Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-18 21:11:39 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-18 21:12:35 UTC · last check 2026-11-18 22:50:20 UTC

A.19.UNM:5 - Archetypal Grounding

Use the normalization declaration to re-express coordinate values with their preserved and lost distinctions:

  1. Choose an admissible configured method with its evidence and validity window.
  2. Apply it to produce NCVs.
  3. Return an inverse, equivalence, class-level operation or query result only when its additional conditions hold for the receiving use.

Normalization before comparison. A team compares alternatives using normalization-based comparability:

  • CN-Spec declares:
    • comparability.mode = normalization-based
    • normalization.invariants = {unit-alignment, polarity}
    • a method instance M_unitScale with validity window VW_2026Q1 and evidence pins.
  • UNM applies M_unitScale to each coordinate value, producing NCVs.
  • CPM compares the NCV-profiles (not raw profiles).
  • If required evidence pins are missing for a slice, UNM returns GuardDecision = abstain; this comparison cannot rely on a new admitted NCV.

A many-to-one LUT. Let D be {0,1,2} and n(0)=0, n(1)=n(2)=1. Applying n to 2 returns the transformed value 1. Equality of outputs partitions D into {0} and {1,2}: it is reflexive, symmetric and transitive. The directed edge 2→1 supplies no edge 1→2.

The query x>0 is constant on each class and can be answered from the class. The query x>1 is false at 1 and true at 2, so no function of their common class can recover it. Retain x, split that class with the needed distinction, or return the unresolved answer set {false,true} when that set answers the receiving question. Selecting 1 as a representative would answer a question about the representative, not the lost original input.

Now let a partial operation f be defined at 0 and 1 but not at 2, with f(1)=0. Because 1 ≡_UNM 2 while availability differs, f cannot descend to a representative-independent operation on these classes. Matching only the outputs that happen to exist would miss the failure. Preserve the distinguishing input or refine the class before applying f.

Reversible conversion and partial normalization. For exact temperature values in the declared physical domain, Celsius-to-kelvin conversion n(c)=c+273.15 has inverse c=k-273.15 on its image. For example, 20 °C maps to 293.15 K and back to 20 °C. Measurement uncertainty remains governed by its measurement result; the exact coordinate law does not remove it. More generally, a strictly monotone encoding has an inverse on its image, not automatically everywhere in the named target.

Restrict the LUT above to D={0,1}. Input 2 is then undefined, has no NCV and belongs to no kernel class of that partial normalizer. A policy’s degraded-evidence allowance does not define n(2). Likewise, an idempotence claim needs composability and n(n(x))=n(x) on the named domain; a function’s fibers do not prove it.

Missing or stale inputs in a transformation flow.

  • A selector (or comparator) requires comparability under normalization-based mode.
  • UNM finds that a required coordinate value is missing/stale for the current slice and the instance validity window.
  • UNM returns GuardDecision = abstain (fail-closed) and identifies the missing current measurement. The receiver may reuse an adequate existing result, choose a justified acquisition, or leave this comparison unresolved; any acquisition has its own planning and enactment basis.