B.2:4.8 - Keep Whole Identity, Evidence, Currentness, And Reliance Separate
Keep these five distinctions explicit:
- the existing whole and candidate new whole, their constituents, obtaining constructive relations, assemblies, characteristics, and identity rules are world-side objects and facts under their patterns;
- a B.2 whole-reidentification assertion is a C.2.1 episteme about those objects;
- evidence and assurance relations support or warrant claims about construction and identity grounds, including the reasoned choice of an applicable criterion in :4.0;
- use G.11 to determine whether the selected assertion or record edition is current for the receiving use;
- a person or system performing the receiving work decides whether to rely, decline to rely, defer, or reopen.
Evidence present or missing, and a current or stale record, can change what an evaluation returns and whether a person or system relies while performing receiving work. They cannot turn the same whole into a new whole or a new whole into the same one. Whether the existing whole continues or a new whole must be identified follows the identity and reidentification rules plus the construction facts. A.1 recognition alone does not establish a B.2 whole-reidentification claim or select B.2.