PLEURODESIS
INTRODUCTION
Induction of symphysis of visceral and parietal pleura
Agent – exuberant inflammatory response
Objective – prevent accumulation of air/fluid
Tube/Thoracoscopy/Intrapleural catheter
MECHANISM
Inflammatory response
Imbalance – pleural coagulation and fibrinolysis
Favoring adhesion formation
Mesothelial cells lining pleurae
Exposure ot TFG-β – produce collagen = adhesion
Successful pleurodesis: high VEGF and Bfgf
TFG-β: Transforming Growth Factor
VEGF: Vascular Endothelial Growth Factor
bFGF: basic Fibroblast Growth Factor
INDICATIONS & CONTRAINDICATIONS
INDICATIONS:
Recurrent symptomatic malignant pleural effusion (MPE)
Recurrent pneumothorax
Refractory benign effusions
CONTRAINDICATIONS:
No absolute C.I.
Critically ill with high oxygen need
TYPES
CHEMICAL:
Sclerosant via thoracoscope or chest tube
Powder – sprayed with atomizer
Slurry – liquid preparation
IPC (intrapleural catheter)
Drainage + pleurodesis
Mechanical friction
Chemical impregnated: silver nitrate
TYPES
MECHANICAL:
Pleural abrasion
Pleurectomy
Apical
Total (recurrence: 0.4% v 2.3%)
Open or VATS
Open: if unable to tolerate moderate sedation
CHEMICAL PLEURODESIS
CHEMICAL PLEURODESIS
When?
More than half visceral pleura apposed to parietal
Without need to wait until drain output <150ml
Successful:
No significant recurrence
Complete: no accumulation in 30 days
Partial: some accumulation; symptoms palliated
Failure:
Effusion and symptoms persist
Choice of agent
More than 30 agents proposed (since 1935)
None ideal
Efficacy, safety, availability and cost
Talc poudrage used in 1935 (after lobectomy)
Best studied: talc, tetracycline derivatives and bleomycin
TALC
Most commonly used worldwide
Poudrage since 1935
Slurry since 1958
Asbestos-free magnesium trisilicate
Sterilization: dry heat/ethylene oxide/gamma irradiation
Sifted through mesh
Varying pore size: (11-20 microns, US; 34 in France)
More ARDS in US
TALC
TALC..
TTP (thoracoscopic talc poudrage) superior to TS (talc slurry)
TTP superior to tetracycline, bleomycin, doxycycline (Cochrane)
TAPPS trial (<14F tubes) awaited
British Thoracic Society, European Respiratory Society, American
Thoracic Society:
Talc = agent of choice
Use graded talc (<50% particles under 20µm)
TTP superior in MPE (lung, breast) 16 and mesothelioma
TETRACYCLINE DERIVATIVES
Tetracycline derivatives: parenteral doxycycline
Oral doxycycline in saline also used
Thoracoscopic insufflation
CYTOTOXIC DRUGS
Bleomycin best studied
Irritant
Better in efficacy to tetracycline
Inferior to talc
IODOPOVIDONE
Widespread availability
Low cost
89% success
Varying degrees of pain
Visual loss (>200 ml of 10% solution)
Shorter hospital stay (v. talc)
SILVER NITRATE
Randomised trial:
96% success (v. TS 84%)
‘Rescue’:
Failed talc poudrage
89% efficacy
Minimal side effects even with high dose (1g)
Incremental doses – increasing SIRS but equal success
Decline in use due to pain
Resurgence with use in IPCs
BACTERIAL AGENTS
OK-432:
Strep pyogenes (penicillin-treated)
Initially immunotherapy for malignancy
Japan – widespread use (lack of talc)
Success 70% (upto 85% with minocycline)
Major side effect: Intersitial lung disease (esp with EGFR-TKI); 25% mortality
Corynebacterium parvum:
1978, malignant effusions and ascites
Pleural fluid pH or glucose not an issue (v. other sclerosants)
Comparable to doxycycline
OTHER AGENTS
Mistletoe (Viscum album): Korea (talc and tetracycline not available)
Autologous blood pleurodesis (ABP):
Persistent air leaks
MPE
100-150 ml
Lower rates of pain and hospital stay
Pneumothroaces: promising
MODES OF DELIVERY
Chest tubes:
28-32F: Pain
TIME1 trial: 12 v 24; less pain but higher failure
Meta-analysis: <14 v >14 = similar efficacy
Rotation myth: no difference with q20min rotations v no rotation
Analgesia: intrapleural lidocaine (2-3mg/kg)
Medical thoracoscopy:
Rigid or flexi-rigid thoracoscope
GA not required (conscious sedation, well tolerated)
Talc most commonly used
Advantage: pleural drainage and biopsy
SPECIFIC DISEASE STATES
MALIGNANT PLEURAL EFFUSIONS:
Poor prognosis
Lung cancer MPE: survival 5.5 months
Paramalignant effusions:
Solid tumor + effusion (cytology negative)
Lower survival v cancer without effusion
MPE….
Success rates affected by tumor types
Mesothelioma and lung cancer MPE: higher failure
Breast cancer MPE: more successful (75% v 58% for lung)
Mesothelioma MPE:
Antitumor effect of pleurodesis by inducing inflammation
Increased survival rate
NONMALIGNANT EFFUSIONS
Last resort
Address underlying etiology
Role of IPC:
Refractory heart failure
Refractory hepatic hydrothorax
Longer time to pleurodesis
Higher recurrence
Chylothorax: after conservative and surgical options have failed
PLEURODESIS FOR PNEUMOTHORAX
Secondary pneumothorax (COPD, ILD, cystic fibrosis)
Recurrent primary spontaneous pneumothorax (PSP)
Persistent air leaks (>5 days)
OUT PATIENT PLEURODESIS
IPC: minimized hospitalization
Topical anesthesia
TIME2 trial: reduces dyspnea at 6 months
Disadvantage: cost
ASAP trial:
Aggressive regimen upto 1L/day
Autopleurodesis: 54 days (median)
IPC
ONGOING STUDIES
OMPTIMUM trial:
IPC with TS pleurodesis v TS
REDUCE trial:
IPC in nonmalignant effusion