E.4:4.2.2 - Distinguish composition, specialization and use
Do not infer one relation from another:
| Relation | What must be established | Publication consequence |
|---|---|---|
| A subdiscipline is part of a composite discipline. | C.20’s direct part relation and whole construction, including knowledge-practice coupling and continuity. | Its DPF is a constituent description in the Suite; the Suite explains the connection to the whole. |
| One Method or field is a specialization of another. | The inherited construction or constraints and the added subject-specific conditions. Specialization alone does not establish disciplinary parthood. | Retain the general supplier and develop the specialized contribution where its assumptions belong. |
| Work in one field uses a result from another. | The required result, supplying Method, receiving use and relevant conditions. | Give a direct use or dependency link. Do not include the supplier’s entire DPF merely because that result is useful. |
| Several publications answer one question together. | Their contributions and the conditions for combining them. Use G.5-6 DeclareSetResult only when the already justified joint inclusion must be declared as a JointUseSet. | Supply a cross-framework entry or composition. This need not create a Suite. |
| A publication supports navigation or access. | Its information need, answer, source return and availability. | Keep it as a support publication or independently useful reference; it is not a subdiscipline. |
An engineering decision may need finance, research, mathematical modelling and ethical judgement. Their use does not make their entire disciplines parts of Engineering. Conversely, a subject-specific engineering branch does not become an external supplier merely because its Methods are used in only some projects. Test its participation in the continuing field assembly, not the participant list of one Work occurrence.
Do not force the discipline structure into a tree for filing convenience. If multiple parthood is proposed, establish each direct relation and explain the shared contribution, whole-forming couplings and consequences of change in each assembly.
First test whether the apparent overlap i