Vincor Tarin
Vincor Tarin
Situation Analysis
Issues &
Objectives
Recommendation
Time Line
Financial
Justification
Key Success
Factors
Conclusion
Company Profile
Situation Analysis
Issues &
Objectives
Recommendation
Time Line
Financial
Justification
Key Success
Factors
Conclusion
Company Profile
Situation Analysis
Issues &
Objectives
Recommendation
Time Line
Financial
Justification
Vincor and The New World Of Wine
Presented By Thammasat Consulting
Key Success
Factors Chananun
Manita
Tarin
Conclusion
Sirunya
AGENDA
Company Profile
Company Profile
Situation Analysis
Situation Analysis
Issues &
Objectives
Issues and objectives
Recommendation
Recommendation
Time Line
Financial Justification
Financial
Justification Key Success Factors
Key Success Conclusion
Factors
Conclusion
Vincor International
Financial
Justification Classification Retail Price Premium Brands
Conclusion
Mission Statement
Company Profile
Situation Analysis
Key Success
Factors
Conclusion
Global Market Analysis
Company Profile
Percentage of Global
Imports
Top Wine Consumption
Situation Analysis Consuming Nation (million liters)
1. United Kingdom – 19 %
Company Profile
Key Success
Factors
Conclusion
Current Situation Ultimate Goal
Company Profile North American Player with Global Player with sale of
sale of Cdn$376.6 million Cdn$830 million within 5 years
Situation Analysis
Issues &
Objectives
Issues at Hand Objectives
Evaluate Business proposition to
Recommendation Goundrey Acquisition
Vincor’s Global Strategy
Time Line
Strengthening Increase Sales of US
Financial North American Market Market by CAGR 21% over the next 5 Yr.
Justification
Conclusion
Immediate Strategy: Australian Acquisition
Situation Analysis
8% (P) 7% (UP) • Largest winery in Western Australia
Issues & • Reputation for super and ultra
Objectives 85% (SP) premium wine
• Most important winery for local
Recommendation distributors
Financial
Justification
To Become a Global Player
• One Australian winery (Goundrey) is Acquire Goundrey
Key Success not enough
Factors PLUS
• Complexity of Oversea Integration
an Australian Comparable
• Financial Capability
Conclusion
Short Term Strategy: US Acquisition
Time Line
Conclusion
US Acquisition: Network Target
Situation Analysis OR
NY
Issues &
Objectives
Key Success
Factors
Acquire 3 Wineries with aggregate
= Existing Distribution network Current annual sales of $90Million
Conclusion = Potential Target
Long Term Strategy: UK Penetration
Company Profile
DISTRIBUTION
Situation Analysis
International wine dominates UK market
OUTSOURCE
Issues & Acquiring foreign distribution is expensive
Objectives
Recommendation
Marketing Strategy: Direct Marketing
Time Line
Target Market
Financial
Justification
Age Range Income Range Lifestyle
40 and $50,000 and Upper Business
Key Success above above Clientele
Factors
Financial South UK
Justification
London,
Bristol
Key Success
Factors
2005 Distributor Penetration
Source: Barclay Statistic 2002
2006 Distributor Penetration
Conclusion 2007 Distributor Penetration
Timeline
Integration
Time Line
Long-term Strategy
Financial
London and Bristol
Justification
Distributors
Glasgow and Edinburgh
Distributors
Key Success
Factors
Leeds and Manchester
Distributors
Event Marketing
Conclusion
Financial Forecast
Situation Analysis
CAGR = 17.22%
Situation Analysis
CAGR = 26.54%
Conclusion
Key Success Factors
Company Profile
Situation Analysis
Issues &
Objectives Product
Recommendation
Time Line
Key Success
Factors
Conclusion
Issues are solved
Australian Acquisition
Situation Analysis Evaluate Business
proposition Vincor’s - Goundrey + Comparable
Issues & Global Strategy - Strategic Fits
Objectives - Brand image Consistency
Recommendation
Increase Sales of US United States Conquest
market by CAGR 21% over
Time Line - Acquire 3 New York wineries
the next 5 Yr.
