A.18:3 - Forces
-
F1 — Disciplinary interpretation. Physical measurements and human assessments can use the same structural distinctions while retaining their different domain assumptions and methods.
-
F2 — Comparability and alternative Scales. Compare values under a common Characteristic and Scale with compatible conditions under C.16. The same Characteristic may use different Scales, such as temperature in Celsius or Kelvin; use a declared conversion when the comparison needs a common Scale.
-
F3 — Scale integrity. Retain the distinction between category, order, interval and ratio structure. Numerical labels alone establish neither distances nor admissible arithmetic.
-
F4 — Optional named Levels. A Scale can provide named tiers, such as Technology Readiness Levels or bond credit ratings. A continuous measurement needs no Level labels unless a categorization is introduced.
-
F5 — Method agnosticism. CSLC defines the Characteristic, Scale and value structure. The applicable domain patterns (e.g. Sys-CAL or KD-CAL) govern how values are obtained through sensing, simulation or expert judgement. C.16 and the receiving use supply the further measurement and comparability conditions.