B.2:4.0 - Establish the identity grounds for the comparison
Use this branch when the comparison needs an identity criterion that is unavailable or contested. A sufficient criterion already supplied by the admitted kind and subject practice can be used in :4.2. Here the useful result is a justified rule for the whole being compared, or the missing ground that prevents choosing one.
Recover the subject of the identity claim. State what continuing whole the receiving question concerns and which construction makes it that whole. A commissioned installation, the resources currently performing an order and a supervisor’s jurisdiction can overlap materially while answering different questions. Recover their constituents, organizing relations and relevant occasions before treating their descriptions as rival accounts of one individual. Use A.1 and the kind-specific pattern for the corresponding recognition question. When two accounts concern different subjects, keep each subject and its continuity conditions.
Recover what warrants each proposed rule. Find the domain account that makes the proposed conditions relevant to this whole: for example, the constitutive organization described by a design, an established lifecycle practice, or a theory of the object’s persistence. Follow its reasons into what may change and what ends the individual. Distinguish a condition sufficient for continuity from one merely necessary for it. An identifier, observation or test can help recognize that condition; recover the connection that gives it identifying force. For an institutionally constituted object, the applicable constituting rule can itself supply identity conditions. For a physical organization, a proposed rule also has to fit the organization and changes. A convenient model boundary answers only the questions warranted by its correspondence to that subject.
Compare the consequential alternatives through B.5.TC. Give each proposed account the same identity question and corresponding facts; recover its reasoning, then vary the condition on which the accounts disagree. Choose variations from the disputed claim. Replacement can expose whether the criterion preserves an organization or requires a fixed collection of parts. A temporary loss of functioning tests whether incapacity has been confused with the end of its bearer. A transfer of control tests whether the question follows the installation or a control relationship. Two independently constituted systems with the same output test whether a proposed condition distinguishes individuals or only capability. Division, merger or reconstruction matters when one of those events changes the receiving decision. For an episteme, compare its ClaimGraph, EntityOfConcern and effective ReferenceScheme under C.2.1 even when its carriers differ.
Locate the first reason for disagreement, as B.5.TC:4.4 explains. It may be a different subject, an incompatible domain premise or a missing fact about one continuing whole. A counterexample can defeat a proposed criterion; the surviving proposal needs the positive domain grounds that license its continuity claims. When a theory’s application is unclear, B.5.TU supplies that recovery. Obtain a specialist result or further inquiry only for the consequential ground still missing, using C.11.DUA to judge its attainable contribution and burden.
Return the criterion to the identity comparison. State the selected subject, the rule and its grounds, the changes it permits, and the event or condition that would end continuity. Keep a qualified or partial rule at the strength supported. Feed those results into :4.2 and use A.1.RI when observations still need to be associated under the rule.
Complementary accounts keep their different subjects; unresolved competing criteria for the same subject retain their conditional answers and the fact or domain commitment needed to decide between them. If their difference cannot affect the receiving work, continue that work at its supported scope. A broader identity conclusion remains open.