Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-18 22:51:26 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-18 22:54:45 UTC · last check 2026-11-18 23:05:20 UTC

A.6.3.NAR:7 - Conformance and counterexample replay

CheckPass condition
CC-NAR-1An ordinary user can produce a readable narrative before supplying exact endpoint identities or assurance fields.
CC-NAR-2Reader/listener use, source material, selected structures, and the reason for selecting them are clear.
CC-NAR-3The ordering and connective account are explicit enough to distinguish source relations from narrative links added for readability.
CC-NAR-4The narrative has been compared with its source for preservation, foregrounding, omission, weakening, rearrangement, and unsupported strengthening.
CC-NAR-5The supported use is clear; source return is specified when omitted structure or a changed question requires it. Any excluded use passes F.19:4’s full guard test.
CC-NAR-6Temporal posture, mediation, event-model support, viewpoint, engagement, and worker history appear only when each changes use or blocks a likely overread.
CC-NAR-7Evidence, assurance, ethics, policy, publication, decision, and Work claims use the patterns that define or test those claims.
CC-NAR-8The exact branch opens when the identified receiving use depends on claim identity and preservation. Citation, distribution or generated status alone does not establish that need.
CC-NAR-9In that branch, X and Y are independently identified by claim content, EntityOfConcern and effective interpretation rules (ReferenceScheme); a model, file or prose label alone supplies none of those identities.
CC-NAR-10Exact n : X -> Y states same EntityOfConcern, claim construction, endpoint scheme relation, ordering, preservation, loss, prohibited strengthening, applicability, and return.
CC-NAR-11Additional source epistemes and correspondence dependencies are exact when used; Work, system, system-role kind or assignment, method, publication, carrier, evidence, assurance, and U.View membership remain separately identified and must satisfy their own definitions or tests. Completing the exact record does not itself authorize reliance.
CC-NAR-12Changes to the source, selected structure, order, loss, use, exact identity, depended-on relation or return are checked for their effect on the narrative. Preserve unaffected uses; repair affected content or restrict only uses no longer supported.

Counterexample replay:

CaseRequired result
Ordinary entryA team can turn an architecture trade-off structure into a useful explanatory sequence and loss note without first inventing X, Y, n, Work, or assurance records.
Preserve vs retargetExact NAR requires the same EntityOfConcern; a different narrated concern requires A.6.4 even when derived from X.
Same vs different schemeNarrative order may be primary in either case. Use RT as well when a change of representation language or reasoning medium supports an operation beyond narrative ordering. Scheme difference alone establishes neither n nor correspondence.
Candidate vs U.ViewA valid narrative episteme and NAR construction can fail conformance to viewpoint P. That failed test grants no U.View membership through P; conformance to another viewpoint remains independent.
Source publication/form/carrierA publication can make X available and a form or carrier can express it; none becomes X, and a narrative page or audio file is not Y.
Narrative orderChronology, tension, or didactic order is a declared construction rule, not automatically world-side event order, proof order, performed-Work order, or an obtaining relation.
Controlled lossIf Y is usable only under declared loss, narrower use, and source return, coordinate CSC; NAR ordering alone does not make the loss admissible.
Grounded source, ungrounded narrativeGrounding of X or a designated evidence set does not ground Y; recover a separate EpistemeEmpiricalGroundingRelation for Y only when its own claims satisfy that rule.
Selected structure overreadNAR may order an A.22 structure designated by source claims. Identify the source and receiving epistemes independently; keep the selected-structure and narrative-ordering positions distinct.