In this manuscript, I complicate linear conceptualizations of recovery from sexual trauma and explore some of the temporal anxieties that emerge that appear in discussions of sexual trauma: pre and post, before and after, victim and survivor, for example. I discuss how a historical confluence of sexual stigma, exploitation, and expropriation leave Black women distinctly vulnerable to sexual violence and how the ubiquity of anti-Black, gendered, sexual violence blurs neat temporal demarcations like before and after. I explore Black women’s post-violence sexuality as a chronological marker of difference, not a conceptual marker of difference. Black women’s post-violence sexuality is a spectrum of possibility that rebukes social expectations to perform or profess distance from sexual trauma as evidence of recovery and disrupts linear trajectories of trauma recovery. I read literary representations of Black women’s post-violence sexuality that challenge binaries that characterize popular discourse on sexual trauma and its aftermath. These accounts challenge us to grapple with the sprawling effects of sexual violence and to challenge the conventions that have come to dominate popular discourse about Black women’s sexuality, sexual trauma, and trauma recovery.