OC
TM
                            The History of the Abacus
                                                                             Kevin Samoly, Miami University
           The abacus is a counting tool that has been used for thousands of years. Throughout history, calculating larger
           numbers has been problematic, especially for the common uneducated merchant. Out of this necessity, the
           idea of the abacus was born. Solving problems on an abacus is a quick mechanical process rivaling that of
           modern-day four-function calculators. After first addressing basic counting procedures and memorizing a few
           simple rules, students can use the abacus to solve a variety of problems. The abacus is a timeless computing
           tool that is still applicable in today’s classrooms.
                       Introduction
                             Throughout history, keeping track of
                       numbers has been problematic. How would
                       you keep track of numbers without pen or
      Counting         paper? What if you couldn’t read or write?
   tables have         Without a written language, how would
     over 2000         you add, subtract, multiply, or divide large
                                                                                     Fig 2 Bead frame abacus
                       numbers accurately and efficiently? All
      years of         of these problems can be solved with an             Both computing tools calculate in a similar
  documented           abacus.                                             fashion.
   use, dating            An abacus is a computing tool used for              Counting tables have over 2000 years
        back to        addition, subtraction, multiplication, and          of documented use, dating back to Greeks
                       division. The abacus does not require pen           and Romans. The earliest documented
   Greeks and          or paper and works for any base number              counting boards were simple stone slabs
       Romans.         system. There are two basic forms of the            with parallel and horizontal lines serving as
  The earliest         abacus, the first being a counting table,           place value indicators. The “normal method
     document          which is a specially marked flat surface that       of calculation in Ancient Greece and Rome
                       uses small stones or beans as markers, as           was done by moving counters on a smooth
      counting         shown in Figure 1. The second is a bead             board or table suitably marked with lines or
 boards were           frame abacus, which is a frame with beads           symbols to show the ‘places’” (Pullan, 1968,
 simple stone          strung on wires or rods, shown in Figure 2.         p. 18). The counting board’s development
   slabs with                                                              then stagnated for hundreds of years with
                                                                           the only noticeable change being the move
   parallel and                                                            to vertical place-values lines.
     horizontal                                                               The origin of the portable bead frame
           lines                                                           abacus is not well-known. It was thought
     serving as                                                            to have originated out of necessity for
                                                                           traveling merchants. Some historians credit
   place value                                                             the Chinese as the inventors of bead frame
    indicators.                                                            abacus, while others believe the Romans
                                                                           introduced the abacus to the Chinese
                           Fig 1 Counting table representing 3874          through trade (Moon, 1971). From there,
Page 58                                                Ohio Journal of School Mathematics | Number 65 • Spring, 2012
                                                           OC
                                                           TM
Russia and Japan developed their own             fourth century BC (Pullan, 1968). It’s made
versions of the abacus.                          of white marble and measures 149 × 75 ×
   Today the abacus lives on in rural parts      4.5 cm. On its top face is a set of eleven
of Asia and Africa and has proven to be          parallel lines accompanied with Greek
a timeless computing tool. Its operation         numerals. Metal counters were placed
offers everyone the ability to compute large     on the board between the lines, and the
numbers without any electrical devices. As       number of counters on each line represents
seen in the next section, the simplicity of      different values. The vertical spaces were
counting on the abacus provides endless          used to indicate base units, tens, hundreds,
computing possibilities to people of all ages    etc., and intermediate spaces allowed the
around the world.                                operator to mark larger values, such as
                                                 fives, fifties, etc. Figure 3 depicts this idea.
