Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-18 21:11:39 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-18 21:12:35 UTC · last check 2026-11-18 22:10:10 UTC

A.6.3.RT:1 - Problem frame

Use this pattern when changing the representation language or the reasoning medium helps someone inspect, compare or calculate using the same material. A table shown in time order and the same table aligned by component can use one language while supporting different comparisons. Exporting the chosen table to another file can leave both the language and the reasoning medium unchanged.

Start with the content that must survive and the action the new representation should support. The source can be givens, constraints and a partial construction while the answer is still unknown. Construct the target representation in the chosen medium. Compare it with the source and state what was preserved, foregrounded, rearranged, lost or newly suggested. Exact episteme identities are not prerequisites for this ordinary first result.

Plain starting vocabulary:

TermPlain meaning
source materialThe source claims, table, prose, diagram, model, record, publication, or other material being re-represented. In an exact case, distinguish the source episteme from its form, carrier, world-side concern, and additional inputs.
content to surviveThe claims, relations, commitments, uncertainty, source pins, or distinctions the target representation must still support for the declared use.
target representationThe table, diagram, symbolic expression, sequence of signs or other representation made for the receiving task. Its visible form or carrier does not by itself identify a receiving episteme.
representation languageThe conventional system that admits the expressions and gives them readings. A change in layout can preserve the language while changing what its user can inspect or compare.
reasoning mediumWhat the representation lets a user inspect, compare, infer, traverse, or replay more or less easily.
representation deltaWhat changed in shape, notation, salience, topology, ordering, interaction, or another representation factor.
loss and recoverabilityWhat becomes harder to see or is omitted, and how the user can recover it when it matters.
use and returnWhat the target supports, what it does not support, and when and where to return to source material.
representation workerThe person, team or system doing the conversion. A dated Work claim follows A.13 and independent A.15.1 admission; use F.6 only when precise assignment-bound attribution matters. Doing the conversion grants no authority over the represented claims.

First useful move. Name the content that must survive and the intended user action, choose the representation, make it, and compare it with the source. State the material preservation, loss and use conditions in a compact note. Add a rejected use or return condition only when it changes what the reader should do.

What goes wrong if missed. A cleaner table, diagram, notation, or decoded rendering is treated as harmless formatting after it has hidden uncertainty, changed the concern, imported a new relation, weakened recoverability, or invited a stronger action than the source supports.

What this buys. Users gain a representation suited to their task while preservation, reasoning affordances, loss, unsupported strengthening, and source return stay visible.

Ordinary use. For inspection, comparison, source-finding, technical discussion, or reversible planning preparation, the target representation and compact note are normally enough.

Exact claim identity. Open the episteme-construction branch when a receiving use depends on exact claim identity or an explicit preservation construction. Independent citation, a consequential scheme crossing, disputed support or a decode-mediated claim can create that need. Recover source episteme X, receiving episteme Y and viewing construction v : X -> Y, together with the source claims and relations on which v depends, and the scheme relation, loss/recoverability or assurance needed by that use.

Later-specific occurrence. Open RepresentationTransitionRelation@Context only when actual representation-transformation Work and the six participants defined in §4.1.b are themselves material. An exact v : X -> Y does not imply that occurrence.

Not this pattern when. Use A.6.3.CR for faithful restatement or translation when the receiver needs the same claims in other words or another language, A.6.3.NAR when reader-useful narrative ordering is primary, E.17.EFP when explanation adequacy is primary, A.6.4 when the EntityOfConcern changes, A.7 for carrier work or extraction that has not yet constituted a receiving episteme, and A.6.3.CSC when a narrower-use coarsened receiving episteme is primary.