ADM.7:4 - Solution
ADM.7:4.1 - State the claim and receiving action
Specify what needs to be true, for whom or what, under which relevant rule and time, and what the recipient needs the answer for. Separate parts of a claim when their grounds, supported conclusions or resulting actions differ.
Consider the consequences of a mistaken positive or negative answer for this use. That consequence helps identify the applicable evidence requirement and any needed specialist contribution; it does not authorize the handler to invent a numerical confidence threshold.
For example, proving that a claimant has an effective assignment does not prove that a particular expense falls under it. Checking the expense’s category does not establish that it has not already been reimbursed. Select only the claims actually required for the receiving action.
ADM.7:4.2 - Match available evidence to the claim
Use an applicable existing result when it suffices. Before commissioning another check, establish what evidence is missing. Identify the actual subject, source, criterion, relevant time and stated limitations. Establish enough correspondence to know that the result concerns this person, expense, grant or provider attempt.
Distinguish the source’s identity from the truth of its content. A signed record can support an origin claim while leaving scope, effective date or substantive correctness disputed. FPF A.10 supplies source recovery and bounded reliance when that account needs to remain inspectable; it does not perform the domain check.
Use ADM.3 for a live effective-time question and ADM.4 when participant accounts or cross-source identity prevent the match. Do not build a larger evidence record when the ordinary source and its conditions already answer the question.
ADM.7:4.3 - Reuse the result or perform the needed competent check
Reuse a result when its subject and criterion match the question and the conditions on which the conclusion depends still hold. Name the specific change that would defeat reuse: a different person, a revised policy, a revoked grant, an altered subject or a later time outside the result’s scope.
When evidence is insufficient, select a qualified procedure or competent source that can answer the remaining question. A records custodian may recover a decision; the authorized specialist may interpret a rule; the payment provider may establish an attempt’s effect. A new generic document request cannot replace any of these.
If a domain method is missing, return that method gap through ADM.6. When the task includes a separate assurance claim, FPF B.3 supplies the argument about that exact claim and use. Consequence alone does not require constructing such an assurance claim.
ADM.7:4.4 - Preserve each action-changing outcome
Return the substantive result in ordinary language and retain distinctions the receiving question or action needs.
| Outcome | Meaning and continuation |
|---|---|
| The claim is supported for the stated use | The handler or competent decision holder may use the result under the applicable rule; the check itself does not grant permission or perform provision. |
| Evidence supports the negative condition | Apply the service rule’s response to that established negative result. |
| The evidence is insufficient or conflicting | Report what remains uncertain. Use any directly obtainable evidence or seek the specific competent contribution that would resolve it. |
| The chosen check is inapplicable | Choose the check that actually answers the claim, or return the missing method; an irrelevant test supplies no positive or negative answer. |
| The check cannot currently be performed | Use an adequate existing result or separately permitted alternative if available; otherwise report the unavailable check and dependent action. |
An unavailable mechanism is a fact about checking, not a negative answer about the claimant. A policy may prescribe refusal or deferral when evidence is missing, but that disposition still differs from proof that the claim is false.