C.11.DUA - Make Advice and Evidence Demands Worth Their Burden
Tech name:
DecisionUsefulAdvicePlain name: make advice and evidence demands useful to the recipient’s decision
Type: C-pattern
Status: Stable
C.11.DUA:1 - Problem frame
Use this when a report, expert answer, review comment, rule or checklist asks somebody to act, wait, investigate or supply evidence, but it is unclear how that demand helps their present question or whether they can carry it out.
An engineer reports that a discharge criterion was below the incoming background level. A colleague examining the criterion can use an attributed report and the distinction between total level and the operation’s contribution. An archive search would add work without improving that answer. If the colleague intends to publish who imposed the criterion, a contemporary record may be worth seeking. An answer about which inquiry is worth making can be complete while the authorship of the criterion is still unknown.
The broad activity is decision support through advice. This pattern addresses the branch in which advice turns uncertainty or a requirement into consequential work for its recipient. Its subject is the advice statement or requirement being composed or examined, including the action or inquiry it demands. An empirical claim, recommendation, method instruction and binding requirement retain their different meanings and force. The method recovers the demand, appraises it and returns a usable continuation.
First useful result. Give the supported answer or repaired advice, the continuation available to the recipient, and any limitation that changes its use. The result can be an explanation, recommendation, bounded inquiry, proposed requirement revision or an impasse. Ordinary prose is sufficient.
Ordinary non-use boundary. If the question, support and feasible answer are already clear, answer directly. Use A.10 directly for a source-reliance question, C.11 for an already adequate local choice, or C.19.2 for economical application under an undisputed declaration. This composition adds value when somebody otherwise has to reconstruct the connection between those questions. Domain inference, experimental design, permission and enactment remain with their own methods and authorities.
C.11.DUA:2 - Problem
A limitation is often followed by a demand that does not follow from it. “This study cannot establish the effect” can be true while “therefore commission the ideal experiment before doing anything” is infeasible or inferior to a bounded action. Conversely, an inexpensive check may distinguish a damaging commitment from a useful alternative. Skipping it merely because the present answer is convenient repeats the same failure to compare consequences.
The difficulty starts before a well-formed option set. Advice such as “validate thoroughly” can hide an investigator, access requirement, delay, claimed guarantee and transfer of cost to somebody else. The recipient has to recover that work before choosing whether it is worthwhile.
A further failure appears at completion. A method may allow work to proceed without more inquiry yet require a probe block, waiver or explanation of every omitted check before accepting the answer. Producing that account is itself work. Sometimes a retained reason protects a later use; sometimes it adds nothing to the completed decision.
C.11.DUA:3 - Forces
| Force | Tension |
|---|---|
| Truthful support and useful continuation | The present evidence may support a narrower answer than the requested one; scarce resources do not strengthen that evidence. |
| Inquiry and commitment | Information or computation can improve a choice, while delay, opportunity cost and investigation risk can worsen it. |
| Requirement merits and present force | A requirement may deserve revision while continuing to constrain what the recipient can presently do. |
| Immediate and later value | Operational action, explanatory progress, better models and future options can all matter at different horizons. |
| Protective contribution and distributed burden | A cheap measure for the issuer can be costly for its recipient or shift risk to another affected party. |
| Useful basis and unnecessary accounting | A decision needs its supporting basis; a record of an inactive check needs an actual receiving use. |
C.11.DUA:4 - Solution
Start from what the recipient is trying to settle. Recover the work hidden in the advice, compare what that work can change with what it costs, and give the best warranted continuation. Follow that continuation through the required result and stopping point.
C.11.DUA:4.1 - Recover the receiving question and demanded work
Identify the question the recipient needs answered and the horizon at which an improvement matters. Read an existing instruction as something somebody would have to perform: what would they believe, do, stop doing, postpone or spend if they followed it?
Recover the performer, resources, access, time or authority that affects feasibility. A study ending after the decision window serves a different use. For a request for help, establish whose result is wanted. For a shared deliverable, identify the work each participant can supply. If the recipient is to acquire an ability, identify what they must later do under the support conditions intended for that use and what performance would show it. Successful joint work alone warrants the claim about the deliverable (Library Reference §9.3.1).
For a text review, examine the connected passage that creates the demand, including its steps, mandatory fields and completion clauses. “Consider further evidence” and “obtain it before proceeding” impose different work. A final template can impose work that the preceding prose made optional.