History Throughout the Ancient                   Tables could easily be arranged to compute         To unravel
Worlds                                           addition and subtraction problems. As time         the history
   It is certain that mechanical aids have       passed and cross-cultural exchange took            of the abacus
been used as calculation devices by ancient      place, the abacus evolved into a tailored
civilizations. Merchants may have even           tool that reflected the operator’s individual
                                                                                                    we look next
used a crude form of the counting table          needs.                                             at classical
during prehistoric times. Ever since the                                                            paintings and
Phoenicians, Egyptians, and Greeks were                                                             literature;
involved in Mediterranean trade, the abacus
has become a world-wide computing tool
                                                                                                    however, these
(Moon, 1971).                                                                                       historical
   Since the abacus’ history is not clear, the                                                      artifacts
origin of the tool can only be speculated.                                                          do not
Counting boards are thought to be the
predecessor of the beaded abacus. Counting
                                                                                                    portray the
boards were likely crudely constructed                                                              lower class
wooden tables, lost to decomposition like                                                           merchants and
the wooden huts in which they were used                                                             businessmen
(Pullan, 1968). To unravel the history of the
abacus we look next at classical paintings
                                                                                                    who
and literature; however, these historical                                                           frequently
artifacts do not portray the lower class                                                            used counting
merchants and businessmen who frequently                                                            boards.
used counting boards. “One could hardly
expect the aristocratic Plato, for instance,
to write a treatise on a device used by slaves
and petty tradesmen” (Moon, 1971, 21).
For this reason, the abacus is often left out
of Greek and Roman history.
Salamis Counting Board
   The oldest existing counting board was
discovered on the island of Salamis about a
century ago (see Fig 3). It has been estimated
that the counting board dates back to the                Fig 3 Salamis Counting Board
Ohio Journal of School Mathematics | Number 65 • Spring, 2012                                               Page 59
                                                   OC
                                                   TM
                    Medieval Counting Boards                         Other Abaci
                       Counting boards were used throughout              The bead frame abacus and a counting
                    Europe during the Middle Ages until the          board have many features in common but
                    16th century when they were replaced by          are unique to the cultures that use them.
                    pencil-and-paper calculations. Arithmetic        The counting boards are thought to be more
                    books depicting counting boards became           flexible than the bead frame abacus because
                    the first documentation with the advent of       the operator has an unlimited supply of
                    more modern publication methods (Moon,           markers, but the bead frame abacus is
                    1971). The illustrations often display           more compact, portable, and is capable of
                    two mathematicians solving equations,            more rapid computing. In the following
                    one using a counting table and the other         sections we will explore the unique features
                    calculating with pencil and paper. One           of different forms of beaded abaci as they
                    such painting is shown in Figure 4.              evolved around the world.
                                                                     Roman Abacus
     Arithmetic                                                          The Roman abacus features sliding
                                                                     counters permanently attached to the
books depicting                                                      device. It consists of a metal plate with
       counting                                                      fixed counters sliding in grooves. Each
        boards .                                                     lower grove holds four markers, except for
       . . often                                                     the right-most groove which holds five.
                                                                     Similarly, each of the upper grooves holds
    display two                                                      one marker. Beads in the upper slots have
mathematicians                                                       a value five times that of the marker below.
          solving                                                    Suan-pan
     equations,                                                          “Some authorities believe that the Roman
                                                                     abacus was introduced into China early in
    one using a                                                      the Christian era by traveling merchants”
 counting table,                                                     (Moon, 1971, p. 30). The earliest mention
  and the other                                                      of the abacus in Chinese literature did not
     calculating                                                     occur until the 12th century. The Suan-
                    Fig 4 Mathematicians solving equations with a    pan is widely used throughout China and
   with pen and           counting table and pen and paper           other parts of Asia. The Suan-pan features
           paper.                                                    five unit beads on each lower rod and two
                       Medieval counting boards were arranged
                                                                     ‘five-beads’ on each upper rod, as shown in
                    vertically with the numbers increasing
                                                                     Figure 5.
                    as they moved away from the operator.
                                                                     Soroban
                    Counters were placed on lines or grooves
                                                                         The modern Japanese abacus, known as
                    signifying a specific place-value while larger
                                                                     a Soroban, was developed from the Chinese
                    values could be marked between the lines.
