A.6.REL:7 - Conformance Checklist
- Across the subject pattern and the current use, the relation kind, relation-participant meanings, relation obtaining predicate, actual relation participants, applicability, relation occurrence-identity rule, and any currently needed
RelationSignatureSlotSpecs are recoverable. An ordinary relation sentence remains complete without repeating that settlement. - The text does not conflate relation obtaining, predicate satisfaction, root-kind admission, explicit-individuation work, identifier assignment, and reference use.
- Root
U.Relationadmission is governed byE.24.UKfrom the commonA.6.RELdiscipline and the relation-specific witness supplied by each direct relation pattern; project use does not repeat the admission decision. - After the readable direct relation, ask whether the receiving use needs to reidentify this occurrence or distinguish it from another. A simple current report can stop; a history, same-occurrence comparison or dependent relation can require the identity branch.
- Apply the subject pattern’s obtaining test to the relevant case facts or constituting history and state the supported result. Assertion polarity or an evidence/reliance result supplies no occurrence merely by its form; any constitutive contribution must satisfy the direct rule in section 4.3.
- Every admitted direct or derived relation kind has a direct governing settlement that declares its occurrence-identity rule; ordinary omission of explicit individuation or an occurrence designator does not count as absence of that rule.
- Participant-determined identity is used only when the direct ontology establishes that the same participant identities cannot recur in distinct occurrences of that relation kind.
- When the same participants can recur, the direct pattern declares the domain discriminator; maximal continuous obtaining interval and constituting work are possible choices only when that pattern includes them in the occurrence-identity rule.
- When construction is constitutive, the constructing system, input entities, performed construction work, and identity contribution are named; representation creation is not substituted for construction.
- Each object in the relation-object architecture is reidentified under its subject pattern and connected to adjacent objects only by the direct relations stated in section 4.1.
- Before asserting or relying on a relation occurrence as another relation’s participant, identify it under its direct rule. The receiving assertion’s reference remains distinct from that world-side participant.
- When the receiving use needs occurrence identity, apply the direct same-versus-new-occurrence rule without first creating a
RelationSignature. Follow section 4.2 and add a designator or reference only when stable reference is needed. - Another episteme edition, publication occurrence, name association, or reference use does not by itself establish another world-side relation occurrence. Apply the direct occurrence-identity rule to the current case facts or constituting history; use A.10 only for a separate evidence-based reliance judgment.