Keep three answers distinct:
| Receiving question | Useful answer | Governing contribution when needed |
|---|---|---|
| What does the present basis support? | An attributed claim, supported conclusion and its use limit. | A.10; direct domain inference or C.28 for a causal use. |
| What can the recipient reasonably do with that basis? | A feasible continuation, narrower use, reversible action, deferral or stop. | C.11 for a local choice; C.11.CRC when the finite contribution comparison is missing. |
| What further inquiry could improve that use? | A worthwhile attainable check, or continuation with the present basis. | C.11 for information or computation value; the direct subject method for the inquiry. |
Resolve these questions when relevant to the receiving use; they are not three mandatory output fields. A source limitation qualifies the attempted claim. It does not by itself choose evidence acquisition.
C.11.DUA:4.2 - Compare attainable inquiry with its receiving value
If the relevant distinction or possible result is not yet expressible, use B.5:4.1.2 to develop grounds from an accessible episode, source or attempt. The immediate comparison can concern a bounded exploration likely to improve the description or reveal a dependency. It need not promise a particular discovery. Return with the basis obtained before demanding a specific action-changing answer. Appraising an already formulated inquiry and constructing its missing basis are different contributions.
For an optional inquiry, identify a plausible result that would change the conclusion, choice or warranted use. Compare it with using present knowledge, taking a smaller reversible step, using a different source, narrowing the claim, deferring or stopping. For a binding inquiry, identify the work due, its recipient and the evidence or report owed under the governing rule. Compare permitted ways of meeting it. A duty to measure and report can hold whatever the reading is.
Include the attainable inquiry’s cost, delay, displaced work and downside. Compare what it adds to the present configuration and horizon; C.11.CRC supplies that missing comparison when needed. A large uncertainty is not sufficient reason for a large study. Ask how resolving it could improve this use. A cheap probe that can change an irreversible commitment deserves a different answer from an expensive check whose plausible results leave the useful answer unchanged.
Qualitative or ordinal judgement often suffices. A numerical value-of-information or computation model is useful when it improves the choice; do not demand probabilities or a common scalar merely to fill a form. If plausible differences in judgement could reverse an important recommendation, examine those differences at proportionate effort. Keep distinct consequences visible when a scalar would hide the trade-off.
An inquiry can be useful even if the physical action stays the same. It may establish which claim is warranted, meet an applicable evidence condition or make a proposed use admissible. Conversely, inability to obtain evidence does not make the stronger claim true or admissible.
For exploratory research, name the explanatory, model-building, hypothesis-discriminating or option-creating gain at the research horizon. A study can earn its cost through those gains before an operational intervention is selected. The direct research method must still connect its attainable observations to that gain.
C.11.DUA:4.2.1 - Compare a proposed change with continuing the work
For optional advice to change a way of working, include continuing without that change in the comparison. A useful new contribution can be considered while the present work succeeds and its constraints remain unchanged. Recover what the recipient could gain, on which horizon, and what following the advice would require.
When the gain depends on a constituent action, use B.1.5.EW to recover the encompassing work performed through it, the contributions needed below it and the conditions that change its use. Use B.1.5.RS for a proposed replacement in those wholes. Include a second receiving whole or an intermediate connection while it can reverse the advice. Use an already adequate account directly.
Compare the full continuation: understanding and discussing the advice, obtaining support, learning, adaptation, coordination, execution and displaced work. Use C.11.CRC when the finite comparison or interactions are missing. If several changes compete for the same recipient capacity, compare their combined demand with ongoing commitments and changes already selected. Individually useful changes may require a smaller set, deferral or a different combination.
Keep deciding to think further, presenting advice, deciding to change and performing the change separate. Cheap computation can justify frequent consideration while interruption and transition costs justify infrequent advice or intervention. Consider timing and a smaller change when those alternatives matter. A change in performer capability or adaptation cost can justify reconsidering the encompassing way of working.
Use the available basis before asking the recipient for more work. Unclear benefit alone gives the recipient no obligation to prove an optional suggestion useless or fund an expensive evaluation. Obtain more information only when a plausible attainable answer can change a worthwhile continuation.
If presenting the advice has no proportionate basis, continue without presenting it; no rejection record is required merely to finish. Preserve a reason or reconsideration condition only for a receiving use that needs it.
