle material but only depend on particle density, the                             Sharif University of Technology, Tehran, Iran, and is currently an MS degree
equations are solved for two cases, in which fluid density is                             student of Electrical Engineering at the University of Calgary, Canada. His
greater and smaller than particle density. Verification has been                          research interests include: MEMS, microfluidics, and bio-engineering. He has
                                                                                          worked on Micro-bubble generation for Ultrasonography in his MSc period. He
done for the ReP value, which confirms the solution for the first                         has also worked on Micropumps and Droplet Breakup in Microfluidics.
t = 0.1 s.
    The results show that the most important force governing
particle motion is the pressure gradient force.                                           Mohsen Karmozdi received his MS degree in Mechanical Engineering from
    The present work can be used in a wide area of engineering                            Sharif University of Technology, Tehran, Iran, where he is currently a PhD degree
                                                                                          student in the same subject. His research interests include: fluid mechanics in
fields like cyclones.                                                                     microfluids, energy auditing, MEMS and micropumps.
References
                                                                                          Reza Maddahian received his PhD degree in Mechanical Engineering from
                                                                                          Sharif University of Technology, Tehran, Iran, in 2012. He has published several
 [1] Pagalthivarthi, K.V. and Gupta, P.K. ‘‘Particle tracking in rotating channel
                                                                                          papers in numerical fluid mechanics, and is currently working on the design
     flow’’, Indian J. Eng. Mater. Sci., 15(5), pp. 365–376 (2008).
                                                                                          and optimization of static and rotary de-oiling hydro-cyclones for separation of
 [2] Basset, A.B., Treatise on Hydrodynamics, 2, Deighton Bell, London
                                                                                          oil from water. His research interests include: heat transfer, swirling flows, and
     pp. 285–297 (1888).
                                                                                          multiphase flows.
 [3] Boussinesq, J. ‘‘Analytical theory of heat (Theorie analytique de la
     chaleur)’’, In L Ecole Polytechnique, 2, p. 224. Gauthiers Villars, Paris (1903).
 [4] Oseen, C.W., Hydrodynamics (Hydrodynamik), Akademische Verlagsge-
     sellschaft, Leipzig p. 132 (1927).                                                   Bahareh Firoozabadi received her PhD degree in Mechanical Engineering
 [5] Maxey, M.R. and Riley, J.J. ‘‘Equation of motion for a small rigid sphere in         from Sharif University of Technology, Tehran, Iran, where she is currently
     a non-uniform flow’’, Phys. Fluids, 26(4), pp. 883–889 (1983).                       Associate Professor in the School of Mechanical Engineering. Her research
 [6] Henderson, K., Gwynllywa, D. and Barenghi, C. ‘‘Particle tracking in                 interests include: fluid mechanics in density currents, focusing on bio fluid
     Taylor–Couette flow’’, Eur. J. Mech. B, 26, pp. 738–748 (2007).                      mechanics, and porous media. She teaches fluid mechanics and gas dynamics
 [7] Michaelides, E.E. ‘‘Review – The transient equation of motion for particles,         for undergraduates, and viscous flow, advanced fluid mechanics, continuum
     bubbles and droplets’’, J. Fluids Eng., 119(2), pp. 233–247 (1997).                  mechanics and bio fluid mechanics for graduate students.