C.20:4.4 - Identity, continuity, and change
The discipline’s identity is not the extensional part list. It is the exact candidate with its field boundary, practice-and-knowledge assembly principle, obtaining constructive relations, whole-forming architecture, and declared whole characteristic under one direct reidentification rule.
The same discipline may continue through a permitted canon revision, method replacement, institutional change, publication change, or temporary part-relation change when the rule admits that variation and the field boundary, required contribution meanings, essential couplings, and whole characteristic remain within their declared continuity conditions. The rule must say which substitutions are permitted and how the replacement contribution reconnects to the assembly.
A change outside those conditions identifies another candidate or leaves the stronger claim unresolved. When a receiving use asks whether the old whole can still explain the case, run B.2’s existing-whole explanation check after the direct C.20 facts are recovered. Loss of evidence, another description edition, a renamed field, or a stale registry entry does not itself end or create a discipline.
“Discipline edition” can concern different objects. Recover the changed subject:
- revised canon, standard, method description, classification assertion, or discipline description is another C.2.1 episteme when its identity discriminator changes, with historical continuation tested separately;
- a newly available edition has its own E.24.PUB publication occurrence, particular expression, carrier, audience, use, and availability interval;
- an unchanged discipline during a proper interval may be described through the direct temporal and A.14 phase route;
- a changed field assembly outside the reidentification rule requires another discipline candidate, not a renamed description.
Identify a reusable publication form and its conformance separately when the current use relies on its rules. Keep the change rationale as claim content of one exact C.2.1-identified revision or decision episteme.
When historical continuation is asserted, the assertion about the exact EpistemeEditionRelation cites the exact source use, applicable continuity policy or rule, and the preserved and deliberately changed claim, EntityOfConcern, and scheme features that the rule consumes. Revision Work, Method, provenance, change facts, and evidence are case facts; no label establishes continuity.
When availability changes,