- Expand market
Financial coverage (East coast)
Justification - Broaden Brand Portfolio
Increase the Sales
proportion from UK to Enter United Kingdom
Key Success 13.2% or the total sales
Factors of Cdn $110 Million by
- Outsource Distribution
2007
- Marketing campaign
- Regional Selection
Conclusion
Company Profile
Situation Analysis
Issues &
Objectives
Recommendation
Time Line
Financial
Justification
Key Success
Factors
Conclusion
Slide Navigator
Company Profile
• Company Profile
• Mission Statement
Situation Analysis • Global Market Analysis
• Market Analysis
Issues &
Objectives • Current position and Ultimate goal
• Issues & Objective
Recommendation • Immediate Strategy
• Short Term Strategy
Time Line • Long Term Strategy
• Time Line
Financial • Financial Justification
Justification
– Revenue
– Net Income
Key Success – Financing
Factors
• Key Success Factors
• Conclusions
Conclusion
Back Up Navigator
Conclusion
Why acquisition not strategic alliance (US)
Company Profile
Advantages of Acquisition
Situation Analysis
-Complete control over wineries and
Issues &
distribution is crucial in order to successfully
Objectives compete in the US Market
- Consolidation trend
Recommendation
Time Line
Drawbacks of Strategic Alliances
Financial -Reliability of strategic partners is likely
Justification
to be controversial
-Should those partners be trusted to handle
Key Success
Factors our products?
Conclusion
Why have more than one distributor?
Company Profile
• Mitigating sole distributor risk
Situation Analysis – Decrease risk of losing entire distributing
network
Issues &
Objectives • Broaden the geographic market
Recommendation
coverage
– Prominent distributors from different
Time Line geographic areas
– Attain geographical core competency from
Financial
Justification each distributor
Key Success
Factors
Conclusion
Our Value Proposition to Distributors
Company Profile
Company Marketing
Great Product
Credibility Support
Situation Analysis
Issues &
Objectives
• Wide range of super premium product
Recommendation
– Australian, US, Canada
Conclusion
Why do you need marketing campaign
in the UK not US?
Company Profile
UK MARKET US MARKET
Situation Analysis
• Existing US market
• Lack of expertise
• Already have local expertise
Issues & • Unknown market
Objectives • Well established brands and
• High competition rate for
network distribution
Australian wine
Recommendation requires marketing • Recent acquisitions is
campaigns in order to competent enough on their
make our product known marketing campaign
Time Line
to consumers • Good performance
Financial – Acquisition of Hogue added 11
Justification sales people which immediately
increased Vincor’s annual U.S.
Sales volume to more than 1
Key Success million cases
Factors
Conclusion
Portfolio Management
Recommendation
Exporting Australian wine Integration of products from
Time Line
Into the US market US, Canada, and Australia
Financial
Justification
Key Success
Factors
Conclusion
Why not acquire winery plant in UK?
Company Profile
Time Line
Financial
Justification
Key Success
Factors
Conclusion
UK Distributor criteria
Company Profile
At least 10 years of experience in wine distribution
Situation Analysis
within UK
One of the top 5 UK distributors
Issues &
Objectives Promising future of network expansion into other
European countries (foundation for Vincor’s further
Recommendation
penetration into Europe)
Time Line Extensive network of super and ultra premium wine
Financial distribution channels
Justification
Distributors’ product image are consistent with that of
Key Success Vincor (premium and above)
Factors
Conclusion
Will imported Australian wine cannibalize US wine?
Company Profile
• Inevitable loss
Situation Analysis • Offer consumers with a wider variety of
products
Issues &
Objectives • Increasing trend of Australian wine
Recommendation
consumption
• Addition of Australian brands to US brands
Time Line
can better solidify market base in US and UK
Financial
Justification
Key Success
Factors
Conclusion
Opportunity Loss for Late Entry - UK
Company Profile
Key Success
Factors
Conclusion
Marketing Campaign to End-consumers
Company Profile
Conclusion
GDP - UK
Company Profile
City GDP per Capita (€)
Situation Analysis
London 35,702
Issues &
Objectives
Edinburg 35,018
Recommendation
Glasgow 31,893
Time Line
Bristol 29,437
Financial
Justification Leeds 25,619
Manchester 21,099
Key Success
Factors
Source: Eurostat: Region: Statistical Year book 2003
Conclusion
Why can’t we achieve Cdn$1000 Million
Conclusion
Integration
Company Profile
Conclusion
Distribution Channels in US
Company Profile
• Ideally:
Situation Analysis
– High-end Restaurants
Issues &
Objectives – Duty Free
Recommendation
– Hotel (5 stars)
Time Line
• Nevertheless, it’s heavily
Financial
depend upon relationship
Justification
with distributors.
