B.1:9 - Consequences
Positive consequences:
- Users can combine aggregation notation with an independently grounded account of the objects and relations.
- Part-whole claims expose their objects, relations, and construction grounds for review.
- Role, Method, Work, mathematical-lens, and publication descriptions remain distinguishable from part-whole claims.
- Whole reidentification has an entry condition for B.2.
Costs:
- Users must identify the claim kind before choosing a notation.
- Further grounds depend on the claim: work occurrence evidence uses
A.15.1; work-resource aggregation usesB.1.6; an unresolved mathematical representation-choice, transfer or reliance question usesC.29. UseB.2.Pfor unresolved emergence-family wording andB.2when changed facts leave a consequential existing-whole versus new-whole question.