C.2.1:9.7 - Readable wiring diagram as a proxy
Wiring-model episteme E1 concerns exact harness H under reference scheme S1, which resolves connector designators, pin identities, and connection predicates. If only layout changes in a wiring-diagram representation, identify the exact representation transition and preserved connector, pin, and connection correspondence; E1 remains the same. If instead only an exact publication form, carrier, or rendering changes, identify that E.17/E.24.PUB object and relation; E1 again remains the same. If a connection claim is removed from E1’s ClaimGraph or the legend changes the effective reference scheme, the changed claim content or scheme identifies episteme E2.
The wiring-diagram representation under its stated diagram scheme represents the connectivity of H; its mapping resolves connector marks and pin marks to the independently identified connectors and pins. A layout-only transition preserves connector identity, pin identity, and connection predicates. If the diagram omits a connection that remains in E1’s ClaimGraph, that representation loses one connection predicate. If a revised legend no longer resolves an earlier mark to its connector, that mark-to-connector reference is lost. The diagram remains admissible for maintenance diagnosis only while the connections on which that diagnosis depends are preserved and recoverable; stop that use or return to the source relation structure when they are not.
For a concrete typed receiving use, let local kind K_H admit already identified epistemes about H whose complete content consists of affirmative or negative physical-connectivity claims between identified pins under S1. The criterion excludes other subjects, proximity readings, and additional claim families; it classifies whole epistemes, not claim-content or scheme individuals. C.3.2 judges candidates against that criterion. Let E1 assert that pin P1 is connected to pin P2.
| Proposed replacement | Constitution and receiving-use result |
|---|---|
| a layout change preserving every connector, pin, connection claim, and S1 rule | the same E1; the receiver still checks that its representation exposes the connections needed for diagnosis |
| the same claim field now denies that P1 is connected to P2 | a different episteme that still meets K_H; admissible input does not mean equal content or a conservative replacement of E1 |
| the same marks now mean spatial proximity under S2 | a different episteme because interpretation changes; it fails K_H’s fixed physical-connectivity criterion |
| a proposed input whose governing legend is unavailable | membership and any identity comparison depending on that legend remain unresolved; a PDF carrier alone is not an episteme candidate |
A readability score can improve while the diagram makes the connections needed for diagnosis harder to recover. When that score is used as the practical value, apply E.13: name the intended diagnostic value, the readability proxy, and what became worse. Use the representation branch in :4.0 for the transition and its preserved or lost structure.