Key Success
Factors
Conclusion
Headquarters in UK
Company Profile
• With 2 cities in one region cover a greater market
Situation Analysis area
Issues & • Effective distribution channel within the region
Objectives
• Strength in one region will benefit another region
Recommendation • Having weak market presence in a wider
geographical area is less favorable than having a
Time Line
strong presence in a concentrated area
Financial
Justification – Do not want to be perceived by consumers as inferior
to competitors’ brands present in the same area
Key Success
Factors
Conclusion
Acquisition Targets
Company Profile
Issues &
• Same firm’s characteristic, size, and
Objectives
revenue
Recommendation
Time Line
Financial
Justification
Key Success
Factors
Conclusion
Historical Financial Statement
Company Profile
Historical Ratio Analysis
F'98 F'99 F'00 F'01 F'02
Situation Analysis Liquidity Ratios
Current Ratio
Issues & Quick Ratio
Leverage Ratios
Objectives
Debt Ratio 37.16% 47.46% 42.25% 64.66% 24.45%
TIE Ratio
Recommendation Profitability Ratios
NPM 5.23% 4.62% 4.96% 4.85% 7.14%
ROE 10.56% 10.10% 10.29% 9.84% 6.78%
Time Line ROA 6.63% 5.31% 5.94% 3.48% 5.12%
Asset Utilization
Total Asset Turnover 1.267813 1.14882 1.197856 0.717169 0.71706
Financial DSO
Justification Inventory Turnover
Key Success
Factors
Conclusion
Overall Financial Position
Company Profile
Issues &
• Low leverage, high debt capacity
Objectives
• Low asset utilization rate, due to
Recommendation
acquisitions
Time Line
Financial
Justification
Key Success
Factors
Conclusion
Assumptions
Income Statement
Company Profile F'02 F'03F F'04F F'05F F'06F F'07F
Revenue 376.6
EBITDA 70.5 18.70% 19.30% 20.50% 20.70% 20.70%
%Revenue 18.70%
Situation Analysis Depre&Amor 9.00% 9.00% 9.00% 9.00% 9.00%
EBIT 58.53 15% 15% 16% 17% 17.00%
Interest Exp. 22.66
Issues & EBT 35.87
Objectives Tax 8.97
Net Income 26.9 8.00% 8.00% 9.00% 10.00% 10.00%
Avg. Capital Employed 468.2 88.03% 88.03% 88.03% 88.03% 88.03%
ROCE (EBIT) 12.50%
Recommendation
Balance Sheet
F'02 F'03F F'04F F'05F F'06F F'07F
Time Line Funds Employed
Receivables 55.1 13.31% 13.31% 13.31% 13.31% 13.31%
Inventory 175.6 35.22% 35.22% 35.22% 35.22% 35.22%
Financial Working Capital 184.9 33.00% 33.00% 33.00% 33.00% 33.00%
Net Fixed Asset 178.8 0.00% 0.00% 1.50% 1.50% 1.50%
Justification Other Assets 161.5 5.00% 3.00% 3.00% 3.00% 3.00%
Funds Employed 525.2
Turnover 0.71706
Key Success
Financing
Factors Debt (net) 110.1
Deferred Tax 18.3 20.99% 20.99% 20.99% 20.99% 20.99%
Equity 396.8 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00%
Financing 525.2
Conclusion
Pro Forma Statement
Company Profile
Ratio Analysis
F'02 F'03F F'04F F'05F F'06F F'07F
Situation Analysis Liquidity Ratios
Current Ratio
Quick Ratio
Issues & Leverage Ratios
