Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-18 21:11:39 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-18 21:12:35 UTC · last check 2026-11-18 22:15:20 UTC

B.2:11 - Decision-bearing SoTA account

Practical questionPrimary sourceAdopt, adapt, or reject in B.2Effect in this pattern
When may a configured production arrangement be treated as a distinct operating whole?Bartels et al., Dependable Cyber-Physical Matrix Production Systems Utilizing Holonic Multi-agent Systems (2025), and Macherki et al., QHAR: Q-Holonic-Based Architecture for Self-Configuration of Cyber-Physical Production Systems (2021), with a production-system case illustrating how the architecture could support reconfiguration.Adopt the practical need to recover entities, flows, coordination, dynamic interdependence, control organization, and reconfiguration purpose. Reject a named holonic architecture, control layer, or reconfiguration event as sufficient whole identity.Section 4 requires the A.1 and applicable kind-specific criteria for a positive new-whole claim. Section 5.1 adds the objective, feedback and supervision grounds used by its regulated-system case.
What separates inputs, construction, and the resulting whole?Florio and Linnebo, Introduction to Constructional Ontology (2024), and Borgo and Righetti, Towards Applied Constructional Ontology (2025).Adopt the separation among accepted inputs, constitutive organization, and resulting identity. Adapt it to FPF’s direct part relations, assembly, reidentification rule, and admitted holon kinds. Reject a trigger profile, record, tuple, or Method label as the constructor that makes the whole exist.Sections 1, 4, 4.3, and 5 distinguish world-side construction from comparison and record epistemes.
How should agency bear on whole reidentification?Michael Levin, Technological Approach to Mind Everywhere (2022).Adopt non-binary, multi-characteristic, empirically tested agency and multi-scale competency as possible evidence about a system. Reject an agency label or threshold as a root kind or automatic new-whole result.Section 4.5 treats an agency threshold as a possible trigger when it raises a consequential question about retaining or reidentifying the whole.
What can a multiscale mathematical signal contribute?Akhtyrchenko, Katsnelson, and Ustyuzhanin, Directing Open-Ended Evolution in Artificial Life via Multi-Scale Path Divergence (v2, 3 August 2026), defines MSPD over realized trajectories as a multiscale analytical and optimization measure.Adopt MSPD as a possible analytical input when its trajectory assumptions match the case. Reject a high MSPD, RG-like score, graph pattern, or benchmark jump as whole reidentification.Sections 0, 4.7, and 8 use C.29 for a remaining representation-choice, transfer or reliance question and retain the B.2 identity comparison.

Constructional ontology makes the identity consequences of inputs and organizing relations inspectable. Its applied use depends on the intended ontology and domain commitments; those grounds determine which proposed construction answers the identity question. Section :4.0 connects their recovery with B.5.TC’s comparison of competing accounts.

The manufacturing studies contribute reasons for control organization and reconfiguration; a production or recovery result supports the corresponding behavioral claim. Identifying the continuing individual additionally needs its construction and continuity grounds. The case in :5.7 develops that connection under engineering premises.