An existing obligation still constrains the available continuations. Examine its merits and possible revision through section 4.3 when that question is live.
C.11.DUA:4.3 - Appraise a disputed requirement and its current force
When the requirement itself is in question, identify the quantity, activity or claim it governs and the problem it is meant to address. Examine its basis and uncertainty, threshold, protective contribution, burden and distribution of error costs. Include delay and displaced risks: reducing one named risk may increase another.
Compare retaining, tightening, relaxing or replacing the requirement only where these are meaningful alternatives. Resolve labels such as “safety” or “security” to the particular hazard, exposure, action or evidence condition. Apply the same proportionality question to the evidence demanded to justify the requirement itself.
A limit below background calls first for distinguishing the incoming background, the activity’s attributable increment and the total resulting level. A total-exposure objective can justify reducing background too. Neither “below background” nor “required for safety” settles the merits without that contribution comparison.
Keep the merits judgement separate from the currently available action set. A binding requirement continues to govern until the relevant authority or agreement changes it. Advice can recommend a lawful exception, a revised criterion or another activity and identify the feasible route to that change. If the current requirement makes the proposed action unavailable and no acceptable alternative or timely revision is feasible, state that impasse.
When applying apparatus under C.19.2, compare eligible applications under the current result, guarantee and constraints. A cheaper method that drops a required guarantee is a different proposal. Resume under a revised declaration only when that revision is available through its governing authority or agreement.
C.11.DUA:4.4 - Return the advice through first useful completion
Give the supported answer and available continuation in language the recipient can use. Retain uncertainty, attribution, a reason or a return condition when it changes that use. Where a substantive decision record is needed, put this content in the same result.
For an external-text review, return a concrete repair: identify the demanded work, the consequence or burden that makes it defective, and the smallest replacement that reaches a warranted result. Keep a useful evidence demand when the comparison supports it. A finding for another author can be durable without becoming a per-sentence ledger.
Follow the selected method through its completion requirements. Keep the recommendation or decision and its useful basis. An inactive inquiry creates no empty field, no waiver and no requirement to explain why checking was omitted. If a later recipient would otherwise overgeneralize the result, infer fresh evidence or miss a material limitation, retain the minimum explanation in that result. A short useful explanation alone need not instantiate a complete probe account.
Apply the same appraisal to any prescribed record. If it has binding force, distinguish its usefulness from what the current procedure requires and use the available revision route. This appraisal does not grant permission to disregard it.
Finish when the recipient has the warranted answer and continuation for the present question, including a justified stop when necessary. Reopen when the receiving use, possible consequence, feasible means, source basis or information opportunity changes materially.
C.11.DUA:4.5 - Keep recognition and assurance about the same advice
The opening and worked situations help the reader recognize a consequential demand and repair it. The checklist below tests that same advice and the work it demands. It does not introduce a separate admission record or require every use to undergo a new review.
Use A.10 for the evidence boundary, C.11 for a choice result, D.4 for ethical mediation and the direct assurance method for a stronger guarantee when that question is live. Advice that a step is sensible supplies neither permission nor evidence that the step was performed.
C.11.DUA:5 - Archetypal Grounding
These illustrative situations state their conditions for the comparison. Reported experience remains attributed; the numerical example uses stipulated decision inputs, not measurements from performed experiments.
C.11.DUA:5.1 - A useful distinction now and corroboration for a later claim
Present use. An engineer reports a criterion below incoming background. The recipient wants to understand whether that is necessarily a design mistake. An archive search would take weeks. Its plausible results could change the historical account but would not change the requested distinction.
Completed answer. “On your account, the threshold was below the incoming background. A criterion for the operation’s added contribution and a criterion for total exposure govern different quantities; the latter can require reducing background too. Compare the protection gained with the feasible treatment burden before judging the threshold.”
That answer supplies the requested distinction and identifies the engineer as the source of the threshold report. The answer itself completes this use; a second account of why archives were not searched adds nothing.
Changed use. The recipient now plans to attribute responsibility in a report. Suppose an accessible contemporary record can identify who set the criterion and what it governed. A one-hour record check is feasible and could settle the attribution.
Completed advice. “Before assigning responsibility in the report, check the contemporary record for who set the criterion and what it governed. If that remains unresolved, present the engineer’s account as their reported experience and leave responsibility unassigned.” The recipient has a feasible next check and a way to finish the report if the record leaves the attribution unresolved.