                                                           Fig 5 Other abaci
  Page 60                                          Ohio Journal of School Mathematics | Number 65 • Spring, 2012
                                                           OC
                                                           TM
                                    Fig 6 Soroban Abacus
Suan-pan. The Sorban features four unit         Each heaven bead in the upper deck has a
beads on the lower rods, and one ‘five bead’    value of 5, each earth bead in the lower deck     The Soroban
on the upper rods as depicited in Figure 6.     has a value of 1, as seen in Figure 6. The
                                                                                                  abacus is
The Sorban also features large sharp-edge       beads are considered counted when they
beads that are easily manipulated, and          are moved towards the divider separating          ideal for a
the distance through which they move is         the upper and lower decks.                        base-ten
relatively short, allowing for high-speed           Once it is understood how to count            numbering
operation.                                      using an abacus, any integer can easily be
                                                                                                  system, in
Schoty                                          found. The general rule is that the value
   The Russian abacus, the Schoty, features     of any given bead is ten times that of the        which each
ten beads per rod and no dividing bar,          bead to its immediate right, or one tenth         rod acts as
as depicted in Figure 5. This requires the      the value of the bead to its immediate left       a placeholder
movement of a larger number of beads over       (Kojima, 1954). Decimals are represented
                                                                                                  and can
a relatively far distance, but is said to be    right of the unit rod, also seen in Figure 6.
easier to learn than instruments utilizing          There are two general rules for quickly and   represent
markers of value five. While all the previous   easily solving any addition and subtraction       values 0
devices were operated horizontally, the         problem with the Soroban abacus. First,           through 9.
Russian instrument can also be operated         the operator should always solve problems
vertically (Pullan, 1968).                      from left to right (Kojima, 1954). This may
                                                be confusing at first but will drastically
Abacus Operation                                increase the speed of operation, and with
   In general, all abaci work in a similar      a little practice can make computing an
fashion. In this section we explore how         easy-to-learn mechanical process. Second,
to operate the popular Soroban abacus.          the operator must be familiar with how to
The Soroban abacus is ideal for a base-ten      find complementary numbers, specifically,
numbering system, in which each rod acts        always with respect to 10 (Kojima, 1954).
as a placeholder and can represent values       A number’s complement is found through
0 through 9. On each rod, the Soroban           a simple addition problem. The value
has one bead in the upper deck, know as         added to the original number to make 10
a heaven bead, and four beads in the lower      is the number’s complement. For example,
deck, know as earth beads (Kojima, 1954).       the complement of 7, with respect to 10,
Ohio Journal of School Mathematics | Number 65 • Spring, 2012                                              Page 61
                                                   OC
                                                   TM
                  is 3 and the complement of 6, with respect           This leaves us with 1 bead registered on
                  to 10, is 4.                                      rod G (the tens rod) and 2 beads on rod H
                                                                    (the unit rod), as shown in Figure 9. The
                  Addition                                          result shows that 8+4 is 12.
                     When solving addition problems with               This rule remains the same regardless of
                  the Soroban abacus, subtraction is required       the numbers used. Consider, for instance
                  when the addends sum to a value greater           the addition problem 356+472. First
                  than 9. In such a case, the complement is         register 356 on rods F, G, and H, with H as
                  subtracted and 1 bead is added to the next        the unit rod, as shown in Figure 10.
                  highest place value (Heffelfinger and Flom,
                  2011). For example, consider adding 8 and
 This lesson      4. The process begins by registering 4 on
   built upon     the unit rod H, as shown in Figure 7.
 the concept
of measuring
   lines using
       iterated                                                                Fig 10 356 on rods FGH
  lengths, and                                                         Recall that when performing operations,
successfully                                                        we work from left to right. Next, add 4
built a bridge                  Fig 7 4 on rod H
                                                                    hundreds to rod F (adding 5 and subtracting
                                                                    1). The abacus now reads 756, as shown in
    from this                                                       Figure 11.
   concept to        Because the sum of the two numbers is
                  greater than 9, subtraction must be used.
     the more     We subtract the complement of 8 - namely
      abstract    2 - from 4 on rod H and add 1 bead to tens
         ruler.   rod G. This is illustrated in Figure 8.
