B.2:11 - Decision-bearing SoTA account
| Practical question | Primary source | Adopt, adapt, or reject in B.2 | Effect in this pattern |
|---|---|---|---|
| When may a configured production arrangement be treated as a distinct operating whole? | Bartels et al., Dependable Cyber-Physical Matrix Production Systems Utilizing Holonic Multi-agent Systems (2025), and Macherki et al., QHAR: Q-Holonic-Based Architecture for Self-Configuration of Cyber-Physical Production Systems (2021), with a production-system case illustrating how the architecture could support reconfiguration. | Adopt the practical need to recover entities, flows, coordination, dynamic interdependence, control organization, and reconfiguration purpose. Reject a named holonic architecture, control layer, or reconfiguration event as sufficient whole identity. | Section 4 requires the A.1 and applicable kind-specific criteria for a positive new-whole claim. Section 5.1 adds the objective, feedback and supervision grounds used by its regulated-system case. |
| What separates inputs, construction, and the resulting whole? | Florio and Linnebo, Introduction to Constructional Ontology (2024), and Borgo and Righetti, Towards Applied Constructional Ontology (2025). | Adopt the separation among accepted inputs, constitutive organization, and resulting identity. Adapt it to FPF’s direct part relations, assembly, reidentification rule, and admitted holon kinds. Reject a trigger profile, record, tuple, or Method label as the constructor that makes the whole exist. | Sections 1, 4, 4.3, and 5 distinguish world-side construction from comparison and record epistemes. |
| How should agency bear on whole reidentification? | Michael Levin, Technological Approach to Mind Everywhere (2022). | Adopt non-binary, multi-characteristic, empirically tested agency and multi-scale competency as possible evidence about a system. Reject an agency label or threshold as a root kind or automatic new-whole result. | Section 4.5 treats an agency threshold as a possible trigger when it raises a consequential question about retaining or reidentifying the whole. |
| What can a multiscale mathematical signal contribute? | Akhtyrchenko, Katsnelson, and Ustyuzhanin, Directing Open-Ended Evolution in Artificial Life via Multi-Scale Path Divergence (v2, 3 August 2026), defines MSPD over realized trajectories as a multiscale analytical and optimization measure. | Adopt MSPD as a possible analytical input when its trajectory assumptions match the case. Reject a high MSPD, RG-like score, graph pattern, or benchmark jump as whole reidentification. | Sections 0, 4.7, and 8 use C.29 for a remaining representation-choice, transfer or reliance question and retain the B.2 identity comparison. |
Constructional ontology makes the identity consequences of inputs and organizing relations inspectable. Its applied use depends on the intended ontology and domain commitments; those grounds determine which proposed construction answers the identity question. Section :4.0 connects their recovery with B.5.TC’s comparison of competing accounts.
The manufacturing studies contribute reasons for control organization and reconfiguration; a production or recovery result supports the corresponding behavioral claim. Identifying the continuing individual additionally needs its construction and continuity grounds. The case in :5.7 develops that connection under engineering premises.