C.11.DUA:5.2 - A completed choice with conditional inquiry content
A research team chooses among feasible plans A, B and C. Two calibration states, s1 and s2, have equal weight. The team’s rule minimizes expected residual loss; shorter duration breaks equal-loss ties. The following are cardinal comparison inputs.
| Present model T0 | A | B | C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Residual loss in s1 | 6 | 2 | 4 |
| Residual loss in s2 | 8 | 3 | 5 |
| Expected residual loss | 7 | 2.5 | 4.5 |
Completed decision. Retain T0 and: “The research team chooses B now among A, B and C for this experiment. At equal state weights the expected losses are 7, 2.5 and 4.5. We minimize expected residual loss, with duration breaking ties.” B is preferable in either state. The current basis supports this choice; no unresolved inquiry alternative needs a separate account.
A completion form demanding unused probe budget, cost and information/computation fields would add omission accounting to that result. Conditional inquiry content leaves the decision and its basis intact.
Opposed condition. Change the loss model to T1 below. A specified one-day calibration can distinguish the states perfectly, an available technician can perform it, and two days remain. The team accepts that delay for a reduction in expected loss.
| Changed model T1 | A | B | C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Residual loss in s1 | 0 | 3 | 5 |
| Residual loss in s2 | 8 | 3 | 5 |
| Expected residual loss | 4 | 3 | 5 |
Completed first choice. Retain T1 and: “Probe again with the one-day calibration. Choosing B now has expected loss 3; choosing A after s1 or B after s2 has expected loss 1.5. The available day and technician make the probe feasible, and the team accepts the delay for that reduction.” This is a completed C.11 probe-again result. The measurement remains to be performed. An actual s1 result would then select A; s2 would select B.
Transfer requiring a reason. Return to T0, now sent to a colleague considering B for another calibration range. Retain: “B was selected using the existing model T0 and its two calibration states; distinguishing those states would not alter that choice. For another calibration range, reopen the comparison using evidence applicable to that range.” The explanation changes the colleague’s use: reopen the comparison instead of treating B as generally preferred. It belongs in the same decision result and needs no empty probe block.
C.11.DUA:5.3 - Repair a study demand in an external report
A consultancy report says, “Do not introduce the revised teaching exercise until a large randomized study proves its effect.” The teaching team must choose materials for four sessions next month; that study would take two years. The present synthesis does not establish a causal learning effect. The team’s immediate question is whether the revised materials can meet the existing course requirements with less preparation.
For this illustrative comparison, both formats meet the content and participant-protection requirements, and no binding rule requires the proposed effect study for this bounded use. The remaining uncertainty is whether the revised materials run with the room’s existing tools. The team requires that readiness to be established before selecting them. A thirty-minute setup rehearsal by the instructor in that room can settle it; it creates no student exposure.
Use the team’s stipulated planning estimates: the current exercise requires ninety minutes of preparation per session; the revised materials require thirty if compatible, otherwise the team retains the current exercise. The same room and tools will serve all four sessions. The team regards compatibility and incompatibility as equally plausible and prefers less instructor preparation once the course and protection constraints are met. The rehearsal fits the available preparation window.
A successful rehearsal makes the revised materials available and saves four hours across the sessions; a failed rehearsal leaves the current exercise selected. With equal weights, the expected preparation saving is two hours before the rehearsal’s half-hour cost, or ninety minutes net. Retaining the current exercise uses no rehearsal time but forgoes that opportunity. These estimates warrant this rehearsal; its small size and reversibility alone would not.
Completed advice. “Run the half-hour setup rehearsal to settle compatibility with this room’s tools. If the revised materials work, use them for the four sessions; otherwise retain the current exercise. Under our stated estimates, that information saves an expected ninety minutes of instructor time after its cost. Keep the learning-effect claim open.”
The advice gives the team a decision it can now make about the rehearsal. Compatibility with the stated room and tools becomes known only after the rehearsal is performed. If domain review identifies an unacceptable participant risk or a binding evidence prerequisite, meet the governing condition before using the materials.
Opposed cost condition. Suppose the same discriminating rehearsal now requires three hours of instructor time, still within the available preparation window. Its expected gross preparation saving remains two hours. The completed advice changes: “Retain the current exercise for these four sessions. The proposed rehearsal would cost an expected hour more than it saves. The current materials meet the course requirements; the comparative learning-effect claim remains unresolved.” A longer study remains a separate research proposal whose attainable contribution and burden must be justified for its own receiving use.