Objectives Debt Ratio 24.45% 27.16% 35.05% 32.76% 27.85% 21.39%
TIE Ratio 2.58 3.64 2.81 3.20 4.44 6.95
Profitability Ratios
Recommendation NPM 7.14% 7.46% 6.74% 6.73% 8.05% 9.18%
ROE 6.78% 8.27% 8.53% 9.11% 10.69% 11.61%
ROA 5.12% 6.02% 5.54% 6.12% 7.71% 9.12%
Time Line Asset Utilization
Total Asset Turnover 0.71706 0.807224 0.821351 0.91005 0.957825 0.994324
DSO
Financial
Inventory Turnover
Justification
Key Success
Factors
Conclusion
Free Cash Flow Analysis
NPV
Company Profile F'03F F'04F F'05F F'06F F'07F
EBITDA W 89.64 115.42 124.35 140.08 152.55
Investment 115.1786 120 0 0 0
Situation Analysis Tax 11.92 13.44 15.79 20.75 25.49
Terminal Value 1230.815
CF - 37.46 - 18.02 108.55 119.33 1,357.87
Issues &
EBITDA WO 75.28 78.80 82.13 84.87 87.71
Objectives
Investment
Tax 12.77 12.34 11.86 10.90 10.59
Recommendation Terminal Value 707.6191
CF 62.51 66.47 70.27 73.96 784.74
FCFF - 99.97 - 84.48 38.28 45.36 573.14
Time Line
WACC
Kd 13.00%
Financial Wd 21.72%
Justification Tax 25%
Ke 16%
We 78.28%
Key Success WACC 14.64%
Factors
Conclusion
Revenue Break-down
Assumption Sales Target
F'02 F'03F F'04F F'05F F'06F F'07F
Company Profile Canada
Vincor 270.00 280.80 292.03 303.71 312.82 322.21
R.H. Phillips 9.00 9.18 9.36 9.55 9.74 9.94
Hogue 11.00 11.22 11.44 11.67 11.91 12.14
Situation Analysis Goundrey - - - 5.00 6.20 7.69
NY - - - - - -
Total 290.00 301.20 312.84 329.94 340.67 351.98
Issues & U.S.
Objectives Vincor 30.00 30.00 30.00 30.00 30.00 30.00
R.H. Phillips 36.00 38.88 41.99 44.09 46.29 48.61
Hogue 44.00 49.28 54.21 58.54 62.06 65.78
Goundrey - - - 15.00 20.00 22.00
Recommendation NY - - 90.00 97.20 103.03 109.21
Total 110.00 118.16 216.20 244.83 261.38 275.60
Australia
Time Line Vincor - - - - - -
R.H. Phillips - - - - - -
Hogue - - - - - -
Financial Goundrey 50.00 60.00 69.00 79.35 87.29 96.01
Justification NY - - - - - -
Total 50.00 60.00 69.00 79.35 87.29 96.01
U.K.
Key Success Vincor - - - 5.00 8.00 10.00
R.H. Phillips - - - 5.00 8.00 10.00
Factors Hogue - - - 5.00 8.00 10.00
Goundrey - - - 20.00 36.00 50.00
NY - - - 15.00 24.00 30.00
Total - - - 50.00 84.00 110.00
Conclusion Total Sales 450.00 479.36 598.04 704.12 773.34 833.60
Revenue Growth Assumptions
U.K.
Key Success Vincor 5.00% 5.00%
Factors R.H. Phillips 12.50% 10.00%
Hogue 12.50% 10.00%
Goundrey 20.00% 20.00%
NY 12.50% 10.00%
Conclusion
Revenue Growth
Company Profile
Recommendation
UK
Time Line
- Market penetration by establish distribution network one
Financial region each year
Justification
- Marketing strategy helps with product acceptance
Key Success
Factors
Conclusion
Revenue in UK
Company Profile
Situation Analysis
Issues &
Objectives
Total market size of 3.7 billion pound
Recommendation Growth rate is very high especially for new world wines
Time Line
Financial
Justification
Key Success
Factors
Conclusion