C.40.OD:4.2 - Formulate the problem and the inquiries needed to choose a direction
Keep ordinary work running where it remains useful. Preserve enough of a consequential episode to recover what was being attempted, the way used, its premises and what happened. The episode may be a failure, an unexpectedly successful response or a newly available means. Use a sufficient established account. When different live explanations would change the continuation, distinguish them before selecting the repair. For example, inability to supply a result can concern an inadequate Method, unavailable authority or an unlearned operation. Sending all three into a training programme would give them the wrong continuation.
Problematisation produces a formulation that can guide the search for a solution. Characterize what happened or what has become possible, for whom it matters, and under which conditions. Specify the change or gain in understanding sought and the evidence by which a proposed solution could be judged. If the present way breaks down, locate the failed premise or the observation needed to find it. A promising opportunity can also warrant a new problem. B.5.PI helps notice a difficulty and open an inquiry. C.40.OI bounds the inquiry. C.40.PC and C.40.CD support constructing and revising the problem and a possible contribution.
Use the thin ProblemCard in C.22.2:2.1 to check the formulation. The signal, affected situation and criterion should let an evaluator judge a proposed result without access to the formulator’s preferred solution. The formulator can also apply the criterion. Assign a separate evaluator when the assessment requires independence. Record a missing criterion or observation and obtain it before using the card to judge a solution. The formulation can be ready for a search while the method is still unknown.
A question asks for an answer. “Which field marks a revised record?” requests information that may help choose a processing Method. A research problem can itself be expressed as a question. “What is the smallest number of sessions compatible with these conflicts?” names a result to establish. A schedule attaining the number and a reason no smaller number suffices settle it. For an inquiry whose answer form needs construction, use B.5.QD:4.3 to name the objects, premises, allowed changes and what would answer it. A known, directly obtainable fact can be requested in ordinary language.
The formulation and available answers supply two different receiving operations:
- Direction construction compares worthwhile attainable changes for the subject, including their means, losses and dependence on others’ contributions. It uses the understood difficulty and known possibilities, and identifies what further answer could change the choice.
- Method or knowledge inquiry searches, adapts, constructs or investigates the missing operation or relation. State what result would settle its present question and how that result could be used. The inquiry need not wait for a fully settled strategy when what can be done affects what is worth choosing. Once an adequate method is known, plan the executable work under A.15.2. Specify who will use the method, the result to deliver, its conditions of execution and how to check it. Once the performer has carried out the task, compare the actual result with the problem’s acceptance criterion.
The returns matter. A technical inquiry that establishes a cheaper usable way can change the direction. A participant’s objection can expose an unwanted result and change the problem formulation or proposed direction. An unavailable decision power can require a different undertaking. Do not freeze the formulation simply because one branch has begun work.
A direction is ready for the next construction when it specifies enough of the subject’s changed possibilities and receiving conditions to distinguish ways of obtaining them. It need not settle every future question. “Use a consultant’s answer”, “make this judgement with obtainable help”, and “organize and revise our own way of making this judgement” specify different results even when all three begin at the same failed project.