A.6.REL:9 - Consequences
Benefits. A.6.REL supplies no universal truth-maker, occurrence-identity discriminator, or representation form; for each direct relation, use the truth and occurrence-identity conditions in its defining pattern, and for the selected representation, use the form in its representation pattern.
In a direct species under U.SystemRoleAssignment, A.2.1 uses uninterrupted predicate obtaining and a demonstrated false gap to distinguish repeated episodes for history or Work attribution. In the formal reduced case, 3 < 5 remains assertion content and needs no explicitly individuated relation occurrence. In C.22.PFR, the actual-condition and criterion-applicability relation occurrences are already individuated under their own direct rules before PFR uses them as participants.
Each assertion remains a claim-bearing episteme.
Costs. The receiving use must recover and apply the direct relation kind’s identity rule. Determine whether participant identity, temporal extent, constituting Work or another domain discriminator supplies the needed reidentification or distinction. A data schema that used row identity as ontology may need to expose the domain identity it hid.
Limits. A.6.REL does not decide whether a direct relation obtains, define every relation kind, or prescribe a storage model. It does not supply evidence, comparison, publication, forecast, scenario, counterfactual, permission, or temporal semantics governed by neighboring patterns. It also does not turn assertion polarity, a separately governed claim family, or a reliance posture into an obtaining occurrence.