C.11.DUA:5.4 - Earn a long research horizon
A research group has two rival explanations of a recurrent anomaly. Neither yet supports an intervention. For one instrument setting their predicted ranges overlap in the middle and differ at the ends, even after allowing for measurement error. The instrument is available for four weeks. A broader survey would exhaust the year’s allocation without separating the predictions.
The group must choose a design for its next instrument. A result compatible with only one model would change that design. The group judges the chance and value of resolving this design choice worth the four weeks, after comparing the best other use of that time. A result in the overlap would leave both models in contention.
Completed advice. “Use the four weeks for the measurement. Compare the observed result, including its uncertainty, with both prediction ranges. If only one accommodates it, use that finding in the design choice. If both do, retain both explanations. If neither does, check the measurement and reconsider both models. The broader survey offers no comparable basis for the design choice.”
The attainable gain is a better basis for instrument design. No immediate operational intervention is required. If instrument uncertainty makes every attainable result compatible with both predictions, or a more valuable use of the four weeks becomes available, reconsider the allocation.
C.11.DUA:6 - Bias-Annotation
The recipient’s urgency can make cheap action seem preferable even when a decisive check is available. Conversely, the advice issuer can enjoy the benefit of confidence while transferring investigation costs and delay to others. Compare those consequences explicitly where they differ across affected parties.
An operational vocabulary can undervalue explanation and future options. State the receiving horizon and research gain before judging inquiry. A safety label can also suppress appraisal of a criterion, while a cost argument can hide its protective contribution. Preserve both the merits question and the requirement’s current force.
C.11.DUA:7 - Conformance Checklist
The following conditions concern the advice being composed or examined. They require no separately completed checklist.
| ID | Condition |
|---|---|
| CC-C11DUA.1 | The receiving question and the action, delay, expenditure or inquiry demanded by the advice are clear enough to judge their contribution. |
| CC-C11DUA.2 | The answer preserves what present evidence supports and its use boundary. Infeasible acquisition does not strengthen the claim. |
| CC-C11DUA.3 | Appraise an optional inquiry by its attainable gain, cost, delay, displaced work and downside. For a binding inquiry, preserve what must be done and compare the permissible means when the choice matters. Qualitative comparison can suffice. |
| CC-C11DUA.4 | When a requirement’s merits are disputed, the appraisal addresses its governed quantity or activity, purpose, contribution and burden while keeping present force separate. |
| CC-C11DUA.5 | The result reaches the first useful completion for this recipient. Its decision and useful basis remain; inactive inquiry adds no placeholder, waiver or omission account. |
| CC-C11DUA.6 | Any reason or limitation needed by the decision or a later recipient remains in the same result. Changed use can make previously unnecessary inquiry worthwhile. |
| CC-C11DUA.7 | The stated continuation is feasible under the current conditions, or the answer identifies the impasse. Future authorization or evidence is not treated as obtained. |
| CC-C11DUA.8 | Domain inference, choice, ethical and assurance claims retain their direct methods. Explanatory and future-option gains are judged at their receiving horizon. |
C.11.DUA:8 - Common Anti-Patterns and How to Avoid Them
| Misuse | Consequence and repair |
|---|---|
| Limitation becomes a study order | An unsupported stronger claim is followed by infeasible acquisition. Preserve the limitation and compare available continuations, as in 5.3. |
| Uncertainty alone justifies investigation | A large unknown consumes resources although resolving it cannot improve this use. Identify the possible change and attainable contribution. |
| Cheapness substitutes for support | A convenient action is presented as validating its premise. Keep the claim boundary and examine whether a check could change the warranted use. |
| Optional inquiry returns as a mandatory waiver | The reader finishes the choice and must then account for unused fields. Make the completion form conditional, as in T0. |
| Every explanation is deleted as overhead | A later recipient mistakes a bounded choice for a general result. Retain the scope explanation that changes that use. |
| Requirement criticism becomes permission | An argued revision is treated as already effective. State present force and the available revision route. |
| Only immediate action counts as value | Useful model discrimination is dismissed. Compare research gains and displaced opportunities at the research horizon. |
C.11.DUA:9 - Consequences
Advice becomes a usable answer to a receiving question. The practitioner can continue with qualified knowledge, select worthwhile inquiry, repair a requirement proposal or recognize an impasse. A reviewer can repair an external report without requiring FPF-formatted input.