                                                                               Fig 11 756 on rods FGH
                                                                        Now add 7 tens to rod G. Because
                                                                    5+7 > 9, the complement of 7 - namely
                                                                    3 - is subtracted from rod G, and 1 bead
                        Fig 8 Subtracting 2 and adding 10           added to rod F. The resulting value, 826, is
                                                                    illustrated in Figure 12.
                        Fig 9 Final result showing 4+8=12                      Fig 12 826 on rods FGH
Page 62                                            Ohio Journal of School Mathematics | Number 65 • Spring, 2012
                                                         OC
                                                         TM
    The final step is to add 2 to the unit
rod H. This yields the final solution 828
illustrated in Figure 13.
                                                        Fig 15 6432 on rods EFGH
          Fig 13 828 on rods FGH
Subtraction
   As we all know, subtraction is the
opposite operation of addition. Thus,
when subtracting with the Soroban abacus,
we add the complement and subtract 1
                                                        Fig 16 1432 on rods EFGH
bead from the next highest place value. For
example, when subtracting 8 from 12, start
by registering 1 on the tens rod G and 2 on
the units rods H. No tens are subtracted,
so we begin by subtracting 7 from rod H.
Because 2 − 8 < 0, the complement of 8
- namely 2 - is added to the units rod H,
and 1 bead is subtracted from the tens rod
G. This is shown in Figure 14. This leaves
the answer 4.                                            Fig 17 1132 on rods FGH
                                               When subtracting 6 tens from rod G, the
                                               complement of 6 - namely 4 - is added to
                                               rod G, and 1 bead is subtracted from rod
                                               F. The abacus now reads 1072 as shown in
                                               Figure 18. The final step is to subtract 1
                                               from the unit rod H. The abacus depicts
                                               the final solution, 1071 (left to the reader).
     Fig 14 Adding 2 and subtracting 10
   Next, we examine a more challenging
problem, 6432-5361. First register 6432
on rods E, F, G, and H, with H as the
units rod (Fig 15). Subtract 5 thousands
from rod E, leaving 1432 (Fig 16). Next,
subtract 3 hundreds from rod F. As Figure
17 illustrates, the abacus now reads 1132.               Fig 18 1072 on rods FGH
Ohio Journal of School Mathematics | Number 65 • Spring, 2012                                   Page 63
                                         OC
                                         TM
          Multiplication
             Multiplication problems, although
          potentially more difficult than addition
          and subtraction, can be easily computed
          with the Soroban abacus. Before students
          can successfully complete multiplication
          problems, they must first be familiar with
          multiplication tables through          9 × 9.
          Registering the multiplicand and the                        Fig 19 Registering 36 x 4
          multiplier is the most critical step in the
          process. This ensures the ones value of the
          product falls neatly on the unit rod.
             As an example, let’s consider the
          multiplication problem 36 × 4, with
          multiplicand 36 and multiplier 4. We
          begin by placing our finger on unit rod H
          and count left one rod for every digit in
          the multiplier (1 position to rod G) and          Fig 20 Partial product 24 on GH with F reset to 0
          one rod for each digit in the multiplicand
          (2 positions to rod E) (Heffelfinger and
          Flom, 2011). Next, register 36 on rods E
          and F. Then place 4 on rod B. This leaves
          enough space to help students distinguish
          the multiplicand from the multiplier, as
          suggested in Figure 19.
             Performing multiplication on the abacus
          involves nothing more than the addition
                                                            Fig 21 Final product 144 on FGH with D reset to 0
          of partial products. Our first step is
          multiplying 6 by 4, and adding the partial
                                                           and-pencil calculations. Furthermore, the
          product on the two rods, GH, to the right
                                                           process utilizes addition, subtraction, and
          of the multiplicand. Since we’ve accounted
                                                           multiplication we’ve discussed in previous
          for the 6, we reset rod F to zero. These steps
                                                           sections of this paper. As such, we explore
          are illustrated in Figure 20.
