Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-18 21:11:39 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-18 21:12:35 UTC · last check 2026-11-18 22:15:20 UTC

A.14:4 - Solution — extend the mereology catalogue

A.14 defines three additional direct sub-relations of partOf:

  1. PortionOf — a measured part of a whole under one extensive measure and boundary rule.
  2. AspectOf — a bearer-dependent structural part distinguished under a named facet rule.
  3. PhaseOf — the same holon restricted to a proper time interval.

Two neighboring distinctions govern how these relations are used:

  • Keep local kinds, Methods, and Work out of structural part trees. Do not treat a local system-role kind or a Method as a structural part. A separately identified System or Episteme may have its own direct part relation; use method-composition patterns for submethods and A.15.1 for Work parts and occurrences.
  • Use the collection’s own belongs-to rule. State who or what may belong, what makes belonging begin and end, and how recurrence and past belonging are handled. FPF does not use one public MemberOf relation for unlike collections. Belonging alone establishes neither holonhood nor parthood, and it does not rule out a separately grounded constructive part relation after all six A.1 matters pass.

The classical pair ComponentOf (structural, discrete) and ConstituentOf (conceptual, logical/epistemic) remain as in the kernel; § 6 distinguishes them from PortionOf, AspectOf, PhaseOf, and collection belonging.