8.0

Buttermilk

1725 W Division St, Chicago, Illinois 60622

$$$$

AmericanBar

Wicker Park

Directions

CHIReview

photo credit: Alex Zandro

A picture of the food spread at Buttermilk, including a chicken caesar wrap, chicken sandwich, and chicken tenders.
8.0
Directions

Perfect for

Casual DinnersWalk-InsDrinks & A Light Bite

The Taco Sublime team already makes some of our favorite burgers and tacos, and they continue their handheld food domination with Buttermilk. Armed with perfectly golden fried chicken, this resident kitchen of Wicker Park’s Little Victories is a deep-frying force to be reckoned with. Every form of poultry here is fantastic—chunky tenders, caesar wraps, nacho-cheese-drizzled loaded fries, and giant sandwiches where the crunchy farmbird sticks out of the potato buns like Saturn’s rings. Paired with Little Victories’ delicious cocktails, Buttermilk's menu is a perfect pregame before a couple of rounds of darts in the busy, wood-paneled bar.

Food Rundown

Chicken Sandwich

You can get this with add-ons like cheese, bacon, or an egg, but it doesn’t need them. There’s plenty of savoriness from the crunchy breading and juicy meat, complemented by tanginess from mayo and pickles, and slightly sweet potato buns. We like to get some dipping sauce involved, too—either the BBQ for some sweetness or the buffalo for a bit of kick.

A fried chicken sandwich.

photo credit: Alex Zandro

Tenders

Don’t care about bread and just want some pure, unadulterated bird? Get these. Okay, maybe not completely pure, because the sauces should get in on the action here, too.

A plate of chicken tenders with two dipping sauces.

photo credit: Alex Zandro

Chicken Caesar Wrap

This parmesan-dusted specimen is CCW craftsmanship of the highest caliber. It’s a chunky package of dressing, crisp romaine, well-seasoned fried chicken bits, and pita chips. But thanks to expert tortilla wrapping and griddle work, it never falls apart.

A plate with a chicken caesar wrap.

photo credit: Alex Zandro

Loaded Fries

This is prime drunk food, but it’s so good you’ll probably finish it before your beer. The crisp, McDonald’s-esque fries are an excellent vehicle for the salty fried chicken, and a rich combination of ranch, housemade Pleaser sauce, and nacho cheese.

A plate of fries with fried chicken and drizzles of sauce.

photo credit: Alex Zandro

Included In

Location

1725 W Division St, Chicago, Illinois 60622

What Our Ratings Mean
Learn more

Truly Excellent: An 8 should be on your must-try list, because 8s are great. These spots are worth making an effort or crossing town for.

Learn more

Suggested Reading

Taco Sublime image
8.2

Taco Sublime

Mexican

McKinley Park

Taco Sublime is a pop-up inside of Marz Brewery in McKinley Park with great fried cheese tacos and smashburgers.

The whole lemon dessert from Valhalla.

There are a lot of places to eat in Wicker Park, but these are the best ones.

A tray of wings with a side of ranch.

From Korean lollipop chicken to crunchy jumbo wings doused in mild sauce, here are 21 of the best chicken wings in Chicago.

A plate with a chicken caesar wrap.

For when a salad is too little and a sandwich is too much.

Infatuation Logo

Cities

Information

  • Newsletter
  • Contact Us
  • Sitemap
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Online Tracking Opt Out Guide
2025 © The Infatuation Inc. All Rights Reserved.
The views and opinions expressed on The Infatuation’s site and other platforms are those of the authors and do not reflect the official policy or position of (or endorsement by) JPMorgan Chase. The Infatuation and its affiliates assume no responsibility or liability for the content of this site, or any errors or omissions. The Information contained in this site is provided on an "as is" basis with no guarantees of completeness, accuracy, usefulness or timeliness.

FIND PLACES ON OUR APP

Get it on Google PlayDownload on the App Store