B.2:4.2 - Existing-whole comparison and optional result
First perform an ordinary comparison: compare the observed change with explanations that preserve the existing whole. Consider better parts, corrected relations, improved measurement, method or Work repair, richer phase coverage, capability change, and architecture-view repair only when their patterns make those explanations current. If one explanation is sufficient for the receiving use, keep the existing whole and stop B.2. Use the subject pattern for any remaining question.
For each material explanation, test three things together: whether it covers the change needed by the receiving use, whether the old identity rule permits it, and whether it is compatible with the established facts. When continuity across observations is uncertain, use A.1.RI to construct the possible connections and test them against the subject constraints. A changed part may preserve one whole’s identity and defeat another’s; the applicable identity rule decides.
| Comparison result | Grounds and next move |
|---|---|
sufficient | At least one supported explanation meets the receiving use while preserving the existing whole’s identity. Keep that whole; continue under the subject pattern only for a remaining question. |
insufficient | An established condition necessary for the receiving use cannot be met while preserving the prior identity; or the governing facts and rules justify a closed set of applicable alternatives and every alternative fails. Proceed to the candidate’s A.1 and kind-specific tests. |
unknown | A deciding fact or rule is unavailable, or material alternatives remain that would change whether a new whole is needed. Obtain that missing basis or retain the unresolved comparison. |
An unsuccessful search for an explanation does not establish insufficient. A closed comparison needs a reason why its alternatives cover the named question, not an inventory of every imaginable explanation. If all remaining identity alternatives permit the same needed continuation, A.1.RI allows that continuation without settling the unused identity distinction; this does not establish an MHT claim.
When another use must inspect or cite the outcome, identify an optional ExistingWholeExplanationResult episteme whose EntityOfConcern is the existing whole:
| Content field | Value kind and use |
|---|---|
observedChangeClaimRef | U.EpistemeRef resolving to the observed-gain or observed-shift claim. |
candidateExplanationClaimRefs[] | Claims under their subject patterns. |
explanationEvidenceRelationRefs[] | Evidence relations used to assess those explanations. |
existingWholeSufficiencyVerdict | sufficient, insufficient, or unknown for the named receiving use. |
remainingWholeReidentificationQuestionRef? | The residual question when the result is insufficient or unknown. |
The practitioner performs the comparison; the optional episteme records its outcome. Identity and relation claims depend on the facts and rules used in that comparison.