| Gate‑as‑law | Preconditions written as “laws” | Confuses law and admission condition; breaks substitution | Move to A-* in the canonical source of the admission rule (Mechanism.AdmissibilityConditions for a mechanism); reference L-* terms. |
| Deontics in predicates | “MUST” inside definitions or gates | Confuses governance with truth or admissibility | Rewrite the definition or gate as L-*/A-*; add a generic D-* prescription or an independently established individual-duty claim when current. |
| Unresolved duty bearer | “The API promises” is used for an individual duty without its actual bearer and commitment | The institutional claim cannot be settled from the interface wording | Recover the policy and generic prescription, or the actual bearer and separately obtaining U.Commitment when an individual duty is claimed. Keep measured property (E-*) and metric definition (L-*) separate; use A.6.C when ambiguity changes interpretation or use. |
| Unestablished operational-result guarantees | An asserted p95 result lacks its actual evaluation | The operational-result claim lacks the basis needed to settle it | Use A.6.C:4.3 when the guarantee’s meaning is ambiguous. For an operational result, state the actual Work, evaluation, or observation, predicate and object, scope/window, and result; if that basis is absent, leave the result unestablished. Add A.10 support and a D-* → E-* link only when the receiving reliance and duty claims need them. A carrier-existence observation alone does not complete the measured claim. |
| Paraphrase drift | A restatement changes the governing rule | Different faces can then imply different conditions or consequences | Reference the claim ID or canonical location and repair the explanation to preserve its meaning; use a Claim Register when useful. |
| View‑fork semantics | A face introduces new L/A/D/E content | Violates “no new semantics” publication discipline | Put any new boundary claim in its canonical source before publishing it on a face. Mark explanatory commentary informative when it adds no boundary semantics. |