                                                           the following example, 19 ÷ 5, by means
             A similar process is followed to multiply
                                                           of a series of visual steps that connect our
          30 by 4. Its product, 120, is added to rods
                                                           abacus work to the traditional paper-and-
          EFG. Since we’ve accounted for the 30 in
                                                           pencil procedure familiar to many teachers.
          our calculation, we reset rod D to zero. This
                                                              As Figures 22-25 suggest, division
          leaves the final product, 144, on rods FGH
                                                           on the abacus provides students with
          as shown in Figure 21. Once addition
                                                           an alternative to paper-and-pencil
          is mastered, the reader is encouraged to
                                                           calculation that provides a more hands-
          try multiplication problems that involve
                                                           on experience for young learners. Our
          carrying, such as 36 × 9.
                                                           example is rudimentary. For a more in-
                                                           depth treatment of the topic, readers are
          Division
                                                           encouraged to explore resources provided
            Solving division problems on the
                                                           in the reference list of this paper.
          Soroban abacus mirrors familiar paper-
Page 64                                  Ohio Journal of School Mathematics | Number 65 • Spring, 2012
                                                             OC
                                                             TM
                                                           Fig 22 Setting up 19 divided by 5
                                                      Fig 23 Determing the number of 5’s in 19
                                                 Fig 24 Multiplying divisor by quotient and subtracting
                                                                     from dividend
                                                        Fig 25 Final solution, 19 ÷ 5 = 3R4
Summary
    The abacus has played a vital role in mathematics that can still be seen today. Its
portability made it a popular tool used by merchants and allowed it to be introduced to
all parts of the world. Its flexibility allowed the abacus to evolve into a tool that could be
used across cultures. Its mechanical operation allows addition, subtraction, multiplication,
and division to be done accurately and efficiently without pencil and paper, rivaling that
Ohio Journal of School Mathematics | Number 65 • Spring, 2012                                             Page 65
                                       OC
                                       TM
          of a four-function calculator. The abacus      Kojima, T. (1954). The Japanese abacus.
          is window into the past which allows             Retrieved       from        www.omerique.
          users to process operations in the same          net/twiki/pub/Recursos/ElAbaco/
          fashion of that done for thousands of years.     takashikojima1.pdf
          Moreover, the device provides students         Moon, P., (1971). The abacus: its history,
          in today’s classrooms with alternatives to       its design, its possibilities in the modern
          paper-and-pencil procedures that let them        world. New York, New York: Gordon
          explore calculations in a more hands-on          & Breach Science Publishers
          manner.                                        Pullan, J.M., (1968). The History of the
                                                           Abacus. London, England: Hutchin &
          References                                       Co LTD.
          Heffelfinger, T. & Flom, G., (2011). The
            Bead Unbaffled - An Abacus Manual.           Sources of Images
            Abacus: Mystery of the Bead. Retrieved       Figure 1: http://homepage.mac.com/
            September 27, 2011, from http://             shelleywalsh/MathArt/CBAddition.html
            webhome.idirect.com/~totton/abacus/          Figure 2: http://encyclopedia2.
                                                         thefreedictionary.com/Bead+frame
                           KEVIN       SAMOLY,           Figure 3: http://www.historyofinforma-
                           samolykm@                     tion.com/index.php?id=1664
                           muohio.edu, is a              Figure 4: http://www.mlahanas.de/
                           senior at Miami               Greeks/Counting.htm
                           University.       He          Figure 5: http://www.ucmas.ca/our-
                           enjoys     traveling,         programs/how-does-it-work/what-is-an-
                           cycling,         and          abacus/
           playing sports. His areas of interest         Figure 6: http://webhome.idirect.
           include middle school mathematics             com/~totton/abacus/
           and social studies education. He is           Figures 7-25: Drawn by the author using
           currently looking for employment              Adobe Illustrator
           opportunities in Ohio.
Page 66                                Ohio Journal of School Mathematics | Number 65 • Spring, 2012