Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-18 21:11:39 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-18 21:12:35 UTC · last check 2026-11-18 22:10:10 UTC

C.40.OD:4.6 - Compare alternatives that remain whole

Construct alternatives far enough to compare their attainable effects, costs and receiving uses. C.40.DC constructs possible directions, C.40.JF tests their joint reachability, and C.40.CU develops a reproducible way. Take the characteristics that matter to the affected roles and specify the constraints for acceptance and the improvements sought. For alternatives compared under common conditions, one dominates another when it does at least as well on every selected criterion and better on at least one. The remaining trade-offs call for a choice. A change of criteria can reveal a different problem and calls for a fresh comparison.

Keep promising alternatives in the archive. The portfolio contains the undertakings actually selected within the available capacity, time, authority and resources. A trial can earn its place by opening a direction that current performance alone would miss. Strategizing supplies a justified choice and commitments when the direction or means are unsettled (STR.18). Work on the chosen way and evidence from its use establish what changed.

Several routes can be live together:

  • A usable Method exists. Obtain its result, use it, adapt it or develop the capability to perform it, according to the sought result. A course is not required when a qualified provider is the sufficient alternative.
  • The Method exists but is not feasible locally. Obtain missing inputs or assistance, change access or allocation, or adapt the Method’s contextual realization. If that exposes a poor direction, return to direction construction.
  • The proposed way is underdeveloped. Use C.39 and C.40.CD/CU to construct and try it. Do not sell established provision of a result that the proposed way cannot yet supply.
  • A consequential knowledge claim is unresolved. Use the applicable research practice. Independent research can also be worthwhile without an immediate product customer; give it its own result, conditions and resources.
  • The participant can perform the work only with continuing help. Compare maintained support with a learning transition and a different division of work. Neither dependence nor independence is universally superior.
  • The current arrangement produces the result but blocks further development. Compare changes to problem formulation, authority, learning opportunity and support, not merely faster execution of the same routine.

These branches can rejoin or reopen one another. They are not stages that every undertaking must complete in order. A fully formed local question can enter near its receiving use; a failed trial can return to the underlying purpose rather than repeat an unchanged solution.