The method costs the attention needed to recover hidden work and compare its consequences. That cost is unnecessary for an already clear bounded answer. It also cannot make unavailable means available or settle domain evidence and authority questions by general reasoning alone.
C.11.DUA:10 - Architectural Rationale
The recurring problem is the connection between a qualified claim and the work an answer asks somebody to perform. A.10 supplies bounded reliance; C.11 chooses among available options and tests probe-worthiness; C.11.CRC compares a finite contribution; C.19.2 limits apparatus effort under a declaration. Here those contributions are composed after recovering the receiving question and demand, including appraisal of the declaration itself when disputed.
This gives advice authoring and advice review the same method. Both start with what the recipient would do and end with usable advice. A wording repair under F.19 may make a demand clear while leaving its cost or merits unresolved. A decision calculation may be correct while answering a different question from the one the recipient needs.
The smaller route is direct use of the existing patterns or a short composing entry. Prefer it whenever it reaches the same warranted completion at comparable effort. This companion is useful where recovery of implicit work, requirement appraisal and the connected completion would otherwise have to be reconstructed.
C.11.DUA:11 - SoTA-Echoing
Value of information already supplies an answer to whether uncertainty is worth reducing. The additional work here is recovering the question hidden in advice and carrying the answer through completion. The following comparisons adopt source contributions at the effort the receiving problem needs.
| Practice question and source | Contribution and limit | Use here |
|---|---|---|
| Preliminary inquiry prioritization: Runge and colleagues, A Simplified Method for Value of Information Using Constructed Scales, 2023. | Constructed scales make preliminary comparison possible before full outcome predictions; uncertainty magnitude and decision relevance make different contributions. This is a foundation for a cheaper assessment, not a requirement for quantified ordinary advice. | Adapt: first identify what resolving uncertainty can change; use a qualitative comparison when sufficient, adding scales when they improve the choice. |
| Robustness of elicited priorities: Davis and colleagues, constructed information value with uncertain scoring, 2026. | Their kestrel research case extends constructed information value with iterative scoring and parametric uncertainty. Changes in elicitation and scores can change priorities. The domain case does not validate this entire advice method. | Adapt: examine plausible scoring differences when they could reverse an important recommendation. Repeated elicitation is conditional, not a routine prerequisite. |
| Imperfect evidence: Gutierrez, Glymour and Davey Smith, Evidence triangulation in health research, 2025. | Differently biased lines can strengthen inference through triangulation. The relevant biases and inference rules depend on the domain. | Adapt: compare a feasible complementary source with the ideal-study demand. Triangulation itself must earn the work; it is not a universal preliminary condition. |
| Protection requirements: IAEA, GSR Part 3, general principles of protection and safety, §§1.13–1.15 and 1.22. | Justification and optimization provide an established protection practice that considers social and economic factors. This source neither establishes the reported episode in 5.1 nor decides a local requirement’s validity. | Adapt: compare protective contribution and burden, including the governing quantity and present force. Use the applicable domain standard and authority for an actual operating decision. |
Compared with demanding the ideal evidence package first, this method can reach a warranted explanation or bounded continuation with less work. Compared with immediate action without inquiry, it retains a feasible check that changes a choice or admissible claim. Those are conditional gains: the quality of the domain models, the available observations and the recipient’s use remain decisive.
C.11.DUA:12 - Relations
- Uses:
A.10for source-reliance boundaries;C.11for local choice and probe-worthiness;C.11.CRCwhen a finite contribution comparison is missing;C.19.2for economical application under the current declaration. - Coordinates with:
C.18when useful options or hypotheses must be generated;C.28and direct domain methods when the advice depends on causal inference;D.4for ethical mediation; the applicable assurance method for a stronger guarantee. - Used by:
F.19when clear wording leaves a questionable substantive demand;E.19when advice usefulness, feasibility or evidence burden is the live review question;E.11.PUAwhen a pattern’s demanded work obstructs its first useful result. - Leaves with their owners: authorization, requirement enactment, domain research design, actual Work and its evidence. The recommendation supplies a reasoned continuation; those contributions determine whether and how it can be carried out.